Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
15 Alabama opinions name it 2 courts 1853–1930 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by Alabama courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in Alabama. | ||
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Alabama. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
First National Bank v. Allen
green
1 sentence1930The only ease coming to our attention, where the fraud of the agent would not affect the general rule, is First National Bank of Birmingham v. Allen, 100 Ala. 476 , 14 So. 335 , 27 L. | 1 | 1930–1930 |
Nolen v. East
neutral
2 sentences1929Nolen v. East, 181 Ala. 226 , 61 So. 261 . 1929Nolen v. East, 181 Ala. 226 , 61 So. 261 . | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Adler v. Martin
green
2 sentences1912The plaintiff, when he received his injuries, was crossing the street at a regular street crossing for pedestrians; and we find nothing in the disputed state of the facts which takes this case out of the operation of the general rule that negligence is not imputed, as a matter of law, to persons crossing a street at a regular crossing for pedestrians without stopping, looking, and listening for automobiles or other vehicles. — Adler v. Martin, 179 Ala. 97 , 59 South. 597 . (1) The evidence was in dispute as to how the plaintiff held his umbrella on the occasion of the injury. 1912The plaintiff, when he received his injuries, was crossing the street at a regular street crossing for pedestrians; and we find nothing in the disputed state of the facts which takes this case out of the operation of the general rule that negligence is not imputed, as a matter of law, to persons crossing a street at a regular crossing for pedestrians without stopping, looking, and listening for automobiles or other vehicles. — Adler v. Martin, 179 Ala. 97 , 59 South. 597 . (1) The evidence was in dispute as to how the plaintiff held his umbrella on the occasion of the injury. | 1 | 1912–1912 |
Doe ex dem. McPherson v. Walters
neutral
1 sentence1898We have reached the conclusion, that the courts can make no exception, based on sound and just principles which would exclude railroad companies from the operation of the general rule, that in actions of ejectment at law the legal title must prevail.” — Hawkins v. Ross, 100 Ala. 459 ; Walker v. Murphy, 34 Ala. 591 ; Nelson v. Kelly, 91 Ala. 569 ; McCarty v. Woodstock Iron Co., 92 Ala. 468 ; Morgan v. Carey, 73 Ala. 222 ; McPherson v. Walters, 16 Ala. 714 . | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Walker's Heirs v. Murphy
neutral
1 sentence1898We have reached the conclusion, that the courts can make no exception, based on sound and just principles which would exclude railroad companies from the operation of the general rule, that in actions of ejectment at law the legal title must prevail.” — Hawkins v. Ross, 100 Ala. 459 ; Walker v. Murphy, 34 Ala. 591 ; Nelson v. Kelly, 91 Ala. 569 ; McCarty v. Woodstock Iron Co., 92 Ala. 468 ; Morgan v. Carey, 73 Ala. 222 ; McPherson v. Walters, 16 Ala. 714 . | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Morgan v. Casey
neutral
1 sentence1898We have reached the conclusion, that the courts can make no exception, based on sound and just principles which would exclude railroad companies from the operation of the general rule, that in actions of ejectment at law the legal title must prevail.” — Hawkins v. Ross, 100 Ala. 459 ; Walker v. Murphy, 34 Ala. 591 ; Nelson v. Kelly, 91 Ala. 569 ; McCarty v. Woodstock Iron Co., 92 Ala. 468 ; Morgan v. Carey, 73 Ala. 222 ; McPherson v. Walters, 16 Ala. 714 . | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Nelson v. Kelly
neutral
1 sentence1898We have reached the conclusion, that the courts can make no exception, based on sound and just principles which would exclude railroad companies from the operation of the general rule, that in actions of ejectment at law the legal title must prevail.” — Hawkins v. Ross, 100 Ala. 459 ; Walker v. Murphy, 34 Ala. 591 ; Nelson v. Kelly, 91 Ala. 569 ; McCarty v. Woodstock Iron Co., 92 Ala. 468 ; Morgan v. Carey, 73 Ala. 222 ; McPherson v. Walters, 16 Ala. 714 . | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Hawkins v. Ross
neutral
