judge committed reversible error (Pennsylvania) · Go Syfert
← Pennsylvania issues

judge committed reversible error in Pennsylvania

9 Pennsylvania opinions name it 3 courts 1957–2024 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Pennsylvania courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
Commonwealth v. McFaddengreen
pasuperct · 2017 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2024–2024
1 sentence

2024In a non-jury trial, the trial judge “is presumed to know the law,” Commonwealth v. McFadden, 156 A.3d 299, 309 (Pa. Super. 2017), and great deference is “afforded to the trial court judge’s discretion to adjudge the credibility of witnesses and to determine whether their testimony, if believed, establishes the elements of the offenses charged.” See Commonwealth v. Stays, 70 A.3d 1256, 1267 (Pa. Super. 2013).

11
Commonwealth v. Staysgreen
pasuperct · 2013 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2024–2024
1 sentence

2024In a non-jury trial, the trial judge “is presumed to know the law,” Commonwealth v. McFadden, 156 A.3d 299, 309 (Pa. Super. 2017), and great deference is “afforded to the trial court judge’s discretion to adjudge the credibility of witnesses and to determine whether their testimony, if believed, establishes the elements of the offenses charged.” See Commonwealth v. Stays, 70 A.3d 1256, 1267 (Pa. Super. 2013).

11
Commonwealth v. Hegginsgreen
pasuperct · 2002 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2018–2018
1 sentence

2018See Commonwealth v. Heggins, 809 A.2d 908 , 912 n.2 (Pa.Super. 2002) (“[A]n issue identified on appeal but not developed in the appellant’s brief is abandoned and, therefore, waived.”). -5- J-S38010-18 5. [Appellant] avers that the trial judge committed reversible error when he allowed evidence . . . regarding the plea of . . .

11
Commonwealth v. 108.3 Acres of Landgreen
pa · 1968 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1979–1979
2 sentences

1979See Commonwealth v. 108.3 Acres of Land, 431 Pa. 341 , 246 A.2d 124 (1968).

1979See Commonwealth v. 108.3 Acres of Land, 431 Pa. 341 , 246 A.2d 124 (1968).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Pennsylvania. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

CaseCitedYears
Commonwealth v. Joyner green
pa · 1976
2 sentences

2015Whether the trial judge committed reversible error in failing to instruct the jury about improper prosecutor remarks during a closing when [Appellant] was called a “monster” and a “snake in the grass,” despite an objection from counsel on the basis of Commonwealth v. Joyner [ 365 A.2d 1233 (Pa. 1976)][?] V.

2015Whether the trial judge committed reversible error in failing to instruct the jury about improper prosecutor remarks during a closing when [Appellant] was called a “monster” and a “snake in the grass,” despite an objection from counsel on the basis of Commonwealth v. Joyner [ 365 A.2d 1233 (Pa. 1976)][?] V.

12015–2015
Commonwealth v. Wilds green
pasuperct · 1976
2 sentences

1982This court, in Commonwealth v. Wilds, 240 Pa.Super. 278 , 362 A.2d 273 (1976), outlined the prerequisites for preserving for appellate review a contention of error in the trial court’s charge: “Error is preserved for appellate review in two ways.

1982This court, in Commonwealth v. Wilds, 240 Pa.Super. 278 , 362 A.2d 273 (1976), outlined the prerequisites for preserving for appellate review a contention of error in the trial court’s charge: “Error is preserved for appellate review in two ways.

11982–1982
Commonwealth v. Shadron green
pa · 1977
2 sentences

1977In Commonwealth v. Shadron, 471 Pa. 461 , 370 A.2d 697 (1977), this court, in discussing the failure of the trial court to charge on the elements of an underlying felony when felony murder is one of the theories of the Commonwealth’s case, stated: “ . . .

1977In Commonwealth v. Shadron, 471 Pa. 461 , 370 A.2d 697 (1977), this court, in discussing the failure of the trial court to charge on the elements of an underlying felony when felony murder is one of the theories of the Commonwealth’s case, stated: “ . . .

