collateral challenge in Indiana

23 Indiana opinions name it 2 courts 1887–2020 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Indiana courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (7)

Case	Followed	Cited
Weatherford v. Stategreen ind · 1993 · cited in 4 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 1998–2002 2 sentences 2002DISCUSSION "Indiana's postconviction rules do not afford convicted persons an opportunity for a super appeal, but instead create a narrower remedy permitting the collateral challenge of convictions under certain enumerated cireumstances." Jones v. State, 693 N.E.2d 605, 607 (Ind.Ct.App.1998) (citing Weatherford v. State, 619 N.E.2d 915, 916 (Ind.1993)). 2002DECISION “Indiana’s postconviction rules do not afford convicted persons an opportunity for a super appeal, but instead create a narrower remedy permitting the collateral challenge of convictions under certain enumerated circumstances.” Jones v. State, 693 N.E.2d 605, 607 (Ind.Ct.App.1998) (citing Weatherford v. State, 619 N.E.2d 915, 916 (Ind.1993)).	4	4
Williams v. Stategreen ind · 2000 · cited in 2 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2001–2002 2 sentences 2002Williams v. State, 724 N.E.2d 1070, 1076 (Ind.2000). 2001Williams v. State, 724 N.E.2d 1070, 1076 (Ind.2000).	2	2
Jones v. Stategreen indctapp · 1998 · cited in 2 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2002–2002 2 sentences 2002DISCUSSION "Indiana's postconviction rules do not afford convicted persons an opportunity for a super appeal, but instead create a narrower remedy permitting the collateral challenge of convictions under certain enumerated cireumstances." Jones v. State, 693 N.E.2d 605, 607 (Ind.Ct.App.1998) (citing Weatherford v. State, 619 N.E.2d 915, 916 (Ind.1993)). 2002DECISION “Indiana’s postconviction rules do not afford convicted persons an opportunity for a super appeal, but instead create a narrower remedy permitting the collateral challenge of convictions under certain enumerated circumstances.” Jones v. State, 693 N.E.2d 605, 607 (Ind.Ct.App.1998) (citing Weatherford v. State, 619 N.E.2d 915, 916 (Ind.1993)).	2	2
Stephens v. Stategreen ind · 2004 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2020–2020 1 sentence 2020Cf. Stephens v. State, 818 N.E.2d 936, 939 (Ind. 2004) (stating that a defendant cannot collaterally attack a sentence on appeal from a probation revocation).	1	1
Nemec v. Shradergreen del · 2010 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2016–2016 1 sentence 2016See Nemec, 991 A.2d at 1127 (recognizing that challenged conduct may not breach the implied covenant if it advances the legitimate interest of a relying counter-party).	1	1
Indiana Department of Environmental Management v. Conardgreen ind · 1993 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2006–2006 1 sentence 2006Mgmt. v. Conard, 614 N.E.2d 916, 922 (Ind.1993) (defining a collateral challenge as "an attack made in a proceeding that has an independent purpose other than to impeach or overturn the judgment, although impeaching or overturning the judgment may be necessary to the success of the action”). 7 .	1	1
Bivins v. Stategreen ind · 2000 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 2001–2001 1 sentence 2001See Bivins v. State, 735 N.E.2d 1116 (Ind.2000).	1	1

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

Case	Negative	Cited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Indiana. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (28)

