51 Pennsylvania opinions name it 6 courts 1883–2026 8 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by Pennsylvania courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital of the Sisters of Christian Charitygreen2 sentences2021See Octave, 103 A.3d 1255 ; Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hosp. of the Sisters of Christian Charity, 32 A.3d 800, 808 (Pa. Super. 2011). 2021See Octave, 103 A.3d 1255 ; Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hosp. of the Sisters of Christian Charity, 32 A.3d 800, 808 (Pa. Super. 2011). | 3 | 3 |
United States v. Narcisogreen2 sentences2020The Court continued, “‘the very words of the rule ― ‘interest of justice’ ― mandate the broadest inquiry into the nature of the challenged proceeding.” Id. (quoting United States v. Narciso, 446 F.Supp. 252, 304 (E.D. 2017In United States v. Narciso, 446 F.Supp. 252, 304 (E.D.Mich. 1977), the [district] court stated that “the very words of the rule—‘interest of justice’—mandate the broadest inquiry into the nature of -3- J-S23045-17 the challenged proceeding.” A judge granting a new trial under this Rule need assign no reason other than it is required in the interest of justice. | 3 | 3 |
Commonwealth v. Phillipsgreen2 sentences2022Commonwealth v. Phillips, 141 A.3d 512, 518 (Pa. Super. 2016) (case citations and original brackets omitted), appeal denied, 161 A.3d 796 (Pa. 2016). 20 We recognize that while the filing of a post-sentence motion is optional, a defendant is required to file such a motion when challenging the verdict on weight of the evidence grounds or when the challenge involves the discretionary aspects of sentence in order to preserve such issues for appellate review. 2021Phillips, supra at 518 (cleaned up). | 2 | 2 |
Octave ex rel. Octave v. Walkergreen2 sentences2021See Octave, 103 A.3d 1255 ; Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hosp. of the Sisters of Christian Charity, 32 A.3d 800, 808 (Pa. Super. 2011). 2021See Octave, 103 A.3d 1255 ; Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hosp. of the Sisters of Christian Charity, 32 A.3d 800, 808 (Pa. Super. 2011). | 2 | 2 |
Bednar v. Dana Corp.green2 sentences2013Pa.R.C.P. 127; Bednar v. Dana Corp., 962 A.2d 1232, 1236 (Pa.Super.2008). 2011When the words of a rule are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit. (c) When the words of a rule are not explicit, the intention of the Supreme Court may be ascertained by considering, among other matters (1) the occasion and necessity for the rule; (2) the circumstances under which it was promulgated; (3) the mischief to be remedied; (4) the object to be attained; (5) the prior practice, if any, including other rules and Acts of Assembly upon the same or similar subjects; (6) the consequences of a particular inter | 2 | 2 |
Smith v. Morrell Beer Distributors, Inc.green1 sentence2024Smith v. Morrell Beer Distribs., Inc., 29 A.3d 23, 25 (Pa. Super. 2011). | 1 | 1 |
Commonwealth v. Moralesgreen1 sentence2024Pa.R.J.A. 108(b). -6- J-S44025-24 Rule of Evidence 804(b)(6) sets forth the hearsay exception known as “forfeiture by wrongdoing.” See Pa.R.E. 804(b)(6); Commonwealth v. Morales, 91 A.3d 80, 94 (Pa. 2014). | 1 | 1 |
In re Interest of S.S.P.green1 sentence2022See, e.g., Estate of Benyo, 233 A.3d at 782, Commonwealth by Shapiro, 194 A.3d at 1027 ; Giulian, 141 A.3d at 1267 ; Roethlein, 81 A.3d at 822 . | 1 | 1 |
Meadows v. Goodmangreen2 sentences2020Any other action or proceeding to recover damages for injury to person or property which is founded on negligent, intentional, or otherwise tortious conduct[.]” 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5524(7); see also Meadows v. Goodman, 993 A.2d 912, 915 (Pa. Super. 2010) (“The statute of limitations for a personal injury claim is two years.”). -5- J-S22029-20 (c) When the words of a rule are not explicit, the intention of the Supreme Court may be ascertained by considering, among other matters (1) the occasion and necessity for the rule; (2) the circumstances under which it was promulgated; (3) the mischief to be r 2020Any other action or proceeding to recover damages for injury to person or property which is founded on negligent, intentional, or otherwise tortious conduct[.]” 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5524(7); see also Meadows v. Goodman, 993 A.2d 912, 915 (Pa. Super. 2010) (“The statute of limitations for a personal injury claim is two years.”). -5- J-S22029-20 (c) When the words of a rule are not explicit, the intention of the Supreme Court may be ascertained by considering, among other matters (1) the occasion and necessity for the rule; (2) the circumstances under which it was promulgated; (3) the mischief to be r | 1 | 1 |
Willits v. Fryergreen1 sentence2018When the words of a rule are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.” Willits, 734 A.2d at 427 (citation to Pa.R.Civ.P. reformatted). | 1 | 1 |
Tillery, S. v. The Children's Hospital of Phila.green1 sentence2018Tillery v. Children’s Hosp. of Philadelphia, 156 A.3d 1233, 1249 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal denied, 172 A.3d 592 (Pa. 2017) (case citation omitted). | 1 | 1 |
Vogelsberger v. Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC Health Systemgreen1 sentence2017Vogelsberger v. Magee-Womens Hosp. of UPMC Health System, 903 A.2d 540, 550 (Pa. Super. 2006). | 1 | 1 |
Roth v. Rossgreen1 sentence2017Roth v. Ross, 85 A.3d 590, 592-93 (Pa. Super. 2014) (case citations and some quotation marks omitted). | 1 | 1 |
