Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
6 New York opinions name it 3 courts 2003–2013 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
People v. Tankleffgreen2 sentences2012In making our determination, we do not decide whether, as the defendant contends, New York recognizes a free-standing claim of actual innocence that is cognizable by, or which may be addressed within the parameters of, CPL 440.10 (1) (h) (see People v Tankleff, 49 AD3d at 182 ). 2012In making our determination, we do not decide whether, as the defendant contends, New York recognizes a free-standing claim of actual innocence that is cognizable by, or which may be addressed within the parameters of, CPL 440.10 (1) (h) (see People v Tankleff, 49 AD3d at 182 ). | 1 | 4 |
Broder v. Cablevision Systemsgreen1 sentence2013Corp., 418 F3d 187, 200 [2d Cir 2005] [affirming dismissal of a General Business Law § 349 claim where plaintiff did not “make a free-standing claim of deceptiveness under GBL § 349 that happens to overlap with a possible claim under (another state statute),” but rather alleged that a violation of the other statute was, in itself, a section 349 violation]). | 1 | 1 |
State v. Ratliffgreen1 sentence2003Many states have similarly held that a free-standing claim of actual innocence is insufficient to provide for postconviction relief (State v Byrd, 145 Ohio App 3d 318, 323, 710 NE2d 1043 , 1053-1054 [2001]; Reedy v Wright, 2002 WL 598434 , 2002 Va Cir LEXIS 64 [Va Cir Ct, Apr. 8, 2002]; State v Ratliff, 71 SW3d 291, 296-298 [Tenn 2001]; State v Placzkiewicz, 307 Mont 189, 192 , 36 P3d 934, 936 [2001]; State v Norsworthy, 71 SW3d 610 [Mo 2002]; Pellegrini v State, 117 Nev 860, 34 P3d 519, 537 [2001]; Heffernan v State, 2002 WL 1303388 , 2002 Ark LEXIS 363 [Ark Cir Ct, June 13, 2002]). | 1 | 1 |
State v. Placzkiewiczgreen2 sentences2003Many states have similarly held that a free-standing claim of actual innocence is insufficient to provide for postconviction relief (State v Byrd, 145 Ohio App 3d 318, 323, 710 NE2d 1043 , 1053-1054 [2001]; Reedy v Wright, 2002 WL 598434 , 2002 Va Cir LEXIS 64 [Va Cir Ct, Apr. 8, 2002]; State v Ratliff, 71 SW3d 291, 296-298 [Tenn 2001]; State v Placzkiewicz, 307 Mont 189, 192 , 36 P3d 934, 936 [2001]; State v Norsworthy, 71 SW3d 610 [Mo 2002]; Pellegrini v State, 117 Nev 860, 34 P3d 519, 537 [2001]; Heffernan v State, 2002 WL 1303388 , 2002 Ark LEXIS 363 [Ark Cir Ct, June 13, 2002]). 2003Many states have similarly held that a free-standing claim of actual innocence is insufficient to provide for postconviction relief (State v Byrd, 145 Ohio App 3d 318, 323, 710 NE2d 1043 , 1053-1054 [2001]; Reedy v Wright, 2002 WL 598434 , 2002 Va Cir LEXIS 64 [Va Cir Ct, Apr. 8, 2002]; State v Ratliff, 71 SW3d 291, 296-298 [Tenn 2001]; State v Placzkiewicz, 307 Mont 189, 192 , 36 P3d 934, 936 [2001]; State v Norsworthy, 71 SW3d 610 [Mo 2002]; Pellegrini v State, 117 Nev 860, 34 P3d 519, 537 [2001]; Heffernan v State, 2002 WL 1303388 , 2002 Ark LEXIS 363 [Ark Cir Ct, June 13, 2002]). | 1 | 1 |
State Ex Rel. Amrine v. Ropergreen1 sentence2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 1 |
Ex Parte Franklingreen1 sentence2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 1 |
Pellegrini v. Stategreen1 sentence2003Many states have similarly held that a free-standing claim of actual innocence is insufficient to provide for postconviction relief (State v Byrd, 145 Ohio App 3d 318, 323, 710 NE2d 1043 , 1053-1054 [2001]; Reedy v Wright, 2002 WL 598434 , 2002 Va Cir LEXIS 64 [Va Cir Ct, Apr. 8, 2002]; State v Ratliff, 71 SW3d 291, 296-298 [Tenn 2001]; State v Placzkiewicz, 307 Mont 189, 192 , 36 P3d 934, 936 [2001]; State v Norsworthy, 71 SW3d 610 [Mo 2002]; Pellegrini v State, 117 Nev 860, 34 P3d 519, 537 [2001]; Heffernan v State, 2002 WL 1303388 , 2002 Ark LEXIS 363 [Ark Cir Ct, June 13, 2002]). | 1 | 1 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
People v. Washington
green
1 sentence2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 2003–2003 |
Miller v. Commissioner of Correction
green
2 sentences2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). 2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 2003–2003 |
Herrera v. Collins
green
1 sentence2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 2003–2003 |
Schlup v. Delo
red
1 sentence2003In Schlup ( 513 US at 316 ), the United States Supreme Court indicated that if it were to adopt a constitutional standard for a free-standing claim of innocence, it would require unquestionable evidence that the petitioner was innocent. | 1 | 2003–2003 |
State v. Norsworthy
green
1 sentence2003Many states have similarly held that a free-standing claim of actual innocence is insufficient to provide for postconviction relief (State v Byrd, 145 Ohio App 3d 318, 323, 710 NE2d 1043 , 1053-1054 [2001]; Reedy v Wright, 2002 WL 598434 , 2002 Va Cir LEXIS 64 [Va Cir Ct, Apr. 8, 2002]; State v Ratliff, 71 SW3d 291, 296-298 [Tenn 2001]; State v Placzkiewicz, 307 Mont 189, 192 , 36 P3d 934, 936 [2001]; State v Norsworthy, 71 SW3d 610 [Mo 2002]; Pellegrini v State, 117 Nev 860, 34 P3d 519, 537 [2001]; Heffernan v State, 2002 WL 1303388 , 2002 Ark LEXIS 363 [Ark Cir Ct, June 13, 2002]). | 1 | 2003–2003 |
In Re Clark
red
1 sentence2003The courts and individual judges or justices that have discussed the appropriate burden of proof for a free-standing claim of innocence have come to divergent opinions (see Herrera, 506 US 390 [1993]; Washington, 171 Ill 2d at 489, 665 NE2d at 1337 ; Miller, 242 Conn 745, 700 A2d 1108 ; In re Clark, 5 Cal 4th at 798, 855 P2d at 761 ; Ex parte Franklin, 72 SW3d 671, 678 [Tex 2002]; Roper, 102 SW3d at 547 [Mo]). | 1 | 2003–2003 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.