quoted rule (Pennsylvania) · Go Syfert
← Pennsylvania issues

quoted rule in Pennsylvania

30 Pennsylvania opinions name it 9 courts 1904–2019 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Pennsylvania courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (11)

CaseFollowedCited
Commonwealth v. Wexlergreen
pa · 1981 · cited in 2 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1997–1997
2 sentences

1997In its written opinion in support of the ex-pungement order, the court quoted the factors set forth in Commonwealth v. Wexler, 494 Pa. 325, 330 , 431 A.2d 877, 879 (1981).

1997In its written opinion in support of the ex-pungement order, the court quoted the factors set forth in Commonwealth v. Wexler, 494 Pa. 325, 330 , 431 A.2d 877, 879 (1981).

22
Commonwealth, Aplt. v. Myers, D.green
pa · 2017 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2019–2019
1 sentence

2019The quoted analysis by Justice Wecht addressed actual consent with explicit reference to “the statutory mechanism by which a police officer may seek to obtain voluntary consent[.]” Id. at 1176.

11
Butler v. KIWI, SAgreen
pasuperct · 1992 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2019–2019
1 sentence

2019While the trial court did not use the term “presumption,” it adequately informed the jury that Dr. Babb had the burden to show that his contract restricted Geisinger from terminating him “for any reason or no reason at all.” This Court has held a trial court “may properly refuse a requested instruction when the substance of that request has already been given in either a general or specific charge.” Butler v. Kiwi, S.A., 604 A.2d 270, 273 (Pa.Super. 1992).

11
Rompilla v. Beardred
scotus · 2005 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2008–2008
2 sentences

2008See Rompilla, 545 U.S. at 387 , 125 S.Ct. 2456 ([T]he Commonwealth has come up with no reason to think the quoted standard impertinent here.).

2008See Rompilla, 545 U.S. at 387 , 125 S.Ct. 2456 ([T]he Commonwealth has come up with no reason to think the quoted standard impertinent here.).

11
Commonwealth v. Jonesgreen
pasuperct · 1994 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1996–1996
2 sentences

1996See, e.g., Commonwealth v. Jones, 432 Pa.Super. 97, 103 , 637 A.2d 1001, 1004 (1994).

1996See, e.g., Commonwealth v. Jones, 432 Pa.Super. 97, 103 , 637 A.2d 1001, 1004 (1994).

11
Commonwealth v. Clantongreen
pa · 1959 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1976–1976
2 sentences

1976In Commonwealth v. Clanton, 395 Pa. 521, 528 , 151 A.2d 88, 92 (1959), where the evidence was that as part of a continuous episode a man had shot both the woman he thought to be his wife and her paramour and where he was subsequently tried only for the murder of the paramour, we expressed reservations as to whether the language of the act could be construed to permit a wife to testify against her husband, even though "the shooting of the victim and of defendant's wife alleged is . . . so interwoven as to be actually one event." We held, however, that we did not need to determine the alleged wi

1976In Commonwealth v. Clanton, 395 Pa. 521, 528 , 151 A.2d 88, 92 (1959), where the evidence was that as part of a continuous episode a man had shot both the woman he thought to be his wife and her paramour and where he was subsequently tried only for the murder of the paramour, we expressed reservations as to whether the language of the act could be construed to permit a wife to testify against her husband, even though "the shooting of the victim and of defendant's wife alleged is . . . so interwoven as to be actually one event." We held, however, that we did not need to determine the alleged wi

11
Holton Estategreen
pa · 1960 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1970–1970
2 sentences

1970The court below relied upon the following language from Holton Estate, 399 Pa. 241, 247 , 159 A. 2d 883, 886 (1960), as dispositive of the instant case: “An examination of this statute clearly reveals the legislative intent: to include within the term ‘child’ or ‘children’ of a person other than the testator an adopted ‘child’ or ‘children’ provided, however, that such adoption took place before the execution of the will, and to exclude such adopted child or children if the adoption took place after the execution of the will.” However, we made it perfectly clear in that case that a prerequisit

1970The court below relied upon the following language from Holton Estate, 399 Pa. 241, 247 , 159 A. 2d 883, 886 (1960), as dispositive of the instant case: “An examination of this statute clearly reveals the legislative intent: to include within the term ‘child’ or ‘children’ of a person other than the testator an adopted ‘child’ or ‘children’ provided, however, that such adoption took place before the execution of the will, and to exclude such adopted child or children if the adoption took place after the execution of the will.” However, we made it perfectly clear in that case that a prerequisit

11
Commonwealth Ex Rel. Schwartz v. Bierlygreen
pa · 1940 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1958–1958
1 sentence

1958Schwartz v. Bierly, 339 Pa. 213, 217 (1940), the court, in quoting this definition, emphasized the words, “the entire loss falls on him.” In Kanefsky v. National Commercial Mutual Fire Insurance Company, 154 Pa. Superior Ct. 171, 175 (1943), the court said: “For reasons fully explained in our cases, the clauses relating to unconditional and sole ownership and title are enforced.

