finding against presumption (California) · Go Syfert
← California issues

finding against presumption in California

13 California opinions name it 1 courts 1926–1973 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by California courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (9)

CaseFollowedCited
Estate of Trelutgreen
calctapp · 1938 · cited in 4 California opinions naming this issue, 1947–1962
2 sentences

1962Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court . . . unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support.” (Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723 [ 80 P.2d 147 ].) On the other hand, where it appears that a trial court has arbitrarily drawn a conclusion that a business is the separate property of a husband without giving heed to the rule that it “was respondents’ duty to clarify the history of the property and to show by a preponderance of the evidence what part of the same was separate property,” its judgme

1962Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court . . . unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support.” (Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723 [ 80 P.2d 147 ].) On the other hand, where it appears that a trial court has arbitrarily drawn a conclusion that a business is the separate property of a husband without giving heed to the rule that it “was respondents’ duty to clarify the history of the property and to show by a preponderance of the evidence what part of the same was separate property,” its judgme

44
Thomasset v. Thomassetred
calctapp · 1953 · cited in 2 California opinions naming this issue, 1958–1973
2 sentences

1958Code, § 164), but whether such presumptions have been rebutted" is primarily a question of fact.” In Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723 [ 80 P.2d 147 ], it was said: “[A] finding of a trial court that property is either separate or community in character is binding and conclusive upon the appellate court, if it is supported by sufficient evidence,' or if it is based On conflicting evidence or upon evidence that is subject to different inferences. [Citation.] ' Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court , [citation], unless the evidence to rebut it is so

1958Code, § 164), but whether such presumptions have been rebutted" is primarily a question of fact.” In Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723 [ 80 P.2d 147 ], it was said: “[A] finding of a trial court that property is either separate or community in character is binding and conclusive upon the appellate court, if it is supported by sufficient evidence,' or if it is based On conflicting evidence or upon evidence that is subject to different inferences. [Citation.] ' Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court , [citation], unless the evidence to rebut it is so

12
Morris v. Bermangreen
calctapp · 1958 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1973–1973
2 sentences

1973Whether the presumption of the community nature of the Buick created by its registration in the name of the parties has been rebutted is primarily a question of fact “ ‘[A] finding of a trial court that property is either separate or community in character is binding and conclusive upon the appellate court, if it is supported by sufficient evidence, or if it is based on conflicting evidence or upon evidence that is subject to different inferences. [Citation.] Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court [citation], unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and

1973Whether the presumption of the community nature of the Buick created by its registration in the name of the parties has been rebutted is primarily a question of fact “ ‘[A] finding of a trial court that property is either separate or community in character is binding and conclusive upon the appellate court, if it is supported by sufficient evidence, or if it is based on conflicting evidence or upon evidence that is subject to different inferences. [Citation.] Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court [citation], unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and

11
Fellows v. Fellowsgreen
calctapp · 1930 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1962–1962
2 sentences

1962(Estate of McCarthy, 127 Cal.App. 80, 88 [ 15 P.2d 223 ] ; see also Estate of Follows, 106 Cal.App. 681 [ 289 P. 887 ].) The fact that a substantial business owned at the termination of a long marriage had had its origin in a small business acquired by the husband before the marriage does not mean that it is all the separate property of the husband.

1962(Estate of McCarthy, 127 Cal.App. 80, 88 [ 15 P.2d 223 ] ; see also Estate of Follows, 106 Cal.App. 681 [ 289 P. 887 ].) The fact that a substantial business owned at the termination of a long marriage had had its origin in a small business acquired by the husband before the marriage does not mean that it is all the separate property of the husband.

11
Estate of McCarthygreen
calctapp · 1932 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1962–1962
2 sentences

1962(Estate of McCarthy, 127 Cal.App. 80, 88 [ 15 P.2d 223 ] ; see also Estate of Follows, 106 Cal.App. 681 [ 289 P. 887 ].) The fact that a substantial business owned at the termination of a long marriage had had its origin in a small business acquired by the husband before the marriage does not mean that it is all the separate property of the husband.

1962(Estate of McCarthy, 127 Cal.App. 80, 88 [ 15 P.2d 223 ] ; see also Estate of Follows, 106 Cal.App. 681 [ 289 P. 887 ].) The fact that a substantial business owned at the termination of a long marriage had had its origin in a small business acquired by the husband before the marriage does not mean that it is all the separate property of the husband.