1 sentence1898We have reached the conclusion, that the courts can make no exception, based on sound and just principles which would exclude railroad companies from the operation of the general rule, that in actions of ejectment at law the legal title must prevail.” — Hawkins v. Ross, 100 Ala. 459 ; Walker v. Murphy, 34 Ala. 591 ; Nelson v. Kelly, 91 Ala. 569 ; McCarty v. Woodstock Iron Co., 92 Ala. 468 ; Morgan v. Carey, 73 Ala. 222 ; McPherson v. Walters, 16 Ala. 714 . | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Morrison v. Stevenson
green
1 sentence1896As was said in Bercy v. Lavretta, supra: “Whoever relies on the exception, to relieve him from the operation of the general rule, must- state facts which show he is within the exception.” And as was said in Morrison v. Stevenson, supra: “In its nature and operation the statute creates an exception to the general statute of limitations — it withdraws a particular case, which otherwise would fall within the words and bar of the statute. | 1 | 1896–1896 |
Bercy v. Lavretta
neutral
1 sentence1896As was said in Bercy v. Lavretta, supra: “Whoever relies on the exception, to relieve him from the operation of the general rule, must- state facts which show he is within the exception.” And as was said in Morrison v. Stevenson, supra: “In its nature and operation the statute creates an exception to the general statute of limitations — it withdraws a particular case, which otherwise would fall within the words and bar of the statute. | 1 | 1896–1896 |
Lytle's Exec'r v. Pope's Adm'r
neutral
1 sentence1889Not having paid more than the amount for which he was absolutely liable, his estate is not entitled to contribution, unless there are circumstances which take the case out of the operation of the general rule. — Ex parte Gifford, 6 Ves. 805; Davies v. Humphries, 6 M. & W. 152; Lyttle v. Pope, 11 B. | 1 | 1889–1889 |
Pollock & Co. v. Gantt
green
1 sentence1888We need only to refer to the following cases: Brigham v. Carlisle, 78 Ala. 243 ; Union Refining Co. v. Barton, 77 Ala. 148 ; Pollock v. Gantt, 69 Ala. 373 ; Beck v. West, ante, p. 213. | 1 | 1888–1888 |
Union Refining Co. v. Barton
neutral
1 sentence1888We need only to refer to the following cases: Brigham v. Carlisle, 78 Ala. 243 ; Union Refining Co. v. Barton, 77 Ala. 148 ; Pollock v. Gantt, 69 Ala. 373 ; Beck v. West, ante, p. 213. | 1 | 1888–1888 |
Brigham & Co. v. Carlisle
green
1 sentence1888We need only to refer to the following cases: Brigham v. Carlisle, 78 Ala. 243 ; Union Refining Co. v. Barton, 77 Ala. 148 ; Pollock v. Gantt, 69 Ala. 373 ; Beck v. West, ante, p. 213. | 1 | 1888–1888 |
State v. Bradshaw's Adm'r
neutral
1 sentence1887This principle was expressly decided in State v. Bradshaw, 60 Ala. 239 . | 1 | 1887–1887 |
Wickersham v. Chicago Zinc Co.
neutral
1 sentence1886It would be both unjust and unreasonable to impute notice by mere construction under such circum stances, and such is tlie established rule of law on this subject. — Terrell v. Branch Bank of Mobile, 12 Ala. 502 ; Lucas v. Bank of Darien, 2 Stew. 321 ; Wickersham v. Chicago Zinc Company ( 18 Kan. 481 ), 26 Amer. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Rake's Adm'r v. Pope
green
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Terrell v. Branch Bank at Mobile
green
1 sentence1886It would be both unjust and unreasonable to impute notice by mere construction under such circum stances, and such is tlie established rule of law on this subject. — Terrell v. Branch Bank of Mobile, 12 Ala. 502 ; Lucas v. Bank of Darien, 2 Stew. 321 ; Wickersham v. Chicago Zinc Company ( 18 Kan. 481 ), 26 Amer. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Tarleton v. Johnson
neutral
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Thomason v. Odum
green
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Patton v. Hamner
neutral
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Hopkinson v. Shelton
neutral
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Gilbreath v. Jones
neutral
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Burt v. Sternburgh
neutral
