correctness rule (Nebraska) · Go Syfert
← Nebraska issues

correctness rule in Nebraska

23 Nebraska opinions name it 1 courts 1893–1967 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Nebraska courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

CaseFollowedCited
Spomer v. Allied Electric & Fixture Co.green
neb · 1930 · cited in 1 Nebraska opinions naming this issue, 1964–1964
2 sentences

1964See Spomer v. Allied Electric & Fixture Co., 120 Neb. 399 , 232 N. W. 767 . *236 The defendants concede the correctness of the rule of law urged by the plaintiff, but dispute its application herein.

1964See Spomer v. Allied Electric & Fixture Co., 120 Neb. 399 , 232 N. W. 767 . *236 The defendants concede the correctness of the rule of law urged by the plaintiff, but dispute its application herein.

11
Carlile v. Bentleygreen
neb · 1908 · cited in 1 Nebraska opinions naming this issue, 1962–1962
2 sentences

1962See Carlile v. Bentley, 81 Neb. 715 , 116 N. W. 772 , in which we said: “Where evidence that is not properly admissible has been received in evidence over objections *578 to a question, but where there is nothing in the form of the question to indicate that the evidence would be inadmissible, the aggrieved party cannot complain, unless he moves to strike out and withdraw from the consideration of the jury the objectionable testimony.” No such motion was made.

1962See Carlile v. Bentley, 81 Neb. 715 , 116 N. W. 772 , in which we said: “Where evidence that is not properly admissible has been received in evidence over objections *578 to a question, but where there is nothing in the form of the question to indicate that the evidence would be inadmissible, the aggrieved party cannot complain, unless he moves to strike out and withdraw from the consideration of the jury the objectionable testimony.” No such motion was made.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Nebraska. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (34)

CaseCitedYears
McIntosh v. State green
neb · 1920
2 sentences

1967The applicable rule is stated in McIntosh v. State, 105 Neb. 328 , 180 N. W. 573 , 12 A. L.

1967The applicable rule is stated in McIntosh v. State, 105 Neb. 328 , 180 N. W. 573 , 12 A. L.

21926–1967
Exchange Elevator Co. v. Marshall green
neb · 1946
2 sentences

1950Exchange Elevator Company v. Marshall, 147 Neb. 48 , 22 N. W. 2d 403 .

1950Exchange Elevator Company v. Marshall, 147 Neb. 48 , 22 N. W. 2d 403 .

11950–1950
State ex rel. Cary v. Cochran green
neb · 1940
2 sentences

1942In State v. Cochran, 138 Neb. 163 , 292 N. W. 239 , a case similar in principle, this court said: “An action for mandamus against the administrative officers of the state to compel the proper enforcement of the irrigation laws, and thereby prevent unlawful diversions of water by junior appropriators, is properly maintainable in the county where the resulting damages occur.” Defendant state officers attack the correctness of this rule and urge that this court depart therefrom.

1942In State v. Cochran, 138 Neb. 163 , 292 N. W. 239 , a case similar in principle, this court said: “An action for mandamus against the administrative officers of the state to compel the proper enforcement of the irrigation laws, and thereby prevent unlawful diversions of water by junior appropriators, is properly maintainable in the county where the resulting damages occur.” Defendant state officers attack the correctness of this rule and urge that this court depart therefrom.

11942–1942
Peter v. Finzer neutral
neb · 1928
1 sentence

1935In this connection the correctness of the doctrine of Peter v. Finzer, 116 Neb. 380 , is challenged because, though in harmony with the determination of the majority of the jurisdictions which have considered the subject involved therein, it is inconsistent with the well-established rules of suretyship.

11935–1935
Chase v. Waterbury Savings Bank green
conn · 1904
1 sentence

1933Noah v. Bowery Savings Bank, 225 N. Y. 284 ; Chase v. Waterbury Savings Bank, 77 Conn. 295 .

11933–1933
Noah v. . Bowery Savings Bank green
ny · 1919
1 sentence

1933Noah v. Bowery Savings Bank, 225 N. Y. 284 ; Chase v. Waterbury Savings Bank, 77 Conn. 295 .

