enforcement claim (Arkansas) · Go Syfert
← Arkansas issues

enforcement claim in Arkansas

20 Arkansas opinions name it 2 courts 1909–2025 3 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Arkansas courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
Forrest City MacHine Works, Inc. v. Aderhold Ex Rel. Cross County Bankgreen
ark · 1981 · cited in 3 Arkansas opinions naming this issue, 2021–2025
2 sentences

2025Furthermore, the supreme court held that “a vested right exists when the law declares that one has a claim against another, or it declares that one may resist the enforcement of a claim by another.” Id.

2023We have held “[a] vested right exists when the law declares that one has a claim against another, or it declares that one may resist the enforcement of a claim by another.” Forrest City Machine Works, Inc. v. Aderhold, 273 Ark. 33, 41 , 616 S.W.2d 720, 724 (1981).

23
RMP RENTALS v. Metroplex, Inc.green
ark · 2004 · cited in 3 Arkansas opinions naming this issue, 2005–2019
2 sentences

2019In RMP Rentals v. Metroplex, Inc. , 356 Ark. 76 , 81, 146 S.W.3d 861 , 864 (2004), our supreme court distinguished the two: Choice-of-forum clauses in contracts have generally been held binding, unless it can be shown that the enforcement of the clause would be unreasonable and unfair.

2019In RMP Rentals v. Metroplex, Inc. , 356 Ark. 76 , 81, 146 S.W.3d 861 , 864 (2004), our supreme court distinguished the two: Choice-of-forum clauses in contracts have generally been held binding, unless it can be shown that the enforcement of the clause would be unreasonable and unfair.

13
Servewell Plumbing, LLC v. Summit Contractors, Inc.green
ark · 2005 · cited in 1 Arkansas opinions naming this issue, 2010–2010
2 sentences

2010See Servewell Plumbing, 362 Ark. at 603 , 210 S.W.3d at 106 (citing RMP Rentals v. Metroplex, Inc., 356 Ark. 76 , 146 S.W.3d 861 (2004)).

2010See Servewell Plumbing, 362 Ark. at 603 , 210 S.W.3d at 106 (citing RMP Rentals v. Metroplex, Inc., 356 Ark. 76 , 146 S.W.3d 861 (2004)).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Arkansas. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (23)

CaseCitedYears
Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co. green
ark · 1952
2 sentences

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

21971–1971
Stricklin v. Mitchell neutral
ark · 1961
2 sentences

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

21971–1971
Mortensen v. Ballard green
ark · 1945
2 sentences

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

21971–1971
Walker v. Norton green
ark · 1940
2 sentences

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

1971Stricklin v. Mitchell, 234 Ark. 31 , 350 S. W. 2d 319 ; Seawood v. Ozan Lumber Co., 221 Ark. 196 , 252 S. W. 2d 829 ; Mortensen v. Ballard, 209 Ark. 1 , 188 S. W. 2d 749 ; Cullins v. Webb, supra; Walker v. Norton, 199 Ark. 593 , 135 S. W. 2d 315 .

21971–1971
Love v. Cowger green
ark · 1917
2 sentences

1946Reeves v. City of Hot Springs, 103 Ark. 430 , 147 S. W. 445 ; Love v. Cowger, 130 Ark. 445 , 197 S. W. 853 .” Appellee, by timely motion,’ called attention to the deficiency in appellants’ abstract, and asked that the judgment of the trial court be affirmed under rule 12 of this court, which provides: “If abstract and brief have not been filed by the appellant in accordance with Rules 9 and 10, when the case is called for trial, the appellee may have the appeal dismissed or the judgment affirmed ’as of course. ’ ’ This cause has been regularly reached for submission, and the deficiency in the

1946Reeves v. City of Hot Springs, 103 Ark. 430 , 147 S. W. 445 ; Love v. Cowger, 130 Ark. 445 , 197 S. W. 853 .” Appellee, by timely motion,’ called attention to the deficiency in appellants’ abstract, and asked that the judgment of the trial court be affirmed under rule 12 of this court, which provides: “If abstract and brief have not been filed by the appellant in accordance with Rules 9 and 10, when the case is called for trial, the appellee may have the appeal dismissed or the judgment affirmed ’as of course. ’ ’ This cause has been regularly reached for submission, and the deficiency in the

21920–1946
Reeves v. Hot Springs neutral
ark · 1912
2 sentences

1946Reeves v. City of Hot Springs, 103 Ark. 430 , 147 S. W. 445 ; Love v. Cowger, 130 Ark. 445 , 197 S. W. 853 .” Appellee, by timely motion,’ called attention to the deficiency in appellants’ abstract, and asked that the judgment of the trial court be affirmed under rule 12 of this court, which provides: “If abstract and brief have not been filed by the appellant in accordance with Rules 9 and 10, when the case is called for trial, the appellee may have the appeal dismissed or the judgment affirmed ’as of course. ’ ’ This cause has been regularly reached for submission, and the deficiency in the

