doubtful claim (Indiana) · Go Syfert
← Indiana issues

doubtful claim in Indiana

6 Indiana opinions name it 2 courts 1885–1940 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Indiana courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (0)

CaseFollowedCited
No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in Indiana.

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Indiana. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (12)

CaseCitedYears
Barrett v. City of Mobile green
ala · 1900
1 sentence

1940The subject is discussed in Barrett v. City of Mobile (1900), 129 Ala. 179 , 30 So. 36 , 87 Am.

11940–1940
Fender v. Phillips green
indctapp · 1915
2 sentences

1938J. 324, §17. “. . . it is a familiar principle of law that the com *551 promise of a matter in dispute is a sufficient consideration to support a contract, when the same is entered into in the absence of fraud.” Fender, Admr. v. Phillips, Admr. (1915), 59 Ind. App. 85, 92 , 108 N. E. 971 .

1938J. 324, §17. “. . . it is a familiar principle of law that the com *551 promise of a matter in dispute is a sufficient consideration to support a contract, when the same is entered into in the absence of fraud.” Fender, Admr. v. Phillips, Admr. (1915), 59 Ind. App. 85, 92 , 108 N. E. 971 .

11938–1938
Burget v. Merritt neutral
ind · 1900
1 sentence

1907Whether section two of the act of 1889 (Acts 1889, p. 430, §2645 Burns 1894) relates to warranty mortgages, or whether to prior or subsequent conveyances, as questioned by appellants, are questions not material to the disposition of this case (Burget v. Merritt [1900], 155 Ind. 143 ), for it is very clear that under the broader and less doubtful rule of the common law appellants have no interest in the fund in controversy that they can assert against the beneficiaries under the mortgage.

11907–1907
Hoy v. State, ex rel. Buchanan green
ind · 1907
1 sentence

1907Hoy v. State, ex rel. (1907), 168 Ind. 506 .

11907–1907
Harter v. Johnson green
ind · 1861
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Cronkhite v. White neutral
ind · 1865
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Thompson v. Nelson green
ind · 1867
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Henry v. Ritenour neutral
ind · 1869
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Smith v. Boruff neutral
ind · 1881
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Harris v. Cassady neutral
ind · 1886
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Emery v. Royal neutral
ind · 1889
1 sentence

1895The court says: ‘ ‘ The most that can be claimed by the plaintiff, * "x" is that it was a doubtful one; and the compromise of a pending suit upon a doubtful claim is a good consideration for a promise. ” In Harris v. Cassady, 107 Ind. 158 , the court says: “ It is not necessary that the claim asserted should be a legal one, but it is necessary that it must have some foundation in law or in equity. * * If the claim asserted by the appellants appeared to have any foundation, the cases of Henry v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 ; Cronkhite v. White, 25 Ind. 418 ; Thompson v. Nelson, 28 Ind. 431 , and Hart

11895–1895
Fitzpatrick v. Papa green
ind · 1883
1 sentence

1885It was held in Fitzpatrick v. Papa, 89 Ind. 17 , that “A married- woman who executes a mortgage to secure the release of a valid lien can not escape the consequences of her act upon the ground that the mortgage was executed to secure the debt of the husband.

11885–1885

Where else courts name it

GA 11 (1913–1999) MO 9 (1907–2004) NY 6 (1850–1995) MS 6 (1930–2011) IN 6 (1885–1940) WA 5 (1923–2007) PA 5 (1922–1973) IL 4 (1910–1937) KY 4 (1923–1952) CA 3 (1915–1978) NM 3 (1936–1956) MN 3 (1977–1986) TX 3 (1963–1994) MA 3 (1875–1963) NC 3 (1939–1975) AZ 3 (1952–2014) WI 3 (1951–2024) NH 3 (1845–2001) KS 2 (1926–1926) FL 2 (2009–2009) HI 2 (1917–1956) VT 2 (1985–2005) AL 2 (1951–2005)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check