11933–1933
Gillilan v. Kendall & Smith green
neb · 1889
1 sentence

1931The sole question presented to and decided by this court in the case of Gillilan v. Kendall & Smith, 26 Neb. 82 , is the correctness of the instruction of the district court as the same appears on page 84.

11931–1931
Boyd v. United States red
scotus · 1886
1 sentence

1923The only doubt which has been cast upon the correctness of this rule is based upon the decisions of the United States supreme court in Boyd v. United States, 116 U. S. 616 , Weeks v. United States, 232 U. S. 383 , and Silverthorne v. United States, 251 U. S. 385 .

11923–1923
Weeks v. United States red
scotus · 1914
1 sentence

1923The only doubt which has been cast upon the correctness of this rule is based upon the decisions of the United States supreme court in Boyd v. United States, 116 U. S. 616 , Weeks v. United States, 232 U. S. 383 , and Silverthorne v. United States, 251 U. S. 385 .

11923–1923
Silverthorne Lumber Co. v. United States red
scotus · 1920
1 sentence

1923The only doubt which has been cast upon the correctness of this rule is based upon the decisions of the United States supreme court in Boyd v. United States, 116 U. S. 616 , Weeks v. United States, 232 U. S. 383 , and Silverthorne v. United States, 251 U. S. 385 .

11923–1923
City of Beatrice v. Black neutral
neb · 1889
1 sentence

1922The first syllabus is as follows: “Where a public road has been established by proceedings .under the statute and opened and traveled by the public for more than ten years, the public thereby acquires an easement therein, and the court will not examine the original proceedings for the laying out of the road and determine whether or not they were valid.” That case followed City of Beatrice v. Black, 28 Neb. 263 , and has been cited with approval in Close v. Swanson, 64 Neb. 389 , and Kime v. Cass County, 71 Neb. 677 , In Close v. Swanson, supra, the court distinguished the Lydich case, citing t

11922–1922
Close v. Swanson neutral
neb · 1902
1 sentence

1922The first syllabus is as follows: “Where a public road has been established by proceedings .under the statute and opened and traveled by the public for more than ten years, the public thereby acquires an easement therein, and the court will not examine the original proceedings for the laying out of the road and determine whether or not they were valid.” That case followed City of Beatrice v. Black, 28 Neb. 263 , and has been cited with approval in Close v. Swanson, 64 Neb. 389 , and Kime v. Cass County, 71 Neb. 677 , In Close v. Swanson, supra, the court distinguished the Lydich case, citing t

11922–1922
Kime v. Cass County neutral
neb · 1904
1 sentence

1922The first syllabus is as follows: “Where a public road has been established by proceedings .under the statute and opened and traveled by the public for more than ten years, the public thereby acquires an easement therein, and the court will not examine the original proceedings for the laying out of the road and determine whether or not they were valid.” That case followed City of Beatrice v. Black, 28 Neb. 263 , and has been cited with approval in Close v. Swanson, 64 Neb. 389 , and Kime v. Cass County, 71 Neb. 677 , In Close v. Swanson, supra, the court distinguished the Lydich case, citing t

11922–1922
Pasewalk v. Bollman neutral
neb · 1890
1 sentence

1921In affirming the judgment of the court below the rule was announced, in the former opinion of this court, that such judgment was not conclusive upon an indemnitor under those circumstances, and the correctness of that rule is vigorously challenged by the appellant on the ground that it is in conflict with the decision of this court in Pasewalk v. Bollman, 29 Neb. 519 .

11921–1921
Richards v. Connell neutral
neb · 1895
1 sentence

1905In Richards v. Connell, 45 Neb. 467 , it was held: “The owner of a vacant lot upon which is situated a pond of water or dangerous excavation is not required to fence it, or otherwise insure the safety of strangers, old or young, who may resort to said premises not by invitation, express or implied, but for the purpose of amusement or from motives of curiosity.” This rule was referred to with approval by Judge Siodgwiok in an elaborate opinion in Tucker v. Draper, ( 52 Neb. 66 , where it is said: “We have no doubt that under the facts in that case the law Avas correctly applied.” It may be cons

11905–1905
Holt County v. Scott green
neb · 1897
1 sentence

1903In the case of Holt County v. Scott, 53 Neb. 176 , we held that “the fact that an official bond has been approved does not of itself constitute or- evidence the delivery and acceptance of the bond.” It is further stated in the opinion therein (p. 198) that “if the bond is appiwed, this fact also shows that the investigation has disclosed everything to be satisfactory, but the approval does not constitute or evidence a delivery and an acceptance.” We are thus fully committed to the doctrine complained of.

