assumption analysis (Oregon) · Go Syfert
← Oregon issues

assumption analysis in Oregon

10 Oregon opinions name it 2 courts 1918–2025 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Oregon courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
State v. Burtongreen
or · 2025 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
1 sentence

2025See 373 Or at 764-65.

11
United States v. Narcisogreen
mied · 1977 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1990–1990
2 sentences

1990United States v. Narciso, 446 F. Supp. 252, 289 (E.D.Mich. 1977) (statement of patient he "was shot" admissible but statement "shot by white man" not admissible), interprets the identical provisions of the Federal Rules of Evidence, FRE 803(4), as follows: "Yet while the doctor's motive was further diagnosis, the underlying assumption of the rule requires the Court to inquire as to the declarant's motivation for giving the information.

1990United States v. Narciso, 446 F Supp 252, 289 (ED Mich 1977) (statement of patient he “was shot” admissible but statement “shot by white man” not admissible), interprets the identical provisions of the Federal Rules of Evidence, FRE 803(4), as follows: “Yet while the doctor’s motive was further diagnosis, the underlying assumption of the rule requires the Court to inquire as to the declarant’s motivation for giving the information.

11
Dixon v. Foxgreen
or · 1928 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1934–1934
2 sentences

1934See Dixon v. Fox, 127 Or. 446 ( 271 P. 593 ).

1934See Dixon v. Fox, 127 Or. 446 ( 271 P. 593 ).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oregon. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (14)

CaseCitedYears
Welch v. Johnson green
· 1919
2 sentences

2019The court nevertheless concluded that "[i]f, as the trial court expressly found, the assumption clause was inserted in the paper 'by and through a mistake or oversight of the scrivener, and without the knowledge or consent of either the grantor or grantee,' [the plaintiff] is entitled to a reformation of the deed * * *." Id. at 600 , 183 P. 776 .

2019The court nevertheless concluded that "[i]f, as the trial court expressly found, the assumption clause was inserted in the paper 'by and through a mistake or oversight of the scrivener, and without the knowledge or consent of either the grantor or grantee,' [the plaintiff] is entitled to a reformation of the deed * * *." Id. at 600 , 183 P. 776 .

12019–2019
State v. Long green
orctapp · 1991
2 sentences

1992Although they are internally sensible, Denton Plastics and State v. Long, supra , *42 are hard to reconcile with Dollarhide .

1992Although they are internally sensible, Denton Plastics and State v. Long, supra, are hard to reconcile with Dollarhide .

11992–1992
State v. Chinn green
or · 1962
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
State v. Perry green
or · 1984
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
State v. Lowry green
or · 1983
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
Katz v. United States green
scotus · 1967
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
State v. Caraher green
or · 1982
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
Oliver v. United States green
scotus · 1984
2 sentences

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

1985Although there is some justification for the parties’ assumption that the analysis under both the state and federal constitutional provisions is that enunciated in Katz v. United States, 389 US 347 , 88 S Ct 507 , 19 L Ed 2d 576 (1967), see, e.g., State v. Chinn, 231 Or 259 , 373 P2d 392 (1962); State v. Caraher, 293 Or 741 , 653 P2d 942 (1982); State v. Lowry, 295 Or 337 , 667 P2d 996 (1983); State v. Perry, 298 Or 21 , 688 P2d 827 (1984), the Katz analysis has undergone something akin to metamorphosis, culminating in Oliver v. United States, 466 US 170 , 104 S Ct 1735 , 80 L Ed 2d 214 (1984)

11985–1985
Jones v. Flannigan green
or · 1974
1 sentence

1980Collateral estoppel applies "only to material issues or determinative facts which were actually or necessarily adjudicated in the prior action.” Jones v. Flannigan, 270 or 121, 124, 526 P2d 543 (1974).

