laid down rule in Minnesota

11 Minnesota opinions name it 1 courts 1881–1964 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Minnesota courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

Case	Followed	Cited
Kileen v. Kennedygreen minn · 1903 · cited in 1 Minnesota opinions naming this issue, 1964–1964 2 sentences 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing. 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing.	1	1
Hook v. Northwest Thresher Co.green minn · 1904 · cited in 1 Minnesota opinions naming this issue, 1935–1935 2 sentences 1935See also Hook v. Northwest Thresher Co. 91 Minn. 482 , 98 N. W. 463 ; and the annotation “Judgment as lien on judgment debtor’s equitable interest in real property,” 30 A. L. 1935See also Hook v. Northwest Thresher Co. 91 Minn. 482 , 98 N. W. 463 ; and the annotation “Judgment as lien on judgment debtor’s equitable interest in real property,” 30 A. L.	1	1
Marston v. Williamsgreen minn · 1890 · cited in 1 Minnesota opinions naming this issue, 1904–1904 2 sentences 1904See also Marston v. Williams, 45 Minn. 116 ; 47 N. W. 644 . 1904See also Marston v. Williams, 45 Minn. 116 ; 47 N. W. 644 .	1	1

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

Case	Negative	Cited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Minnesota. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (14)

Case	Cited	Years
Newlin v. Hoyt green minn · 1904 2 sentences 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing. 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing.	1	1964–1964
Ferguson v. Trovaten green minn · 1905 2 sentences 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing. 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing.	1	1964–1964
Bey v. Keeping green minn · 1934 2 sentences 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing. 1964See, Kileen v. Kennedy, 90 Minn. 414 , 97 N. W. 126 ; Newlin v. Hoyt, 91 Minn. 409 , 98 N. W. 323 ; Ferguson v. Trova-ten, 94 Minn. 209 , 102 N. W. 373 . 497 In Bey v. Keeping, 192 Minn. 283 , 256 N. W. 140 , also, we held that in order to conform to the requirements of the statute of frauds the acceptance of the terms of a written proposal for the purchase of real estate must be in writing.	1	1964–1964
Krause v. Krause green ny · 1941 1 sentence 1964In Krause v. Krause, 285 N. Y. 27 , 32 N. E. (2d) 779, the trust was found to be illusory in an opinion which apparently held that under the facts in that case there was an intent to cut off the surviving spouse with little or nothing.	1	1964–1964
Ristau v. Riley green minn · 1950 2 sentences 1959In Ristau v. Riley, 230 Minn. 341 , 41 N. W. (2d) 772 , this court laid down a rule which we think has application here. 1959In Ristau v. Riley, 230 Minn. 341 , 41 N. W. (2d) 772 , this court laid down a rule which we think has application here.	1	1959–1959
Heinrich v. Englund neutral minn · 1885 2 sentences 1958Whitaker v. McClung, 14 Minn. 131 (170); Leyde v. Martin, 16 Minn. 24 (38); Heinrich v. Englund, 34 Minn. 395 , 26 N. W. 122 ; Ferch v. Hiller, 209 Minn. 124 , 295 N. W. 504 . 1958Whitaker v. McClung, 14 Minn. 131 (170); Leyde v. Martin, 16 Minn. 24 (38); Heinrich v. Englund, 34 Minn. 395 , 26 N. W. 122 ; Ferch v. Hiller, 209 Minn. 124 , 295 N. W. 504 .	1	1958–1958
Friederick v. Skellet Co. neutral minn · 1930 2 sentences 1958It is our opinion that this court laid down the rule applicable to this case in Friederick v. Skellet Co. 180 Minn. 382 , 231 N. W. 7 . 1958It is our opinion that this court laid down the rule applicable to this case in Friederick v. Skellet Co. 180 Minn. 382 , 231 N. W. 7 .	1	1958–1958
Ferch v. Hiller green minn · 1941 2 sentences 1958Whitaker v. McClung, 14 Minn. 131 (170); Leyde v. Martin, 16 Minn. 24 (38); Heinrich v. Englund, 34 Minn. 395 , 26 N. W. 122 ; Ferch v. Hiller, 209 Minn. 124 , 295 N. W. 504 . 1958Whitaker v. McClung, 14 Minn. 131 (170); Leyde v. Martin, 16 Minn. 24 (38); Heinrich v. Englund, 34 Minn. 395 , 26 N. W. 122 ; Ferch v. Hiller, 209 Minn. 124 , 295 N. W. 504 .	1	1958–1958
Barrett v. Smith green minn · 1931 1 sentence 1945Minn. 431, 237 N. W. 15 , where it stated: “* * * And if the matter is to be reconsidered, the first order should be vacated pending the reconsideration.” No notice was served upon plaintiff of the filing of the first order denying the motion for new trial.	1	1945–1945
Follansbee v. Johnson neutral minn · 1881 2 sentences 1908This court laid down the rule in Follansbee v. Johnson, 28 Minn. 311 , 9 N. W. 882 , following the general trend of the adjudicated cases elsewhere, that the grantee in a deed of conveyance, by assuming the payment of an outstanding mortgage on the land, for which his grantor is personally liable, legally obligates himself to pay the debt, and his contract may be enforced by the mortgagee. 1908This court laid down the rule in Follansbee v. Johnson, 28 Minn. 311 , 9 N. W. 882 , following the general trend of the adjudicated cases elsewhere, that the grantee in a deed of conveyance, by assuming the payment of an outstanding mortgage on the land, for which his grantor is personally liable, legally obligates himself to pay the debt, and his contract may be enforced by the mortgagee.	1	1908–1908
Atwater v. Manchester Savings Bank green minn · 1891 2 sentences 1904Bank, 45 Minn. 341 , 48 N. W. 187 , this court laid down the rule that under the statutes above cited equitable interests in real property are subject to the lien of a judgment, and may be sold on execution. 1904Bank, 45 Minn. 341 , 48 N. W. 187 , this court laid down the rule that under the statutes above cited equitable interests in real property are subject to the lien of a judgment, and may be sold on execution.	1	1904–1904
Reitan v. Goebel neutral minn · 1885 2 sentences 1900In Reitan v. Goebel, 33 Minn. 151 , 22 N. W. 291 , the court laid down the rule that words charging an unmarried female with incontinence are actionable per se. 1900In Reitan v. Goebel, 33 Minn. 151 , 22 N. W. 291 , the court laid down the rule that words charging an unmarried female with incontinence are actionable per se.	1	1900–1900
Chalmers v. Whittemore neutral minn · 1875 1 sentence 1881In Chalmers v. Whittemore, 22 Minn. 305 , this court laid down the rule that “where an unauthorized communication is made to a juror in a cause on trial, which may have influenced his mind in favor of the successful party, a new trial will be granted for that reason; but if it is apparent that the communication could not have had such influence, it is no ground for a new trial.” And in Koehler v. Cleary 23 Minn. 325 , “the proper rule in such cases we deem to be, that if it does not appear that the misconduct was occasioned by the prevailing party, or any one in his behalf, and if it does not	1	1881–1881
Koehler v. Cleary neutral minn · 1877 1 sentence 1881In Chalmers v. Whittemore, 22 Minn. 305 , this court laid down the rule that “where an unauthorized communication is made to a juror in a cause on trial, which may have influenced his mind in favor of the successful party, a new trial will be granted for that reason; but if it is apparent that the communication could not have had such influence, it is no ground for a new trial.” And in Koehler v. Cleary 23 Minn. 325 , “the proper rule in such cases we deem to be, that if it does not appear that the misconduct was occasioned by the prevailing party, or any one in his behalf, and if it does not	1	1881–1881

