Tbe rule (Iowa) · Go Syfert
← Iowa issues

Tbe rule in Iowa

26 Iowa opinions name it 1 courts 1867–1963 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Iowa courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
Larsen & Son v. Retail Merchants Mutual Insurancegreen
iowa · 1931 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1955–1955
2 sentences

1955Co., 212 Iowa 943, 945, 946 , 237 N.W. 468 , and generally with statements in 1 C.

1955Co., 212 Iowa 943, 945, 946 , 237 N.W. 468 , and generally with statements in 1 C.

11
Kinney v. Slatterygreen
iowa · 1879 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1898–1898
11
State v. Hazengreen
· 1874 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1893–1893
11
Carpenter v. Parkergreen
iowa · 1867 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1871–1871
11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Iowa. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (37)

CaseCitedYears
Kelly v. Emary green
iowa · 1951
2 sentences

1963In tbe case of breach of warranty of quality, such loss, in tbe absence of special circumstances showing proximate damage of a greater amount, is tbe difference between the value of tbe goods at tbe time of delivery to the buyer and tbe value they would have bad if they bad answered to tbe warranty.” ' Tbe rule set out. in subsection 7, supra, is recognized in Drager v. Carlson Hybrid Corn Co., Inc., 244 Iowa 78, 86 , 56 N.W.2d 18, 23 , and is stated in somewhat more general terms in Kelly v. Emary, 242 Iowa 683, 690 , 45 N.W.2d 866, 871 .

1963In tbe case of breach of warranty of quality, such loss, in tbe absence of special circumstances showing proximate damage of a greater amount, is tbe difference between the value of tbe goods at tbe time of delivery to the buyer and tbe value they would have bad if they bad answered to tbe warranty.” ' Tbe rule set out. in subsection 7, supra, is recognized in Drager v. Carlson Hybrid Corn Co., Inc., 244 Iowa 78, 86 , 56 N.W.2d 18, 23 , and is stated in somewhat more general terms in Kelly v. Emary, 242 Iowa 683, 690 , 45 N.W.2d 866, 871 .

11963–1963
Drager v. Carlson Hybrid Corn Co. green
iowa · 1952
2 sentences

1963In tbe case of breach of warranty of quality, such loss, in tbe absence of special circumstances showing proximate damage of a greater amount, is tbe difference between the value of tbe goods at tbe time of delivery to the buyer and tbe value they would have bad if they bad answered to tbe warranty.” ' Tbe rule set out. in subsection 7, supra, is recognized in Drager v. Carlson Hybrid Corn Co., Inc., 244 Iowa 78, 86 , 56 N.W.2d 18, 23 , and is stated in somewhat more general terms in Kelly v. Emary, 242 Iowa 683, 690 , 45 N.W.2d 866, 871 .

1963In tbe case of breach of warranty of quality, such loss, in tbe absence of special circumstances showing proximate damage of a greater amount, is tbe difference between the value of tbe goods at tbe time of delivery to the buyer and tbe value they would have bad if they bad answered to tbe warranty.” ' Tbe rule set out. in subsection 7, supra, is recognized in Drager v. Carlson Hybrid Corn Co., Inc., 244 Iowa 78, 86 , 56 N.W.2d 18, 23 , and is stated in somewhat more general terms in Kelly v. Emary, 242 Iowa 683, 690 , 45 N.W.2d 866, 871 .

11963–1963
Independent School District v. County Board of Education green
iowa · 1959
2 sentences

1960In re Community School District of Malvern, 250 Iowa 1240 , 98 N.W.2d 737 .

1960In re Community School District of Malvern, 250 Iowa 1240 , 98 N.W.2d 737 .

11960–1960
Riter v. Keokuk Electro-Metals Company green
iowa · 1957
2 sentences

1959Nor do we have a case where an industrial plant in the process of its operation is emitting noxious fumes, as in Riter v. Keokuk Electro-Metals Co., 248 Iowa 710 , 82 N.W.2d 151 . *11 Tbe motion to direct a verdict for the defendants was properly sustained. — Affirmed.

1959Nor do we have a case where an industrial plant in the process of its operation is emitting noxious fumes, as in Riter v. Keokuk Electro-Metals Co., 248 Iowa 710 , 82 N.W.2d 151 . *11 Tbe motion to direct a verdict for the defendants was properly sustained. — Affirmed.