11
Walsh v. Walshgreen
calctapp · 1943 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1949–1949
2 sentences

1949In addition to the provision in the agreement that after-acquired property should have a separate character, it must be borne in mind that therein appellant also disclaimed and relinquished to his wife “all marital rights of or to property now belonging to her, or that she may hereafter acquire ...” also “all and every right of inheritance, or right in law and in equity. ’ ’ Granting that improvements were added to the property by appellant or at his expense, the title thereto followed the title to the land (3 Cal.Jur. 10-Yr.Supp. 525; Shaw v. Bernal, 163 Cal. 262, 267 [ 124 P. 1012 ]; Dunn v.

1949In addition to the provision in the agreement that after-acquired property should have a separate character, it must be borne in mind that therein appellant also disclaimed and relinquished to his wife “all marital rights of or to property now belonging to her, or that she may hereafter acquire ...” also “all and every right of inheritance, or right in law and in equity. ’ ’ Granting that improvements were added to the property by appellant or at his expense, the title thereto followed the title to the land (3 Cal.Jur. 10-Yr.Supp. 525; Shaw v. Bernal, 163 Cal. 262, 267 [ 124 P. 1012 ]; Dunn v.

11
Shaw v. Bernalgreen
cal · 1912 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1949–1949
2 sentences

1949In addition to the provision in the agreement that after-acquired property should have a separate character, it must be borne in mind that therein appellant also disclaimed and relinquished to his wife “all marital rights of or to property now belonging to her, or that she may hereafter acquire ...” also “all and every right of inheritance, or right in law and in equity. ’ ’ Granting that improvements were added to the property by appellant or at his expense, the title thereto followed the title to the land (3 Cal.Jur. 10-Yr.Supp. 525; Shaw v. Bernal, 163 Cal. 262, 267 [ 124 P. 1012 ]; Dunn v.

1949In addition to the provision in the agreement that after-acquired property should have a separate character, it must be borne in mind that therein appellant also disclaimed and relinquished to his wife “all marital rights of or to property now belonging to her, or that she may hereafter acquire ...” also “all and every right of inheritance, or right in law and in equity. ’ ’ Granting that improvements were added to the property by appellant or at his expense, the title thereto followed the title to the land (3 Cal.Jur. 10-Yr.Supp. 525; Shaw v. Bernal, 163 Cal. 262, 267 [ 124 P. 1012 ]; Dunn v.

11
Estate of Adesgreen
calctapp · 1947 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1949–1949
2 sentences

1949In other words the presumption of section 164, which was but disputable (Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723, 724 [ 80 P.2d 147 ]) as between the spouses, was dispelled by the agreement, and the court’s finding against the presumption is binding on appeal (Estate of Trelut, supra; Estate of Ades, 81 Cal.App.2d 334, 337 [ 184 P.2d 1 ]).

1949In other words the presumption of section 164, which was but disputable (Estate of Trelut, 26 Cal.App.2d 717, 723, 724 [ 80 P.2d 147 ]) as between the spouses, was dispelled by the agreement, and the court’s finding against the presumption is binding on appeal (Estate of Trelut, supra; Estate of Ades, 81 Cal.App.2d 334, 337 [ 184 P.2d 1 ]).

11
Archer v. Harveygreen
cal · 1912 · cited in 1 California opinions naming this issue, 1926–1926
1 sentence

1926As held in Archer v. Harvey, 164 Cal. 274, 276 [ 128 Pac. 210 ], where the evidence is not brought up on appeal its sufficiency to support a finding against the bar of the statute cannot be questioned.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in California. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

CaseCitedYears
Olson v. Cornwell green
calctapp · 1933
2 sentences

1962Supp. 573.) Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court ( Estate of Cronvall, 220 Cal. 503 [ 31 P.2d 372 ]), unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support. ( Olson v. Cornwell, 134 Cal. App. 419 [ 25 P.2d 879 ].) It is finally in each case a question of fact for the court or jury to determine whether the evidence is sufficient to overcome the presumption.

1962Supp. 573.) Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court ( Estate of Cronvall, 220 Cal. 503 [ 31 P.2d 372 ]), unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support. ( Olson v. Cornwell, 134 Cal. App. 419 [ 25 P.2d 879 ].) It is finally in each case a question of fact for the court or jury to determine whether the evidence is sufficient to overcome the presumption.

61938–1962
Estate of Cronvall green
cal · 1934
2 sentences

1962Supp. 573.) Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court (Estate of Cronvall, 220 Cal. 503 [ 31 P.2d 372 ]), unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support.