Where else courts name it

OK 65 (1898–1980) NY 41 (1863–2006) IL 26 (1895–1982) WA 20 (1898–1970) TX 20 (1915–1982) CA 18 (1900–2000) LA 16 (1905–1985) KY 15 (1859–1980) WV 14 (1881–1994) FL 13 (1918–2004) AR 11 (1905–1963) NC 11 (1890–1929) MN 11 (1881–1964) GA 10 (1904–1967) TN 10 (1933–2006) IA 10 (1916–1992) ID 9 (1893–1958) AL 8 (1857–2004) MI 7 (1873–1935) NJ 7 (1940–1994) MT 7 (1904–1958) ND 7 (1909–1950) OR 7 (1912–1963) AZ 7 (1948–1969) NE 6 (1880–1953) MS 6 (1918–1964) PA 5 (1931–1980) IN 5 (1876–1992) KS 5 (1884–1965) SC 5 (1934–2025) OH 4 (1894–1941) VA 4 (1876–1951) SD 4 (1904–1957) WI 4 (1861–1930) MD 3 (1939–1979) ME 3 (1949–1965) CO 3 (1918–1924) AK 2 (1960–1969) VT 2 (1861–1887) MO 2 (1929–1980) CT 2 (1979–1979) DE 2 (1897–1948) DC 2 (1914–1958) HI 2 (1971–1976)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check