17 Kentucky opinions name it 2 courts 1915–1977 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by Kentucky courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in Kentucky. | ||
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Kentucky. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
Ormsby v. City of London
neutral
2 sentences1977In Ormsby v. City of London, 220 Ky. 148, 149 , 294 S.W. 1025 (1927) the court stated: This court has adopted the rule that a property owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. 1977In Ormsby v. City of London, 220 Ky. 148, 149 , 294 S.W. 1025 (1927) the court stated: This court has adopted the rule that a property owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. | 2 | 1930–1977 |
Lindon v. Potter
neutral
2 sentences1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . 1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . | 1 | 1952–1952 |
McHargue v. Conrad
green
2 sentences1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . 1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . | 1 | 1952–1952 |
Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co.
neutral
2 sentences1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . 1952McHargue v. Conrad et al., 312 Ky. 434 , 227 S.W.2d 977 ; Lindon v. Potter, 306 Ky. 511 , 208 S.W. 2d 515 ; Choate v. Farrar Lumber Co., 189 Ky. 271 , 224 S.W. 1045 . | 1 | 1952–1952 |
Major v. Rudolph
neutral
2 sentences1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . 1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . | 1 | 1951–1951 |
Commonwealth v. Temple
neutral
2 sentences1951Commonwealth v. Temple, 239 Ky. 188 , 39 S.W.2d 228, 229 . 1951Commonwealth v. Temple, 239 Ky. 188 , 39 S.W.2d 228, 229 . | 1 | 1951–1951 |
Moreland's Adm'r v. Stone
green
2 sentences1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . 1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . | 1 | 1951–1951 |
Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell's Adm'r
neutral
2 sentences1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . 1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . | 1 | 1951–1951 |
Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey
neutral
2 sentences1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . 1951Owen Motor Freight Lines v. Russell’s Adm’r, 260 Ky. 795 , 86 S.W.2d 708 ; Major v. Rudolph, 218 Ky. 1 , 290 S.W. 688 ; Louisville Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Ramey, 222 Ky. 286 , 300 S.W. 890 ; Moreland’s Adm’r v. Stone, 292 Ky. 521 , 166 S.W.2d 998 . | 1 | 1951–1951 |
Horn v. State
neutral
1 sentence1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon | 1 | 1949–1949 |
Fletcher v. Tyler
green
2 sentences1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon 1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon | 1 | 1949–1949 |
Scott v. Scott
neutral
2 sentences1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon 1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon | 1 | 1949–1949 |
Baker v. Baker
neutral
1 sentence1949“In the Scott (Scott v. Scott, 172 Ky. 658 , 190 S. W. 143 ) and Baker (Baker v. Baker, 191 Ky. 325 , 230 S. W. 293 ) Cases, supra, and many others referred to therein, it is shown that this court has adopted the rule of construction, as applying to a deed or will made by a near relative to a named parent and his or her children, as conveying a life interest to the named parent, with remainder to his or her children; but this rule, like others, will surrender to a different intention, as gathered according to the rules, supra. So that, in its last analysis, every case must depend largely upon | 1 | 1949–1949 |
Riner v. Catron
neutral
2 sentences1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . 1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . | 1 | 1943–1943 |
Piney Oil Gas Company v. Allen
green
1 sentence1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . | 1 | 1943–1943 |
Commonwealth v. Ryan
green
1 sentence1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . | 1 | 1943–1943 |
Cook v. McKee
neutral
2 sentences1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . 1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . | 1 | 1943–1943 |
Barton v. Jones
neutral