11
Kanefsky v. National Commercial Mutual Fire Insurancegreen
pasuperct · 1943 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1958–1958
1 sentence

1958Schwartz v. Bierly, 339 Pa. 213, 217 (1940), the court, in quoting this definition, emphasized the words, “the entire loss falls on him.” In Kanefsky v. National Commercial Mutual Fire Insurance Company, 154 Pa. Superior Ct. 171, 175 (1943), the court said: “For reasons fully explained in our cases, the clauses relating to unconditional and sole ownership and title are enforced.

11
Neel's Estategreen
scotus · 1916 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1930–1930
11
Strauss v. Mendelsohngreen
pasuperct · 1916 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1926–1926
11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Pennsylvania. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (29)

CaseCitedYears
Wainwright v. Witt green
scotus · 1985
2 sentences

1986More recently, Justice Rehnquist, speaking for the Court in Wainright v. Witt, 469 U.S. 412 , 105 S.Ct. 844 , 83 L.Ed.2d 841 (1985), stated the following: We therefore take this opportunity to clarify our decision in Witherspoon and to reaffirm the above quoted standard from Adams as the proper standard for determining when a prospective juror may be excluded for cause because of his or her views on capital punishment.

1986More recently, Justice Rehnquist, speaking for the Court in Wainright v. Witt, 469 U.S. 412 , 105 S.Ct. 844 , 83 L.Ed.2d 841 (1985), stated the following: We therefore take this opportunity to clarify our decision in Witherspoon and to reaffirm the above quoted standard from Adams as the proper standard for determining when a prospective juror may be excluded for cause because of his or her views on capital punishment.

21986–1986
Livingstone v. Boston Insurance green
· 1916
2 sentences

1958In Livingstone v. Boston Insurance Company, 255 Pa. 1 (1916), the court defined the clause “sole and unconditional ownership” by saying: “The provisions of an insurance policy are construed favorably to the assured, and where he has an insurable interest and is the substantial owner of the property so that the entire loss falls on him, it satisfies the above quoted clause as to ownership, although he may not have a perfect legal title to the insured property.” In Commonwealth ex rel.

1940This court defined the clause, “sole and unconditional ownership”, in Livingstone v. Boston Insuranee Co., 255 Pa. 1 , when, in speaking through Mr. Justice Walling, we said (p. 4) : “The provisions of an insuranee policy are construed favorably to the assured; and where he has an insurable interest and is the substantial owner of the property so that the entire loss falls on him, it satisfies the above quoted clause as to ownership, although he may not have a perfect legal title to the insured property.” (Italics added.) As we have stated above, the Act of 1938, supra, places the expense of i

21940–1958
Colville v. Allegheny County Retirement Board green
pa · 2007
2 sentences

2009Colville v. Allegheny County Retirement Board, 592 Pa. 433 , 926 A.2d 424 (2007).

2009Colville v. Allegheny County Retirement Board, 592 Pa. 433 , 926 A.2d 424 (2007).

12009–2009
Adams v. Texas green
scotus · 1980
2 sentences

1986Moreover, the United States Supreme Court in Wainwright v. Witt, 469 U.S. 412 , 105 S.Ct. 844 , 83 L.Ed.2d 841 (1985), recently stated the following: *19 We therefore take this opportunity to clarify our decision in Witherspoon and to reaffirm the above quoted standard from Adams [v. Texas, 448 U.S. 38 , 100 S.Ct. 2521 , 65 L.Ed.2d 581 (1980) ] as the proper standard for determining when a prospective juror may be excluded for cause because of his or her views on capital punishment.

1986Moreover, the United States Supreme Court in Wainwright v. Witt, 469 U.S. 412 , 105 S.Ct. 844 , 83 L.Ed.2d 841 (1985), recently stated the following: *19 We therefore take this opportunity to clarify our decision in Witherspoon and to reaffirm the above quoted standard from Adams [v. Texas, 448 U.S. 38 , 100 S.Ct. 2521 , 65 L.Ed.2d 581 (1980) ] as the proper standard for determining when a prospective juror may be excluded for cause because of his or her views on capital punishment.

11986–1986
Janes v. Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board green
pacommwct · 1979
1 sentence

1982However, even when giving the need here, a “broad construction” as to “actualnecessity.” Janis v. Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board, _ Pa. Commw. __, 402 A. 2d 1093 , (1979) we must recognize the necessity for another liquor license in this resort even though the township is already one over quota.

