correctness rule (Alabama) · Go Syfert
← Alabama issues

correctness rule in Alabama

53 Alabama opinions name it 4 courts 1843–2011 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Alabama courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

CaseFollowedCited
Doerr v. Warnergreen
minn · 1956 · cited in 2 Alabama opinions naming this issue, 1979–1997
2 sentences

1997The basic correctness of this rule becomes at once apparent if it is borne in mind that the order removing an action to a Federal court does not terminate the state court's jurisdiction but merely stays or interrupts proceedings in that court pending a disposal of the action by the Federal court." Doerr v. Warner , 247 Minn. 98 , 106 , 76 N.W.2d 505 , 512 (1956).

1997The basic correctness of this rule becomes at once apparent if it is borne in mind that the order removing an action to a Federal court does not terminate the state court's jurisdiction but merely stays or interrupts proceedings in that court pending a disposal of the action by the Federal court." Doerr v. Warner , 247 Minn. 98 , 106 , 76 N.W.2d 505 , 512 (1956).

12
Ward v. Stategreen
ala · 1874 · cited in 1 Alabama opinions naming this issue, 1945–1945
1 sentence

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Alabama. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (69)

CaseCitedYears
Pickle's Adm'r v. Ezzell neutral
ala · 1855
2 sentences

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , 6 South. 366 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.”- In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Adm’r, 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Adm’r v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all. claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some other person ‘who knows the

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.” In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Admr., 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Admr. v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the sufficiency of proof of a claim against insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some othe

41858–1916
Haden v. McCarty green
ala · 1963
2 sentences

1975State v. Southern Electric Generating Co., 27A Ala. 668, 151 So.2d 216 ; Haden v. McCarty, 275 Ala. 76 , 152 So.2d 141 .

1975State v. Southern Electric Generating Co., 27A Ala. 668, 151 So.2d 216 ; Haden v. McCarty, 275 Ala. 76 , 152 So.2d 141 .

31964–1975
State v. Southern Electric Generating Company green
ala · 1963
2 sentences

1975This court approved the following in Hamm, supra: “The State, in insisting that the administrative construction has had such effect, relies on the statement appearing in the last paragraph of the opinion in State v. Southern Electric Generating *336 Co., 274 Ala. 668, 671 , 151 So.2d 216 , to the effect that the State is ‘bound by the administrative construction of twenty-five years.’ This expression was considered in the recent case of International Union of Operating Engineers, Local Union No. 321 (AFL-CIO) v. The Water Works Board of the City of Birmingham, 276 Ala. 462, 163 So.2d 619 , whe

1975This court approved the following in Hamm, supra: “The State, in insisting that the administrative construction has had such effect, relies on the statement appearing in the last paragraph of the opinion in State v. Southern Electric Generating *336 Co., 274 Ala. 668, 671 , 151 So.2d 216 , to the effect that the State is ‘bound by the administrative construction of twenty-five years.’ This expression was considered in the recent case of International Union of Operating Engineers, Local Union No. 321 (AFL-CIO) v. The Water Works Board of the City of Birmingham, 276 Ala. 462, 163 So.2d 619 , whe

31964–1975
Lay v. Clark's Adm'r neutral
ala · 1858
2 sentences

1878Under section 2568 of the Code, executors and administrators may file claims against insolvent estates on information and belief; these are expressly permitted by statute, but even here the Supreme Court says in Pickle’s Administrator v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , that knowledge of the correctness of the claim and that it is due, must he averred, and in Lay v. Clarke’s Administrator, 31 Ala. 409 , the affidavit must show that the claim is a just and subsisting demand.

1861To constitute a valid filing of a claim against an insolvent estate, an affidavit must he made, verifying the claim, by the oath of the claimant, or some other person who knows the correctness of the claim.” — -Code, § 1847 ; Lay v. Clark, 31 Ala. 409 ; Carhart v. Clark, ib. 396.

