When it becomes necessary in a police or fire department, through lack of work or funds, or for causes other than those outlined in section 124.34 of the Revised Code, to reduce the force in such department, the youngest employee in point of service shall be first laid off. Should a position in the police or fire department once abolished or made unnecessary be found necessary to be re-created or re-established within three years from the date of abolishment, or should a vacancy occur through death, resignation, or any other cause within three years from the date of the abolishment of the position or layoff, the oldest employee in point of service of those laid off shall be entitled to the position, providing he was at the date of his separation a regular and permanent employee. If any employee, laid off as prescribed in this section, enters into the active service of the army, navy, marine corps, or other armed service of the United States, the period such employee serves therein shall not be considered in the determination of the three years stipulated as a maximum time within which reinstatements shall be made; such three-year period shall be computed exclusive of the time the employee spent in the armed services. When a position above the rank of patrolman in the police department and above the rank of regular fireman in the fire department is abolished, and the incumbent has been permanently appointed, he shall be demoted to the next lower rank and the youngest officer in point of service in the next lower rank shall be demoted, and so on down until the youngest person in point of service has been reached, who shall be laid off.
A badge such as ▸ 12 cases opens the cases that cite that subsection.
The 19 cases that cite Ohio Rev. Code § 124.37 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment.RelevanceNewestTreatment
“This appeal also presents the fundamental question of whether the city should have been required to comply with R.C. 124.37 under the circumstances of the instant case.”
The case’s holding
An appellate court remand must be premised on a determination that error occurred below and a ruling on that error.
Later courts cite it for
“must be premised on a determination that error occurred below and a ruling on that error.” · 1 citing court
“44, 1 which provides the procedure for pro *160 motion of police patrolmen, and R.C. 124.37, 2 which sets forth the procedure for removals, reappointments and demotions in police and fire departments.”
Later courts cite it for
“the procedure for promotion provided in r.c. 124.44 is mandatory upon the occurrence of a vacancy in a position above police patrolman, and the vacant position must be filled by appointment before it is abolished pursuant to r.c. 124.37, which presupposes the existence of an incumbent.” · 3 citing courts
3
GREENMcAlpin v. Shirey, 698 N.E.2d 1051 (Ohio Ct. App. 1st Dist. 1997).
cites § 124.37 9×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 124.37
“Because of the abolishment, appellant was promoted to assistant police chief for one day and then demoted the following day, pursuant to the procedure set forth in R.C. 124.37. Appellant presents two assignments of error for review.”
Later courts cite it for
“appointing authorities shall demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that a job abolishment was undertaken due to the lack of the continuing need for the position, a reorganization for the efficient operation of the appointing authority, for reasons of economy or for a lack of work expected to last more than twelve months.” · 2 citing courts
“Here, however, there were neither allegations of bad faith nor any facts entered into the record to show any bad faith or an intentional violation of laws by the city.”
The case’s holding
A municipal charter supersedes general state statutes only where the conflict is expressed by the clear and express terms of the charter rather than by mere inference.
Later courts cite it for
“although the constitution gives municipalities the authority to adopt home rule, local self-government, the exercise of those powers by the adoption of a charter should clearly and expressly state the areas where the municipality intends to supersede and override general state statutes.” · 4 citing courts
“R.C. 124.37 reads, in relevant part, as follows: “When a position above the rank of patrolman in the police department and above the rank of regular fireman in the fire department is abolished, and the incumbent has been permanently appointed, he shall be demoted to the next…”
“The defendant-appellant Cincinnati Civil Service Commission (“the CCSC”) held by a two-to-one vote that (1) it had jurisdiction to hear the promotion-eligible firefighters’ complaint, and (2) the claims of the promotion-eligible firefighters should be reexamined, and status and…”
“44 is mandatory upon the occurrence of a vacancy in a position above police patrolman, and the vacant position must be filled by appointment before it is abolished pursuant to R.C. 124.37, which presupposes the existence of an incumbent.”
Later courts cite it for
“many 'matters of local self-government' are, in fact, matters of detail and procedure that are out of place in a charter, which is comparable to a local constitution.” · 2 citing courts
“re to post the notice of *16 complement would have on compliance by appellees with Ohio’s civil service laws; (3) what entity has the authority to establish the sergeants’ complement; (4) what method was used to set the complement at one hundred fifteen on November 3, 1982; (5)…”
“The issue raised on appeal requires us to interpret the language of both R.C. 124.37 and 124.44. As the construction of a statute is a question of law, not fact, a trial court’s interpretation of a statute is not entitled to deference on appeal.”
“44 is mandatory upon the occurrence of a vacancy in a position above police patrolman, and the vacant position must be filled by appointment before it is abolished pursuant to R.C. 124.37, which presupposes the existence of an incumbent.”
“328, R.C. 124.37, and any other applicable civil service statute or rule having to deal with the filling and abolishment of positions above the rank of patrolman with this language.”
“44 because city had passed authorized-strength ordinance abolishing their positions upon their retirement—R.C. 124.37 does not require demotion or layoff whenever a reduction of authorized strength of a police force has been enacted—Court of appeals’ dismissal of petition…”
cites § 124.37 9×subsections: (A) 2×cited by 1 case
Where it cites § 124.37
“: {¶ 1} Plaintiff-appellant, Richard Deem (“Deem”), appeals the trial court’s judgment affirming the Fairview Park Civil Service Commission’s decision finding that defendant-appellee, city of Fairview Park (“Fairview” or “the City”), could legally reduce his pay rate pursuant to…”
“R.C. 124.37, which deals with removals, reappointments and demotions in police and fire departments, provides, in part, that: “When it becomes necessary in a police or fire department, through lack of work or funds * * * to reduce the force in such department, the youngest…”
“This division need not concern the Court in this case, however, because the basis for the earlier split was an Ohio statute, O.R.C. § 124.37, which required seniority-based layoffs.”
“We affirm, because in deciding which members of a rank should be demoted under R.C. 124.37, the city must base its decision on the employees’ length of service at that particular rank.”
“The trial court, following a bench trial, concluded that the Springfield City Charter provision was in direct conflict with R.C. 124.37 and 124.44; that the charter provision prevailed, as a matter of law; that the lieutenant positions were properly abolished in accordance with…”
“This is an appeal by appellants from a judgment of the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas which affirmed an order of the State Personnel Board of Review that R.C. 124.37 is not applicable to county sheriffs’ departments.”
The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.
Citing cases by year
197819992020
One bar per year. Tallest: 3 cases in 2011. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.
By court
Ohio Ct. App.11Ohio66th Cir.1N.D. Ohio1
By subsection
(A)1 case
Deem v. Fairview Park, 2011-Ohio-5836.“: {¶ 1} Plaintiff-appellant, Richard Deem (“Deem”), appeals the trial court’s judgment affirming the Fairview Park Civil Service Commission’s decision finding that defendant-appellee, city of Fairview Park (“Fairview” or “the City”), could legally reduce his pay rate pursuant to…”
Sections that the same cases cite. The first number is counted among the 100 cases that cite § 124.37 most heavily: how many of them are also among the other section’s own 20 leading cases.