leading principle (New York) · Go Syfert
← New York issues

leading principle in New York

11 New York opinions name it 5 courts 1864–1955 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
Everitt v. . Everittgreen
ny · 1864 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 1896–1896
1 sentence

1896J., in Everitt v. Everitt, ( 29 N. Y. 39, 75, 77 ), viz.: “ The leading inquiry upon which the question of vesting or not vesting turns, is whether the gift is immediate and the time of payment or of enjoyment only postponed, or is future and contingent, depending upon the beneficiary arriving of age or surviving some other person, or the like. futurity is annexed to the substance of the gift, the vesting is suspended, but if it appear to relate to the time of payment only, the legacy vests instanter.” And in this con dition of things, the fact that a trust was also created by the will would n

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (18)

CaseCitedYears
People v. . Moses green
ny · 1893
1 sentence

1955(People v. Dunford, 207 N. Y. 17 ; People v. Moses, 140 N. Y. 214 .) The intention of the Legislature was to prohibit the carrying on of public selling to the extent of seriously interrupting the religious observance of Sunday.

11955–1955
People v. . Dunford green
ny · 1912
1 sentence

1955(People v. Dunford, 207 N. Y. 17 ; People v. Moses, 140 N. Y. 214 .) The intention of the Legislature was to prohibit the carrying on of public selling to the extent of seriously interrupting the religious observance of Sunday.

11955–1955
In re the Estate of Ingraham neutral
nysurct · 1936
1 sentence

1947The leading principle -of the cases is, that when the testator bequeath a sum of money, or, which is the same thing, a life annuity, in such a manner as to show a separate and independent intention that, the money shall be paid to the legatee at all events, that intention will not be permitted to be overruled, merely by a direction in the will that the money is to be raised in a particular way, or out of a particular fund. * * * If we were to hold that the widow was to have nothing, less the property or securities in which the estate happened to be invested yielded income, and that, she was no

11947–1947
In re the Estate of Weir neutral
nysurct · 1939
1 sentence

1947Matter of Weir ( 172 Misc. 74 ) the testator’s residuary estate was given t° his children with the direction to pay his widow $2,500 per year “ out of the income thereof ”.

11947–1947
Pierrepont v. . Edwards green
ny · 1862
1 sentence

1944Thus the trustees were directed “ to pay to the widow $7,000 per annum so long as she should remain a widow ” (Pierrepont v. Edwards, supra); to “ pay over to my wife out of the income of such trust fund a yearly income of Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000.00) to be paid in quarterly installments as long as she shall live ” (Matter of Whitcomb, supra).

11944–1944
In re the Estate of Whitcomb neutral
nysurct · 1940
1 sentence

1944Thus the trustees were directed “ to pay to the widow $7,000 per annum so long as she should remain a widow ” (Pierrepont v. Edwards, supra); to “ pay over to my wife out of the income of such trust fund a yearly income of Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000.00) to be paid in quarterly installments as long as she shall live ” (Matter of Whitcomb, supra).

11944–1944
In re Conger green
· 1903
1 sentence

1927(Matter of Becker, 59 Misc. 135 ; Matter of Conger, 81 App. Div. 493 .) A legacy is contingent when the enjoyment of it depends upon some particular event, as the arrival of the legatee at a certain age, but if it appears to relate to the time of payment only, the legacy vests .immediately.

11927–1927
In re the Judicial Settlement of the Account of Becker neutral
nysurct · 1908
1 sentence

1927(Matter of Becker, 59 Misc. 135 ; Matter of Conger, 81 App. Div. 493 .) A legacy is contingent when the enjoyment of it depends upon some particular event, as the arrival of the legatee at a certain age, but if it appears to relate to the time of payment only, the legacy vests .immediately.

11927–1927
Vanderpoel v. . Loew green
· 1889
1 sentence

1896(Vanderpoel v. Loew, 112 N. Y. 167 -181.) But there were other provisions in this will connected with this trust and with the final disposition of the property.

11896–1896
Thurber v. . Chambers green
· 1876
1 sentence

1894Thurber v. Chambers, 66 N. Y. 42 ; Slimson v. Vroman, 99 N. Y. 80 .

11894–1894
Parshall v. . Eggert green
ny · 1873
1 sentence

1893The leading rule of exposition is, that a contract shall be interpreted to give effect to the intention of the parties, Story on Cont, § 634; 2 Parsons on Cont, 494; Bishop on Cont, § 575; Parshall v. Eggerl, 54 N. Y., 18 , and it does seem rational and manifestly just that a party should know with whom he is contracting, before or at the time of the sale, and that no stranger "can be thrust upon him afterwards to his possible disadvantage, and this is evidently just what was contemplated and intended here.

