careful analysis (Delaware) · Go Syfert
← Delaware issues

careful analysis in Delaware

11 Delaware opinions name it 3 courts 1925–2026 3 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Delaware courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
Du Pont v. Du Pontgreen
del · 1951 · cited in 1 Delaware opinions naming this issue, 2026–2026
2 sentences

2026That section provides, in relevant part, that “[t]he General Assembly, notwithstanding anything contained in this Article, shall have power to repeal or alter any Act of the General Assembly giving jurisdiction to . . . the Court of Chancery . . . [and that it] shall also have power to confer upon . . . the Court of Chancery jurisdiction and powers in addition to those hereinbefore mentioned . . . .”49 After a careful analysis of the constitutional development of 47 Dupont II, 85 A.2d at 726. 48 Id. at 727. 49 Id. 23 the Court of Chancery’s equity jurisdiction, the DuPont II majority concluded

2026That section provides, in relevant part, that “[t]he General Assembly, notwithstanding anything contained in this Article, shall have power to repeal or alter any Act of the General Assembly giving jurisdiction to . . . the Court of Chancery . . . [and that it] shall also have power to confer upon . . . the Court of Chancery jurisdiction and powers in addition to those hereinbefore mentioned . . . .”49 After a careful analysis of the constitutional development of 47 Dupont II, 85 A.2d at 726. 48 Id. at 727. 49 Id. 23 the Court of Chancery’s equity jurisdiction, the DuPont II majority concluded

11
Crawford v. Washingtongreen
scotus · 2004 · cited in 1 Delaware opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
2 sentences

2025But the parties have cited no case squarely addressing the issue, and we have similarly found none. 84 Carrion, 265 A.3d at 126. 85 Crawford, 541 U.S. at 68. 22 Crawford, the United States Supreme Court declined to define a “testimonial statement,” identifying instead several factual situations which comprised “core” testimonial statements, and leaving for courts in the future to define its contours.86 Following the guidance set forth in Crawford, our Court, in Chavis v. State, conducted a careful analysis of testimonial statements in the context of forensic evidence.87 In Chavis several non-t

2025But the parties have cited no case squarely addressing the issue, and we have similarly found none. 84 Carrion, 265 A.3d at 126. 85 Crawford, 541 U.S. at 68. 22 Crawford, the United States Supreme Court declined to define a “testimonial statement,” identifying instead several factual situations which comprised “core” testimonial statements, and leaving for courts in the future to define its contours.86 Following the guidance set forth in Crawford, our Court, in Chavis v. State, conducted a careful analysis of testimonial statements in the context of forensic evidence.87 In Chavis several non-t

11
Weinberger v. UOP, Inc.green
del · 1983 · cited in 1 Delaware opinions naming this issue, 1985–1985
1 sentence

1985See 457 A.2d at 711, 714 .

11
In Re Fischergreen
del · 1981 · cited in 1 Delaware opinions naming this issue, 1983–1983
1 sentence

1983See In re Fischer, Del.Supr., 425 A.2d 601, 602-03 (1981).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Delaware. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (7)

CaseCitedYears
Bearden v. Georgia green
scotus · 1983
1 sentence

2023For Bearden, see Bearden, 461 U.S. at 666–67 (“Whether analyzed in terms of equal protection or due process, the issue cannot be resolved by resort to easy slogans or pigeonhole analysis, but rather requires a careful inquiry into such factors as ‘the nature of the individual interest affected, the extent to which it is affected, the rationality of the connection 24 depart from the widely accepted principle that “financial need alone [does not] identif[y] a suspect class for purposes of equal protection analysis.”80 Accordingly, because Burroughs cannot demonstrate that Delaware’s bail statute

12023–2023
CML V, LLC v. Bax green
del · 2011
2 sentences

2020Creditor fiduciary claims cannot exist in the DST context because the mandatory language in the DSTA limiting derivative standing to beneficial owners still controls. “[C]ourts cannot interpret the common law to override the express provision the General Assembly adopted.” 467 On this point, Bax is instructive.468 There, the Supreme Court considered whether Gheewalla (which holds that creditors of insolvent corporations may have standing to bring derivative claims) applied to creditor suits in the context of an insolvent LLC. 469 The Supreme Court construed materially similar statutory languag

2020Creditor fiduciary claims cannot exist in the DST context because the mandatory language in the DSTA limiting derivative standing to beneficial owners still controls. “[C]ourts cannot interpret the common law to override the express provision the General Assembly adopted.” 467 On this point, Bax is instructive.468 There, the Supreme Court considered whether Gheewalla (which holds that creditors of insolvent corporations may have standing to bring derivative claims) applied to creditor suits in the context of an insolvent LLC. 469 The Supreme Court construed materially similar statutory languag

12020–2020
In Re IBP, Inc., Shareholders Litigation green
delch · 2001
1 sentence

2017Id. 237 IBP, 789 A.2d at 65 . 58 Based on a careful analysis of the purpose of such a clause, Chief Justice Strine articulated a three-part framework for determining when such a provision is triggered: [E]ven where a Material Adverse Effect condition is as broadly written as the one in the Merger Agreement, that provision is best read as a backstop protecting the acquiror from [1] the occurrence of unknown events that [2] substantially threaten the overall earnings potential of the target in [3] a durationally-significant manner.

