has always rule (Texas) · Go Syfert
← Texas issues

has always rule in Texas

10 Texas opinions name it 2 courts 1885–1935 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Texas courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (0)

CaseFollowedCited
No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in Texas.

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Texas. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (18)

CaseCitedYears
Kampman v. Tarver neutral
tex · 1895
2 sentences

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Tex. 424 ; Selman v. Wolfe, 27 Tex. 72 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Tex. 218 , 9 S. W. 141 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Tex. 402 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Tex. 257 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Tex. 727 ; Bonner v. Hearne, 75 Tex. 252 , 12 S. W. 38 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 63 Tex. 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Tex. 497 , 29 S. W. 768 .

21915–1915
Taylor v. Hall green
tex · 1888
2 sentences

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Tex. 424 ; Selman v. Wolfe, 27 Tex. 72 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Tex. 218 , 9 S. W. 141 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Tex. 402 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Tex. 257 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Tex. 727 ; Bonner v. Hearne, 75 Tex. 252 , 12 S. W. 38 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 63 Tex. 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Tex. 497 , 29 S. W. 768 .

21915–1915
Bonner v. Hearne green
tex · 1889
2 sentences

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Tex. 424 ; Selman v. Wolfe, 27 Tex. 72 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Tex. 218 , 9 S. W. 141 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Tex. 402 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Tex. 257 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Tex. 727 ; Bonner v. Hearne, 75 Tex. 252 , 12 S. W. 38 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 63 Tex. 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Tex. 497 , 29 S. W. 768 .

21915–1915
McElroy v. Carmichael neutral
tex · 1851
1 sentence

1935The Supreme Court, as early as McElroy v. Carmichael, 6 Tex. 454 , and again in Houghton v. State, 41 Tex. 136 , and in all cases since that time, announces this as a rule, and has been universally followed from that day to this.

11935–1935
Houghton v. State neutral
tex · 1874
1 sentence

1935The Supreme Court, as early as McElroy v. Carmichael, 6 Tex. 454 , and again in Houghton v. State, 41 Tex. 136 , and in all cases since that time, announces this as a rule, and has been universally followed from that day to this.

11935–1935
Gregg v. Cole green
tex · 1849
1 sentence

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

11915–1915
Keenan v. Perry green
tex · 1859
1 sentence

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

11915–1915
Selman v. Wolfe green
tex · 1863
1 sentence

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

11915–1915
Scoby v. Sweatt neutral
tex · 1866
1 sentence

1915Bryan v. Sundberg, 5 Texas, 417 ; Selman v. Wolf, 27 Texas, 68 ; Taylor v. Hall, 71 Texas, 213 ; Cannon v. Vaughan, 12 Texas, 400 ; Keenan v. Perry, 24 Texas, 253 ; Scoby v. Sweatt, 28 Texas, 713 ; Bonner v. Hearn, 75 Texas, 242 ; Duncan v. Taylor, 62 Texas, 649 ; Kampman v. Tarver, 87 Texas, 491 .

11915–1915
Estes v. State green
texcrimapp · 1898
1 sentence

1913In the case of Estes v. State, 38 Texas Crim.

11913–1913
Young v. State neutral
texcrimapp · 1903
1 sentence

1913This has always been the rule in this court, and was specifically enforced in the case of Young v. State, 45 Texas Crim.

11913–1913
Dever v. State green
texcrimapp · 1895
1 sentence

1913It has been contended that the opinion of this court in the case of Dever v. State, 37 Texas Crim.

11913–1913
Bigham v. State green
texcrimapp · 1892
1 sentence

1912Other cases so holding: Drummond v. State, 2 Texas, 156 ; Bigham v. State, 31 Texas Crim.

11912–1912
Drummond v. Republic of Texas neutral
tex · 1847
1 sentence

1912Other cases so holding: Drummond v. State, 2 Texas, 156 ; Bigham v. State, 31 Texas Crim.

11912–1912
State v. Morris neutral
tex · 1875
1 sentence

1912(Morris v. State, 43 Texas, 372 .) However, if we did not consider the originals sent up, the printed matter on the letterhead, circular and card are copied in the statement of facts, but we hold that the trial court on its own motion or the application of either party, when it is deemed necessary, may order any original paper introduced in evidence sent to this court for our inspection.

11912–1912
Croomes v. State green
texcrimapp · 1899
1 sentence

1911In Croomes v. State, 40 Texas Crim.

11911–1911
Burrell v. State green
tex · 1857
1 sentence

1885(Johnson v. Brown, 51 Texas, 65 ; Burrell v. The State, 18 Texas, 713 ; Dixon v. The State, 15 Texas Ct. App., 271.) The court erred in refusing to allow the proposed testimony to sustain the impeached witness.

11885–1885
Johnson v. Brown green
tex · 1879
1 sentence

1885(Johnson v. Brown, 51 Texas, 65 ; Burrell v. The State, 18 Texas, 713 ; Dixon v. The State, 15 Texas Ct. App., 271.) The court erred in refusing to allow the proposed testimony to sustain the impeached witness.

11885–1885

Where else courts name it

TX 10 (1885–1935) MO 7 (1892–1943) PA 4 (1906–1966) MI 4 (1878–2010) CA 4 (1902–1970) KS 3 (1928–1935) WA 3 (1937–2023) NY 3 (1843–1976) IL 3 (1913–1993) OH 2 (1917–1954) AR 2 (1974–1979) OK 2 (1933–1935)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check