11893–1893
Rice v. . Harbeson neutral
ny · 1876
1 sentence

1891This is the leading principle which runs through the cases cited upon this point. * * * It is the duty of courts to search for a construction that will carry the plain purpose of the testator’s bounty into effect.” Again: “The common law rule that the personal estate of a deceased person will be applied to the payment of his contract debts, to the relief of his real estate, is not, however, of universal application, and will not be enforced where it is in apparent hostility to' the plain intent of the deceased as expressed in his will, and would defeat bequests made therein.” Rice v. Harbeson,

11891–1891
Warner v. . Durant green
· 1879
1 sentence

1889(Leake v. Robinson, 2 Mer. 363; Warner v. Durant, 76 N. Y. 133 ; Smith v. Edwards, 88 id. 92.) The latter principle is invoked in this case.

11889–1889
Higinbotham v. . Stoddard neutral
ny · 1878
1 sentence

1882Cases, 284; Jackson v. Rosevelt, 13 Johns., 97 ; O'Donnells v. Lindsay, 39 Superior Ct., 537.) A leading rule of the interpretation of the description of land contained in deeds among private parties is, that that which is certain must prevail over that which is less so, and hence quantity, as the less certain call of the deed, often yields to courses and distances which are more certain, and these again to fixed natural objects which are still more certain. ( Wendell v. The People, 8 Wend., 183 ; Northrop v. Sumney, 27 Barb., 196 ; Higinbotham, v. Stoddard, 72 N. Y., 94 .) It is apparent in t

11882–1882
Northrop v. Sumney neutral
nysupct · 1858
1 sentence

1882Cases, 284; Jackson v. Rosevelt, 13 Johns., 97 ; O'Donnells v. Lindsay, 39 Superior Ct., 537.) A leading rule of the interpretation of the description of land contained in deeds among private parties is, that that which is certain must prevail over that which is less so, and hence quantity, as the less certain call of the deed, often yields to courses and distances which are more certain, and these again to fixed natural objects which are still more certain. ( Wendell v. The People, 8 Wend., 183 ; Northrop v. Sumney, 27 Barb., 196 ; Higinbotham, v. Stoddard, 72 N. Y., 94 .) It is apparent in t

11882–1882
Jackson ex dem. Carman v. Rosevelt neutral
· 1816
1 sentence

1882Cases, 284; Jackson v. Rosevelt, 13 Johns., 97 ; O'Donnells v. Lindsay, 39 Superior Ct., 537.) A leading rule of the interpretation of the description of land contained in deeds among private parties is, that that which is certain must prevail over that which is less so, and hence quantity, as the less certain call of the deed, often yields to courses and distances which are more certain, and these again to fixed natural objects which are still more certain. ( Wendell v. The People, 8 Wend., 183 ; Northrop v. Sumney, 27 Barb., 196 ; Higinbotham, v. Stoddard, 72 N. Y., 94 .) It is apparent in t

11882–1882
Wendell v. Jackson ex dem. People neutral
· 1831
1 sentence

1882Cases, 284; Jackson v. Rosevelt, 13 Johns., 97 ; O'Donnells v. Lindsay, 39 Superior Ct., 537.) A leading rule of the interpretation of the description of land contained in deeds among private parties is, that that which is certain must prevail over that which is less so, and hence quantity, as the less certain call of the deed, often yields to courses and distances which are more certain, and these again to fixed natural objects which are still more certain. ( Wendell v. The People, 8 Wend., 183 ; Northrop v. Sumney, 27 Barb., 196 ; Higinbotham, v. Stoddard, 72 N. Y., 94 .) It is apparent in t

11882–1882
Gilman v. . Reddington green
· 1861
1 sentence

1864If futurity is annexed to the substance of the gift, the vesting is suspended; but if it appear to relate to the time of payment only, the legacy vests instanter. (1 Jarman on Wills, 760; Gilman v. Reddington, 24 N.Y. 9 .) And words directing division or distribution between two or more objects at a future time are equivalent to a direction to pay.

11864–1864

Where else courts name it

NV 16 (1952–2018) AL 13 (1843–2011) NY 11 (1864–1955) CA 10 (1858–1949) TX 10 (1885–2025) TN 9 (1914–2023) PA 7 (1899–2021) AR 6 (1892–1996) MD 6 (1880–2012) MI 6 (1918–1981) WI 4 (1881–1926) NJ 3 (1990–2021) NC 3 (1895–2009) ME 3 (1899–2025) OK 3 (1899–1964) LA 2 (1944–1987) AK 2 (1962–1977) DC 2 (1989–2009) OH 2 (1977–2007) KS 2 (1893–1905) MO 2 (1915–1930) IA 2 (1865–1976) KY 2 (1935–1936) VT 2 (1920–2018) AZ 2 (1924–1926)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check