California Codes homeSearch California
Cal. CodesEvidence CodeDivision 3. General ProvisionsChapter 5. Weight of Evidence Generally

Cal. Evidence Code § 413 (2026)

Edition and currency
leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTleginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026) ACTIVE · 37 IN 5Y cited 1968–2026 111citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 111 opinions since 1968, 37 of them in the last five years.

In determining what inferences to draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the trier of fact may consider, among other things, the party’s failure to explain or to deny by his testimony such evidence or facts in the case against him, or his willful suppression of evidence relating thereto, if such be the case.

The 20 cases that cite Cal. Evidence Code § 413 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENPeople v. Cortez, 63 Cal. 4th 101 (2016).
cites § 413 4×cited by 197 cases
Where it cites § 413
“) We disagreed, based largely on the Legislature‘s failure to modify Penal Code section 1127 or Evidence Code section 413. As noted earlier, the former provides that, ―in any criminal case, whether the defendant testifies or not, his failure to explain or to deny by his…”
The case’s holding
A jury instruction regarding a defendant's failure to explain or deny incriminating evidence applies only when the defendant completely fails to do so or claims lack of knowledge.
Later courts cite it for
“applies only when a defendant completely fails to explain or deny incriminating evidence, or claims to lack knowledge and it appears from the evidence that the defendant could reasonably be expected to have that knowledge.” · 14 citing courts
2
GREENTemple Cmty. Hosp. v. Superior Court, 20 Cal. 4th 464 (1999).
cites § 413 14×cited by 84 cases
Where it cites § 413
“First among these remedies is the evidentiary inference permitted by Evidence Code section 413, which permits the trier of fact to infer that evidence suppressed by a party was unfavorable to the party.”
The case’s holding
Damages for the tort of intentional spoliation of evidence are too speculative to support a cause of action (evidence spoliation tort).
Later courts cite it for
“we observe that to the extent a duty to preserve evidence is imposed by statute or regulation upon the third party, the legislature or the regulatory body that has imposed this duty generally will possess the authority to devise an effective sanction for violations of that duty.” · 3 citing courts
3
GREENCedars-Sinai Med. Ctr. v. Superior Court, 18 Cal. 4th 1 (1998).
cites § 413 8×cited by 262 cases
Where it cites § 413
“This evidentiary inference, currently set forth in Evidence Code section 413 and in the standard civil jury instructions, has a long common law history.”
The case’s holding
No separate tort remedy exists for the intentional spoliation of evidence by a party to the underlying litigation if the spoliation is discovered before the litigation concludes.
Later courts cite it for
“to take extraordinary measures to preserve for an indefinite period documents and things of no apparent value solely to avoid the possibility of spoliation liability if years later those items turn out to have some potential relevance to future litigation.” · 7 citing courts
4
GREENPeople v. Saddler, 24 Cal. 3d 671 (1979).
cites § 413 8×cited by 187 cases
Where it cites § 413
“If the Legislature so intended, it would have modified other statutes which permit comment on a testifying defendant's failure to explain or deny.”
The case’s holding
A trial court must have evidentiary support in the record to justify instructing a jury that it may draw adverse inferences from a defendant's failure to explain or deny evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“may be considered in assessing the prejudicial effect of an improper instruction.” · 7 citing courts
5
GREENPeople v. Grandberry, 35 Cal. App. 5th 599 (Ct. App. 2019).
cites § 413 4×cited by 47 cases
Where it cites § 413
“Code, § 413 ["In determining what inferences to *606 draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the trier of fact may consider, among other things, the party's failure to explain or to deny by his testimony such evidence or facts in the case against him, or his…”
The case’s holding
A jury may draw an adverse inference from a testifying defendant's failure to explain or deny incriminating evidence within the scope of relevant cross-examination.
Later courts cite it for
“calcrim no. 361 rests on the logical inference that if a person charged with a crime is given the opportunity to explain or deny evidence against him or her but fails to do so, then that evidence may be entitled to added weight.” · 7 citing courts
6
GREENIn re Avena, 12 Cal. 4th 694 (1996).
cites § 413 4×cited by 230 cases
Where it cites § 413
“It should have been produced or trial counsel should have been able to give a definite and plausible reason for its disappearance.”
The case’s holding
To demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must show that counsel's performance was deficient and that this deficiency resulted in prejudice to the defendant.
Later courts cite it for
“under the 'cumulative error' doctrine, errors that are individually harmless may nevertheless have a cumulative effect that is prejudicial.” · 68 citing courts
7
GREENPeople v. Zamora, 28 Cal. 3d 88 (1980).
cites § 413 4×cited by 124 cases
Where it cites § 413
