salutary rule (Kentucky) · Go Syfert
← Kentucky issues

salutary rule in Kentucky

16 Kentucky opinions name it 2 courts 1907–1977 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Kentucky courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

CaseFollowedCited
Wendt v. Berrygreen
kyctapp · 1913 · cited in 1 Kentucky opinions naming this issue, 1960–1960
2 sentences

1960See Wendt v. Berry, 1913, 154 Ky. 586 , 157 S.W. 1115 , 45 L.R.A., N.S., 1101, Ann.Cas.1915C, 493.

1960See Wendt v. Berry, 1913, 154 Ky. 586 , 157 S.W. 1115 , 45 L.R.A., N.S., 1101, Ann.Cas.1915C, 493.

11
Singers-Bigger v. Younggreen
ca8 · 1908 · cited in 1 Kentucky opinions naming this issue, 1917–1917
1 sentence

1917See Singers-Bigger v. Young, 166 Fed. 82 ; Hampton v. Buchanan, 51 Wash. 155 ; Morel v. Hoge, 130 Ga. 625 ; Cone’s Exor. v. Russell, 48 N. J.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Kentucky. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (24)

CaseCitedYears
Commonwealth Ex Rel. Vincent, Atty. Gen. v. Withers green
kyctapphigh · 1936
2 sentences

1977Gen. v. Withers, 266 Ky. 29 , 98 S.W.2d 24 (1936) defined the perimeters of self-interest in situations of this type as follows: It is a salutary doctrine that he who is intrusted with the business of others cannot be allowed to make such business an object of profit to himself.

1977Gen. v. Withers, 266 Ky. 29 , 98 S.W.2d 24 (1936) defined the perimeters of self-interest in situations of this type as follows: It is a salutary doctrine that he who is intrusted with the business of others cannot be allowed to make such business an object of profit to himself.

11977–1977
Estelle v. Williams green
scotus · 1976
2 sentences

1977As Chief Justice Burger stated in Estelle v. Williams, supra: “The reason for this rule is clear: if the defendant has an objection, there is an obligation to call the matter to the court’s attention so that the trial judge will have an opportunity to remedy the situation.” 425 U.S. 501 , 508 n.3, 96 S.Ct. 1691, 1695 .

1977As Chief Justice Burger stated in Estelle v. Williams, supra: “The reason for this rule is clear: if the defendant has an objection, there is an obligation to call the matter to the court’s attention so that the trial judge will have an opportunity to remedy the situation.” 425 U.S. 501 , 508 n.3, 96 S.Ct. 1691, 1695 .

11977–1977
United States v. Virgil D. Dardi, Robert B. Gravis, Charles Rosenthal and Charles Berman green
ca2 · 1964
2 sentences

1965Appellant relies upon United States v. Dardi, *359 330 F.2d 316 (2 C.C.A.) in which the salutary rule is announced: "It is improper to utilize a Grand Jury for the sole or dominating purpose of preparing an already pending indictment for trial." We are in accord with the principle.

1965Appellant relies upon United States v. Dardi, 330 F.2d 316 (2 C.C.A.) in which the salutary rule is announced: “It is improper to utilize a Grand Jury for the sole or dominating purpose of preparing an already pending indictment for trial.” We are in accord with the principle.

11965–1965
Kinmon v. Commonwealth green
kyctapphigh · 1964
1 sentence

1956Cf. Kinmon v. Commonwealth, Ky., 383 S.W.2d 338 .

11956–1956
Meglemery v. Weissinger neutral
kyctapp · 1910
1 sentence

1950The principal reason is in part: “It is of the highest importance that municipal and other bodies of public servants should be free from every kind of personal influence in making appointments that carry with them services to which the public are entitled and compensation that the public must pay.” [ 140 Ky. 353 , 131 S. W. 41 ] In the present case, Smith, the appointee, had helped to create the vacancy and to keep it open for nearly eight months.

11950–1950
Bradley v. Commonwealth green
kyctapphigh · 1927
2 sentences

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

11949–1949
Commonwealth Ex Rel. Cooper v. Howard neutral
kyctapphigh · 1937
2 sentences

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

11949–1949
Allen, Comlth's Atty. v. Bach, District Judge green
kyctapphigh · 1930
2 sentences

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

11949–1949
Petrey v. Holliday green
kyctapp · 1917
2 sentences

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

1949Petrey v. Holliday, 178 Ky. 410 , 199 S. W. 67 ; Bradley v. Commonwealth, 218 Ky. 675 , 291 S. W. 1047 ; Allen v. Bach, 233 Ky. 501 , 26 S. W. 2d 43 ; Commonwealth by Cooper v. Howard, 267 Ky. 287 , 102 S. W. 2d 18 .

