California Codes homeSearch California
Cal. CodesEvidence CodeDivision 3. General ProvisionsChapter 5. Weight of Evidence Generally

Cal. Evidence Code § 412 (2026)

Edition and currency
leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTleginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026) ACTIVE · 47 IN 5Y cited 1966–2026 129citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 129 opinions since 1966, 47 of them in the last five years.

If weaker and less satisfactory evidence is offered when it was within the power of the party to produce stronger and more satisfactory evidence, the evidence offered should be viewed with distrust.

The 20 cases that cite Cal. Evidence Code § 412 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENOrange Cnty. Water Dist. v. Alcoa Global Fasteners, Inc., 12 Cal. App. 5th 252 (Ct. App. 2017).
cites § 412 18×cited by 74 cases
Where it cites § 412
“edure, section 1048, subdivision (b) by scheduling a bench trial on the District's statutory *493 (equitable) claims before a jury trial on the District's common law (legal) claims, thereby depriving the District of its right to trial by jury; (3) the court erred by applying its…”
The case’s holding
A plaintiff in a private cost recovery action must establish that the site on which hazardous substances are contained is a threatened contamination or pollution site.
Later courts cite it for
“a person who has incurred response or corrective action costs in accordance with this chapter, chapter 6.5 (commencing with section 25100), or the federal act may seek contribution or indemnity from any person who is liable pursuant to this chapter.” · 3 citing courts
2
GREENPeople v. Harrison, 35 Cal. 4th 208 (2005).
cites § 412 4×cited by 262 cases
Where it cites § 412
“Defendant argues that special instruction D "reflects the provisions of Evidence Code section 412.”
The case’s holding
Evidence of a separate criminal act is admissible to prove consciousness of guilt when it is relevant to identity or intent.
Later courts cite it for
“a prosecutor's misconduct violates the fourteenth amendment to the federal constitution when it 'infects the trial with such unfairness as to make the conviction a denial of due process.' in other words, the misconduct must be 'of sufficient significance to result in the denial of the defendant's right to a fair trial.' a prosecutor's misconduct 'that does not render a criminal trial fundamentally unfair' violates california law 'only if it involves " 'the use of deceptive or reprehensible methods to attempt to persuade either the court or the jury.” · 12 citing courts
3
GREENOrange Cnty. Water Dist. v. MAG Aerospace Indus., Inc., 12 Cal. App. 5th 229 (Ct. App. 2017).
cites § 412 5×cited by 17 cases
Where it cites § 412
“ial court erred under Code of Civil Procedure section 1048, subdivision (b) by scheduling a bench trial on the District's equitable claims before a jury trial on the District's legal claims, thereby depriving the District of its right to trial by jury; (3) the trial court erred…”
4
GREENPeople v. Von Villas, 10 Cal. App. 4th 201 (Ct. App. 1992).
cites § 412 5×cited by 53 cases
Where it cites § 412
“” The proffered defense instruction, based upon Evidence Code section 412, 22 would, it is contended, properly guide the jury in dealing with the inadvertently lost bindle.”
The case’s holding
A journalist's shield rights prevail over a defendant's right to discovery when the sought unpublished information lacks a reasonable possibility of providing exculpatory or impeaching evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“power of the party to produce stronger and more satisfactory evidence.” · 3 citing courts
5
GREENTemple Cmty. Hosp. v. Superior Court, 20 Cal. 4th 464 (1999).
cites § 412 4×cited by 84 cases
Where it cites § 412
“(See Evid.Code, § 412 ["If weaker and less satisfactory evidence is offered when it was within the power of the party to produce stronger and more satisfactory evidence, the evidence offered should be viewed with distrust.”
The case’s holding
Damages for the tort of intentional spoliation of evidence are too speculative to support a cause of action (evidence spoliation tort).
Later courts cite it for
“we observe that to the extent a duty to preserve evidence is imposed by statute or regulation upon the third party, the legislature or the regulatory body that has imposed this duty generally will possess the authority to devise an effective sanction for violations of that duty.” · 3 citing courts