31860–1878
International Union of Operating Engineers, Local Union No. 321 v. Water Works Board green
ala · 1964
2 sentences

1975This court approved the following in Hamm, supra: “The State, in insisting that the administrative construction has had such effect, relies on the statement appearing in the last paragraph of the opinion in State v. Southern Electric Generating *336 Co., 274 Ala. 668, 671 , 151 So.2d 216 , to the effect that the State is ‘bound by the administrative construction of twenty-five years.’ This expression was considered in the recent case of International Union of Operating Engineers, Local Union No. 321 (AFL-CIO) v. The Water Works Board of the City of Birmingham, 276 Ala. 462, 163 So.2d 619 , whe

1975This court approved the following in Hamm, supra: “The State, in insisting that the administrative construction has had such effect, relies on the statement appearing in the last paragraph of the opinion in State v. Southern Electric Generating *336 Co., 274 Ala. 668, 671 , 151 So.2d 216 , to the effect that the State is ‘bound by the administrative construction of twenty-five years.’ This expression was considered in the recent case of International Union of Operating Engineers, Local Union No. 321 (AFL-CIO) v. The Water Works Board of the City of Birmingham, 276 Ala. 462, 163 So.2d 619 , whe

21964–1975
Mobile County v. Williams green
ala · 1913
2 sentences

1938Mobile County v. Williams, 180 Ala. 639 , 61 So. 963 .

1938Mobile County v. Williams, 180 Ala. 639 , 61 So. 963 .

21934–1938
Dennis v. Coker's Adm'r neutral
ala · 1859
2 sentences

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , 6 South. 366 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.”- In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Adm’r, 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Adm’r v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all. claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some other person ‘who knows the

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.” In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Admr., 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Admr. v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the sufficiency of proof of a claim against insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some othe

21916–1916
Globe Iron Roofing & Corrugating Co. v. Thacher neutral
ala · 1888
2 sentences

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , 6 South. 366 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.”- In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Adm’r, 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Adm’r v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all. claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some other person ‘who knows the

1916In Globe Iron Roofing, etc., Co. v. Thacher, 87 Ala. 458 , the statute there in question required that the claim of an original contractor or materialman must be verified “by the oath of the claimant, or some other person having knowledge of the facts.” In each of the cases of Dennis v. Coker, Admr., 34 Ala. 611 , and Pickle’s Admr. v. Ezzell, 27 Ala. 623 , where the question of the sufficiency of proof of a claim against insolvent estates was for decision, the court held that the statute required “all claims against insolvent estates to be verified by the oath of the claimant, or of some othe

21916–1916
Ex Parte Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. green
ala · 1997
1 sentence

2011The basic correctness of this rule becomes at once apparent if it is borne in mind that the order removing an action to a Federal court does not terminate the state court’s jurisdiction but merely stays or interrupts proceedings in that court pending a disposal of the action by the Federal court.’ ” The Court in Metropolitan Life also stated that, in adopting the above-quoted language in King , the Court "implicitly overruled an earlier line of cases holding that the proper removal of an action from a state court to a federal court immediately divests the state court of jurisdiction and mak[es

12011–2011
State Dept. of Human Resources v. Funk green
alacivapp · 1994
1 sentence

1997State Dep't of Human Resources v. Funk , 651 So.2d 12 (Ala.Civ.App. 1994).

11997–1997
United States v. Hilton Jerry Kelton green
ca8 · 1971
1 sentence

1984“Defense charge 14: “ ‘Crime of aiding and abetting .is one requiring specific intent, and mere association, as opposed to participation is not sufficient to establish guilt, nor is mere presence at scene of crime alone sufficient to sustain the burden of proof the government bears.’ United States v. Kelton, 446 F.2d 669 .” We do not question the correctness of the principle of law asserted in any of the four requested written charges.

11984–1984
First Colored Cumberland Presbyterian Church v. W. D. Wood Lumber Co. neutral
ala · 1921
2 sentences

1953Wood Lumber Co., 205 Ala. 442 , 88 So. 433 , and Buettner Bros, v. Goodhope Missionary Baptist Church, supra. We recognize the correctness of this principle, but we think that it is without application here.