11982–1982
Commonwealth v. Robinson green
pa · 1976
2 sentences

1982In Com. v. Robinson, 468 Pa. 575 , 364 A. 2d 665 , (1976), the court says, after quoting the statute and emphasizing the exceptions, that: “It is conceded that the quoted exception contained in the statute made the wife competent to testify to Robinson’s alleged acts of violence directed against her” (585-586); the same notion is repeated later in the opinion (585).

1982In Com. v. Robinson, 468 Pa. 575 , 364 A. 2d 665 , (1976), the court says, after quoting the statute and emphasizing the exceptions, that: “It is conceded that the quoted exception contained in the statute made the wife competent to testify to Robinson’s alleged acts of violence directed against her” (585-586); the same notion is repeated later in the opinion (585).

11982–1982
Commonwealth v. Galloway green
pasuperct · 1979
2 sentences

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

11982–1982
Commonwealth v. Barksdale green
pasuperct · 1971
2 sentences

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

11982–1982
Haas v. Fitzpatrick green
pasuperct · 1934
2 sentences

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

1982But the Court further said in footnote 6 that: “We note also that her testimony about these actions was corroborated at trial by other eyewitnesses and was otherwise uncontroverted.” Compare: Com. v. Galloway, 271 Pa. Super. 305, 307 , 413 A. 2d 418 , (1979); Com. v. Barksdale, 219 Pa. Super. 444, 448 , 281 A. 2d 703 , (1971); Haas v. Fitzpatrick, 117 Pa. Super. 21, 25 , 177 A. 326 , (1935). .

11982–1982
Wedner v. Fidelity Security Sytems, Inc. green
pasuperct · 1973
1 sentence

1975The law does not favor the enforcement of such contracts and will ignore such clauses when the exculpated party is a common carrier, public utility, or one acting under a public duty: Wedner v. Fidelity Security Systems, Inc., 228 Pa. Superior Ct. 67 (1973); Restatement, Contracts, §575.

11975–1975
McAndrews v. SPENCER Et Ux. green
pa · 1972
2 sentences

1975Id. at 270 , 290 A.2d at 259 .

1975Id. at 270 , 290 A.2d at 259 .

11975–1975
New Eastwick Corp. v. Philadelphia Builders Eastwick Corp. green
pasuperct · 1968
1 sentence

1968Builders Eastwick Corp., 430 Pa. 46 (1968); Shilanski v. Farrell, 57 Pa. Superior Ct. 137 (1914); but this is an exception to the above quoted rule and such a provision will not be implied from a contract ambiguous as to time.

11968–1968
Shilanski v. Farrell neutral
pasuperct · 1914
1 sentence

1968Builders Eastwick Corp., 430 Pa. 46 (1968); Shilanski v. Farrell, 57 Pa. Superior Ct. 137 (1914); but this is an exception to the above quoted rule and such a provision will not be implied from a contract ambiguous as to time.

11968–1968
Commonwealth v. Johnson green
pa · 1943
2 sentences

1958In many jurisdictions courts in determining proper sentences consider official records and the reports of probation officers, psychiatrists and others." Commonwealth v. Johnson, 348 Pa. 349 , 35 A. 2d 312 , reaffirmed the above quoted principle of law enunciated in the Petrillo case, and added the following (page 354): "Any other rule than the one thus enunciated would be an impracticable one for courts to apply in exercising their discretionary power, within statutory limits, to impose appropriate sentences on convicted defendants, in the vast majority of criminal cases.

1958In many jurisdictions courts in determining proper sentences consider official records and the reports of probation officers, psychiatrists and others." Commonwealth v. Johnson, 348 Pa. 349 , 35 A. 2d 312 , reaffirmed the above quoted principle of law enunciated in the Petrillo case, and added the following (page 354): "Any other rule than the one thus enunciated would be an impracticable one for courts to apply in exercising their discretionary power, within statutory limits, to impose appropriate sentences on convicted defendants, in the vast majority of criminal cases.

11958–1958
West v. MacMillan (Et Al.) green
· 1930
2 sentences

1956It is well established that an insurance policy will be construed most strongly against the insurer who has prepared it: MacDonald v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., 304 Pa. 213 , 155 A. 491 ; West v. MacMillan (and Automobile Underwriters Insurance Co., Garnishees), 301 Pa. 344 , 152 A. 104 .

1956It is well established that an insurance policy will be construed most strongly against the insurer who has prepared it: MacDonald v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., 304 Pa. 213 , 155 A. 491 ; West v. MacMillan (and Automobile Underwriters Insurance Co., Garnishees), 301 Pa. 344 , 152 A. 104 .

