Idaho Code homeSearch Idaho

Idaho Code § 72-423 (2026)

Permanent disability. 

Edition and currency
text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) cited 1975–2024 41citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 41 opinions since 1975, 1 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (6) (1 case).

Permanent disability. 

"Permanent disability" or "under a permanent disability" results when the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.

The 20 cases that cite Idaho Code § 72-423 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENReynolds v. Browning Ferris Indus., 751 P.2d 113 (Idaho 1988).
cites § 72-423 10×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“" I.C. § 72-423 uses the phrase "and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
The case’s holding
The commission must retain jurisdiction or issue an award accounting for both present and probable future disability when a claimant has a progressive impairment.
Later courts cite it for
“whenever the commission explicitly retains jurisdiction over a matter, that act by its very nature infers that there is neither a final determination of the case nor a final permanent award to the employee.” · 3 citing courts
2
YELLOWPaulson v. Idaho Forest Indus., Inc., 591 P.2d 143 (Idaho 1979).
cites § 72-423 6×cited by 54 cases
Overruled by Jones v. Emmett Manor on other grounds: 3 citing opinions limit it to other grounds.
Where it cites § 72-423
“[2] Disability, whether temporary or permanent, involves a "decrease in wage-earning capacity," I.”
The case’s holding
Medical testimony sufficiently establishes causation if it plainly and unequivocally conveys a conviction that events are causally related without requiring a specific verbal formula.
Later courts cite it for
“no special verbal formula is necessary when, as here, a doctor's testimony plainly and unequivocally conveys his conviction that events are causally related.” · 1 citing court
3
GREENBennett v. Clark Hereford Ranch, 680 P.2d 539 (Idaho 1984).
cites § 72-423 8×cited by 20 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“Bennett filed an application with the Industrial Commission requesting an award of permanent disability compensation pursuant to I.C. § 72-423. [2] The hearing before a referee was held on May 6, 1980.”
The case’s holding
Permanent disability is determined by whether a physical impairment, taken in conjunction with non-medical factors, reduces a claimant's capacity for gainful activity.
Later courts cite it for
“whether the physical impairment, taken in conjunction with non-medical factors, has reduced the claimant's capacity for gainful activity.” · 1 citing court
4
GREENHorton v. Garrett Freightlines, Inc., 772 P.2d 119 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“" I.C. § 72-423. When that time has arrived (here the Commission fixed the *140 date March 1985) the Commission makes its appraisal of the claimant's " present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent…”
The case’s holding
An employer is liable only for the additional disability resulting from an industrial injury and not for disability caused by pre-existing conditions that were not aggravated by the injury.
Later courts cite it for
“in cases of permanent disability less than total, if the degree or duration of disability resulting from an industrial injury or occupational disease is increased or prolonged because of a preexisting physical impairment, the employer shall be liable only for the additional disability from the industrial injury or occupational disease.” · 1 citing court
5
GREENGraybill v. Swift & Co., 766 P.2d 763 (Idaho 1988).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“" Accordingly, the commission determined that claimant's permanent disability under I.C. § 72-423 [1] was 6 1/2% of the whole man.”
The case’s holding
Permanent disability exceeds permanent impairment only if the physical impairment, combined with non-medical factors, has reduced the claimant's capacity for gainful activity.
Later courts cite it for
“the test for determining whether a claimant has suffered a permanent disability in excess of permanent impairment is whether the physical impairment, taken in conjunction with non-medical factors, has reduced the claimant's capacity for gainful activity.” · 3 citing courts
6
GREENUrry v. Walker & Fox Masonry Contractors, 769 P.2d 1122 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“Rather, disability is determined by viewing the impact of the impairment upon the individual in light of "nonmedical factors, such as age, sex, education, economic and social environment." I.C. § 72-425.”
The case’s holding
Pain relating to functional loss is a medical factor that must be considered when determining impairment rather than being treated merely as a nonmedical factor in determining disability.
Later courts cite it for
“if a decision, taken as a whole, appears to reflect a misapprehension of law, the proper appellate response is to vacate the decision and to remand the case for reconsideration in light of the proper legal framework.” · 4 citing courts
7
GREENRivas v. K.C. Logging, 7 P.3d 212 (Idaho 2000).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. A rating of permanent disability is “an appraisal of the injured employee’s present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent impairment and by pertinent nonmedical factors.”
The case’s holding
Courts generally do not award attorney fees in appeals by claimants from industrial commission decisions unless the appeal is made in bad faith or for an improper purpose.
Later courts cite it for
“generally, this court does not award attorney fees in appeals by claimants from decisions of the industrial commission.” · 2 citing courts
8
GREENMarquez v. Pierce Painting, Inc., 423 P.3d 1011 (Idaho 2018).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. The evaluation of a permanent disability is defined as an “appraisal of the injured employee’s present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent impairment and by pertinent nonmedical factors…”
Later courts cite it for
“according to its plain meaning, while not losing sight of its 'potency.” · 2 citing courts
9
GREENBaldner v. Bennett's, Inc., 649 P.2d 1214 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 58 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“— `Permanent disability' or `under a permanent disability' results when the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
The case’s holding
Appellate courts will not consider or review issues that were not raised in the lower court.
Later courts cite it for
“ijssues not raised below and presented for the first time on appeal will not be considered or reviewed.” · 1 citing court