Case	Cited	Years
Ford v. State green indctapp · 2001 2 sentences 2003Ford, 755 N.E.2d at 1141 . 2002Id.	2	2002–2003
Van Meter v. State green ind · 1995 1 sentence 2018“Criminal defendants may not circumvent these procedures by seeking remedies under the civil law.” Id. (internal citations omitted); see also Ind. Post-Conviction Rule 1(b) (providing that the post- conviction rules provide the exclusive method to raise a collateral challenge to a criminal conviction or sentence).	1	2018–2018
Cinergy Corp. v. St. Paul Surplus Lines Insurance Co. green indctapp · 2003 1 sentence 2012Cinergy, 785 N.E.2d at 590 .	1	2012–2012
Jackson v. State green indctapp · 2005 1 sentence 2006Today we issue an order denying transfer in Jackson v. State, 826 N.E.2d 120 (Ind.Ct.App.2005).	1	2006–2006
Groseclose Ex Rel. Harries v. Dutton green tnmd · 1984 2 sentences 2005Lexis 3702 (M.D.Pa.2004) (relying on both the principles of Rees and Dusky to determine competency to forego a collateral challenge); Groseclose v. Dutton, 594 F.Supp. 949 , 957 n. 4 (M.D.Tenn.1984) (stating that Dusky is analytically equivalent to the Rees competency test). 2005Lexis 3702 (M.D.Pa.2004) (relying on both the principles of Rees and Dusky to determine competency to forego a collateral challenge); Groseclose v. Dutton, 594 F.Supp. 949 , 957 n. 4 (M.D.Tenn.1984) (stating that Dusky is analytically equivalent to the Rees competency test).	1	2005–2005
Timberlake v. State green ind · 2001 1 sentence 2005Id. (citing Ind. Post-Conviction Rule 1(1)).	1	2005–2005
Commonwealth v. Lopez green mass · 1998 2 sentences 2004After discussing the holding in Parke , the court concluded that "a collateral challenge, like the defendant's, to a prior conviction by guilty plea ... must be accompanied by sufficient credible and reliable evidence to rebut a presumption that the prior conviction was valid." Id. 2004After discussing the holding in Parke, the court concluded that "a collateral challenge, like the defendant's, to a prior conviction by guilty plea ... must be accompanied by sufficient credible and reliable evidence to rebut a presumption that the prior conviction was valid." Id.	1	2004–2004
McBroom v. Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. green scotus · 2002 1 sentence 2002A collateral challenge to the conviction and sentence under Indiana’s rules for post-conviction relief was denied by the post-conviction court and affirmed on appeal in Wrinkles v. State, 749 N.E.2d 1179 (Ind.2001), cert. denied — U.S. -, 122 S.Ct. 1610 , 152 L.Ed.2d 624 (2002).	1	2002–2002
Straughn v. Kimmy green scotus · 2002 1 sentence 2002A collateral challenge to the conviction and sentence under Indiana’s rules for post-conviction relief was denied by the post-conviction court and affirmed on appeal in Wrinkles v. State, 749 N.E.2d 1179 (Ind.2001), cert. denied — U.S. -, 122 S.Ct. 1610 , 152 L.Ed.2d 624 (2002).	1	2002–2002
Wrinkles v. State green ind · 2001 1 sentence 2002A collateral challenge to the conviction and sentence under Indiana’s rules for post-conviction relief was denied by the post-conviction court and affirmed on appeal in Wrinkles v. State, 749 N.E.2d 1179 (Ind.2001), cert. denied — U.S. -, 122 S.Ct. 1610 , 152 L.Ed.2d 624 (2002).	1	2002–2002
Minnick v. State green ind · 1998 1 sentence 1999Minnick v. State, 698 N.E.2d 745 (Ind.1998).	1	1999–1999
Adams v. New York green · 1904 1 sentence 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L.	1	1945–1945
McSwain v. State neutral indctapp · 1929 2 sentences 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L. 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L.	1	1945–1945
Hantz v. State neutral indctapp · 1929 2 sentences 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L. 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L.	1	1945–1945
People v. Brocamp green ill · 1923 2 sentences 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L. 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L.	1	1945–1945
People v. Castree green ill · 1924 2 sentences 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L. 1945In support of this view appellee cites Hantz v. State (May 8, 1929, Transfer denied Jan. 29, 1931), 92 Ind. App. 108 , 166 N. E. 439 ; McSwain v. State (May 10, 1929), 89 Ind. App. 592 , 166 N. E. 444 , 167 N. E. 568 ; People v. Castree (1924), 311 Ill. 392 , 143 N. E. 112 ; People v. Brocamp (1923), 307 Ill. 448 , 138 N. E. 728; Adams v. New York (1904), 192 U S. 585, 48 L.	1	1945–1945
State v. Shelton neutral mo · 1926 2 sentences 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc	1	1927–1927
Bergman v. State green wis · 1926 2 sentences 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc	1	1927–1927
Frihart v. State green wis · 1926 2 sentences 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc 1927“When a magistrate issues a search warrant, he thereby declares that he is satisfied that probable cause exists.” Frihart v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 622 , 208 N. W. 469 ; Bergman v. State (1926), 189 Wis. 615 , 208 N. W. 470 . 346 State v. Shelton (1926), 314 Mo. 333 , 284 S. W. 433 , holds that it cannot be presumed, in a collateral inquiry on a motion to quash a search warrant issued by a justice of the peace on application of the prosecuting attorney and served by the sheriff, that such officers have failed to perform their duties properly and that a defendant may not thus impeach the searc	1	1927–1927
Exchange Bank v. Ault neutral ind · 1885 1 sentence 1897Bailey v. Rinker, 146 Ind. 129 ; Shoemaker v. South Bend Spark Arrester Co., 135 Ind. 471; Nichols v. State, 127 Ind. 406 ; Exchange Bank v. Ault, 102 Ind. 322 .	1	1897–1897
Nichols v. State green ind · 1891 1 sentence 1897Bailey v. Rinker, 146 Ind. 129 ; Shoemaker v. South Bend Spark Arrester Co., 135 Ind. 471; Nichols v. State, 127 Ind. 406 ; Exchange Bank v. Ault, 102 Ind. 322 .	1	1897–1897
Shoemaker v. South Bend Spark Arrester Co. green ind · 1893 1 sentence 1897Bailey v. Rinker, 146 Ind. 129 ; Shoemaker v. South Bend Spark Arrester Co., 135 Ind. 471; Nichols v. State, 127 Ind. 406 ; Exchange Bank v. Ault, 102 Ind. 322 .	1	1897–1897
Bailey v. Rinker green ind · 1896 1 sentence 1897Bailey v. Rinker, 146 Ind. 129 ; Shoemaker v. South Bend Spark Arrester Co., 135 Ind. 471; Nichols v. State, 127 Ind. 406 ; Exchange Bank v. Ault, 102 Ind. 322 .	1	1897–1897
Wright v. State neutral ind · 1855	1	1887–1887
Wentworth v. Alexander neutral ind · 1878	1	1887–1887
Smith v. Hess green ind · 1884	1	1887–1887
Holderman v. Thompson neutral ind · 1886	1	1887–1887
Willis v. Bayles green ind · 1886	1	1887–1887

