suggested rule (Utah) · Go Syfert
← Utah issues

suggested rule in Utah

7 Utah opinions name it 2 courts 1917–2026 3 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Utah courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

CaseFollowedCited
State v. Arnoldgreen
utah · 1938 · cited in 2 Utah opinions naming this issue, 2022–2022
2 sentences

2022State v. Arnold, 79 P.2d 87, 87 (Utah 1938).

2022State v. Arnold, 79 P.2d 87, 87 (Utah 1938).

22
Kerr v. City of Salt Lakegreen
utah · 2013 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 2018–2018
2 sentences

2018See Kerr v. City of Salt Lake , 2013 UT 75 , ¶ 44, 322 P.3d 669 (stating that under the doctrine of invited error, "a litigant may not induce the trial court to make a ruling and then argue on appeal that the ruling was in error").

2018See Kerr v. City of Salt Lake , 2013 UT 75 , ¶ 44, 322 P.3d 669 (stating that under the doctrine of invited error, "a litigant may not induce the trial court to make a ruling and then argue on appeal that the ruling was in error").

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Utah. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (9)

CaseCitedYears
State v. James green
utahctapp · 2026
1 sentence

2026And in the absence of any such evidence, we agree with the State that “painting a child victim as a liar—particularly in a sexual abuse case—can backfire at trial” and that this is a “risk that experienced trial counsel would recognize, but a lay defendant might not.” Counsel instead chose a strategy that called into question Ashley’s memories without accusing her of lying, and this approach allowed Counsel to humanize Ashley 20221106-CA 33 2026 UT App 20 State v. James without conceding guilt.

12026–2026
Colo. Dept. of Soc. Serv. v. BD. OF CTY. COM'RS green
colo · 1985
1 sentence

1991Fifty years later, in Colorado Department of Social Services v. Board of County Commissioners, 697 P.2d 1 (Colo.1985), the court was confronted with a legislative act requiring both the state and the counties to contribute revenues to finance public assistance.

11991–1991
Hughes v. State green
colo · 1935
2 sentences

1991The court suggested a test to be used for determining whether a purpose is state or local: “Is it for strictly county uses, for which the county or its inhabitants alone would benefit, or is it for a purpose in which the entire state is concerned or will benefit?” Id., 49 P.2d at 1011 .

1991The court suggested a test to be used for determining whether a purpose is state or local: “Is it for strictly county uses, for which the county or its inhabitants alone would benefit, or is it for a purpose in which the entire state is concerned or will benefit?” Id., 49 P.2d at 1011 .

11991–1991
Justesen v. Olsen green
utah · 1935
2 sentences

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

11953–1953
Peterson v. Wood green
utah · 1927
2 sentences

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

11953–1953
Wrathall v. Johnson green
utah · 1935
2 sentences

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

11953–1953
Herriman Irrigation Co. v. Keel green
utah · 1902
2 sentences

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

1953Co. v. Keel, 25 Utah 96 , 69 P. 719 ; Peterson v. Wood, 71 Utah 77 , 262 P. 828 ; Wrathall v. Johnson, 86 Utah 50 , 40 P. 2d 755 ; Justesen v. Olsen, 86 Utah 158 , 40 P. 2d 802 ; see also Hutchins, Selected Problems in the Law of Water Rights in the West, pages 173 to 180, dealing with “Appropriations of Ground Water." Note that the cases which are cited are in accord with the above statement, but that the author suggests a contrary rule under the Utah law, which would be less favorable to appellants, also note our comment on those cases and the suggested rule in Hanson v. Salt Lake City, supr

11953–1953
Carreras v. Municipality of Humacao neutral
prsupreme · 1940
1 sentence

1917It is therefore error to leave the case to the jury where the plaintiff has offered no evidence which indicates that other employers in the same business had promulgated any such rule, or that the suggested rule was necessary or practicable, or that the necessity and propriety of malting such rule was so obvious as to make the question one of common knowledge and experience. ’ ’ McCarty, District Judge, sitting in the ease of Fritz v. Electric Light Co., 18 Utah, 493 , 56 Pac. 90 , in speaking for this court, says: “There are certain kinds of employment where, on account of their nature, it be

11917–1917
Fritz v. Salt Lake & Ogden Gas & Electric Light Co. neutral
utah · 1899
1 sentence

1917It is therefore error to leave the case to the jury where the plaintiff has offered no evidence which indicates that other employers in the same business had promulgated any such rule, or that the suggested rule was necessary or practicable, or that the necessity and propriety of malting such rule was so obvious as to make the question one of common knowledge and experience. ’ ’ McCarty, District Judge, sitting in the ease of Fritz v. Electric Light Co., 18 Utah, 493 , 56 Pac. 90 , in speaking for this court, says: “There are certain kinds of employment where, on account of their nature, it be

11917–1917

Where else courts name it

CA 47 (1934–2025) PA 45 (1899–2026) IL 34 (1908–2023) TX 24 (1938–2021) OH 15 (1970–2026) NC 13 (1924–2018) FL 12 (1957–2026) OR 11 (1944–2024) MO 11 (1960–2017) NY 10 (1936–2013) MA 10 (1977–2011) NJ 9 (1950–2008) AZ 9 (1965–2025) MD 8 (1974–2015) UT 7 (1917–2026) CT 6 (1940–2013) AR 6 (1950–2016) DC 6 (1959–2005) WY 6 (1967–2008) MI 6 (1957–2014) LA 6 (1975–2023) IN 5 (1924–2008) GA 5 (1983–2005) WA 5 (1970–2025) CO 4 (1986–2019) MN 4 (1897–2015) OK 4 (1932–2014) KS 4 (1964–2009) TN 4 (2004–2017) RI 3 (1982–2011) AK 3 (1980–1997) NE 3 (1951–2025) MT 3 (1928–2003) IA 2 (2001–2021) SD 2 (1979–1988) SC 2 (1984–1990) WV 2 (1955–1955) NH 2 (2006–2014) MS 2 (1972–1996) KY 2 (1919–1959) WI 2 (1977–2000)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check