1953Wood Lumber Co., 205 Ala. 442 , 88 So. 433 , and Buettner Bros, v. Goodhope Missionary Baptist Church, supra. We recognize the correctness of this principle, but we think that it is without application here.

11953–1953
Adams v. State green
alactapp · 1915
1 sentence

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Jetton v. State neutral
ala · 1940
2 sentences

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Jetton v. State neutral
alactapp · 1939
2 sentences

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Beall v. State green
ala · 1875
1 sentence

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Graves v. State neutral
ala · 1879
1 sentence

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Johnson v. State neutral
ala · 1883
1 sentence

1945See Ward v. State, 50 Ala. 120 ; Beall v. State, 53 Ala. 460 ; Graves v. State, 63 Ala. 134 ; Johnson v. State, 73 Ala. 483 ; Adams v. State, 13 Ala.App. 330 , 69 So. 357 ; Jetton v. State, 29 Ala.App. 134 , 195 So. 283 , certiorari denied 239 Ala. 306 , 195 So. 284 .

11945–1945
Batson v. Alexander City Bank neutral
ala · 1912
2 sentences

1941Michie on Banks and Banking, Vol. 5, Chap. 9, Sec. 265, p. 485; 21 R.C.L., Sec. 41, p. 44; Batson v. Alexander City Bank, 179 Ala. 490 , 60 So. 313 .

1941Michie on Banks and Banking, Vol. 5, Chap. 9, Sec. 265, p. 485; 21 R.C.L., Sec. 41, p. 44; Batson v. Alexander City Bank, 179 Ala. 490 , 60 So. 313 .

11941–1941
Kennedy v. Lyke neutral
ala · 1917
2 sentences

1931Brannan v. Sherry, 195 Ala. 272 . 71 So. 106 ; Kennedy v. Lyde, 200 Ala. 604 , 76 So. 962 .

1931Brannan v. Sherry, 195 Ala. 272 . 71 So. 106 ; Kennedy v. Lyde, 200 Ala. 604 , 76 So. 962 .

11931–1931
Brannan v. Sherry neutral
ala · 1916
2 sentences

1931Brannan v. Sherry, 195 Ala. 272 . 71 So. 106 ; Kennedy v. Lyde, 200 Ala. 604 , 76 So. 962 .

1931Brannan v. Sherry, 195 Ala. 272 . 71 So. 106 ; Kennedy v. Lyde, 200 Ala. 604 , 76 So. 962 .

11931–1931
Central of Ga. Ry. Co. v. Brister neutral
ala · 1906
2 sentences

1915The decision relied on was modified, in the presently pertinent particular, on rehearing in the case of Central of Georgia Railway Co. v. Brister, 145 Ala. 432, 434-436 , 40 South. 512 .

1915The decision relied on was modified, in the presently pertinent particular, on rehearing in the case of Central of Georgia Railway Co. v. Brister, 145 Ala. 432, 434-436 , 40 South. 512 .

11915–1915
Louisville & Nashville Railroad v. Brinkerhoff & Co. neutral
ala · 1898
1 sentence

1915Co. v. Brinkerhoff, 119 Ala. 606 , 24 South. 892 , treating charge 5, as sustaining the correctness of the instruction above-quoted.

11915–1915
Fletcher v. State neutral
ala · 1902
2 sentences

1914This court, however, is committed to the correctness of the doctrine, and has followed it in a turntable case- — that of Alabama Great Southern Railroad Co. v. Crocker, 131 Ala. 585 , 31 South. 561 .

1914This court, however, is committed to the correctness of the doctrine, and has followed it in a turntable case- — that of Alabama Great Southern Railroad Co. v. Crocker, 131 Ala. 585 , 31 South. 561 .