11903–1903
Pennock v. Douglas County neutral
neb · 1894
1 sentence

1899The correctness of the rule announced in Pennock v. Douglas County, supra, is denied by plaintiff.

11899–1899
People ex rel. Drake v. Mahaney green
mich · 1865
1 sentence

1898The supreme court of Michigan steadfastly denied the power of the legislature to deprive municipal corporations of the right of local self-government, although in People v. Mahaney, 13 Mich. 481 , that court, in harmony with the principle announced by many courts, approved a law authorizing the selection by the governor of police commissioners for cities, recognizing a distinction betAveen officers whose duties are purely of a local character and officers chosen for a particular city or toAvn whose duties are of a public or general nature, and which concern the state or general public.

11898–1898
People ex rel. Le Roy v. Hurlbut green
mich · 1871
2 sentences

1898This is but the restatement of the doctrine laid down by Justice Cooley, after an able and exhaustive discussion of the question, participated in by all members of the court, in People v. Hurlbut, 24 Mich. 44 .” Judge McGrath, after stating that the correctness of the doctrine enunciated in People v. Hurlbut, supra, has not been since questioned but approved in numerous cases which he cites, said: “The act of 1857 is therefore invalid, as the legislature cannot divest the people of the county of Wayne of the right to select their own officers in the usual manner.” The Michigan cases referred t

1898This is but the restatement of the doctrine laid down by Justice Cooley, after an able and exhaustive discussion of the question, participated in by all members of the court, in People v. Hurlbut, 24 Mich. 44 .” Judge McGrath, after stating that the correctness of the doctrine enunciated in People v. Hurlbut, supra, has not been since questioned but approved in numerous cases which he cites, said: “The act of 1857 is therefore invalid, as the legislature cannot divest the people of the county of Wayne of the right to select their own officers in the usual manner.” The Michigan cases referred t

11898–1898
Carstens v. McDonald neutral
neb · 1894
1 sentence

1898We are fully persuaded that the facts in the case at bar bring it within the principle announced in Carstens v. McDonald, 38 Neb. 858 , where it was stated: “A mere declaration by a party to a contract'that he does not intend |to carry out the terms thereof before performance is due /will not constitute a breach, so as to authorize the other to at once maintain an action.; for the party, at any time before the period fixed for performance, has the right to recant and comply with his agreement; but if he fails to withdraw his declaration before the time comes for performance, it will excuse the

11898–1898
Terry v. Beatrice Starch Co. neutral
neb · 1895
1 sentence

1898We are fully persuaded that the facts in the case at bar bring it within the principle announced in Carstens v. McDonald, 38 Neb. 858 , where it was stated: “A mere declaration by a party to a contract'that he does not intend |to carry out the terms thereof before performance is due /will not constitute a breach, so as to authorize the other to at once maintain an action.; for the party, at any time before the period fixed for performance, has the right to recant and comply with his agreement; but if he fails to withdraw his declaration before the time comes for performance, it will excuse the

11898–1898
State ex rel. Taylor v. Town Board of Supervisors neutral
wis · 1887
1 sentence

1897Co., 70 Wis. 335 ; State v. Supervisors of Delafield, 69 Wis. 264 .) The correctness of this rule, as an abstract proposition, is attended with no difficulty; but, as with many others, the difficulty arises when we attempt to treat it as of universal applicability.

11897–1897
Kelly v. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co. neutral
wis · 1887
1 sentence

1897Co., 70 Wis. 335 ; State v. Supervisors of Delafield, 69 Wis. 264 .) The correctness of this rule, as an abstract proposition, is attended with no difficulty; but, as with many others, the difficulty arises when we attempt to treat it as of universal applicability.

