519 North Carolina opinions name it 1 courts 1870–1963 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by North Carolina courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
Walker v. . Walkergreen2 sentences1941See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184); Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” John G-. 1940See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184) ; Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” Tbe charge of plaintiffs against defendant was to tbe effect that defendant’s driver permanently injured them in tbe course of bis employment by defendant. | 2 | 2 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in North Carolina. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
State v. . Mills
neutral
2 sentences1939S. v. Mills, 91 N. C., 581 , 594.” For tbe sake of completeness, although not important in tbe case at bar, we might add to this a fourth condition that the declarant, if living, would have been a competent witness to testify as to the matter. 1935At tbe time they (tbe dying declarations) were made, tbe declarant should have been in actual danger of death, (2) that be should have a full apprehension of bis danger, and (3) that death should have ensued.” S. v. Mills, 91 N. C., 581 (594). | 3 | 1925–1939 |
State v. . Nash
green
2 sentences1955S. v. Dills, 210 N.C. 178 , 185 S.E. 677 ; S. v. Nash, 86 N.C. 650 ; S. v. Gibson, 170 N.C. 697 , 86 S.E. 774 . 1943S. v. Hankins, 136 N. C., 621 , 48 S. E., 593 ; S. v. Taylor, 133 N. C., 755 , 46 S. E., 5 ; S. v. Nash, 86 N. C., 650 . | 2 | 1943–1955 |
Sigmon v. . Shell
neutral
2 sentences1954See S. v. Jenkins, 195 N.C. 747 , 143 S.E. 538 ; S. v. Camphell, 182 N.C. 911 , 110 S.E. 86 ; Sigmon v. Shell, 165 N.C. 582 , 81 S.E. 739 .” To tbe disapproval of this statement of law, firmly embodied in our decisions, I do not agree. 1954See S. v. Jenkins, 195 N.C. 747 , 143 S.E. 538 ; S. v. Camphell, 182 N.C. 911 , 110 S.E. 86 ; Sigmon v. Shell, 165 N.C. 582 , 81 S.E. 739 .” To tbe disapproval of this statement of law, firmly embodied in our decisions, I do not agree. | 2 | 1925–1954 |
State v. . Campbell
green
2 sentences1954See S. v. Jenkins, 195 N.C. 747 , 143 S.E. 538 ; S. v. Camphell, 182 N.C. 911 , 110 S.E. 86 ; Sigmon v. Shell, 165 N.C. 582 , 81 S.E. 739 .” To tbe disapproval of this statement of law, firmly embodied in our decisions, I do not agree. 1922Tbe defendants, having lost before tbe jury, doubtless appealed “to see bow it might strike tbe Court.” Tbe remaining exceptions, calling in question tbe validity of our State statutes since tbe adoption of tbe XVIII Amendment to tbe Constitution of tbe United States, must Fe overruled on authority of S. v. Campbell, 182 N. C., 911 , and cases there cited. | 2 | 1922–1954 |
State v. . Thomas
green
2 sentences1952S. v. Morgan, 226 N.C. 414 , 38 S.E. 2d 166 . 1947S. v. Morgan, 226 N. C., 414 , 38 S. E. (2d), 166 . | 2 | 1947–1952 |
State v. . Morgan
green
2 sentences1952S. v. Morgan, 226 N.C. 414 , 38 S.E. 2d 166 . 1947S. v. Morgan, 226 N. C., 414 , 38 S. E. (2d), 166 . | 2 | 1947–1952 |
Green v. . Griffin
green
2 sentences1950If tbe act is intentional, and violates tbe order, tbe penalty is incurred, whether an indignity to tbe Court or a contempt of its authority, was or was not tbe motive for doing it.” Green v. Griffin, 95 N.C. 50 ; Nobles v. Roberson, 212 N.C. 334 . 1914Combes v. Adams, 152 N. C., pp. 64-70; Greene v. Griffin, 95 N. C., 50 ; McRae v. Comrs., 74 N. C., 415 ; Bank v. Stilling, 32 S. C., 102. | 2 | 1914–1950 |
