evaluation factors (Michigan) · Go Syfert
← Michigan issues

evaluation factors in Michigan

12 Michigan opinions name it 2 courts 1991–2022 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Michigan courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
United States v. Dominguez Benitezgreen
scotus · 2004 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
2 sentences

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

11
United States v. Olanogreen
scotus · 1993 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
2 sentences

2015Olano, 507 US at 737 (“[A] plain error affecting substantial rights does not, without more, satisfy the [fourth prong], for otherwise the discretion afforded by [the plain error test] would be illusory.”) (emphasis added).

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

11
Neder v. United Statesgreen
scotus · 1999 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
2 sentences

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Michigan. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

CaseCitedYears
Vicencio v. Ramirez green
michctapp · 1995
2 sentences

2017In Grimm, 291 Mich App at 149 - 150, this Court stated and ruled: -5- Petitioner contends that this Court's evaluation of factors analogous to those cited in Vicencio v Jaime Ramirez, MD, PC, 211 Mich App 501 ; 536 NW2d 280 (1995), would indicate that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion and urges the adoption of similar factors here.

2017In Grimm, 291 Mich App at 149 - 150, this Court stated and ruled: -5- Petitioner contends that this Court's evaluation of factors analogous to those cited in Vicencio v Jaime Ramirez, MD, PC, 211 Mich App 501 ; 536 NW2d 280 (1995), would indicate that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion and urges the adoption of similar factors here.

32010–2017
People v. Hardin green
mich · 1985
2 sentences

2018The evaluation of an instruction’s potential coercive effect should also consider “whether the court required, or threatened to require, the jury to deliberate for an unreasonable length of time or for unreasonable intervals.” Id. at 316 .

2016The evaluation of an instruction’s potential coercive effect should also consider “whether the court required, or threatened to require, the jury to deliberate for an unreasonable length of time or for unreasonable intervals.” Id. at 316 .

22016–2018
Grimm v. Department of Treasury green
michctapp · 2010
2 sentences

2017In Grimm, 291 Mich App at 149 - 150, this Court stated and ruled: -5- Petitioner contends that this Court's evaluation of factors analogous to those cited in Vicencio v Jaime Ramirez, MD, PC, 211 Mich App 501 ; 536 NW2d 280 (1995), would indicate that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion and urges the adoption of similar factors here.

2017In Grimm, 291 Mich App at 149 - 150, this Court stated and ruled: -5- Petitioner contends that this Court's evaluation of factors analogous to those cited in Vicencio v Jaime Ramirez, MD, PC, 211 Mich App 501 ; 536 NW2d 280 (1995), would indicate that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion and urges the adoption of similar factors here.

22017–2017
People v. Swain green
michctapp · 2010
2 sentences

2015In Swain, 288 Mich App at 638 , this Court described the standard as requiring a defendant to demonstrate that it is more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have found the defendant guilty.

2014In Swain, 288 Mich App at 638 , this Court described the standard as requiring a defendant to demonstrate that it is more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have found the defendant guilty.

22014–2015
Herrera v. Collins green
scotus · 1993
2 sentences

2015Herrera itself declined to precisely identify what standard would apply to the evaluation of such a claim, explaining only that it “would necessarily be extraordinarily high.” See Herrera, 506 US at 417 .

2014Herrera itself declined to precisely identify what standard would apply to the evaluation of such a claim, explaining only that it “would necessarily be extraordinarily high.” See Herrera, 506 US at 417 .

22014–2015
Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency green
scotus · 2002
1 sentence

2022The Supreme Court first noted that it is “inappropriate to treat cases involving physical takings as controlling precedents for the evaluation of a claim that there has been a ‘regulatory taking[.]’ ” Id. at 323 .

12022–2022
In Re Brown green
mich · 1999
2 sentences

2019This recommendation is based on the following evaluation of the factors set forth in In re Brown, 461 Mich. 1291 , 1292-1293; 625 N.W.2d 744 (1999).

2019This recommendation is based on the following evaluation of the factors set forth in In re Brown, 461 Mich. 1291 , 1292-1293; 625 N.W.2d 744 (1999).

12019–2019
People v. Goldsmith green
mich · 1981
2 sentences

2016Additionally, an instruction is coercive if it directs the jury to reach a unanimous verdict “as part of its civic duty” and “contains the message that the failure to reach a verdict constitutes a failure of purpose.” Id., citing People v Goldsmith, 411 Mich 555, 561 ; 309 NW2d 182 (1981).

2016Additionally, an instruction is coercive if it directs the jury to reach a unanimous verdict “as part of its civic duty” and “contains the message that the failure to reach a verdict constitutes a failure of purpose.” Id., citing People v Goldsmith, 411 Mich 555, 561 ; 309 NW2d 182 (1981).

12016–2016
Rose v. Clark green
scotus · 1986
1 sentence

2015In short, structural errors carry with them Olano’s something “more” that is required to establish the fourth prong. 74 71 Neder, 527 US at 8 (quotation marks and citation omitted). 72 Id. at 8-9 , quoting Rose, 478 US at 577-578 ; see also United States v Dominguez Benitez, 542 US 74, 81 ; 124 S Ct 2333 ; 159 L Ed 2d 157 (2004) (characterizing structural errors as those that “undermin[e] the fairness of a criminal proceeding as a whole”). 73 See Berger, Moving Toward Law: Refocusing the Federal Courts’ Plain Error Doctrine in Criminal Cases, 67 U Miami L Rev 521, 544 (2013) (“[T]he third and

12015–2015
People v. Dendel green
mich · 2008
1 sentence

2012The trial court’s determinations indicate that it credited defense counsel’s testimony and held that counsel’s defense strategy was objectively reasonable. “ ‘[Rjegard shall be given to the special opportunity of the trial court to judge the credibility of the witnesses who appeared before it.’ ” Dendel, 481 Mich at 130 , quoting MCR 2.613(C).

12012–2012
Woodworth v. Woodworth green
michctapp · 1983
1 sentence

1991Woodworth, supra, pp 268-269 , discussed two methods of compensating a nonstudent spouse for an interest in an advanced degree: (1) awarding a percentage share of the present value of the future earnings attributable to the degree, or (2) restitution.

11991–1991

Statutes the citing opinions construe

MI § Mich. Comp. Laws § 205.735a (3) MI § Mich. Comp. Laws § 750.227b (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

NJ 178 (1964–2026) CA 32 (1976–2026) TX 28 (1986–2026) IL 24 (1978–2025) MN 20 (1987–2025) PA 19 (1979–2026) NY 15 (1972–2024) OH 13 (1985–2025) WA 12 (2009–2024) MI 12 (1991–2022) NM 11 (1972–2023) CT 11 (1977–2024) LA 11 (1999–2022) MA 8 (1989–2023) GA 8 (1981–2021) FL 7 (1982–2003) NC 7 (2020–2023) ID 6 (1983–2012) MO 5 (1973–2015) CO 5 (1994–2018) VT 4 (1971–2007) UT 4 (1980–2017) NH 3 (1994–1997) MT 3 (1982–2019) ME 3 (2011–2015) OR 3 (2014–2026) AL 2 (1978–2004) WV 2 (2005–2017) SC 2 (2015–2021) NE 2 (2016–2025) KS 2 (2001–2014) WI 2 (2004–2008) AK 2 (1972–1978) AZ 2 (2018–2022) DC 2 (1992–1994) HI 2 (1986–2020) IA 2 (2005–2014) DE 2 (2021–2023)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check