11914–1914
Carlisle v. Davis green
ala · 1846
1 sentence

1913Evidence of an admission by a defendant that a fixed and certain sum is due, which was claimed of him on account by the plaintiff, will support a count on a stated account, though such admission was made in response to the assertion of a claim by the plaintiff which was not accompanied by a statement of the items comprising the account; the essential matter being that the account received the assent of both parties to it. — 1 Cyc. 367; Loventhal & Son v. Morris, 103 Ala. 332 , 15 South. 672 ; Carlisle v. Davis, 9 Ala. 858 .

11913–1913
Loventhal & Son v. Morris green
ala · 1893
1 sentence

1913Evidence of an admission by a defendant that a fixed and certain sum is due, which was claimed of him on account by the plaintiff, will support a count on a stated account, though such admission was made in response to the assertion of a claim by the plaintiff which was not accompanied by a statement of the items comprising the account; the essential matter being that the account received the assent of both parties to it. — 1 Cyc. 367; Loventhal & Son v. Morris, 103 Ala. 332 , 15 South. 672 ; Carlisle v. Davis, 9 Ala. 858 .

11913–1913
Harwell v. Phillips & Buttroff Manfg. Co. neutral
ala · 1898
1 sentence

1913Co., 123 Ala. 460 , 26 South. 501 .

11913–1913
Beard v. Union & American Publishing Co. green
ala · 1881
1 sentence

1912The contract shows more than an ordinary sale, and in its entirety covers the furnishing of material and the erection of same in a specified manner, as well as many other acts, such as the construction of brick wall, wainscoting, tinting, and the doing of divers things, in addition to supplying the material, and therefore includes the doing of business in this state as previously defined by this court. - — American Amusement Co. v. East Lake Co., supra; Beard’s Case, 71 Ala. 60 .

11912–1912
Ballentine v. Foster neutral
ala · 1900
11911–1911
Schloss v. Hewlett green
ala · 1886
11910–1910
Brunson v. Morgan neutral
ala · 1888
11907–1907
Hyndman v. Hyndman green
vt · 1845
11903–1903
Oakley v. Shelley neutral
ala · 1900
11903–1903
Frank v. Pickens green
ala · 1881
11902–1902
Bartol v. Calvert neutral
ala · 1852
11901–1901
Carhart, Bros. & Co. v. Clark's Adm'r green
ala · 1858
11901–1901
Thornton v. Moore neutral
ala · 1878
11901–1901
Spigener v. State neutral
ala · 1878
11901–1901
Thames v. Herbert green
ala · 1878
11901–1901
Sumner v. Woods neutral
ala · 1880
11900–1900

Where else courts name it

UT 234 (1937–2026) CA 96 (1860–2026) MO 91 (1840–1986) TX 85 (1866–2025) NY 76 (1834–2021) AL 53 (1843–2011) IL 45 (1870–2020) LA 35 (1828–2022) IA 33 (1862–1978) GA 32 (1895–2021) OK 29 (1899–1968) WA 29 (1894–2007) PA 25 (1885–2020) IN 25 (1855–1980) KS 24 (1875–1990) NE 23 (1893–1967) MI 22 (1859–2017) KY 20 (1891–1979) CT 18 (1828–2020) CO 17 (1881–2006) AR 15 (1852–1989) OR 15 (1887–2015) MT 14 (1887–2011) VA 14 (1877–2022) FL 13 (1913–2016) OH 13 (1869–2010) MN 12 (1872–2010) SC 12 (1922–1951) WI 12 (1843–2009) AZ 11 (1900–1999) NC 11 (1881–1989) NJ 11 (1825–2025) MD 10 (1854–2025) ID 9 (1894–2023) MA 8 (1865–2012) NV 8 (1867–1959) ND 8 (1905–2023) MS 7 (1895–1953) SD 6 (1913–1979) WV 6 (1887–2021) HI 6 (1902–2015) DC 6 (1958–2023) WY 6 (1894–1985) NM 5 (1921–1976) DE 5 (1896–1961) TN 4 (1921–1992) RI 4 (1879–2024) NH 3 (1855–1894) ME 2 (1889–1946)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check