11897–1897
Stacy v. Vermont Central Railroad neutral
vt · 1860
1 sentence

1895Co., 32 Vt., 551 , the court, while intimating some doubt as to the correctness of the doctrine, states that it has been so long established that it will not be departed from, but also states the reason for it to be, in the first place, that the former decision has the same weight as authority as a decision in another case, and, in the second place, that it is an adjudication between the parties.

11895–1895
Jones v. Nebraska City neutral
neb · 1871
11895–1895
Stewart v. Otoe County green
neb · 1873
11895–1895
Sessions v. Irwin neutral
neb · 1878
11895–1895
Studebaker Bros. Manufacturing Co. v. McCargur neutral
neb · 1886
1 sentence

1895(Studebaker v. McCargur, 20 Neb., 500 ; Harman v. Barhydt, 20 Neb., 625 ; Todd v. Cremer, 36 Neb., 430 ; Whipple v. Fowler, 41 Neb., 675 .) Without considering the correctness of this rule, it is sufficient to say that it has been for many years established in this state.

11895–1895
Harman v. Barhydt neutral
neb · 1886
1 sentence

1895(Studebaker v. McCargur, 20 Neb., 500 ; Harman v. Barhydt, 20 Neb., 625 ; Todd v. Cremer, 36 Neb., 430 ; Whipple v. Fowler, 41 Neb., 675 .) Without considering the correctness of this rule, it is sufficient to say that it has been for many years established in this state.

11895–1895
Dorrington v. Myers green
neb · 1881
11895–1895
Todd v. Cremer neutral
neb · 1893
1 sentence

1895(Studebaker v. McCargur, 20 Neb., 500 ; Harman v. Barhydt, 20 Neb., 625 ; Todd v. Cremer, 36 Neb., 430 ; Whipple v. Fowler, 41 Neb., 675 .) Without considering the correctness of this rule, it is sufficient to say that it has been for many years established in this state.

11895–1895
Whipple v. Fowler green
neb · 1894
1 sentence

1895(Studebaker v. McCargur, 20 Neb., 500 ; Harman v. Barhydt, 20 Neb., 625 ; Todd v. Cremer, 36 Neb., 430 ; Whipple v. Fowler, 41 Neb., 675 .) Without considering the correctness of this rule, it is sufficient to say that it has been for many years established in this state.

11895–1895
Pond v. People green
mich · 1860
11894–1894
Post v. Garrow neutral
neb · 1886
11893–1893

Where else courts name it

UT 233 (1937–2026) CA 96 (1860–2026) MO 91 (1840–1986) TX 85 (1866–2025) NY 76 (1834–2021) AL 53 (1843–2011) IL 45 (1870–2020) LA 35 (1828–2022) IA 33 (1862–1978) GA 32 (1895–2021) WA 29 (1894–2007) OK 29 (1899–1968) PA 25 (1885–2020) IN 25 (1855–1980) KS 24 (1875–1990) NE 23 (1893–1967) MI 22 (1859–2017) KY 20 (1891–1979) CT 18 (1828–2020) CO 17 (1881–2006) AR 15 (1852–1989) OR 15 (1887–2015) MT 14 (1887–2011) VA 14 (1877–2022) OH 13 (1869–2010) FL 13 (1913–2016) SC 12 (1922–1951) MN 12 (1872–2010) WI 12 (1843–2009) AZ 11 (1900–1999) NC 11 (1881–1989) NJ 11 (1825–2025) MD 10 (1854–2025) ID 9 (1894–2023) ND 8 (1905–2023) MA 8 (1865–2012) NV 8 (1867–1959) MS 7 (1895–1953) SD 6 (1913–1979) WV 6 (1887–2021) WY 6 (1894–1985) HI 6 (1902–2015) DC 6 (1958–2023) DE 5 (1896–1961) NM 5 (1921–1976) TN 4 (1921–1992) RI 4 (1879–2024) NH 3 (1855–1894) ME 2 (1889–1946)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check