State v. . Butts
neutral
2 sentences1949As far back as S. v. Butts, 91 N.C. 524 , all tbe requisites of tbe transcript were pointed out, and in S. v. Frizzell, 111 N.C. 722 , the Court said: ‘It is tbe appellant’s duty to see that tbe record is properly and sufficiently made up and transmitted. 1932As far back as S. v. Butts, 91 N. C., 524 , tbe requisites of tbe transcript were pointed out, and in S. v. Frizell, 111 N. C., 725 , tbe Court said: 'An appellant does not do bis duty by simply taking an appeal and leaving it to tbe clerk to send up what be may deem necessary. | 2 | 1932–1949 |
State v. . Stansell
green
2 sentences1947Tbe defendant also complains at the court’s definition of “involuntary manslaughter,” but this was taken almost verbatim from S. v. Stansell, 203 N. C., 69 , 164 S. E., 580 , and is unexceptionable. 1947Tbe defendant also complains at the court’s definition of “involuntary manslaughter,” but this was taken almost verbatim from S. v. Stansell, 203 N. C., 69 , 164 S. E., 580 , and is unexceptionable. | 2 | 1943–1947 |
State v. . Keaton
neutral
2 sentences1947Cf. S. v. Keaton, 206 N. C., 682 , and S. v. Capps, 134 N. C., 622 , 40 S. E., 730 . *411 Tbe rule is, that when it is permissible under the bill to convict the defendant of “a less degree of the same crime,” and there is evidence to support a milder verdict, the defendant is entitled to have the different views presented to the jury under proper instructions, and an error in this respect is not cured by a verdict finding the defendant guilty of a higher offense, for in such case, it cannot be known whether the jury would have convicted of a less degree of the same crime if the different views 1934S. v. Keaton, supra. Nor was tbe error cured by tbe verdict. | 2 | 1934–1947 |
State v. . Stancill
green
2 sentences1946S. v. Stancill, 178 N. C., 683 , 100 S. E., 241 . 1926Tbe exception to tbe rule has been fully discussed by Walker, J., in S. v. Stancill, 178 N. C., 683 , and in a valuable note to tbe case of People v. Moleneux, 168 N. Y., 264 , as reported in 62 L. | 2 | 1926–1946 |
State v. . Hairston
green
2 sentences1946S. v. Hairston, 222 N. C., 455 , 23 S. E. (2d), 885 ; S. v. Potts, 100 N. C., 457 , 6 S. E., 657 . 1946S. v. Hairston, 222 N. C., 455 , 23 S. E. (2d), 885 ; S. v. Potts, 100 N. C., 457 , 6 S. E., 657 . | 2 | 1945–1946 |
State v. . Hammonds
neutral
2 sentences1945S. v. Brown, 218 N. C., 415 , 11 S. E. (2d), 545 ; S. v. Hammonds, 216 N. C., 67 , 3 S. E. (2d), 439 ; S. v. Burney, 215 N. C., 598 , 3 S. E. (2d), 24 ; S. v. Bowser, 214 N. C., 249 , 199 S. E., 31 ; S. v. Hawhins, 214 N. C., 326 , 199 S. E., 31 ; S. v. Evans, 198 N. C., 82 , 150 S. E., 678 ; S. v. Steele, supra; S. v. Dowden, 118 N. C., 1145 , 24 S. E., 722 . *112 Tbe defendant was only fifteen years of age at tbe time be killed tbe deceased. 1945S. v. Brown, 218 N. C., 415 , 11 S. E. (2d), 545 ; S. v. Hammonds, 216 N. C., 67 , 3 S. E. (2d), 439 ; S. v. Burney, 215 N. C., 598 , 3 S. E. (2d), 24 ; S. v. Bowser, 214 N. C., 249 , 199 S. E., 31 ; S. v. Hawhins, 214 N. C., 326 , 199 S. E., 31 ; S. v. Evans, 198 N. C., 82 , 150 S. E., 678 ; S. v. Steele, supra; S. v. Dowden, 118 N. C., 1145 , 24 S. E., 722 . *112 Tbe defendant was only fifteen years of age at tbe time be killed tbe deceased. | 2 | 1940–1945 |
Ford v. Pigeon River Lumber Co.