11949–1949
City of Lexington v. Thompson green
kyctapphigh · 1933
2 sentences

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

11947–1947
Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, Inc. green
kyctapphigh · 1946
2 sentences

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

11947–1947
Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Comm'n of Cal. green
scotus · 1926
2 sentences

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

11947–1947
Roeske v. Lamb neutral
nm · 1935
1 sentence

1947City of Lexington v. Thompson, 250 Ky. 96 , 61 S. W. 2d 1092 ; Reeves v. Adam Hat Stores, 303 Ky. 633 , 198 S. W. 2d 789 ; Roeske v. Lamb, 39 N. M. 111, 41 P. 2d 522 ; Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, 271 U. S. 583 , 46 S. Ct. 605 , 70 L.

11947–1947
Stark's Adm'x v. Herndon's Adm'r green
kyctapphigh · 1942
2 sentences

1942In the recent opinion of Stark’s Adm’x v. Herndon’s Adm’r, 292 Ky. 469 , 166 S. W. (2d) 828 , delivered November 10, 1942, it is pointed out: “Presumptive evidence is the proof of one fact, which when shown, has a legitimate tendency to lead the mind, to the conclusion that another fact to be proven is in existence. * * * Circumstantial evidence is the proof of facts which have a legitimate tendency from the laws of nature, the usual connection of things, and ordinary transactions of business, etc., to show the reasonable mind that the disputed fact was or was not in existence.” Because the sa

1942In the recent opinion of Stark’s Adm’x v. Herndon’s Adm’r, 292 Ky. 469 , 166 S. W. (2d) 828 , delivered November 10, 1942, it is pointed out: “Presumptive evidence is the proof of one fact, which when shown, has a legitimate tendency to lead the mind, to the conclusion that another fact to be proven is in existence. * * * Circumstantial evidence is the proof of facts which have a legitimate tendency from the laws of nature, the usual connection of things, and ordinary transactions of business, etc., to show the reasonable mind that the disputed fact was or was not in existence.” Because the sa

11942–1942
Cook's Administrator v. Franklin Fire Insurance green
kyctapphigh · 1928
2 sentences

1940Cook’s Adm’r v. Franklin Fire Insurance Company, 224 Ky. 360 , 6 S. W. (2d) 477 .

1940Cook’s Adm’r v. Franklin Fire Insurance Company, 224 Ky. 360 , 6 S. W. (2d) 477 .

11940–1940
Harper v. Harper neutral
· 1887
2 sentences

1929Mon.) 71 : ‘ ‘ The salutary principle of equity, now urged in bar of Cook’s right to relief, should not be extended beyond the reason and policy which dictated it; and it does not, therefore, necessarily apply to a case in which the defending party had himself first conceived the fraud for his own benefit, and either by his artifice or influence induced the complaining party to concur with him in the attempted collusion. ’ ’ This case has its analogue in Harper v. Harper, 85 Ky. 160 , 3 S. W. 5, 6 , 8 Ky. Law Rep. 820 , 7 Am.

1929Mon.) 71 : ‘ ‘ The salutary principle of equity, now urged in bar of Cook’s right to relief, should not be extended beyond the reason and policy which dictated it; and it does not, therefore, necessarily apply to a case in which the defending party had himself first conceived the fraud for his own benefit, and either by his artifice or influence induced the complaining party to concur with him in the attempted collusion. ’ ’ This case has its analogue in Harper v. Harper, 85 Ky. 160 , 3 S. W. 5, 6 , 8 Ky. Law Rep. 820 , 7 Am.

11929–1929
Perciful v. Commonwealth green
kyctapphigh · 1925
2 sentences

1927In Perciful v. Com., 212 Ky. 673 , 279 S. W. 1062 , the court so instructed the jury; approving the instruction, this court said: “'The instruction simply gives effect to the salutary rule that temporary insanity, caused solely by voluntary drunkenness at the time of the homicide, does not exempt one from responsibility for his act.” In larceny an attempt to steal must exist.

1927In Perciful v. Com., 212 Ky. 673 , 279 S. W. 1062 , the court so instructed the jury; approving the instruction, this court said: “'The instruction simply gives effect to the salutary rule that temporary insanity, caused solely by voluntary drunkenness at the time of the homicide, does not exempt one from responsibility for his act.” In larceny an attempt to steal must exist.