1946Reeves v. City of Hot Springs, 103 Ark. 430 , 147 S. W. 445 ; Love v. Cowger, 130 Ark. 445 , 197 S. W. 853 .” Appellee, by timely motion,’ called attention to the deficiency in appellants’ abstract, and asked that the judgment of the trial court be affirmed under rule 12 of this court, which provides: “If abstract and brief have not been filed by the appellant in accordance with Rules 9 and 10, when the case is called for trial, the appellee may have the appeal dismissed or the judgment affirmed ’as of course. ’ ’ This cause has been regularly reached for submission, and the deficiency in the

21920–1946
Baum v. Yarberry neutral
ark · 1947
2 sentences

1953In discussing the operation and effect of the statute in Baum v. Yarberry, 212 Ark. 471 , 206 S. W. 2d 190 , we said: ‘ ‘ That the period of limitation fixed by this statute is a comparatively short one, and that an enforcement of the rule provided in this statute may, in some cases, work a great hardship or apparent injustice are matters addressing themselves to the legislative branch of government.” Appellant also argues that the statute is inapplicable because the appellees did not pay taxes on the land until 1950.

1953In discussing the operation and effect of the statute in Baum v. Yarberry, 212 Ark. 471 , 206 S. W. 2d 190 , we said: ‘ ‘ That the period of limitation fixed by this statute is a comparatively short one, and that an enforcement of the rule provided in this statute may, in some cases, work a great hardship or apparent injustice are matters addressing themselves to the legislative branch of government.” Appellant also argues that the statute is inapplicable because the appellees did not pay taxes on the land until 1950.

11953–1953
Elm Springs Canning Co. v. Sullins green
ark · 1944
2 sentences

1952The 1948 Act reads: “In any proceeding for the enforcement of a claim for compensation, the following prima facie presumptions shall exist: . . . (4) That the injury did not result from intoxication of the injured employee while on duty. . . . ” In the case of Elm Springs Canning Co. v. Sullins, 207 Ark. 257 , 180 S. W. 2d 113 , in considering this matter of intoxication in the light of the presumption against it we said: “As indicated, § 24 of the Act makes a prima facie presumption against the injury resulting from intoxication.

1952The 1948 Act reads: “In any proceeding for the enforcement of a claim for compensation, the following prima facie presumptions shall exist: . . . (4) That the injury did not result from intoxication of the injured employee while on duty. . . . ” In the case of Elm Springs Canning Co. v. Sullins, 207 Ark. 257 , 180 S. W. 2d 113 , in considering this matter of intoxication in the light of the presumption against it we said: “As indicated, § 24 of the Act makes a prima facie presumption against the injury resulting from intoxication.

11952–1952
Mikel v. State green
ark · 1930
1 sentence

1936Mikel v. State, 182 Ark. 924 , 33 S. W. (2d) 397 .

11936–1936
Teele v. Bishop of Derry green
mass · 1897
1 sentence

1922In Jackson v. Phillips, supra, the Massachusetts court stated the scope of the enforcement of this doctrine in the following language: “It is accordingly well settled by decisions of the highest authority, that when a gift is made to trustees for a charitable purpose, the general nature of which is pointed out, and which is lawful and valid at the time of the death of the testator, and no intention is expressed to limit it to a particular institution or mode of application, and afterwards, either by change of circumstances the scheme of the testator become impracticable, or by change of law be

11922–1922
Jackson v. Phillips green
mass · 1867
1 sentence

1922In Jackson v. Phillips, supra, the Massachusetts court stated the scope of the enforcement of this doctrine in the following language: “It is accordingly well settled by decisions of the highest authority, that when a gift is made to trustees for a charitable purpose, the general nature of which is pointed out, and which is lawful and valid at the time of the death of the testator, and no intention is expressed to limit it to a particular institution or mode of application, and afterwards, either by change of circumstances the scheme of the testator become impracticable, or by change of law be

11922–1922
Brooks v. International Shoe Co. neutral
· 1918
1 sentence

1918Brooks v. International Shoe Co., supra. But in testing the sufficiency of the account so far as concerns the preservation of the lien, we hold that it is not essential that the account filed be an itemized one. (2-3) The affidavit to the claim was made before and was certified by a notary public in the State of Oklahoma, and it is contended that the affidavit was void because it appears on its face that the notary is a woman.

11918–1918
Jacobson v. Massachusetts green
scotus · 1905
2 sentences

1918Com. v. Jacobson, 197 U. S. 11 , 49 L.

1918Com. v. Jacobson, 197 U. S. 11 , 49 L.

11918–1918
Shorter University v. Franklin neutral
ark · 1905
1 sentence

1918It is a rule of long standing and has been rigidly enforced by this court, as will be seen by reference to the following cases, covering a long period of time: Neal v. Brandon, 74 Ark. 320 ; Shorter University v. Franklin, 75 Ark. 571 ; Merritt v. Wallace, 76 Ark. 217 ; Beavers v. Security Mutual Ins.