1962Supp. 573.) Further, a finding against a presumption is binding upon the appellate court (Estate of Cronvall, 220 Cal. 503 [ 31 P.2d 372 ]), unless the evidence to rebut it is so weak and improbable that the finding is without substantial support.

61938–1962
Wynn v. Wynn green
calctapp · 1959
2 sentences

1961(Cf. Williams v. Williams, supra, 178 Cal.App.2d 522 ; Wynn v. Wynn, 170 Cal.App.2d 484 [ 338 P.2d 930 ].) Such cases are not authority for reversing the contrary finding in this case. 5.

1961(Cf. Williams v. Williams, supra, 178 Cal.App.2d 522 ; Wynn v. Wynn, 170 Cal.App.2d 484 [ 338 P.2d 930 ].) Such cases are not authority for reversing the contrary finding in this case. 5.

11961–1961
Williams v. Williams green
calctapp · 1960
1 sentence

1961(Cf. Williams v. Williams, supra, 178 Cal.App.2d 522 ; Wynn v. Wynn, 170 Cal.App.2d 484 [ 338 P.2d 930 ].) Such cases are not authority for reversing the contrary finding in this case. 5.

11961–1961
Nichols v. Mitchell green
cal · 1948
2 sentences

1961(Cf. Hogevoll v. Hogevoll, supra, 59 Cal.App.2d 188 .) See also Nichols v. Mitchell, 32 Cal.2d 598 , 605 ff [ 197 P.2d 550 ], In many cases in which the court says that tracing of separate funds into the property is not enough to upset the presumption, the trial court found in accordance with the presumption, and the actual holding, therefore, was that tracing is not enough to compel a reversal, i.e., does not compel a finding against the presumption.

1961(Cf. Hogevoll v. Hogevoll, supra, 59 Cal.App.2d 188 .) See also Nichols v. Mitchell, 32 Cal.2d 598 , 605 ff [ 197 P.2d 550 ], In many cases in which the court says that tracing of separate funds into the property is not enough to upset the presumption, the trial court found in accordance with the presumption, and the actual holding, therefore, was that tracing is not enough to compel a reversal, i.e., does not compel a finding against the presumption.

11961–1961
Hogevoll v. Hogevoll green
calctapp · 1943
1 sentence

1961(Cf. Hogevoll v. Hogevoll, supra, 59 Cal.App.2d 188 .) See also Nichols v. Mitchell, 32 Cal.2d 598 , 605 ff [ 197 P.2d 550 ], In many cases in which the court says that tracing of separate funds into the property is not enough to upset the presumption, the trial court found in accordance with the presumption, and the actual holding, therefore, was that tracing is not enough to compel a reversal, i.e., does not compel a finding against the presumption.

11961–1961
Dunn v. Mullan green
cal · 1931
1 sentence

1949In addition to the provision in the agreement that after-acquired property should have a separate character, it must be borne in mind that therein appellant also disclaimed and relinquished to his wife “all marital rights of or to property now belonging to her, or that she may hereafter acquire ...” also “all and every right of inheritance, or right in law and in equity. ’ ’ Granting that improvements were added to the property by appellant or at his expense, the title thereto followed the title to the land (3 Cal.Jur. 10-Yr.Supp. 525; Shaw v. Bernal, 163 Cal. 262, 267 [ 124 P. 1012 ]; Dunn v.

11949–1949
Suhr v. Lauterbach green
cal · 1913
2 sentences

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

11926–1926
Akley v. Bassett green
cal · 1922
2 sentences

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

11926–1926
Kleinclaus v. Dutard green
cal · 1905
2 sentences

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

1926In view of the circumstances shown it cannot be said that the delay was of such duration as to render inequitable an inquiry as to the validity of the respondent’s claim, and the conclusions of the court find support from the evidence (Akley v. Bassett, 189 Cal. 625 [ 209 Pac. 576 ]; Kleinclaus v. Dutard, 147 Cal. 245 [ 81 Pac. 516 ] ; Suhr et al. v. Lauterbach, 164 Cal. 591 [ 130 Pac. 2 ]).

11926–1926
Furman v. The Bon Marche neutral
wash · 1912
1 sentence

1926As held in Archer v. Harvey, 164 Cal. 274, 276 [ 128 Pac. 210 ], where the evidence is not brought up on appeal its sufficiency to support a finding against the bar of the statute cannot be questioned.

11926–1926

Where else courts name it

CA 13 (1926–1973) GA 4 (1922–2013) TX 3 (1923–2008)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check