essence claim (Iowa) · Go Syfert
← Iowa issues

essence claim in Iowa

12 Iowa opinions name it 1 courts 1904–2023 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Iowa courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
Allen v. United Statesgreen
· 1896 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 2023–2023
1 sentence

2023See Davis, 1A verdict-urging instruction is frequently referred to as an “Allen charge,” originating from the Supreme Court case Allen v. United States, 164 U.S. 492 , 501–02 (1896), which approved the use of a verdict-urging instruction.

11
Ahrendsen v. Iowa Department of Human Servicesgreen
iowa · 2000 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 2002–2002
1 sentence

2002Ahrendsen v. Iowa Dep’t of Human Servs., 613 N.W.2d 674, 678 (Iowa 2000) (citation omitted).

11
State v. Coygreen
iowa · 1986 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1987–1987
1 sentence

1987We have recently observed that confrontation is primarily guaranteed “for the purpose of cross-examination, which cannot be had except by the direct and personal putting of questions and obtaining immediate answers.” State v. Coy, 397 N.W.2d 730, 733 (Iowa 1986) (citing State v. Strable, 313 N.W.2d 497, 500 (Iowa 1981)).

11
State v. Strablegreen
iowa · 1981 · cited in 1 Iowa opinions naming this issue, 1987–1987
1 sentence

1987We have recently observed that confrontation is primarily guaranteed “for the purpose of cross-examination, which cannot be had except by the direct and personal putting of questions and obtaining immediate answers.” State v. Coy, 397 N.W.2d 730, 733 (Iowa 1986) (citing State v. Strable, 313 N.W.2d 497, 500 (Iowa 1981)).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Iowa. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (12)

CaseCitedYears
Woods v. Cole green
ill · 1998
2 sentences

2006Indeed, if an apportionment of liability were permitted, the act of one tortfeasor would no longer be the act of ah, and the essence of the doctrine of concerted action would be destroyed. 693 N.E.2d at 337 .

2006Indeed, if an apportionment of liability were permitted, the act of one tortfeasor would no longer be the act of all, and the essence of the doctrine of concerted action would be destroyed. 693 N.E.2d at 337 .

22006–2006
Vania Minor, Individually and as Mother, Natural Guardian and Next Best Friend of D.A. v. State of Iowa, Becky Grabe, Individually and Cleo Hester, Individually green
iowa · 2012
2 sentences

2014Id. at 407 .

2014Id. at 407 .

12014–2014
Arnold Panella v. United States green
ca2 · 1954
2 sentences

2011Id. at 624 .

2011Id. at 624 .

12011–2011
Starrett v. Baudler green
iowa · 1917
1 sentence

1977As aptly stated in Starrett v. Baudler, 181 Iowa 965, 978 , 165 N.W. 216 , 220 (1917): “It is not the essence of this test (continuity), as applied to a water course, that the water should flow of itself continuously, but the test is that the artificial apparatus by which its flow is produced is of a permanent nature.” Requisite continuity was here adequately manifested.

11977–1977
Baer v. Baird Machine Co. green
conn · 1911
2 sentences

1939Baer v. Baird Machine Co., 84 Conn. 269, 273 , 79 A. 673 .

1939Baer v. Baird Machine Co., 84 Conn. 269, 273 , 79 A. 673 .

11939–1939
Bates v. Remley green
iowa · 1937
2 sentences

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

11939–1939
First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell neutral
iowa · 1934
2 sentences

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

11939–1939
666 West End Avenue Corp. v. Palmer green
iowa · 1931
2 sentences

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

1939On the contrary, it is of the very essence of the claim itself. ’ ’ For later confirmation of this sound principle see In re Estate of Palmer, 212 Iowa 21 , 236 N. W. 58 ; First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Terbell, 217 Iowa 624 , 252 N. W. 769 ; Bates v. Remley, 223 Iowa 654 , 273 N. W. 180 .

11939–1939
Louisville Water Co. v. Lally neutral
kyctapp · 1916
1 sentence

1917In such case, that which purports to be evidence is insufficient to constitute a compliance with the requirements of the scintilla rule, for it is the essence of that rule that there must be some evidence (however slight) upon which the jury might rationally find a verdict for the party producing it.” See, also, Louisville Water Co. v. Lally, (Ky.) 182 S. W. 186 , and Peat v. Chicago, M. & St.

11917–1917
Camp v. Camp neutral
vt · 1887
1 sentence

1904Redfield v. Redfield, 75 Iowa, 435 ; Wallace v. Finch, 24 Mich. 255 ; Camp v. Camp, 59 Vt. 667 ( 10 Atl.

11904–1904
Wallace v. Finch green
mich · 1872
1 sentence

1904Redfield v. Redfield, 75 Iowa, 435 ; Wallace v. Finch, 24 Mich. 255 ; Camp v. Camp, 59 Vt. 667 ( 10 Atl.

11904–1904
Redfield v. Redfield neutral
iowa · 1888
1 sentence

1904Redfield v. Redfield, 75 Iowa, 435 ; Wallace v. Finch, 24 Mich. 255 ; Camp v. Camp, 59 Vt. 667 ( 10 Atl.

11904–1904

Where else courts name it

PA 275 (1927–2026) IL 97 (1928–2026) CA 97 (1919–2025) NJ 95 (1937–2026) NY 83 (1908–2025) TX 75 (1941–2025) OH 43 (1901–2025) MI 41 (1936–2025) OR 39 (1899–2022) IN 34 (1932–2025) VA 32 (1896–2025) CT 31 (1933–2025) FL 31 (1961–2024) WA 30 (1913–2026) NC 27 (1931–2025) ME 26 (1995–2024) MD 25 (1968–2025) MA 24 (1960–2025) DC 22 (1977–2024) NE 20 (1895–2024) MO 19 (1941–2024) WI 19 (1909–2025) AZ 19 (1922–2026) WV 19 (1894–2024) GA 18 (1951–2016) NM 17 (1967–2016) AL 15 (1904–2004) LA 14 (1932–2015) NH 14 (1987–2015) CO 14 (1910–2026) DE 13 (1951–2024) IA 12 (1904–2023) MT 11 (1916–2005) TN 10 (1948–2022) KS 10 (1934–2023) KY 10 (1923–2025) VT 8 (1857–2023) RI 7 (1962–2026) AR 7 (1921–2005) ID 6 (1971–1991) OK 6 (1981–2013) AK 6 (1978–1997) MN 6 (1920–2019) HI 5 (1991–2009) WY 5 (1967–2007) SD 5 (1990–2011) PR 3 (1954–1957) MS 3 (1902–2019) UT 2 (1942–2015)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check