neutral
2 sentences1945Henry v. Hilliard, 155 N. C., 372 , 71 S. E., 439 , and eases there cited. 1917A like order was made in Ford v. Lumber Co., 155 N. C., 352 , and tbe Court said, in commenting on a motion to remove tbe cause to tbe Federal Court: “Tbe summons was returnable to September Term, 1910, at which term an order was made in this cause as follows: ‘Plaintiff allowed 40 days to file complaint; defendant has 40 days to file answer.’ Tbe defendant did not except to this order and did not move to dismiss tbe action for failure to file complaint, as it bad a right to do. | 2 | 1917–1945 |
State v. . Hardy
green
2 sentences1943S. v. Ross, 193 N. C., 25 , 136 S. E., 193 ; S. v. Hartsfield, 188 N. C., 357 , 124 S. E., 629 ; S. v. Gamer, 203 N. C., 361 , 166 S. E., 180 ; S. v. Hightower, 187 N. C., 300 , 121 S. E., 616 ; S. v. Hardy, 189 N. C., 799 , 128 S. E., 152 .” S. v. Whitfield, supra; Anno. 84 A. L. 1940It does not mean a doubt founded upon something that you might imagine, but it means a doubt founded upon some substantial reason growing-out of tbe evidence itself which you have beard, so in order to convict these men or any of them, it will be necessary for you to be satisfied from all tbe evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that they are guilty.” Tbe defendants rely on S. v. Hardy, 189 N. C., 799 (805). | 2 | 1940–1943 |
Balcum v. . Johnson
green
2 sentences1943We think tbe exception well taken,, although tbe language to which tbe exception is addressed is a quotation from tbe case of Balcum v. Johnson, 177 N. C., 213 , 98 S. E., 532 ; S. v. McFalls, 221 N. C., 22 , 18 S. E. (2d), 700 ; Light Co. v. Moss, 220 N. C., 200 , 17 S. E. (2d), 10 . 1925Tbe test is set out in Balcum v. Johnson, supra; Harton v. Telephone Co., 141 N. C., 455 . | 2 | 1925–1943 |
State v. . Schoolfield
neutral
2 sentences1942S. v. Schoolfield, 184 N. C., 721 , 114 S. E., 466 ; Williams v. B. & L. 1940Tbe excerpt objected to reads: “Tbe defendant is presumed to be innocent, and this presumption goes with him throughout tbe entire trial and until tbe jury is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of bis guilt; not satisfied beyond any doubt, or all doubt, or a vain or fanciful doubt, but rather what tbat term implies, a reasonable doubt, one based upon common sense and reason, generated by insufficiency of proof.” This is in substantial compliance with tbe decisions of this Court, S. v. Schoolfield, 184 N. C., 721 ; S. v. Hege, supra, and in tbe absence of a request for more specific and more ela | 2 | 1940–1942 |
In Re Hinton
green
2 sentences1941In In re Hinton, 180 N. C., 206 (213), Walker, J., said: “Evidence of tbis kind was competent for tbe jury to consider, for when one can easily disprove a charge by testimony within bis control, and which be can then produce, and fails to do it, it is some proof tbat be cannot refute tbe charge.” In York v. York, 212 N. C., 695 (702), tbe above is quoted and it is there said: “Tbe rule of tbe Hinton case, supra, has been repeatedly approved and followed in recent cases decided by tbis Court. 1940Where tbe employer permits tbe driver to use tbe machine to and from bis home in order that tbe driver may reach bis work earlier, it has been held that tbe relation of master and servant continues during such trips.” In In re Hinton, 180 N. C., 206 (213), Walker, J., said: “Evidence of this kind was competent for tbe jury to consider, for when one can easily disprove a charge by testimony within bis control, and which be can then produce, and fails to do it, it is some proof that be cannot refute tbe charge.” In York v. York, 212 N. C., 695 (702), tbe above-is quoted and it is there said: “Tb | 2 | 1940–1941 |
York v. . York
green
2 sentences1941In In re Hinton, 180 N. C., 206 (213), Walker, J., said: “Evidence of tbis kind was competent for tbe jury to consider, for when one can easily disprove a charge by testimony within bis control, and which be can then produce, and fails to do it, it is some proof tbat be cannot refute tbe charge.” In York v. York, 212 N. C., 695 (702), tbe above is quoted and it is there said: “Tbe rule of tbe Hinton case, supra, has been repeatedly approved and followed in recent cases decided by tbis Court. 1940Where tbe employer permits tbe driver to use tbe machine to and from bis home in order that tbe driver may reach bis work earlier, it has been held that tbe relation of master and servant continues during such trips.” In In re Hinton, 180 N. C., 206 (213), Walker, J., said: “Evidence of this kind was competent for tbe jury to consider, for when one can easily disprove a charge by testimony within bis control, and which be can then produce, and fails to do it, it is some proof that be cannot refute tbe charge.” In York v. York, 212 N. C., 695 (702), tbe above-is quoted and it is there said: “Tb | 2 | 1940–1941 |
Maxwell v. . Distributing Co.