2 sentences1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . 1943Piney Oil & Gas Company v. Allen, 235 Ky. 767 , 32 S. W. (2d) 325 ; Cook v. McKee, 235 Ky. 1 , 29 S. W. (2d) 571 ; Riner v. Catron, 230 Ky. 290 , 19 S. W. (2d) 970 ; Barton v. Jones, 206 Ky. 238 , 267 S. W. 214 . | 1 | 1943–1943 |
Brumleve v. Cronan
green
2 sentences1938So was its election between the different holdings made in these two lines of differing authorities announced by us in the case of Brumleve v. Cronan, 176 Ky. 818 , 197 S. W. 498 , where we said, in an opinion delivered by Judge Hurt, that [page 505]: “The doctrine does not prevail in this jurisdiction, which holds that, although a defendant objects in every possible way to the court assuming jurisdiction of his person, that when his objections are overruled and he pleads to the merits of the action, or does any act which constitutes a defense upon the merits, that he should be considered as h 1938So was its election between the different holdings made in these two lines of differing authorities announced by us in the case of Brumleve v. Cronan, 176 Ky. 818 , 197 S. W. 498 , where we said, in an opinion delivered by Judge Hurt, that [page 505]: “The doctrine does not prevail in this jurisdiction, which holds that, although a defendant objects in every possible way to the court assuming jurisdiction of his person, that when his objections are overruled and he pleads to the merits of the action, or does any act which constitutes a defense upon the merits, that he should be considered as h | 1 | 1938–1938 |
Douglas v. Stokes
green
2 sentences1931Douglas v. Stokes, 149 Ky. 506 , 149 S. W. 849 , 42 L. 1931Douglas v. Stokes, 149 Ky. 506 , 149 S. W. 849 , 42 L. | 1 | 1931–1931 |
Hieber v. Central Kentucky Traction Co.
green
2 sentences1929R. 773, we said: This court has adopted the rule . . . that a consequential injury caused by blasting resulting from the concussion of the atmosphere, sound or otherwise, gives no cause of action against the one doing the blasting unless it is shown that the work was done negligently and that the injury was the result of negligence and not the result of blasting-according to the usual methods and with reasonable care. ’ ’ Among other cases so holding are Heiber v. Central Kentucky Traction Co., 145 Ky. 108 , 140 S. W. 54 , 36 L. 1929R. 773, we said: This court has adopted the rule . . . that a consequential injury caused by blasting resulting from the concussion of the atmosphere, sound or otherwise, gives no cause of action against the one doing the blasting unless it is shown that the work was done negligently and that the injury was the result of negligence and not the result of blasting-according to the usual methods and with reasonable care. ’ ’ Among other cases so holding are Heiber v. Central Kentucky Traction Co., 145 Ky. 108 , 140 S. W. 54 , 36 L. | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Grainger v. Jenkins
neutral
2 sentences1929Grainger v. Jenkins, 156 Ky. 257 , 160 S. W. 926 , L. 1929Grainger v. Jenkins, 156 Ky. 257 , 160 S. W. 926 , L. | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Richardson v. Mehler
green
1 sentence1927Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co., 180 Ky. 242 ( 202 S. W. 679 ); City of Louisville v. Gast, 118 Ky. 570 ( 81 S. W. 693 ); Richardson v. Mehler, 111 Ky. 408 (63 S W. 957); Mudge v. Walker, 122 Ky. 29 ( 90 S. W. 1046 ) ” This court has adopted the rule .that a property Owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. | 1 | 1927–1927 |
City of Louisville v. Gast
neutral
1 sentence1927Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co., 180 Ky. 242 ( 202 S. W. 679 ); City of Louisville v. Gast, 118 Ky. 570 ( 81 S. W. 693 ); Richardson v. Mehler, 111 Ky. 408 (63 S W. 957); Mudge v. Walker, 122 Ky. 29 ( 90 S. W. 1046 ) ” This court has adopted the rule .that a property Owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. | 1 | 1927–1927 |
Mudge v. Walker
neutral
1 sentence1927Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co., 180 Ky. 242 ( 202 S. W. 679 ); City of Louisville v. Gast, 118 Ky. 570 ( 81 S. W. 693 ); Richardson v. Mehler, 111 Ky. 408 (63 S W. 957); Mudge v. Walker, 122 Ky. 29 ( 90 S. W. 1046 ) ” This court has adopted the rule .that a property Owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. | 1 | 1927–1927 |
Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co.