12017–2017
The Honorable Karen Weldin Stewart, CIR-ML, Insurance Commissioner v. Wilmington Trust SP Services, Inc. green
delch · 2015
2 sentences

2015Rather, we agree with the Court of Chancery’s careful analysis of this difficult area of the law.4 (4) The balance the Court of Chancery struck between the need for accountability of professional advisors and the costs of exposing professional advisors to potentially excessive risks is a sensible one, and reflects the one chosen by sister states, such as New York, whose laws are often involved in situations involving Delaware corporations.5 This harmony is beneficial and if it is to be disturbed, that decision is best made by the General Assembly. 3 Id. at 318–20. 4 See id. at 308–20. 5 See id

2015Rather, we agree with the Court of Chancery’s careful analysis of this difficult area of the law.4 (4) The balance the Court of Chancery struck between the need for accountability of professional advisors and the costs of exposing professional advisors to potentially excessive risks is a sensible one, and reflects the one chosen by sister states, such as New York, whose laws are often involved in situations involving Delaware corporations.5 This harmony is beneficial and if it is to be disturbed, that decision is best made by the General Assembly. 3 Id. at 318–20. 4 See id. at 308–20. 5 See id

12015–2015
Curtis v. Board of Supervisors green
cal · 1972
2 sentences

1973After a careful analysis of many federal and state decisions, as well as a close look at the facts of the particular case, the Court in Curtis determined at 104 Cal.Rptr. at 310 , at 501 P.2d at 550 that: “[N]o compelling state interest requires that nonlandowners be excluded from the group empowered to decide whether an election to incorporate a city be called, and no compelling interest is served by allocating power within that group on the basis of assessed value of land.” Although the California Supreme Court did not have the benefit of Salyer, supra, and Associated Enterprises, supra, at

1973After a careful analysis of many federal and state decisions, as well as a close look at the facts of the particular case, the Court in Curtis determined at 104 Cal.Rptr. at 310 , at 501 P.2d at 550 that: “[N]o compelling state interest requires that nonlandowners be excluded from the group empowered to decide whether an election to incorporate a city be called, and no compelling interest is served by allocating power within that group on the basis of assessed value of land.” Although the California Supreme Court did not have the benefit of Salyer, supra, and Associated Enterprises, supra, at

11973–1973
Donaghy v. State green
· 1917
2 sentences

1960The Section expressly enumerates certain misdemeanors and gives authority to the Legislature to confer jurisdiction over other misdemeanors, (see Donaghy v. State, 6 Boyce 467 , 100 A. 696 ), but never once refers to felony nor can such reference be logically inferred.

1960The Section expressly enumerates certain misdemeanors and gives authority to the Legislature to confer jurisdiction over other misdemeanors, (see Donaghy v. State, 6 Boyce 467 , 100 A. 696 ), but never once refers to felony nor can such reference be logically inferred.

11960–1960
Griswold v. Bacheller neutral
circtdri · 1897
1 sentence

1925C.), 77 Fed. 857 , the Court said: “It has been held by cases both at law and in equity that two causes, one at law, one in equity, are ex necessitate so dissimilar that the pendency of one cannot be pleaded in abatement .of the other." A careful analysis of the reasons underlying the rule that an action at law will not abate by reason of the pendency of a proceeding in chancery will, I think, demonstrate its correctness.

11925–1925

Where else courts name it

CA 147 (1905–2026) NY 125 (1885–2026) TX 106 (1914–2025) PA 76 (1908–2025) IL 73 (1901–2025) NJ 49 (1924–2025) FL 41 (1929–2018) MO 37 (1877–2014) NC 36 (1907–2023) LA 34 (1920–2018) WI 30 (1901–2023) IA 26 (1905–2017) OH 26 (1936–2022) CO 25 (1912–2026) MN 24 (1935–2024) MI 24 (1859–2024) MA 22 (1945–2026) OR 22 (1912–2026) WA 19 (1913–2026) KS 19 (1879–2024) MD 16 (1921–2026) NM 16 (1937–2011) MT 16 (1923–2025) WY 15 (1935–2013) GA 14 (1908–2024) ID 14 (1933–2023) KY 13 (1869–2019) OK 13 (1916–2003) TN 13 (1944–2020) AL 13 (1911–2018) SC 12 (1916–2011) AZ 12 (1937–2013) IN 12 (1878–1994) DE 11 (1925–2026) CT 10 (1939–1999) DC 10 (1953–2023) SD 8 (1927–2003) MS 8 (1968–2003) UT 8 (1910–2020) VT 7 (1998–2019) NE 6 (1931–2003) AK 6 (1970–2004) RI 5 (1981–2012) AR 5 (1917–2000) VA 5 (1919–2009) WV 4 (1917–2023) ND 3 (1916–1971) HI 3 (2017–2023) ME 2 (1982–1982) NV 2 (1982–2025)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check