1 sentence1886Ev.,, § 528; Freeman on Judgments, § 257; Rakes v. Pope, 7 Ala. 161 ; Tarleton v. Johnson, 25 Ala. 300 ; Thomason v. Odum, 31 Ala. 108 ; Patton v. Hamner, 33 Ala. 307 ; Hopkinson v. Shelton, 37 Ala. 306 ; Gilbreath v. Jones, 66 Ala. 129 ; Parker v. Thompson, 3 Pick. 429 ; Burt v. Sternburgh, 4 Cow. 559 ; Shuttlesworth v. Hughey, 9 Rich. | 1 | 1886–1886 |
Kidd v. Montague
neutral
1 sentence1879The fund in controversy accrued to the several claimants, legatees, under the will, or by descent; and, unless there be peculiar circumstances in this case, taking it out of the operation of the general rule, our statutes known as the ‘woman’s law’ having nothing to do with the case. — Kidd v. Montague, 19 Ala. 619 . | 1 | 1879–1879 |
Cameron v. Logan
neutral
1 sentence1878If there be nothing in this case to take it without the operation of the general rule, the position is well taken. — Me Cartney v. King, 25 Ala. 681 ; Ricks v. Dillahunty, 8 Par. 134; Worthington v. McRoberts, 9 Ala. 297 ; Burns v. Hamilton, 33 Ala. 210 ; Tudor v. Taylor, 26 Ver. 444; Dunn v. Frazier, 8 Blackf. 432 ; Anderson v. Faulks, 2 Harris & Gill, 346; Cameron v. Logan, 8 Iowa, 434 ; Fox v. Marsh, 3 W. & Serg., 444; Dean v. Morris, 4 Iowa, 312 ; Rodgers v. Smith, 2 Carter, Ind. 526; Mellen v. Boatman, 13 Sm. & Mar. 100; The Monte Allegre, 9 Wheat, 516; Thompson v. Munger, 15 Tex. 523 . | 1 | 1878–1878 |
Worthington v. McRoberts
neutral
1 sentence1878If there be nothing in this case to take it without the operation of the general rule, the position is well taken. — Me Cartney v. King, 25 Ala. 681 ; Ricks v. Dillahunty, 8 Par. 134; Worthington v. McRoberts, 9 Ala. 297 ; Burns v. Hamilton, 33 Ala. 210 ; Tudor v. Taylor, 26 Ver. 444; Dunn v. Frazier, 8 Blackf. 432 ; Anderson v. Faulks, 2 Harris & Gill, 346; Cameron v. Logan, 8 Iowa, 434 ; Fox v. Marsh, 3 W. & Serg., 444; Dean v. Morris, 4 Iowa, 312 ; Rodgers v. Smith, 2 Carter, Ind. 526; Mellen v. Boatman, 13 Sm. & Mar. 100; The Monte Allegre, 9 Wheat, 516; Thompson v. Munger, 15 Tex. 523 . | 1 | 1878–1878 |
McCartney v. King
neutral
1 sentence1878If there be nothing in this case to take it without the operation of the general rule, the position is well taken. — Me Cartney v. King, 25 Ala. 681 ; Ricks v. Dillahunty, 8 Par. 134; Worthington v. McRoberts, 9 Ala. 297 ; Burns v. Hamilton, 33 Ala. 210 ; Tudor v. Taylor, 26 Ver. 444; Dunn v. Frazier, 8 Blackf. 432 ; Anderson v. Faulks, 2 Harris & Gill, 346; Cameron v. Logan, 8 Iowa, 434 ; Fox v. Marsh, 3 W. & Serg., 444; Dean v. Morris, 4 Iowa, 312 ; Rodgers v. Smith, 2 Carter, Ind. 526; Mellen v. Boatman, 13 Sm. & Mar. 100; The Monte Allegre, 9 Wheat, 516; Thompson v. Munger, 15 Tex. 523 . | 1 | 1878–1878 |
Burns v. Hamilton's Adm'r
neutral
1 sentence1878If there be nothing in this case to take it without the operation of the general rule, the position is well taken. — Me Cartney v. King, 25 Ala. 681 ; Ricks v. Dillahunty, 8 Par. 134; Worthington v. McRoberts, 9 Ala. 297 ; Burns v. Hamilton, 33 Ala. 210 ; Tudor v. Taylor, 26 Ver. 444; Dunn v. Frazier, 8 Blackf. 432 ; Anderson v. Faulks, 2 Harris & Gill, 346; Cameron v. Logan, 8 Iowa, 434 ; Fox v. Marsh, 3 W. & Serg., 444; Dean v. Morris, 4 Iowa, 312 ; Rodgers v. Smith, 2 Carter, Ind. 526; Mellen v. Boatman, 13 Sm. & Mar. 100; The Monte Allegre, 9 Wheat, 516; Thompson v. Munger, 15 Tex. 523 . | 1 | 1878–1878 |
| Dunn v. Frazier neutral | 1 | 1878–1878 |
Thompson v. Munger
neutral
1 sentence1878If there be nothing in this case to take it without the operation of the general rule, the position is well taken. — Me Cartney v. King, 25 Ala. 681 ; Ricks v. Dillahunty, 8 Par. 134; Worthington v. McRoberts, 9 Ala. 297 ; Burns v. Hamilton, 33 Ala. 210 ; Tudor v. Taylor, 26 Ver. 444; Dunn v. Frazier, 8 Blackf. 432 ; Anderson v. Faulks, 2 Harris & Gill, 346; Cameron v. Logan, 8 Iowa, 434 ; Fox v. Marsh, 3 W. & Serg., 444; Dean v. Morris, 4 Iowa, 312 ; Rodgers v. Smith, 2 Carter, Ind. 526; Mellen v. Boatman, 13 Sm. & Mar. 100; The Monte Allegre, 9 Wheat, 516; Thompson v. Munger, 15 Tex. 523 . | 1 | 1878–1878 |
| Bristow v. Jones neutral | 1 | 1863–1863 |
| Borland v. Mayo green | 1 | 1863–1863 |
| Abney v. Kingsland & Co. green | 1 | 1863–1863 |
| Moore v. Barclay green | 1 | 1863–1863 |
| Newcombe v. Leavitt neutral | 1 | 1863–1863 |
| Benje v. Creagh's Adm'r green | 1 | 1853–1853 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.