green
2 sentences1941See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184); Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” John G-. 1940See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184) ; Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” Tbe charge of plaintiffs against defendant was to tbe effect that defendant’s driver permanently injured them in tbe course of bis employment by defendant. | 2 | 1940–1941 |
Puckett v. . Dyer
green
2 sentences1941See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184); Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” John G-. 1940See Walker v. Walker, 201 N. C., 183 (184) ; Puckett v. Dyer, 203 N. C., 684 (690); Maxwell v. Distributing Co., 204 N. C., 309 (316).” Tbe charge of plaintiffs against defendant was to tbe effect that defendant’s driver permanently injured them in tbe course of bis employment by defendant. | 2 | 1940–1941 |
Willis v. . New Bern
green
2 sentences1940Plaintiff introduced tbe written “warranty and agreement” and in bis testimony stated on cross-examination: “I sold bim tbe tractor for use in logging operations and understood be was going to use it in logging.” In Willis v. New Bern, 191 N. C., 507 (514), is tbe following: “Tbe rule is tbat if evidence offered by one party is objected to by tbe adverse party and thereafter tbe objecting party elicits tbe same evidence, tbe benefit of tbe objection is lost, and further, if on cross-examination evidence is developed without objection, tbe adverse party can offer evidence in reply relating to t 1933The governing principle was written in Willis v. New Bern, 191 N. C., 507 , 132 S. E., 286 , in these words: “In other words, the rule is, that if evidence offered by one party is objected to by the adverse party and thereafter the objecting party elicits the same evidence, the benefit of the objection is lost,” etc. Complaint is also made that the issues were not submitted to a jury. | 2 | 1933–1940 |
State v. Everitt
green
2 sentences1939S. v. Everitt, 164 N. C., 399 , 79 S. E., 274 . 1939S. v. Everitt, 164 N. C., 399 , 79 S. E., 274 . | 2 | 1917–1939 |
State v. . Marshall
green
2 sentences1938In S. v. Marshall, 208 N. C., 127 , 179 S. E., 427 , tbe principle is clearly stated: “The decisions are to this effect: “1. 1938In S. v. Marshall, 208 N. C., 127 , 179 S. E., 427 , tbe principle is clearly stated: “The decisions are to this effect: “1. | 2 | 1937–1938 |
Peeler v. United States Casualty Co.
green
2 sentences1934Tbe defendant relies upon tbe decision in Peeler v. Casualty Co., 197 N. C., 286 , 148 S. E., 261 . 1934Tbe defendant relies upon tbe decision in Peeler v. Casualty Co., 197 N. C., 286 , 148 S. E., 261 . | 2 | 1932–1934 |
Green Sea Lumber Co. v. Pemberton
neutral
2 sentences1934Lumber Co. v. Pemberton, 188 N. C., 532 . 1934Lumber Co. v. Pemberton, 188 N. C., 532 . | 2 | 1934–1934 |
Vogh v. . Geer
green
2 sentences1930Mere liability to injury is not tbe test, as injuries may result in any kind of work where it is carelessly done, although with proper care it is not specially hazardous.” Vogh v. Geer, 171 N. C., 672 , 23 A. L. 1916Mere liability to injury is not tbe test, as injuries may result in any kind of work where it is carelessly done, although with proper care it is not specially hazardous.” Vogh v. Geer, 171 N. C., 672 . | 2 | 1916–1930 |
Phillips v. Interstate Land Co.
green
2 sentences1927Even without a specific instruction, it was incumbent upon tbe judge to do tbis, for when tbe judge assumes to charge and correctly charges the law upon one phase of the evidence tbe charge is incomplete unless it embraces tbe law as applicable to tbe respective contentions of each party, and such failure is reversible error.” Jarrett v. *720 High Point Co., 144 N. C., 299 ; Lea v. Utilities Co., 176 N. C., 514 ; Butler v. Mfg. 1921Even without a specific instruction it was incumbent upon tbe judge to do this, for when tbe judge assumes to charge and .correctly charges the law upon one phase of tbe evidence, tbe charge is incomplete unless it embraces tbe law as applicable to tbe respective contentions of each party, and such failure is reversible error.” Jarrett v. High Point Co., 144 N. C., 299 ; Lea v. Utilities Co., 176 N. C., 514 . | 2 | 1921–1927 |
Lee v. . Pearce
green
2 sentences1927In Lee v. Pearce, 68 N. C., 76 , Pearson, C. 1921Tbe defendant attacks tbe same (in which, by tbe way, we have shown tbat be has no legal or moral interest or right), upon the ground tbat tbe relation of attorney and client is a fiduciary one, which raises a legal but rebuttable presumption of fraud, or of undue influence which is a species of fraud, and for tbis position be cites Lee v. Pearce, 68 N. C., 76 , and we may add McLeod v. Bullard, 84 N. C., 515, 532 , but if tbat principle be conceded to be tbe law, and we are not casting any doubt upon it, tbe evidence in tbis case establishes beyond cavil, tbat tbe attorneys, who were tbe inte | 2 | 1921–1927 |
| Jarrett v. High Point Trunk & Bag Co. green | 2 | 1921–1927 |
| Starkweather v. . Gravely neutral | 2 | 1925–1926 |
| Harton v. . Telephone Co. green | 2 | 1915–1925 |
| Blackwell Durham Tobacco Co. v. McElwee neutral | 2 | 1909–1921 |
| State v. . Tenant green | 2 | 1911–1921 |
| Starnes v. . Hill green | 2 | 1905–1917 |
| Logan v. . R. R. neutral | 2 | 1901–1909 |
| Hocutt v. . Telegraph Co. neutral | 2 | 1908–1909 |
| Tucker v. . Satterthwaite neutral | 2 | 1903–1906 |
| State v. Payton neutral | 1 | 1963–1963 |
| Poniros v. Nello L. Teer Co. neutral | 1 | 1955–1955 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.