11980–1980
Gordon Creek Tree Farms, Inc. v. Layne green
or · 1962
2 sentences

1968The decision ivas based upon the principle that although an employer is not ordinarily liable for the acts of an independent contractor employed by him, this immunity from liability is not extended to an employer “who orders work to be performed from which, in the natural course of things, injurious consequences must be expected to arise unless means are adopted by which such consequences may be prevented.” ② ( 230 Or at 220 , 368 P2d at 740 .) Plaintiff’s argument proceeds upon the assumption that this principle, which recognizes the liability of an employer for the acts of an independent con

1968The decision ivas based upon the principle that although an employer is not ordinarily liable for the acts of an independent contractor employed by him, this immunity from liability is not extended to an employer “who orders work to be performed from which, in the natural course of things, injurious consequences must be expected to arise unless means are adopted by which such consequences may be prevented.” ② ( 230 Or at 220 , 368 P2d at 740 .) Plaintiff’s argument proceeds upon the assumption that this principle, which recognizes the liability of an employer for the acts of an independent con

11968–1968
State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God, Pentecostal green
or · 1962
2 sentences

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): "It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth." [3] Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963). [4] See 1 Orgel, Valuation Under Eminent Domain § 37 (1953), stating that "the indemnity principle would require the acceptance of value to the owner as the only strictly relevant value." Compar

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): "It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth." [3] Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963). [4] See 1 Orgel, Valuation Under Eminent Domain § 37 (1953), stating that "the indemnity principle would require the acceptance of value to the owner as the only strictly relevant value." Compar

11964–1964
Freedman v. CHOLICK ET UX green
or · 1963
2 sentences

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): "It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth." [3] Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963). [4] See 1 Orgel, Valuation Under Eminent Domain § 37 (1953), stating that "the indemnity principle would require the acceptance of value to the owner as the only strictly relevant value." Compar

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): "It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth." [3] Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963). [4] See 1 Orgel, Valuation Under Eminent Domain § 37 (1953), stating that "the indemnity principle would require the acceptance of value to the owner as the only strictly relevant value." Compar

11964–1964
Eden v. Northwest Brewing Company green
wash · 1936
2 sentences

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): “It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth.” Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963).

1964Co., 188 Wash 512, 516, 63 P2d 418 (1936): "It is settled law in this state that the owner of property may testify to its value upon the assumption or presumption that he is so far familiar with the property and its uses as to know its worth." [3] Cf. State Highway Commission v. Assembly of God et al, 230 Or 167, 177 , 368 P2d 937 (1962); Freedman v. Cholick et ux, 233 Or 569, 577 , 379 P2d 575 (1963). [4] See 1 Orgel, Valuation Under Eminent Domain § 37 (1953), stating that "the indemnity principle would require the acceptance of value to the owner as the only strictly relevant value." Compar

11964–1964
Lowery v. School Trustees. green
nc · 1905
2 sentences

1918If the general scope and purpose of the legislation under consideration are constitutional and constitutional means are provided for effecting the general purpose of the legislation the entire statute will not be declared void because one or more of the details, or minor provisions, or incidental clauses are not in accordance with the Constitution; provided, the invalid part may be eliminated without materially affecting the general purpose: Lowery v. School Trustees, 140 N. C. 33 ( 52 S. E. 267 ); State v. Kelsey, 44 N. J.

1918If the general scope and purpose of the legislation under consideration are constitutional and constitutional means are provided for effecting the general purpose of the legislation the entire statute will not be declared void because one or more of the details, or minor provisions, or incidental clauses are not in accordance with the Constitution; provided, the invalid part may be eliminated without materially affecting the general purpose: Lowery v. School Trustees, 140 N. C. 33 ( 52 S. E. 267 ); State v. Kelsey, 44 N. J.

11918–1918

Where else courts name it

IL 41 (1882–2024) NY 41 (1878–2025) CA 23 (1917–2020) LA 22 (1965–2015) TX 19 (1919–2022) IA 17 (1923–2005) MO 12 (1856–1998) OR 10 (1918–2025) AL 10 (1918–2009) KS 10 (1896–2018) FL 10 (1933–2017) RI 10 (1932–2001) NJ 9 (1930–2020) OK 9 (1931–1998) CT 8 (1908–2022) PA 8 (1933–2010) MI 8 (1935–1993) CO 8 (1897–2004) HI 7 (1941–2010) MD 6 (1940–2022) WI 5 (1903–1986) MA 5 (1942–2010) IN 4 (1907–1999) ME 4 (1935–2008) GA 4 (1935–2022) WA 4 (1933–1992) MN 4 (1890–1994) UT 4 (1899–2024) NE 3 (1932–1936) AZ 3 (1908–1996) KY 3 (1950–2013) NH 2 (1989–1993) AR 2 (1958–2009) MS 2 (2009–2020) SD 2 (1960–1984) SC 2 (1991–2021) MT 2 (1909–1993) OH 2 (1940–2021)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check