Sahutsky v. H.H. Knoebel Sonsgreen1 sentence2013Knoebel Sons, t/a Knoebel’s Grove, 566 Pa. 593 , 782 A.2d 996, 998 (2001) citing Pa.R.C.P. -127 (“When the words of a rule [of civil procedure] are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.”). | 1 | 1 |
| Searles v. Estradagreen | 1 | 1 |
| Woods v. Commonwealth Department of Transportationred | 1 | 1 |
| Pullium v. Laurel School Districtgreen | 1 | 1 |
| United States v. Smithgreen | 1 | 1 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Pennsylvania. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
Lough v. Spring
green
2 sentences2007Hines, 607 A.2d at 303 (quoting Lough v. Spring, 383 Pa.Super. 85 , 556 A.2d 441 , 443 n. 2 (1989)). 1992However, regarding application of Rule 126, we are in agreement with the Superior Court that: [i]n interpreting the rules of procedure in light of Rule 126, we also remain mindful of Pa.R.C.P. 127(b), which states ‘[w]hen the words of a rule are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded *194 under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.’ Thus, although the rules are to be liberally construed, a party seeking redress cannot substantially deviate from the clear mandates of the rules for filing an appeal from an arbitration award; Lough v. Spring, 383 Pa.Superior Ct | 2 | 1992–2007 |
Williamson v. McClure
neutral
2 sentences1933So, also, as is stated in that case at pages 292-3: “In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: ‘The words of that clause would, if taken alone, bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential provisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.’ To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed 1933In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: “The words of that clause would, if taken alone, *293 bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential pi'ovisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.” To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed but a necessary conclusion from the maxim ex a | 2 | 1933–1933 |
Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corp.
neutral
2 sentences1933So, also, as is stated in that case at pages 292-3: “In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: ‘The words of that clause would, if taken alone, bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential provisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.’ To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed 1933In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: “The words of that clause would, if taken alone, *293 bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential pi'ovisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.” To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed but a necessary conclusion from the maxim ex a | 2 | 1933–1933 |
Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Bor. of Saltsburg
neutral
2 sentences1933So, also, as is stated in that case at pages 292-3: “In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: ‘The words of that clause would, if taken alone, bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential provisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.’ To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed 1933In Williamson v. McClure, 37 Pa. 402, 412 , we said: “The words of that clause would, if taken alone, *293 bear the construction placed upon them, but the parties did not place them alone, but connected them with other essential pi'ovisions, and we must read them as they wrote them, and give them the effect, but no more than the effect, which they intended they should have.” To the same effect are Saltsburg Gas Co. v. Saltsburg Boro., 138 Pa. 250, 254 , and Berkley v. Maxwell Motor Sales Corporation, 70 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 422 ; and it is indeed but a necessary conclusion from the maxim ex a | 2 | 1933–1933 |
Ex Relatione Scott v. Jailer
green
2 sentences1929But we must not lose sight of the main object of the statute, which was to relieve from imprisonment in all cases where no offense appears, except that of omitting to pay money due on a contract”: Scott v. The Jailer, supra, page 238. 1883He said the ruling was concurred in by all the judges of the court, except one who was absent: Scott’s Case, 1 Grant 237 ; 2 Phila. 153 . | 2 | 1883–1929 |
Jones v. Wagner
green
2 sentences1903The contention of the plaintiff is that Hopkins must pay, becaus.e a covenant to protect it is found in the following words of the clause quoted: ‘ And all damages direct or consequential and claims therefor, resulting from the mining and removal of said coal, in the doing of any and all the matters and things hereinbefore described, are hereby waived and relinquished by the said party of the first part but, even if it be true that such covenant is there found, the concluding words, ‘ provided the party of the second part takes all ordinary precautions usually taken in mining and removing coal 1901The contention of the plaintiff is that Hopkins must pay, because a covenant to protect it is found in the following words of the clause quoted: “And all damages direct or consequential and claims therefor, resulting from the mining and removal of said coal, in the doing of any and all the matters and things hereinbefore described, are hereby waived and relinquished by the said party of the first part; ” but, even if it be true that such covenant is there found, the concluding words, “ provided the party of the second part takes all ordinary precautions usually taken in mining and removing coa | 2 | 1901–1903 |
A.S. v. Pennsylvania State Police
green
1 sentence2026Id. (c)(1-7). | 1 | 2026–2026 |
Commonwealth v. Giulian v. Aplt.