6
GREENPeople v. Marshall, 13 Cal. 4th 799 (1996).
cites § 412 2×cited by 391 cases
Where it cites § 412
“) [5] Defendant may be understood to suggest his trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance in failing to request the jury be instructed pursuant to Evidence Code section 412, which provides: "If weaker and less satisfactory evidence is offered when it was within the power of…”
The case’s holding
A trial court may constitutionally declare a mistrial due to jury deadlock if such a declaration is a matter of legal necessity.
Later courts cite it for
“the trial court must determine whether the evidence is sufficient to permit the jury to find the preliminary fact true by a preponderance of the evidence.” · 5 citing courts
7
GREENPeople v. Ervine, 47 Cal. 4th 745 (2009).
cites § 412 1×cited by 232 cases
Where it cites § 412
“Although defendant did testify prior to Fox’s testimony that he did not know whether he made a statement about the barricade during the interrogation, the defense still has never claimed that Fox’s account of what defendant said, which was fully consistent with the transcript of…”
The case’s holding
The burden of proof is not met when evidence shows no privileged information was communicated to the prosecution following a jail cell search (basis: evidence of communication).
Later courts cite it for
“the proponent of evidence must identify the specific ground of admissibility at trial or forfeit that basis of admissibility on appeal.” · 7 citing courts
8
GREENCanales v. City of Alviso, 3 Cal. 3d 118 (1970).
cites § 412 4×cited by 56 cases
Where it cites § 412
“As the trial court herein stated upon admitting the petition into evidence, "the court will indicate at this time that it feels it [the petition] has *136 very little probative value, if any, at all with respect to how a person voted because certainly anyone can sign a petition…”
The case’s holding
A voter's signature on a petition urging a specific issue constitutes admissible circumstantial evidence that the voter supported that issue in a subsequent election.
Later courts cite it for
“illegal votes were sufficient in number to account for the result but also that illegal votes were cast in such a manner as in fact to determine the result.” · 1 citing court
9
GREENReeves v. Safeway Stores, Inc., 121 Cal. App. 4th 95 (Ct. App. 2004).
cites § 412 1×cited by 113 cases
Where it cites § 412
“17 A fact finder could also draw an adverse inference (see Evid. Code, § 412) from his arguably pointed evasion of the direct question whether he expected the referral in this case to result in plaintiff’s termination.”
The case’s holding
An employer is liable for retaliatory discharge if an intermediate actor's animus acts as a but-for cause of the adverse action, even if the ultimate decision-maker lacks knowledge.
Later courts cite it for
“to establish an entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, it is not enough to show that one actor acted for lawful reasons when that actor may be found to have operated as a mere instrumentality or conduit for others who acted out of discriminatory or retaliatory animus, and whose actions were a but-for cause of the challenged employment action.” · 5 citing courts
10
GREENVallbona v. Springer, 43 Cal. App. 4th 1525 (Ct. App. 1996).
cites § 412 2×cited by 59 cases
Where it cites § 412
“(Evid. Code, § 412.) 11 Hence, as we shall explain in detail, although accepting parts of Dr.”
The case’s holding
Failure to timely object to a complaint waives statutory protections requiring a court order to include punitive damages in medical professional negligence actions.
Later courts cite it for
“has not established any specific numerical percentage of net worth as constituting the upper permissible limit for the amount of a punitive damages award.” · 3 citing courts
11
GREENNeumann v. Bishop, 59 Cal. App. 3d 451 (Ct. App. 1976).
cites § 412 2×cited by 48 cases
Where it cites § 412
“He apparently engaged in a studied attempt to make capital out of defendant’s failure to produce the potential witnesses, and further erroneously advised the jury that the court would advise them to speculate that there was something suspicious about defendant’s failure to…”
The case’s holding
A court must review the record to determine the extent of counsel's contribution when evaluating whether a judgment is so excessive as to result from passion and prejudice.
Later courts cite it for