“Our law furnishes ample guidelines for cases such as this — guidelines applicable to all parties, prosecutors and defendants alike. Evidence Code section 413 provides in part: "In determining what inferences to draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the…”
The case’s holding
Unsustained citizen complaints against police officers are discoverable and their improper destruction warrants a sanction to ensure a fair trial.
Later courts cite it for
“the courts enjoy a large measure of discretion in determining the appropriate sanction that should be imposed because of the destruction of discoverable records and evidence.” · 6 citing courts
8
GREENKarlsson v. Ford Motor Co., 140 Cal. App. 4th 1202 (Ct. App. 2006).
cites § 413 3×cited by 54 cases
Where it cites § 413
“The instruction, which is based on Evidence Code section 413, was ordered as a lesser sanction to original sanction Nos.”
The case’s holding
A violation of a discovery order is not a prerequisite to issue and evidentiary sanctions when a party engages in a pattern of willful discovery abuse causing evidence unavailability.
Later courts cite it for
“discovery sanctions must be tailored in order to remedy the offending party's discovery abuse, should not give the aggrieved party more than what it is entitled to, and should not be used to punish the offending party. appellate courts review the trial court's order under the deferential abuse of discretion standard.” · 3 citing courts
9
GREENPeople v. Vega, 236 Cal. App. 4th 484 (Ct. App. 2015).
cites § 413 3×cited by 49 cases
Where it cites § 413
“” (See Evid. Code, § 413 [trier of fact may consider any “party’s failure to explain or to deny by his testimony such evidence or facts in the case against him”].”
The case’s holding
Failure to object at trial does not waive an instructional error on appeal if the instruction misstates the law or affects the defendant's substantial rights.
Later courts cite it for
“generally, failure to object does not waive an instructional error on appeal if the instruction was an incorrect statement of law or the defendant's substantial rights were affected.” · 7 citing courts
10
GREENPeople v. Rodriguez, 170 Cal. App. 4th 1062 (Ct. App. 2009).
cites § 413 4×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 413
“361, which is consistent with Evidence Code section 413.”
Later courts cite it for
“calcrim no. 361 is similar in content to caljic no. 2.62.” · 3 citing courts
11
GREENPeople v. Coffman, 34 Cal. 4th 1 (2004).
cites § 413 1×cited by 827 cases
Where it cites § 413
“Code, § 1127; Evid. Code, § 413.) Moreover, the remarks by Coffman’s counsel seem aimed not at implying that Marlow’s failure to testify concerning Orange County signaled his guilt, but rather at suggesting Coffman’s credibility was comparatively strong because she took the…”
The case’s holding
Expert testimony regarding a defendant's prior history of abuse is admissible to establish the defendant's state of mind (People v. Coffman).
Later courts cite it for
“his resistance, far from reflecting a will overborne by official coercion, suggests instead a still operative ability to calculate his self-interest in choosing whether to disclose or withhold information.” · 13 citing courts
12
GREENNew Albertsons, Inc. v. Superior Court, 168 Cal. App. 4th 1403 (Ct. App. 2008).
cites § 413 2×cited by 74 cases
Where it cites § 413
“The court apparently based that part of its ruling on Evidence Code section 413, which states, “In determining what inferences to draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the trier of fact may consider, among other things, the party’s failure to explain or to…”
The case’s holding
Doubts regarding a motion to withdraw or amend an admission are resolved in favor of the moving party to ensure a trial on the merits.
Later courts cite it for
“we review an order imposing discovery sanctions under the abuse of discretion standard. an abuse of discretion occurs if, in light of the applicable law and considering all of the relevant circumstances, the court's decision exceeds the bounds of reason and results in a miscarriage of justice. the abuse of discretion standard affords considerable deference to the trial court, provided that the court acted in accordance with the governing rules of law.” · 10 citing courts
13
GREENWilliamson v. Superior Court, 21 Cal. 3d 829 (1978).
cites § 413 4×cited by 38 cases
Where it cites § 413
“[2] Compare Evidence Code section 413: "In determining what inferences to draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the trier of fact may consider, among other things, the party's failure to explain or to deny by his testimony such evidence or facts in the…”
The case’s holding
Agreements to suppress evidence through consideration such as indemnification are void as against public policy and do not restore work product privileges.
Later courts cite it for
“agreements to suppress evidence have long been held void as against public policy, both in california and in most common law jurisdictions.” · 3 citing courts
14
GREENNeumann v. Bishop, 59 Cal. App. 3d 451 (Ct. App. 1976).
cites § 413 3×cited by 48 cases
Where it cites § 413
“) It was proper for the plaintiff to comment on the defendant’s failure to produce evidence to rebut that testimony offered by the plaintiff to show that she was not violating the basic speed law, and that evidence which showed a computation of her loss of earnings.”
The case’s holding