green
2 sentences1927Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co., 180 Ky. 242 ( 202 S. W. 679 ); City of Louisville v. Gast, 118 Ky. 570 ( 81 S. W. 693 ); Richardson v. Mehler, 111 Ky. 408 (63 S W. 957); Mudge v. Walker, 122 Ky. 29 ( 90 S. W. 1046 ) ” This court has adopted the rule .that a property Owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. 1927Realty Savings Co. v. Southern Asphaltoilene Road Co., 180 Ky. 242 ( 202 S. W. 679 ); City of Louisville v. Gast, 118 Ky. 570 ( 81 S. W. 693 ); Richardson v. Mehler, 111 Ky. 408 (63 S W. 957); Mudge v. Walker, 122 Ky. 29 ( 90 S. W. 1046 ) ” This court has adopted the rule .that a property Owner cannot stand by and see a contractor improve the streets in front of his place under a contract with the city, until after the work has been completed and accepted by the city, and then attack the proceedings under which the work was done for irregularities which do not render the proceedings void. | 1 | 1927–1927 |
Wooden-Ware Co. v. United States
green
2 sentences1926North Jellico Coal Company v. Helton, 187 Ky. 394 ; New Domain Oil and Gas Company v. McKinney, 188 Ky. 186 ; White, Mine and Mineral Remedies Sec. 568; Bolles Woodenware Co. v. United States, 106 U. S. 432 , 1 Sup. Ct. 398; 27 L. 1926North Jellico Coal Company v. Helton, 187 Ky. 394 ; New Domain Oil and Gas Company v. McKinney, 188 Ky. 186 ; White, Mine and Mineral Remedies Sec. 568; Bolles Woodenware Co. v. United States, 106 U. S. 432 , 1 Sup. Ct. 398; 27 L. | 1 | 1926–1926 |
North Jellico Coal Co. v. Helton
green
1 sentence1926North Jellico Coal Company v. Helton, 187 Ky. 394 ; New Domain Oil and Gas Company v. McKinney, 188 Ky. 186 ; White, Mine and Mineral Remedies Sec. 568; Bolles Woodenware Co. v. United States, 106 U. S. 432 , 1 Sup. Ct. 398; 27 L. | 1 | 1926–1926 |
King v. Board of Council
green
2 sentences1925It-is: ‘‘Where injury to realty is permanent, the measure of damage is the depreciation in its market value resulting therefrom. ’’ Toebbe v. City of Covington, 145 Ky. 763 , 141 S. W. 421 ; King v. Board of Council City of Danville, 128 Ky. 321 , 32 R. 1188 , 107 S. W. 1189 ; Fidelity Trust Co. v. Shelbyville Water & Light Co., 110 S. W. 239 , 33 R. 202 . 1925It-is: ‘‘Where injury to realty is permanent, the measure of damage is the depreciation in its market value resulting therefrom. ’’ Toebbe v. City of Covington, 145 Ky. 763 , 141 S. W. 421 ; King v. Board of Council City of Danville, 128 Ky. 321 , 32 R. 1188 , 107 S. W. 1189 ; Fidelity Trust Co. v. Shelbyville Water & Light Co., 110 S. W. 239 , 33 R. 202 . | 1 | 1925–1925 |
| Toebbe v. City of Covington green | 1 | 1925–1925 |
Smith v. Gowdy
green
1 sentence1925Smith v. Gowdy, 196 Ky. 281 ; Newport News & M. | 1 | 1925–1925 |
| Campbell v. Trosper neutral | 1 | 1923–1923 |
| Quigley v. Beam's Admr. neutral | 1 | 1923–1923 |
| Byassee v. Evans neutral | 1 | 1923–1923 |
| Colley v. Commonwealth green | 1 | 1923–1923 |
| Bromley's Admr. v. Washington Life Ins. green | 1 | 1915–1915 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.