11959–1959
Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railroad v. Long neutral
iowa · 1952
2 sentences

1957Co. v. Long, 243 Iowa 514 , 51 N.W.2d 135 ; but it does not excuse the railway company from using reasonable means to warn and protect. *669 Tbe defendant further points out that there were a number of lights of filling stations and spotlights on gas storage tanks in the vicinity of the Lindquist accident which shone in the eyes of approaching motorists and shadowed the crossing.

1957Co. v. Long, 243 Iowa 514 , 51 N.W.2d 135 ; but it does not excuse the railway company from using reasonable means to warn and protect. *669 Tbe defendant further points out that there were a number of lights of filling stations and spotlights on gas storage tanks in the vicinity of the Lindquist accident which shone in the eyes of approaching motorists and shadowed the crossing.

11957–1957
Winkelman v. General Motors Corporation green
nysd · 1942
1 sentence

1952Yet in Winkelman v. General Motors Corp., 44 F. Supp. 960,970 , in a derivative suit there was a settlement with the complainant in which the corporation was paid -$4,500,000 and counsel fees and expenses of $795,000 were allowed. *833 Tbe hearing upon this application was had in the district court and it was submitted on evidence and argument from each side.

11952–1952
Breker v. Rosema green
mich · 1942
2 sentences

1947R. 872, at 873, it is stated: “Tbe rule is well established that where tbe loss of memory or other incapacity rendering tbe survivor of an accident incapable of testifying as to the accident, is shown to be attributable to such accident, it will be presumed, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, that he exercised due care. ’ ’ The foregoing rule is followed in Breker v. Rosema, 301 Mich. 685 , 4 N. W. 2d 57 , 141 A. L.

1947R. 872, at 873, it is stated: “Tbe rule is well established that where tbe loss of memory or other incapacity rendering tbe survivor of an accident incapable of testifying as to the accident, is shown to be attributable to such accident, it will be presumed, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, that he exercised due care. ’ ’ The foregoing rule is followed in Breker v. Rosema, 301 Mich. 685 , 4 N. W. 2d 57 , 141 A. L.

11947–1947
Scott v. Sheedy green
calctapp · 1940
2 sentences

1947R. 867; Hoppe v. Bradshaw, 42 Cal. App. 2d 334 , 108 P. 2d 947 ; Scott v. Sheedy, 39 Cal. App. 2d 96 , 102 P. 2d 575 ; Stotler v. Chicago & A. Ry.

1947R. 867; Hoppe v. Bradshaw, 42 Cal. App. 2d 334 , 108 P. 2d 947 ; Scott v. Sheedy, 39 Cal. App. 2d 96 , 102 P. 2d 575 ; Stotler v. Chicago & A. Ry.

11947–1947
Hoppe v. Bradshaw green
calctapp · 1941
2 sentences

1947R. 867; Hoppe v. Bradshaw, 42 Cal. App. 2d 334 , 108 P. 2d 947 ; Scott v. Sheedy, 39 Cal. App. 2d 96 , 102 P. 2d 575 ; Stotler v. Chicago & A. Ry.

1947R. 867; Hoppe v. Bradshaw, 42 Cal. App. 2d 334 , 108 P. 2d 947 ; Scott v. Sheedy, 39 Cal. App. 2d 96 , 102 P. 2d 575 ; Stotler v. Chicago & A. Ry.

11947–1947
Schoonover v. Osborne neutral
iowa · 1902
1 sentence

1942Shaffer v. Des Moines Coal Co., 122 Iowa, 233 ; Schoonover v. Osborne, 117 Iowa, 427 .

11942–1942
Shaffer v. Des Moines Coal & Hay Co. neutral
iowa · 1904
1 sentence

1942Shaffer v. Des Moines Coal Co., 122 Iowa, 233 ; Schoonover v. Osborne, 117 Iowa, 427 .

