recognition rule (Indiana) · Go Syfert
← Indiana issues

recognition rule in Indiana

9 Indiana opinions name it 2 courts 1887–2013 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Indiana courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
Guilford School Township v. Robertsgreen
indctapp · 1902 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 1949–1949
2 sentences

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Indiana. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (16)

CaseCitedYears
McConaughy v. Secretary of State green
minn · 1909
2 sentences

2013Id. at 22 (quoting McConaughy, 119 N.W. at 417 ).

2013Id. at 22 (quoting McConaughy, 119 N.W. at 417 ).

22013–2013
Kent v. United States green
scotus · 1966
2 sentences

1979The parens patriae doctrine should never cease to shelter those entitled to its benefits and, as suggested in Kent v. United States (1966), 383 U.S. 541 , 86 S.Ct. 1045 , 16 L.Ed.2d 84 , procedural arbitrariness could effectively render it impotent.

1979The parens patriae doctrine should never cease to shelter those entitled to its benefits and, as suggested in Kent v. United States (1966), 383 U.S. 541 , 86 S.Ct. 1045 , 16 L.Ed.2d 84 , procedural arbitrariness could effectively render it impotent.

11979–1979
Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere green
mass · 1936
2 sentences

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11949–1949
Perreault v. Hall green
· 1946
1 sentence

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11949–1949
Grimison v. Board of Education neutral
kan · 1932
2 sentences

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11949–1949
Greco v. Roper green
· 1945
2 sentences

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11949–1949
Ansorge v. City of Green Bay neutral
wis · 1929
2 sentences

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

1949See also Guilford School Tp. v. Roberts (1902), 28 Ind. App. 355 , 62 N. E. 711 ; Grimison v. Board of Education (1932), 136 Kan. 511 , 16 P. 2d 492 ; Greco v. Roper (1945), 145 Ohio St. 243 , 61 N. E. 2d 307 ; Rinaldo v. School Committee of Revere (1936), 294 Mass. 167 , 1 N. E. 2d 37 ; Ansorge v. Green Bay (1929), 198 Wis. 320 , 224 N. W. 119 ; Perreault v. Hall (1946), 94 N. H. 191, 49 A. 2d 812 .

11949–1949
City of Huntingburgh v. First neutral
indctapp · 1896
2 sentences

1938In the case of City of Huntingburgh v. First (1896), 15 Ind. App. 552 , 43 N. E. 17 , appellee recovered judgment against the city for damages sustained when she tripped upon a loose board in a sidewalk which tipped up when her companion, walking by her side, stepped upon it.

1938In the case of City of Huntingburgh v. First (1896), 15 Ind. App. 552 , 43 N. E. 17 , appellee recovered judgment against the city for damages sustained when she tripped upon a loose board in a sidewalk which tipped up when her companion, walking by her side, stepped upon it.

11938–1938
Michael v. Matson green
kan · 1909
2 sentences

1917Indeed, we think an’ examination of the law writers and the decisions of the courts of various jurisdictions will disclose that the courts of most jurisdictions have expressed the rule governing in such cases substantially as above stated. 26 Cyc 105-109, and cases in notes Nos. 19-23; Matson v. Michael (1909) 81 Kan. 360 , 105 Pac. 537 , L.

1917Indeed, we think an’ examination of the law writers and the decisions of the courts of various jurisdictions will disclose that the courts of most jurisdictions have expressed the rule governing in such cases substantially as above stated. 26 Cyc 105-109, and cases in notes Nos. 19-23; Matson v. Michael (1909) 81 Kan. 360 , 105 Pac. 537 , L.

11917–1917
Kern v. Bridwell green
ind · 1889
2 sentences

1915Kern v. Bridewell (1899), 119 Ind. 226 , 21 N. E. 664 , 12 Am.

1915Kern v. Bridewell (1899), 119 Ind. 226 , 21 N. E. 664 , 12 Am.

11915–1915
Powers v. . Shepard neutral
ny · 1872
1 sentence

1887The principle which controls this phase of the question was decided in Powers v. Shepard, 48 N. Y. 540 , for, as the reporter’s head-note states, it was there held that “ The re-enactment of certain of the sections of one act, in a subsequent, one providing for a different scheme, is not a repeal by implication of those sections in the first act.” Our own cases give a substantial recognition to this doctrine.

11887–1887
Cheezem v. State green
ind · 1850
1 sentence

1887Cheezem v. State, 2 Ind. 149 ; Martindale v. Martindale, 10 Ind. 566 ; Cordell v. State, 22 Ind. 1 ; Gorley v. Sewell, 77 Ind. 316 -(319).

11887–1887
Martindale v. Martindale neutral
ind · 1858
1 sentence

1887Cheezem v. State, 2 Ind. 149 ; Martindale v. Martindale, 10 Ind. 566 ; Cordell v. State, 22 Ind. 1 ; Gorley v. Sewell, 77 Ind. 316 -(319).

11887–1887
Cordell v. State neutral
ind · 1864
1 sentence

1887Cheezem v. State, 2 Ind. 149 ; Martindale v. Martindale, 10 Ind. 566 ; Cordell v. State, 22 Ind. 1 ; Gorley v. Sewell, 77 Ind. 316 -(319).

11887–1887
Pennsylvania Co. v. Sinclair green
ind · 1878
1 sentence

1887In Pennsylvania Co. v. Sinclair, supra, it was said r “ Where an intention to commit the injury exists, whether that intention be actual or constructive only, the wrongful act ceases to be a merely negligent injury, and becomes one of violence or aggression.” This is a recognition of the doctrine of the ancient authorities to which we have referred, for they assert the distinction between an actual and an implied or constructive intention.

11887–1887
Gorley v. Sewell green
· 1881
1 sentence

1887Cheezem v. State, 2 Ind. 149 ; Martindale v. Martindale, 10 Ind. 566 ; Cordell v. State, 22 Ind. 1 ; Gorley v. Sewell, 77 Ind. 316 -(319).

11887–1887

Where else courts name it

CA 50 (1895–2025) NY 41 (1826–2018) IL 28 (1889–2025) PA 23 (1909–2017) TX 20 (1902–2019) MD 19 (1856–2015) OH 16 (1900–2016) NC 14 (1892–2019) WI 13 (1871–2025) TN 12 (1926–2023) CT 12 (1860–2018) WA 11 (1906–2018) GA 10 (1904–2013) KY 10 (1838–1993) LA 10 (1907–2013) FL 9 (1944–2025) NJ 9 (1954–2025) IN 9 (1887–2013) IA 8 (1863–2021) CO 8 (1884–2017) MO 8 (1856–1988) MA 7 (1966–2003) OK 6 (1911–2017) AL 6 (1916–2009) MI 6 (1894–2000) UT 5 (1911–2008) SC 4 (1893–2010) MN 4 (1935–2024) MT 4 (1896–1984) ME 4 (1971–2002) WV 4 (1970–2023) DE 4 (1980–2019) OR 4 (1960–1973) NH 4 (1998–2014) MS 4 (2002–2021) NE 4 (1985–2014) AZ 3 (1971–1993) AR 3 (1910–1988) ID 3 (1948–1980) HI 3 (1920–2005) RI 3 (1992–2011) KS 3 (1927–2022) VT 3 (1909–2012) AK 2 (1971–2003) NV 2 (1939–1983) VA 2 (1987–2004) SD 2 (1920–2011) NM 2 (1915–1985) WY 2 (1931–1961)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check