circumstances factors (Michigan) · Go Syfert
← Michigan issues

circumstances factors in Michigan

27 Michigan opinions name it 2 courts 1921–2026 2 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Michigan courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (6)

CaseFollowedCited
International Business MacHines Corp. v. Department of Treasurygreen
michctapp · 2016 · cited in 2 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 2018–2018
2 sentences

2018See Int'l Business Machines Corp. v. Dep't of Treasury , 316 Mich. App. 346 , 352, 891 N.W.2d 880 (2016), in which this Court articulated that the "rule of mandate" reflects "the well-accepted principle in our jurisprudence that a lower court must strictly comply with, and may not exceed the scope of, a remand order." The Supreme Court's remand instructions indicated that this Court "should consider" this issue, and when viewed in context, the Supreme Court's use of "should" does not seem permissive.

2018See Int'l Business Machines Corp. v. Dep't of Treasury , 316 Mich. App. 346 , 352, 891 N.W.2d 880 (2016), in which this Court articulated that the "rule of mandate" reflects "the well-accepted principle in our jurisprudence that a lower court must strictly comply with, and may not exceed the scope of, a remand order." The Supreme Court's remand instructions indicated that this Court "should consider" this issue, and when viewed in context, the Supreme Court's use of "should" does not seem permissive.

22
Leibel v. General Motors Corp.green
michctapp · 2002 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 2020–2020
1 sentence

2020See id. at 236, 240 (noting that attorney-client privilege attaches only to confidential communications between a client and an attorney, and separately noting the circumstances under which a waiver of the privilege may occur after it has attached).

11
People v. Wardgreen
michctapp · 1981 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 1983–1983
2 sentences

1983See People v Ward, 107 Mich App 38 ; 308 NW2d 664 (1981). 2 We note that in applying the circumstances test our findings have varied even when the places were similar.

1983See People v Ward, 107 Mich App 38 ; 308 NW2d 664 (1981). 2 We note that in applying the circumstances test our findings have varied even when the places were similar.

11
People v. Chapmangreen
michctapp · 1977 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 1983–1983
2 sentences

1983See People v Chapman, 73 Mich App 547 ; 252 NW2d 511 (1977).

1983See People v Chapman, 73 Mich App 547 ; 252 NW2d 511 (1977).

11
Smith v. Grange Mutual Fire Insurancegreen
mich · 1926 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 1982–1982
2 sentences

1982See Smith v Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co of Michigan, 234 Mich 119 ; 208 NW 145 (1926); Muniga v General Motors Corp, 102 Mich App 755, 759 ; 302 NW2d 565 (1980).

1982See Smith v Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co of Michigan, 234 Mich 119 ; 208 NW 145 (1926); Muniga v General Motors Corp, 102 Mich App 755, 759 ; 302 NW2d 565 (1980).

11
Kent v. United Statesgreen
scotus · 1966 · cited in 1 Michigan opinions naming this issue, 1977–1977
1 sentence

1977Kent v United States, supra, p 561. " 'To play fair, a trial judge relying upon discretionary power should place on record the circumstances and factors that were crucial to his determination.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Michigan. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (27)

CaseCitedYears
D'Onofrio v. D'Onofrio green
njsuperctappdiv · 1976
2 sentences

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

22017–2017
Spires v. Bergman green
michctapp · 2007
2 sentences

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

22017–2017
Braverman v. GARDEN CITY HOSPITAL green
mich · 2007
2 sentences

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

2017In Spires v Bergman, 276 Mich App 432, 437 ; 741 NW2d 523 (2007), this Court noted that, before the enactment of MCL 722.31, “the D’Onofrio factors were used to determine whether the relocating parent should be allowed to change a child’s domicile.” 2 D’Onofrio v D’Onofrio, 144 NJ Super 200, 206-207; 365 A2d 27 (1976). -2- When the Legislature enacted MCL 722.31, however, it codified the circumstances in which the factors apply.