10
GREENMcgee v. Jd Lumber, 17 P.3d 272 (Idaho 2000).
cites § 72-423 6×cited by 7 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“Specifically, under I.C. § 72-423, “permanent disability” has been defined as the condition that results “when the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can…”
Later courts cite it for
“the law in idaho clearly states that an employee who suffers from a pre- existing condition must establish that his or her disease was aggravated by an accident before they are entitled to recover.” · 1 citing court
11
GREENSeese v. Ideal of Idaho, Inc., 714 P.2d 1 (Idaho 1985).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“§ 72-422) and "permanent disability" (as defined in I.C. § 72-423) involve "different but related classifications.”
Later courts cite it for
“the test for such determination is not whether the claimant is able to work at some employment, but rather whether the physical impairment, taken in conjunction with nonmedical factors, has reduced the claimant's capacity for gainful activity.” · 1 citing court
12
GREENFunes v. Aardema Dairy, 244 P.3d 151 (Idaho 2010).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“§ 72-422. A degree of permanent disability is calculated based on the extent to which “the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
Later courts cite it for
“bear responsibility for the legal arguments advanced on its behalf.” · 1 citing court
13
GREENMayer v. TPC Holdings, Inc., 370 P.3d 738 (Idaho 2016).
cites § 72-423 4×cited by 3 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
““Permanent disability” as defined in Idaho Code section 72-423, “results when the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
14
GREENBrown v. Home Depot, 272 P.3d 577 (Idaho 2012).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. A permanent disability rating is “an appraisal of the injured employee’s present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent impairment and by pertinent nonmedical factors as provided in section…”
The case’s holding
In determining permanent disability, the relevant labor market for non-medical factors and odd-lot status is the labor market existing at the time of the hearing.
15
GREENPage v. McCain Foods, Inc., 179 P.3d 265 (Idaho 2008).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. A permanent disability rating is the appraisal of the claimant’s “present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent impairment and by pertinent nonmedical factors as provided in [I.”
The case’s holding
When the Commission apportions permanent disability to exclude preexisting conditions, it must explain its rationale in sufficient detail to permit appellate review for substantial and competent evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“there is a presumption that the commission by its experience is able to judge the causative factors in a particular case, and the commission is 'allowed a degree of latitude in making an apportionment.” · 2 citing courts
16
GREENSerrano v. Four Seasons Framing, 336 P.3d 242 (Idaho 2014).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“I believe this is a correct reading of the provisions of Idaho Code §§ 72-423 and 72-425. However, Defendants further argue that since Claimant’s immigration status leaves him altogether unemployable in the United States, he cannot meet his burden of demonstrating that his loss…”
The case’s holding
A workers' compensation claimant must prove by a reasonable degree of medical probability that the condition for which benefits are sought was caused by an industrial accident.
17
GREENBoley v. State, Indus. Special Indem. Fund, 939 P.2d 854 (Idaho 1997).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. The evaluation of a permanent disability is an “appraisal of the injured employee’s present and probable future ability to engage in gainful activity .”
The case’s holding
An appellate court reviews commission findings by viewing all facts and inferences in the light most favorable to the prevailing party.
Later courts cite it for
“views all the facts and inferences in the light most favorable to the party who prevailed before the commission.” · 5 citing courts
18
GREENBall v. Daw Forest Prods. Co., 30 P.3d 933 (Idaho 2001).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“Idaho Code section 72-423 defines permanent disability as resulting when the “actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
Later courts cite it for
“the decision to grant or deny a continuance is discretionary, a court may not refuse a continuance where the ends of justice clearly require it to be granted.” · 2 citing courts
19
YELLOWLuAnn Shubert v. Macy's West, Inc., 343 P.3d 1099 (Idaho 2015).
cites § 72-423 2×cited by 8 cases
Abrogated by Sohar Chavez v. Kevin Stokes on other grounds: 3 citing opinions limit it to other grounds.
Where it cites § 72-423
“” I.C. § 72-423. The Commission evaluates whether a worker is permanently disabled by considering the worker’s ability to engage in gainful activity as it is affected by the medical factor of permanent impairment and by non-medical factors in Idaho Code section 72-430.”
Later courts cite it for
“the claimant's burden is to prove to a reasonable degree of medical probability that the injury she claims benefits for is causally related to an accident occurring in the course of employment” · 1 citing court
20
GREENCurtis v. Shoshone Cnty. Sheriff's Off., 629 P.2d 696 (Idaho 1981).
cites § 72-423 1×cited by 50 cases
Where it cites § 72-423
“— ‘Permanent disability’ or ‘under a permanent disability’ results when the actual or presumed ability to engage in gainful activity is reduced or absent because of permanent impairment and no fundamental or marked change in the future can be reasonably expected.”
The case’s holding
The special indemnity fund is liable when a subsequent injury aggravates a preexisting permanent physical impairment even if the impairment did not cause a prior permanent disability.
Later courts cite it for
“since these three statutory definitions (i.c. 72-332(2), -422, -423) were passed simultaneously by the legislature, we can only conclude that the legislature intended that they define three different, but related, classifications. 1971 idaho session laws, ch. 124.” · 2 citing courts

Show all 41 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197519992024

One bar per year. Tallest: 4 cases in 2015. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By subsection
(6)1 case
Neel v. W. Constr., Inc., 206 P.3d 852 (Idaho 2009).

Show all 41 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Idaho Code Home  |  Search Idaho  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com