“to evaluate the defendant's claim that the judgment ... is so excessive as to shock the conscience and give rise to a presumption that it was the result of passion and prejudice ... , it is necessary to review the record on the question of the plaintiff's counsel's contribution to such a result” · 3 citing courts
12
GREENEllis v. Toshiba Am. Info. Sys.., Inc., 218 Cal. App. 4th 853 (Ct. App. 2013).
cites § 412 1×cited by 74 cases
Where it cites § 412
“203 and 204 because there was no evidence that she willfully suppressed evidence.”
The case’s holding
A trial court may deny an attorney's personal fee request and impose discovery sanctions where the attorney destroys electronic time records and fails to comply with court orders for forensic inspection.
13
GREENMaaso v. Signer, 203 Cal. App. 4th 362 (Ct. App. 2012).
cites § 412 1×cited by 28 cases
Where it cites § 412
“536 ]; Evid. Code, §§ 412, 413.) Code of Civil Procedure section 1286.”
The case’s holding
An arbitration award is procured by undue means when a party arbitrator engages in ex parte communication with the neutral arbitrator without notifying the opposing party.
Later courts cite it for
“substantial evidence includes reasonable inferences drawn from the evidence in favor of the judgment.” · 3 citing courts
14
GREENPeople v. Lazanis, 209 Cal. App. 3d 49 (Ct. App. 1989).
cites § 412 2×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 412
“" (Cal. Evid. Code, § 412.) Even more significantly, to hold that evidence of the broadcast's content is enough by itself to prove the officer actually possessed the reasonable suspicion he claimed to possess in that broadcast would effectively abolish the "fellow officer" rule.”
cites § 412 4×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 412
“In this respect the licensee also asserts the board erred in failing to consider Evidence Code sections 412 and 413 [fn.”
Later courts cite it for
“technical rules of evidence do not apply to administrative hearings.” · 2 citing courts
16
GREENIn re Bell, 42 Cal. 4th 630 (2007).
cites § 412 1×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 412
“(See Evid. Code, § 412.) The referee’s finding that Dorton did not recant is therefore supported by substantial evidence, and we accept his finding.”
17
GREENHardesty v. Sacramento Metro. Air Quality Mgmt. Dist., 202 Cal. App. 4th 404 (Ct. App. 2011).
cites § 412 1×cited by 17 cases
Where it cites § 412
“3d 637 ] [where evidence necessary to establish a fact essential to a claim lies peculiarly within the knowledge and competence of one of the parties, that party has the burden of going forward with the evidence on the issue]; Evid. Code, § 412 [“If weaker and less satisfactory…”
18
GREENPeople v. Moran, 1 Cal. 3d 755 (1970).
cites § 412 1×cited by 170 cases
Where it cites § 412
“(Evid. Code, § 412.) Defendant also contends that the recent enactment of the Evidence Code overturns the holding in People v.”
The case’s holding
A conviction for a greater offense is controlling and requires reversal of a conviction for a lesser included offense if the evidence supports the greater verdict.
Later courts cite it for
“if the evidence supports the verdict as to a greater offense, the conviction of that offense is controlling, and the conviction of the lesser offense must be reversed” · 6 citing courts
19
GREENHoughtaling v. Superior Court of San Bernardino Cty., 17 Cal. App. 4th 1128 (Ct. App. 1993).
cites § 412 2×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 412
“If stronger evidence is clearly available, the trial court may draw the inference offered by Evidence Code section 412, and view the proffered evidence with distrust.”
20
GREENDeMiglio v. Mashore, 4 Cal. App. 4th 1260 (Ct. App. 1992).
cites § 412 1×cited by 30 cases
Where it cites § 412
“(See Evid. Code, § 412: “If weaker and less satisfactory evidence is offered when it was within the power of the party to produce stronger and more satisfactory evidence, the evidence offered should be viewed with distrust.”

Show all 129 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
196619962026

One bar per year. Tallest: 15 cases in 2025. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Cal. Ct. App.116Cal.10N.D. Cal.2C.D. Cal.1
By subsection

Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.

Show all 129 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

California Codes Home  |  Search California  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com