11942–1942
Himmelberger v. Central State Bank green
iowa · 1929
2 sentences

1939In tbe case of Re Estate of Talbott, 209 Iowa 1, 4 , 224 N. W. 550, 552 , this court said: “It is tbe general and well recognized rule that tlie necessary legal elements to establish a novation are parties capable of contracting, a valid prior obligation to be displaced, tbe consent óf all parties to tbe substitution, based on sufficient consideration, tbe extinction of tbe old obligation, and tbe creation of a new one.” In Reimers v. Tonne, 207 Iowa 1011 , at page 1016, 221 N. W. 574 , at page 576, this court said: “ It is a familiar rule that tbe mere fact of tbe making of a new contract by

1939In tbe case of Re Estate of Talbott, 209 Iowa 1, 4 , 224 N. W. 550, 552 , this court said: “It is tbe general and well recognized rule that tlie necessary legal elements to establish a novation are parties capable of contracting, a valid prior obligation to be displaced, tbe consent óf all parties to tbe substitution, based on sufficient consideration, tbe extinction of tbe old obligation, and tbe creation of a new one.” In Reimers v. Tonne, 207 Iowa 1011 , at page 1016, 221 N. W. 574 , at page 576, this court said: “ It is a familiar rule that tbe mere fact of tbe making of a new contract by

11939–1939
Reimers v. Tonne neutral
iowa · 1928
2 sentences

1939In tbe case of Re Estate of Talbott, 209 Iowa 1, 4 , 224 N. W. 550, 552 , this court said: “It is tbe general and well recognized rule that tlie necessary legal elements to establish a novation are parties capable of contracting, a valid prior obligation to be displaced, tbe consent óf all parties to tbe substitution, based on sufficient consideration, tbe extinction of tbe old obligation, and tbe creation of a new one.” In Reimers v. Tonne, 207 Iowa 1011 , at page 1016, 221 N. W. 574 , at page 576, this court said: “ It is a familiar rule that tbe mere fact of tbe making of a new contract by

1939In tbe case of Re Estate of Talbott, 209 Iowa 1, 4 , 224 N. W. 550, 552 , this court said: “It is tbe general and well recognized rule that tlie necessary legal elements to establish a novation are parties capable of contracting, a valid prior obligation to be displaced, tbe consent óf all parties to tbe substitution, based on sufficient consideration, tbe extinction of tbe old obligation, and tbe creation of a new one.” In Reimers v. Tonne, 207 Iowa 1011 , at page 1016, 221 N. W. 574 , at page 576, this court said: “ It is a familiar rule that tbe mere fact of tbe making of a new contract by

11939–1939
Safe Deposit & Trust Co. v. Cahn green
md · 1906
2 sentences

1936Savings Deposit and Trust Co. v. Cahn, 102 Md. 530 , 62 Atl. 819 ; Martin v. First Nat.

1936Savings Deposit and Trust Co. v. Cahn, 102 Md. 530 , 62 Atl. 819 ; Martin v. First Nat.

11936–1936
State v. Hendrick green
nj · 1903
1 sentence

1928L. 41 ( 56 Atl. 247 ) ; Hynes v. Hickey, 109 Mich. 188 ( 66 N. W. 1090 ); Dedric v. Hopson, 62 Iowa 562 ; Texas & P. R.

11928–1928
Hynes v. Hickey neutral
mich · 1896
2 sentences

1928L. 41 ( 56 Atl. 247 ) ; Hynes v. Hickey, 109 Mich. 188 ( 66 N. W. 1090 ); Dedric v. Hopson, 62 Iowa 562 ; Texas & P. R.

1928L. 41 ( 56 Atl. 247 ) ; Hynes v. Hickey, 109 Mich. 188 ( 66 N. W. 1090 ); Dedric v. Hopson, 62 Iowa 562 ; Texas & P. R.

11928–1928
Iverson v. McDonnell green
wash · 1904
2 sentences

1928Tbe objection that evidence is incompetent is sufficient where the evidence is incompetent for any purpose. 9 Encyc. of Evidence 73; Iverson v. McDonnell, 36 Wash. 73 ( 78 Pac. 202 ); State v. Hendrick, 70 N. J.

1928Tbe objection that evidence is incompetent is sufficient where the evidence is incompetent for any purpose. 9 Encyc. of Evidence 73; Iverson v. McDonnell, 36 Wash. 73 ( 78 Pac. 202 ); State v. Hendrick, 70 N. J.

11928–1928
Dedric v. Hopson green
iowa · 1883
1 sentence

1928L. 41 ( 56 Atl. 247 ) ; Hynes v. Hickey, 109 Mich. 188 ( 66 N. W. 1090 ); Dedric v. Hopson, 62 Iowa 562 ; Texas & P. R.

11928–1928
Shea v. Keith neutral
iowa · 1925
1 sentence

1926In tbe recent ease of Shea v. Keith, 200 Iowa 300 , we said: “Tbe rule is well stated in Farmers Loan & Tr.