green
1 sentence2022See, e.g., Estate of Benyo, 233 A.3d at 782, Commonwealth by Shapiro, 194 A.3d at 1027 ; Giulian, 141 A.3d at 1267 ; Roethlein, 81 A.3d at 822 . | 1 | 2022–2022 |
Roethlein v. Portnoff Law Associates, Ltd.
green
1 sentence2022See, e.g., Estate of Benyo, 233 A.3d at 782, Commonwealth by Shapiro, 194 A.3d at 1027 ; Giulian, 141 A.3d at 1267 ; Roethlein, 81 A.3d at 822 . | 1 | 2022–2022 |
Schneller v. Cavanaugh-Kerr
green
1 sentence2022Commonwealth v. Phillips, 141 A.3d 512, 518 (Pa. Super. 2016) (case citations and original brackets omitted), appeal denied, 161 A.3d 796 (Pa. 2016). 20 We recognize that while the filing of a post-sentence motion is optional, a defendant is required to file such a motion when challenging the verdict on weight of the evidence grounds or when the challenge involves the discretionary aspects of sentence in order to preserve such issues for appellate review. | 1 | 2022–2022 |
Commonwealth v. Powell
green
1 sentence2020The Court continued, “‘the very words of the rule ― ‘interest of justice’ ― mandate the broadest inquiry into the nature of the challenged proceeding.” Id. (quoting United States v. Narciso, 446 F.Supp. 252, 304 (E.D. | 1 | 2020–2020 |
Brown v. Quest Diagnostics Clinical Labs., Inc.
green
1 sentence2020If “the words of a rule are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.” Id. | 1 | 2020–2020 |
Zielke v. Mullen
green
1 sentence2018Tillery v. Children’s Hosp. of Philadelphia, 156 A.3d 1233, 1249 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal denied, 172 A.3d 592 (Pa. 2017) (case citation omitted). | 1 | 2018–2018 |
Lamar Advantage GP Co. v. City of Pittsburgh
green
1 sentence2016No. 127(b). ‘When the words of a rule are clear and free, from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.” Id. | 1 | 2016–2016 |
Lennon v. Board of Probation Parole
green
1 sentence2013Knoebel Sons, t/a Knoebel’s Grove, 566 Pa. 593 , 782 A.2d 996, 998 (2001) citing Pa.R.C.P. -127 (“When the words of a rule [of civil procedure] are clear and free from all ambiguity, the letter of it is not to be disregarded under the pretext of pursuing its spirit.”). | 1 | 2013–2013 |
Boatin v. Miller
green
1 sentence2011Furthermore, "a note to a rule or an explanatory comment is not a part of the rule, but may be used in construing the rule." Boatin, supra at 427 , citing Pa.R.C.P. 129(e). | 1 | 2011–2011 |
| Hines v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority green | 1 | 2007–2007 |
| Holz v. Holz green | 1 | 2007–2007 |
| LaRue v. McGuire green | 1 | 2006–2006 |
| Jones v. Rivera green | 1 | 2005–2005 |
| Dollar Bank v. Northwood Cheese Co. green | 1 | 1999–1999 |
| Hough v. COM., DEPT. OF TRANSP. green | 1 | 1996–1996 |
| Menarde v. Southeastern Pennsylvania TransporTation Authority green | 1 | 1992–1992 |
| Briga v. Ken-Tuck Signs, Inc. green | 1 | 1992–1992 |
| Black & Brown, Inc. v. Home for the Accepted, Inc. green | 1 | 1992–1992 |
| Meta v. Yellow Cab Co. green | 1 | 1992–1992 |
| Wilk v. Girard Bank green | 1 | 1989–1989 |
| Laudenberger v. Port Auth. of Allegheny green | 1 | 1983–1983 |
| Baker v. Roslyn Swim Club green | 1 | 1976–1976 |
| Kopar v. MAMONE green | 1 | 1971–1971 |
| Nanty-Glo Boro. v. American Surety Co. green | 1 | 1971–1971 |
| Schuster v. Largman neutral | 1 | 1952–1952 |
| Morris v. American Liability & Surety Co. green | 1 | 1951–1951 |
| Hertzog v. Hertzog's Administrator green | 1 | 1943–1943 |
| Goehring's Estate neutral | 1 | 1943–1943 |
| Tursi Et Ux. v. Parry green | 1 | 1942–1942 |
| Pierce v. Boalick neutral | 1 | 1937–1937 |
| McCord's Estate green | 1 | 1929–1929 |
| In re Estate of Moran neutral | 1 | 1917–1917 |
| Downer v. Downer neutral | 1 | 1917–1917 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.