A court must review the record to determine the extent of counsel's contribution when evaluating whether a judgment is so excessive as to result from passion and prejudice.
Later courts cite it for
“to evaluate the defendant's claim that the judgment ... is so excessive as to shock the conscience and give rise to a presumption that it was the result of passion and prejudice ... , it is necessary to review the record on the question of the plaintiff's counsel's contribution to such a result” · 3 citing courts
15
GREENMorgan v. AT&T Wireless Servs., Inc., 177 Cal. App. 4th 1235 (Ct. App. 2009).
cites § 413 1×cited by 122 cases
Where it cites § 413
“Extraneous Allegations In addition to the above allegations, the amended complaint also added more than 16 pages of allegations related to AT&T’s purported suppression and/or spoliation of evidence, and asserted that certain adverse inferences may be made against AT&T under…”
The case’s holding
A fraudulent business practice under the Unfair Competition Law is one likely to deceive the public and does not require the same elements as common law fraud.
Later courts cite it for
“requirement exists in order to allow a defendant to avoid liability for damages if the defendant corrects the alleged wrongs within 30 days after notice, or indicates within that 30-day period that it will correct those wrongs within a reasonable time.” · 8 citing courts
16
GREENLeyva v. Garcia, 20 Cal. App. 5th 1095 (Ct. App. 2018).
cites § 413 1×cited by 26 cases
Where it cites § 413
“In this supplemental paper, plaintiffs argued that because defendant apparently disposed of the wall heater, the trial court should consider evidentiary sanctions against defendant for spoliation of evidence, including an adverse inference under Evidence Code section 413 that…”
Later courts cite it for
“a defendant may show the plaintiff does not possess evidence to support an element of the cause of action by means of presenting the plaintiff's factually devoid discovery responses from which an absence of evidence may be reasonably inferred” · 2 citing courts
17
GREENLas Palmas Assocs. v. Las Palmas Ctr. Assocs., 235 Cal. App. 3d 1220 (Ct. App. 1991).
cites § 413 1×cited by 182 cases
Where it cites § 413
“2d 778 ]; Evid. Code, § 413.) We next turn to whether buyers’ attorney misrepresented the price his clients paid for the shopping center.”
The case’s holding
The conditions under which a corporate entity may be disregarded vary (basis: judicial discretion in piercing the corporate veil).
Later courts cite it for
“it is the general rule that the conditions under which a corporate entity may be disregarded vary according to the circumstances of each case.” · 7 citing courts
18
GREENCnty. of San Bernardino v. Walsh, 158 Cal. App. 4th 533 (Ct. App. 2007).
cites § 413 1×cited by 55 cases
Where it cites § 413
“As stated by the trial court, “[i]n determining what inferences to draw from the evidence or facts in the case against a party, the trier of fact may consider, among other things, the party’s failure to explain or to deny by his testimony such evidence or facts in the case…”
The case’s holding
A defendant may be required to disgorge the amount of their unjust enrichment even if the plaintiff did not suffer a corresponding financial loss.
Later courts cite it for
“typically, the defendant's benefit and the plaintiff's loss are the same, and restitution requires the defendant to restore the plaintiff to his or her original position.” · 3 citing courts
19
GREENCalifornia Fair Emp. & Hous. Comm'n v. Gemini Aluminum Corp., 122 Cal. App. 4th 1004 (Ct. App. 2004).
cites § 413 1×cited by 50 cases
Where it cites § 413
“514 ]; Evid. Code, § 413.) In any event, the burden does not shift to the employee to prove that the employer’s proffered reason is a pretext until the employer shows “that the procedure by which the employee was terminated was ‘validly and fairly devised and administered to…”
The case’s holding
An employer violates the law by failing to make good faith efforts to accommodate religious observances and by retaliating against employees who protest such failures.
Later courts cite it for
“knew the plaintiff was a jehovah's witness and wanted the days off to attend his annual religious convention.” · 2 citing courts
20
GREENMEGA Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court, 172 Cal. App. 4th 1522 (Ct. App. 2009).
cites § 413 1×cited by 47 cases
Where it cites § 413
“6 The court also relied heavily on the fact that the party claiming to have been injured by the “wrong” had existing remedies of both sanctions under the discovery statutes (e.”
The case’s holding
A person must allege and prove actual reliance on misrepresentations to maintain a claim for fraud.
Later courts cite it for
“we, of course, are not bound by the decision of a sister court of appeal. but 'we respect stare decisis, however, which serves the important goals of stability in the law and predictability of decision.” · 4 citing courts

Show all 111 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
196819972026

One bar per year. Tallest: 8 cases in 2025. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Cal. Ct. App.90Cal.15Cal. Ct. App. 5th29th Cir.1C.D. Cal.1Cal. App. Dep’t Super. Ct.1N.D. Cal.1
By subsection

Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.

Show all 111 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

California Codes Home  |  Search California  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com