Statutes the citing opinions construe

IN § Ind. Code § 35-50-2-9 (4)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

PA 107 (1909–2026) WA 90 (1927–2026) OH 66 (1973–2026) TX 63 (1899–2026) CA 53 (1908–2024) NY 44 (1866–2026) FL 38 (1983–2019) VT 36 (1971–2026) IL 33 (1924–2026) MD 25 (1982–2022) IN 23 (1887–2020) OR 22 (1888–2025) MI 21 (1927–2024) AR 19 (1992–2026) MA 13 (1991–2026) MO 13 (1900–2024) GA 13 (1968–2024) CT 12 (1997–2025) KS 12 (1969–2024) AL 11 (1899–2001) WI 10 (1928–2026) CO 10 (1984–2022) NJ 9 (1901–2026) NM 9 (1993–2020) IA 7 (1901–2018) SD 6 (2006–2014) TN 6 (2002–2009) DC 6 (1979–2024) NH 6 (1988–2015) UT 5 (2004–2019) NE 5 (1979–2006) MT 4 (2008–2015) ME 4 (2010–2018) NC 4 (1887–2003) ID 4 (1983–2024) MN 4 (1988–2014) KY 4 (1898–2023) VA 3 (2001–2008) AZ 3 (2011–2024) MS 3 (1922–2011) RI 3 (1998–2007) OK 2 (1978–1981) DE 2 (2021–2021) NV 2 (1995–2013) AK 2 (1967–1988)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check