11927–1927
Morel v. Hoge green
ga · 1908
1 sentence

1917See Singers-Bigger v. Young, 166 Fed. 82 ; Hampton v. Buchanan, 51 Wash. 155 ; Morel v. Hoge, 130 Ga. 625 ; Cone’s Exor. v. Russell, 48 N. J.

11917–1917
West v. Camden green
· 1890
1 sentence

1917The defendant and the Standard Oil Company, for whose benefit’ it is alleged the contract was made, were not all the stockholders, and it seems to us that it was certainly the right of those other stockholders to have the defendant’s .judgment, as • an officer of the company, exercised with a sole regard to the interests of the company.” West v. Camden, supra, stands at the head of a long line of cases laying down the same salutary rule.

11917–1917
Hampton v. Buchanan green
wash · 1908
1 sentence

1917See Singers-Bigger v. Young, 166 Fed. 82 ; Hampton v. Buchanan, 51 Wash. 155 ; Morel v. Hoge, 130 Ga. 625 ; Cone’s Exor. v. Russell, 48 N. J.

11917–1917
Knight's Admr. v. Illinois Central Railroad green
kyctapp · 1911
1 sentence

1917This rule is well stated in Byassee v. Evans, 143 Ky. 418 , where it is said: “While in an equity case we will give judgment according to the weight of the evidence, and the truth as it shall appear from the whole record, when we find the evidence, as in this case, conflicting, and the questions of fact by reason thereof difficult of solution, some reliance should be placed in the circuit judge’s acquaintance with the parties and witnesses and his consideration of the evidence; and if unconvinced by careful consideration of the record that he has erred to the prejudice of the substantial right

11917–1917
Farmers' & Mechanics' Sayings Co. v. Bazore neutral
ark · 1899
1 sentence

1916Under similar circumstances the Supreme Court of Arkansas, in the case of Farmers’ and Merchants’ Savings Company v. Bazore, et al., 54 S. W. 339 , said: “In a quit claim deed for his interest in the property in controversy made by Bazore to Wilson, there was a provision that Wilson should pay all accounts of the firm in which they were partners; and,, if this includes the note to the Farmers’ and Merchants’ Company, Wilson could not be heard to plead usury as to Bazore’s half interest.” To hold as indicated fully recognizes the salutary doctrine of the courts that usury may not be' collected

11916–1916
Parsons v. Commonwealth neutral
kyctapp · 1879
1 sentence

1907Parsons v. Commonwealth, 78 Ky., 102 ; Campbell v. Commonwealth, 88 Ky., 402 , 11 S. W., 290 , 10 Ky. Law Rep., 975 , 21 Am.

11907–1907
Campbell v. Commonwealth green
kyctapp · 1889
2 sentences

1907Parsons v. Commonwealth, 78 Ky., 102 ; Campbell v. Commonwealth, 88 Ky., 402 , 11 S. W., 290 , 10 Ky. Law Rep., 975 , 21 Am.

1907Parsons v. Commonwealth, 78 Ky., 102 ; Campbell v. Commonwealth, 88 Ky., 402 , 11 S. W., 290 , 10 Ky. Law Rep., 975 , 21 Am.

11907–1907

Where else courts name it

NY 90 (1840–2024) CA 80 (1902–2017) PA 66 (1851–2017) NJ 48 (1884–2025) IL 45 (1875–2009) NC 44 (1891–2010) AL 32 (1850–2016) FL 31 (1855–2025) MO 26 (1873–1987) KS 25 (1904–1999) TX 25 (1881–2010) WV 25 (1875–2020) WA 21 (1894–1989) MI 19 (1894–2019) OR 18 (1901–2023) CT 18 (1819–2014) SC 17 (1905–1973) CO 17 (1894–1991) OK 17 (1897–1960) KY 16 (1907–1977) MN 15 (1897–1974) VA 14 (1910–2017) MT 14 (1920–2022) MA 14 (1906–2006) GA 14 (1895–1980) OH 13 (1898–1992) NE 13 (1894–2017) IN 12 (1854–1957) AR 12 (1895–1997) IA 11 (1921–2017) MD 11 (1888–2024) ND 11 (1901–2007) AZ 10 (1919–1970) ME 10 (1913–2018) TN 9 (1919–2000) WI 9 (1883–2023) NV 7 (1910–2023) DE 6 (1910–2020) DC 6 (1910–1989) LA 6 (1892–1979) MS 5 (1916–1988) WY 5 (1891–1975) VT 5 (1829–2004) RI 5 (1924–2011) ID 4 (1894–2009) UT 4 (1893–1939) HI 4 (1923–1953) NM 3 (1943–1965) SD 3 (1917–1948) PR 2 (1944–1952) VI 2 (1991–1997)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check