11977–1977
Commonwealth v. Baranowski green
pa · 1970
1 sentence

1970In tbe recent case of Commonwealth v. Winebrenner, 439 Pa. 73 , 265 A. 2d 108 , we reviewed tbis issue at great length, and once again we reaffirmed a score of prior decisions of tbis Court which held that self-defense was an affirmative defense and tbe defendant bad tbe burden of proving self-defense by a fair preponderance of tbe evidence.

11970–1970
Commonwealth v. Winebrenner green
pa · 1970
1 sentence

1970In tbe recent case of Commonwealth v. Winebrenner, 439 Pa. 73 , 265 A. 2d 108 , we reviewed tbis issue at great length, and once again we reaffirmed a score of prior decisions of tbis Court which held that self-defense was an affirmative defense and tbe defendant bad tbe burden of proving self-defense by a fair preponderance of tbe evidence.

11970–1970
Steffy v. Carson green
pa · 1966
2 sentences

1967The testimony of Robert Vernon, corroborated by Kristol, reveals that he, Vernon, was critical of Levin’s ventilation of the area in which the Cerami-Glaze was being used. *369 Appellant now contends that the trial judge committed reversible error in his refusal to charge the jury-in accordance with appellant’s request that persons who deal with poisonous, noxious, or dangerous substances are held to the highest degree of care to prevent injury resulting from their use, and that it was error for the trial judge to permit the jury to determine its own standard of legal liability by not differen

1967The testimony of Robert Vernon, corroborated by Kristol, reveals that he, Vernon, was critical of Levin’s ventilation of the area in which the Cerami-Glaze was being used. *369 Appellant now contends that the trial judge committed reversible error in his refusal to charge the jury-in accordance with appellant’s request that persons who deal with poisonous, noxious, or dangerous substances are held to the highest degree of care to prevent injury resulting from their use, and that it was error for the trial judge to permit the jury to determine its own standard of legal liability by not differen

11967–1967
McDonald v. Ferrebee neutral
pa · 1951
2 sentences

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

11957–1957
Robinson v. American Ice Co. green
pa · 1927
2 sentences

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

11957–1957
Goff v. College Hill Borough green
pa · 1929
2 sentences

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

11957–1957
McFadden v. Pennzoil Company green
pa · 1941
2 sentences

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

11957–1957
Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co. green
pa · 1942
2 sentences

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

1957Although broader language may be found in a few cases, “There is not the slightest doubt [under the law of Pennsylvania] that a plaintiff is guilty of contributory • negligence and cannot' re cover if his negligence contributed in any degree, * however slight, to the injury: Grimes v. Yellow Cab Co., 344 Pa. 298, 304 , 25 A. 2d 294 ; McFadden v. Pennzoil Co., 341 Pa. 433, 436 , 19 A. 2d 370 ; Robinson v. American Ice Co., 292 Pa. 366, 369 , 141 A. 244 ; Goff v. College Hill Borough, 299 Pa. 343, 347 , 149 A. 477 .”: McDonald v. Ferrebee, 366 Pa. 543, 546 , 79 A. 2d 232 .

11957–1957

Where else courts name it

MS 60 (1987–2026) MA 47 (1977–2025) LA 30 (1950–2007) FL 27 (1953–2007) MD 23 (1976–2020) GA 21 (1939–2016) IL 19 (1968–2021) AL 19 (1970–2012) NJ 17 (1963–2022) DC 16 (1987–2017) SC 15 (1969–2010) NY 14 (1940–2014) TX 13 (1923–2001) TN 12 (1960–2010) MI 11 (1960–2016) PA 9 (1957–2024) VA 8 (1990–2018) KY 8 (1972–2010) DE 6 (1980–2025) NV 5 (2015–2015) NC 5 (1968–1994) CA 4 (1953–1985) OK 4 (1962–1987) OH 3 (1940–2005) IN 3 (1965–1982) UT 3 (1985–2025) OR 3 (1978–2014) WV 2 (1973–1988) MO 2 (2005–2005) CO 2 (2018–2018) AZ 2 (1980–1989) NH 2 (1983–1983)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check