11956–1956
MacDonald v. Metropolitan Life Insurance green
pa · 1931
2 sentences

1956It is well established that an insurance policy will be construed most strongly against the insurer who has prepared it: MacDonald v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., 304 Pa. 213 , 155 A. 491 ; West v. MacMillan (and Automobile Underwriters Insurance Co., Garnishees), 301 Pa. 344 , 152 A. 104 .

1956It is well established that an insurance policy will be construed most strongly against the insurer who has prepared it: MacDonald v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., 304 Pa. 213 , 155 A. 491 ; West v. MacMillan (and Automobile Underwriters Insurance Co., Garnishees), 301 Pa. 344 , 152 A. 104 .

11956–1956
Murdock v. Murdock neutral
pa · 1930
1 sentence

1949On the other hand we have the direct statement in the case of Murdock et al. v. Murdock et al., 300 Pa. 280 (1930) to the effect that “though partners, in the absence of special agreement, receive no compensation, yet ‘a surviving partner is entitled to reasonable compensation for his services in winding up the partnership affairs’ ”.

11949–1949
City Coal Co. v. Marcus green
· 1920
1 sentence

1942Marcus, 95 Conn. 454, 459 .

11942–1942
Pauksztis v. Raeder Blank Book, Lithographing & Printing Co. neutral
pa · 1905
1 sentence

1940It is well settled that one under a duty to insure the property of another is presumptively required to insure it for its full value, and a failure to do so entails liability for all the resulting damages in the event pf its loss: Broussard v. South Texas Rice Company, 103 *218 Tex. 535; Ela v. French, 11 N. H. 356; Shoenfeld v. Fleisher, 73 Ill. 404 ; Pauksztis v. Raeder Blank Book, Lithographing & Printing Company, 212 Pa. 403 .

11940–1940
Shoenfeld v. Fleisher neutral
ill · 1874
1 sentence

1940It is well settled that one under a duty to insure the property of another is presumptively required to insure it for its full value, and a failure to do so entails liability for all the resulting damages in the event pf its loss: Broussard v. South Texas Rice Company, 103 *218 Tex. 535; Ela v. French, 11 N. H. 356; Shoenfeld v. Fleisher, 73 Ill. 404 ; Pauksztis v. Raeder Blank Book, Lithographing & Printing Company, 212 Pa. 403 .

11940–1940
Connell v. Metropolitan Life Insurance neutral
pasuperct · 1901
11938–1938
Panopoulos v. Metropolitan Life Insurance green
pasuperct · 1929
1 sentence

1938Co., 96 Pa. Superior Ct. 325 , the above quoted clause was held to be a “sound-health clause,” and in Connell v. Life Ins.

11938–1938
Finnerty v. Hudson Coal Co. green
pasuperct · 1934
11937–1937
Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Sanderson green
· 1886
11931–1931
Weinmann's Estate green
pa · 1909
11930–1930
Thistle's Estate green
pa · 1919
11930–1930
Yeier v. Hanover Fire Insurance neutral
pasuperct · 1916
11916–1916
Huber v. Hamilton green
pa · 1905
11915–1915
Fairchild v. Dunbar Furnace Co. neutral
· 1889
11904–1904

Statutes the citing opinions construe

PA § 42 Pa. Cons. Stat. § 9711 (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

CA 149 (1893–2020) TX 73 (1914–2024) OK 58 (1923–2016) MO 50 (1910–2006) FL 42 (1908–2018) LA 37 (1918–2004) NC 36 (1940–2023) AL 35 (1907–2024) MI 34 (1949–2024) PA 30 (1904–2019) IL 30 (1903–2015) MS 29 (1931–2022) GA 28 (1918–2018) OR 26 (1917–2020) WA 25 (1911–2018) NY 21 (1902–2012) TN 20 (1927–2016) IA 18 (1921–2016) KS 17 (1911–2004) AR 16 (1921–1998) NJ 15 (1949–1997) MA 15 (1928–2009) AZ 13 (1966–2004) KY 13 (1925–2024) MD 13 (1932–2011) IN 13 (1933–2017) CO 12 (1958–1996) OH 11 (1932–2011) SC 10 (1935–1979) NM 10 (1942–2012) ID 9 (1957–2023) DC 9 (1913–2018) WI 8 (1914–2013) MN 7 (1922–1983) MT 7 (1929–2002) NE 7 (1890–1974) DE 6 (1934–1978) RI 6 (1962–2014) ME 6 (1891–1980) SD 6 (1941–1969) ND 6 (1908–1998) HI 5 (1937–1989) UT 5 (1937–1994) WY 5 (1937–2003) CT 4 (1942–2009) NV 4 (1950–1965) WV 3 (1969–2026) AK 2 (1997–1998) VA 2 (1986–2014) VT 2 (1945–1978)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check