Cases citing this passage
initial decision
Cited 72 times across 63 cases. Most often attributed to PGBA, LLC v. United States, 2004.
Timeline.
First cited 1985
· peak 2006 (10 pins)
· last 2026
· spans 42 years · 13% of all citations are from the last 5 years
· declining
Related passages: frequently cited in the same opinions as this one
co-cited 8×
final decision
co-cited 8×
final order
Oliva v. DVA
· 2026-05-07 · Federal Circuit
Barrette v. DVA
· 2025-11-04 · Federal Circuit
Vindiola v. MSPB
· 2025-09-03 · Federal Circuit
McCloud v. MSPB
· 2025-07-11 · Federal Circuit
Graham v. DOJ
· 2025-06-11 · Federal Circuit
Casarez v. Opm
· 2025-04-14 · Federal Circuit
Crandall v. MSPB
· 2024-11-14 · Federal Circuit
Von Kelsing v. Navy
· 2024-10-15 · Federal Circuit
Muhammad v. DVA
· 2024-08-08 · Federal Circuit
Jenkins v. Department of Transportation
· 2020-08-06 · Federal Circuit
Bowe-Connor v. DVA
· 2017-11-13 · Federal Circuit
Lamb v. Office of Personnel Management
· 2017-03-07 · Federal Circuit
Weathersbee v. Department of the Treasury
· 2017-01-12 · Federal Circuit
Fitzgerald v. Department of Homeland Security
· 2016-09-20 · Federal Circuit
Raymond J. Lucia Companies, Inc. v. Securities & Exchange Commission
· 2016-08-09 · D.C. Circuit
Cobert v. Miller
· 2015-09-02 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
Hall v. Department of Transportation
· 2015-04-08 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
Brison v. Department of Veterans Affairs
· 2013-12-09 · Federal Circuit
Vick v. Department of Transportation
· 2013-11-12 · Federal Circuit
Stewart v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 2013-08-14 · Federal Circuit
Spearman v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 2013-08-08 · Federal Circuit
Donaldson v. Department of Homeland Security
· 2013-07-11 · Federal Circuit
Croal-Manuel v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 2012-07-12 · Federal Circuit
Davis v. United States Postal Service
· 2012-06-12 · Federal Circuit
Wall v. Office of Personnel Management
· 2011-04-08 · Federal Circuit
Cedillo v. Secretary of Health & Human Services
· 2010-08-27 · Federal Circuit
Kornman v. Securities & Exchange Commission
· 2010-01-15 · D.C. Circuit
Malloy v. United States Postal Service
· 2009-08-25 · Federal Circuit
Davis v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 2009-08-04 · Federal Circuit
Stribling v. Department of Education
· 2009-02-05 · Federal Circuit
Deleonardo v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
· 2008-04-29 · Federal Circuit
Popowsky v. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission
· 2007-12-27 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Pangilinan v. Office of Personnel Management
· 2007-08-08 · Federal Circuit
Jenkins v. Department of the Treasury
· 2007-07-16 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
Jochims v. National Labor Relations Board
· 2007-03-23 · D.C. Circuit
Von Muller v. Department of Energy
· 2006-10-10 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
In Re Martin G. Reiffin
· 2006-10-06 · Federal Circuit
Ashworth v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 2006-06-09 · Federal Circuit
Habtemariam v. Office of Personnel Management
· 2006-05-08 · Federal Circuit
Bruckelmyer v. Ground Heaters, Inc.
· 2006-04-20 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
Romeo M. Rasing v. Department of the Navy
· 2006-04-07 · Federal Circuit
Rasing v. Department of the Navy
· 2006-04-07 · Federal Circuit
Fulton v. Dept. Of the Army
· 2006-04-06 · Federal Circuit
Long Lane Limited Partnership v. Bibb
· 2005-12-07 · Federal Circuit
Brown v. Department of Treasury
· 2005-08-05 · Federal Circuit
In Re Innovation Development Group, Inc.
· 2005-03-14 · Federal Circuit
Pgba, LLC v. United States
· 2004-11-22 · Federal Circuit
Pgba, LLC v. United States, and Wisconsin Physicians Service Insurance Corporation
· 2004-11-22 · Federal Circuit
Cossette v. Department of Agriculture
· 2004-10-08 · Federal Circuit · 2 pin-cites
Jacoby v. National Labor Relations Board
· 2003-04-11 · D.C. Circuit
Page 1 of 2 Next →