11918–1918
Merritt v. Wallace neutral
ark · 1905
1 sentence

1918It is a rule of long standing and has been rigidly enforced by this court, as will be seen by reference to the following cases, covering a long period of time: Neal v. Brandon, 74 Ark. 320 ; Shorter University v. Franklin, 75 Ark. 571 ; Merritt v. Wallace, 76 Ark. 217 ; Beavers v. Security Mutual Ins.

11918–1918
Neal v. Brandon green
ark · 1905
1 sentence

1918It is a rule of long standing and has been rigidly enforced by this court, as will be seen by reference to the following cases, covering a long period of time: Neal v. Brandon, 74 Ark. 320 ; Shorter University v. Franklin, 75 Ark. 571 ; Merritt v. Wallace, 76 Ark. 217 ; Beavers v. Security Mutual Ins.

11918–1918
State v. Wood green
· 1888
1 sentence

1916As said by Judge Cockrill in State v. Wood, supra, the reasón is stronger for the enforcement of the rule since the adoption of the Code, for an action in such cases might be prosecuted by the State, as a trustee of an express trust, or by the real party, in interest — that is, by the person entitled to receive the money, who in this instance, is the material-man.

11916–1916
Crook County v. Bushnell neutral
or · 1887
1 sentence

1916See also Huffman v. Koppelkom, 8 Neb. 347 , 1 N. W. 243 ; Crook Co. v. Bushnell, 13 Pac. 886 . (5) Again it is contended by counsel for the defendants that the sureties on the bond are not liable for material that did not go into the construction of the building.

11916–1916
Shayne v. . Evening Post Publishing Co. green
ny · 1901
1 sentence

1914The State, to sustain its contention, relies upon the case of Shayne v. Evening Post Publishing Co., 168 N. Y. 70 , an opinion of the New York Court of Appeals rendered by Judge Parker.

11914–1914
Heartman v. Franks neutral
ark · 1880
1 sentence

1909Hartman v. Franks, 36 Ark. 501 ; Caldwell v. Meshew, 44 Ark. 564 ; Lanigan v. North, 69 Ark. 62 ; Maloney v. State, 91 Ark. 485 ; 4 Cyc. 97. 2.

11909–1909
Caldwell v. Meshew neutral
ark · 1884
1 sentence

1909Hartman v. Franks, 36 Ark. 501 ; Caldwell v. Meshew, 44 Ark. 564 ; Lanigan v. North, 69 Ark. 62 ; Maloney v. State, 91 Ark. 485 ; 4 Cyc. 97. 2.

11909–1909
Lanigan v. North neutral
ark · 1901
1 sentence

1909Hartman v. Franks, 36 Ark. 501 ; Caldwell v. Meshew, 44 Ark. 564 ; Lanigan v. North, 69 Ark. 62 ; Maloney v. State, 91 Ark. 485 ; 4 Cyc. 97. 2.

11909–1909
Maloney v. State green
ark · 1909
1 sentence

1909Hartman v. Franks, 36 Ark. 501 ; Caldwell v. Meshew, 44 Ark. 564 ; Lanigan v. North, 69 Ark. 62 ; Maloney v. State, 91 Ark. 485 ; 4 Cyc. 97. 2.

11909–1909

Where else courts name it

TX 85 (1902–2025) NY 76 (1880–2025) IL 41 (1881–2023) PA 37 (1895–2026) AL 35 (1877–2026) CA 33 (1898–2025) MO 32 (1891–2018) OK 28 (1911–2020) MD 24 (1869–2026) AK 23 (1970–2018) NJ 21 (1951–2024) AR 20 (1909–2025) FL 18 (1889–2018) KS 17 (1895–2024) MS 17 (1895–2023) IN 16 (1894–2024) HI 16 (1969–2025) IA 15 (1871–2014) NC 14 (1903–2025) WA 13 (1905–2018) MI 13 (1878–2019) GA 13 (1936–2020) OH 13 (1910–2020) LA 13 (1906–2023) CT 12 (1926–2025) TN 11 (1897–2015) WI 11 (1899–2010) NE 10 (1891–2020) AZ 10 (1933–2022) OR 9 (1914–2005) MA 9 (1921–2026) KY 7 (1911–1970) DC 7 (1902–2017) SC 7 (1887–2011) MT 6 (1913–2006) MN 5 (1889–1982) ME 5 (1879–1993) VA 4 (1886–1952) NM 4 (1918–2003) CO 4 (1910–2007) WV 4 (1905–1992) DE 3 (1992–2025) ID 3 (1908–1963) WY 3 (1908–1964) UT 3 (1935–2009) VT 2 (1962–1988) VI 2 (2001–2006) SD 2 (1894–1909)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check