11926–1926
Lickleider v. Iowa State Traveling Men's Ass'n green
iowa · 1918
1 sentence

1926Men’s Assn., 184 Iowa 423 , as follows: “Tbe rule, clearly deducible from the overwhelming weight of authority, is that, when injury or death follows or results from a voluntary act of tbe insured, and the act is one which is not manifestly dangerous, but which is ordinarily done or performed without serious consequences to the doer, such result is caused by accidental means.

11926–1926
Farmers Loan & Trust Co. v. Scheetz neutral
iowa · 1923
1 sentence

1926Co. v. Scheetz, 196 Iowa 692 , a case very similar to tbe one before us, where we said: ‘A failing debtor may lawfully exhaust his property to secure or pay some of his creditors, leaving others unprotected, provided only that his purpose in so doing is not tainted with intent to hinder or delay the creditors left, unsecured.

11926–1926
Hanson v. Hammell green
iowa · 1899
1 sentence

1922As bearing on this question, see Hanson v. Hammett, 107 Iowa 171 . 2.

11922–1922
Churchill v. Morse green
ca10 · 1867
1 sentence

1909Churchill v. Morse, 23 Iowa, 229 ; Spaan v. Anderson, 115 Iowa, 121 .

11909–1909
Spaan v. Anderson neutral
iowa · 1901
1 sentence

1909Churchill v. Morse, 23 Iowa, 229 ; Spaan v. Anderson, 115 Iowa, 121 .

11909–1909
Hileman v. Bouslaugh neutral
pa · 1850
1 sentence

1905In Hileman v. Bouslaugh, 13 Pa. 344 ( 53 Am Dec. 474 ), Chief Justice Gibson protested that Tbe rule in Shelley’s Case ill deserves the epithets bestowed on it in tbe argument.

11905–1905
Lewis v. Schultz green
iowa · 1896
1 sentence

1905Lewis v. Schultz, 98 Iowa, 341 ; Powell v. Deveney, 3 Cush. 300 ( 50 Am.

11905–1905
Kearney Milling & Elevator Co. v. Union Pacific Railway Co. green
iowa · 1896
1 sentence

1905Elevator Co. v. U. P. Ry., 97 Iowa, 719 .

11905–1905
Bolton v. Owen neutral
iowa · 1885
1 sentence

1901Fairbairn v. Dana, 68 Iowa, 230 .

11901–1901
Bish v. Hawkeye Ins. green
iowa · 1886
1 sentence

1900Tbe doctrine that such a promise amounts to an estoppel has apparently been recognized in this state in Bishop v. Insurance Co., 69 Iowa, 184 , although it appears that the limitation therein waived ■was created by contract, and not by law.

11900–1900
Hume v. Long neutral
iowa · 1880
11898–1898
Moore v. Antill neutral
iowa · 1880
11898–1898
Killmer v. Wuchner neutral
iowa · 1888
11898–1898
State v. Bennett green
iowa · 1870
11893–1893
Mitchell v. Wiscotta Land Co. green
iowa · 1856
11875–1875
Grant v. Whitwell, Marsh & Talbott green
· 1859
11871–1871
Doane & Co. v. Garretson green
iowa · 1868
11871–1871
Edgerton v. Moore neutral
conn · 1859
11867–1867

Where else courts name it

NC 519 (1870–1963) AL 61 (1852–1933) MO 56 (1853–1954) WI 43 (1866–1918) PA 43 (1861–1984) TN 32 (1872–1966) KY 30 (1876–1945) NY 26 (1855–1958) IA 26 (1867–1963) UT 23 (1897–1924) OR 21 (1867–1973) OK 20 (1916–1937) MI 20 (1914–1969) TX 19 (1894–1934) ND 19 (1913–1943) MT 15 (1897–1960) MN 13 (1893–1957) IL 12 (1911–1965) NE 12 (1896–1920) WA 11 (1898–1937) OH 11 (1900–1974) WV 11 (1924–1960) AR 9 (1854–1965) MD 9 (1906–1933) LA 8 (1913–1933) IN 7 (1876–1918) HI 7 (1896–1915) PR 6 (1906–1934) CT 4 (1891–1972) GA 4 (1897–1961) MS 4 (1903–1960) NM 3 (1918–1923) VA 3 (1928–1953) FL 3 (1923–2018) RI 2 (1879–1917) NV 2 (1875–1875) CO 2 (1908–1933) WY 2 (1930–1931)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check