22017–2017
Fultz v. Union-Commerce Associates green
mich · 2004
2 sentences

2017Generally, “a tort action will not lie when based solely on the nonperformance of a contractual duty.” Fultz v Union-Commerce Assoc, 470 Mich 460, 466 ; 683 NW2d 587 (2004).

2017Generally, “a tort action will not lie when based solely on the nonperformance of a contractual duty.” Fultz v Union-Commerce Assoc, 470 Mich 460, 466 ; 683 NW2d 587 (2004).

22017–2017
Lapasinskas v. Quick green
michctapp · 1969
2 sentences

1982In granting a new trial for the plaintiff in Lapasinskas v Quick, 17 Mich App 733, 739 ; 170 NW2d 318 (1969), then Judge Levin stated: " 'We have no way of knowing whether the defendants’ injection of this issue influenced the jury or whether the trial judge’s cautionary instruction in fact removed any effect adverse to plaintiff’s action.

1982In granting a new trial for the plaintiff in Lapasinskas v Quick, 17 Mich App 733, 739 ; 170 NW2d 318 (1969), then Judge Levin stated: " 'We have no way of knowing whether the defendants’ injection of this issue influenced the jury or whether the trial judge’s cautionary instruction in fact removed any effect adverse to plaintiff’s action.

21977–1982
Wood v. Vroman green
mich · 1921
2 sentences

1976Wood v Vroman, 215 Mich 449, 465 .

1976Wood v Vroman, 215 Mich 449, 465 .

21934–1976
Shawl v. SPENCE BROS., INC. green
michctapp · 2008
1 sentence

2026Shawl, 280 Mich App at 238 .

12026–2026
Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance v. Continental Insurance green
mich · 1995
2 sentences

2023Thus, it is unnecessary to consider which policy is “more specifically tailored to the circumstances of the claim.” See Frankenmuth, 450 Mich at 438 .

2023The Frankenmuth Court reiterated the overarching theme that “where there are competing other insurance clauses, we will endeavor to reconcile them.” Id.

12023–2023
City of Detroit v. State green
michctapp · 2004
2 sentences

2019Moreover, although we have discretion to treat plaintiff’s claim of appeal as a granted application for leave to appeal, State Fairgrounds, 262 Mich App at 546 , under the circumstances at bar, we decline to do so.

2019Plaintiff’s stipulation to dismiss the remaining claim “was clearly designed to circumvent trial procedures and court rules and obtain appellate review of one of the trial court’s initial determinations without precluding further substantive proceedings on the remaining claims.” Id. at 545 .

12019–2019
People v. Hana green
mich · 1994
2 sentences

2015However, “[s]everance is mandated under MCR 6.121(C) only when a defendant provides the court with a supporting affidavit, or makes an offer of proof, that clearly, affirmatively, and fully demonstrates that his substantial rights will be prejudiced and that severance is the necessary means of rectifying the potential prejudice.” People v Hana, 447 Mich 325, 346 ; 524 NW2d 682 (1994), amended on reh sub nom People v Gallina, 447 Mich 1203 (1994), and amended on reh sub nom People v Rode, 447 Mich 1203 (1994).

2015However, “[s]everance is mandated under MCR 6.121(C) only when a defendant provides the court with a supporting affidavit, or makes an offer of proof, that clearly, affirmatively, and fully demonstrates that his substantial rights will be prejudiced and that severance is the necessary means of rectifying the potential prejudice.” People v Hana, 447 Mich 325, 346 ; 524 NW2d 682 (1994), amended on reh sub nom People v Gallina, 447 Mich 1203 (1994), and amended on reh sub nom People v Rode, 447 Mich 1203 (1994).

12015–2015
Weishuhn v. Catholic Diocese of Lansing green
michctapp · 2008
1 sentence

2010Id.

12010–2010
Kipka v. Fountain green
michctapp · 1993
2 sentences

2010We do not believe that placing a guardrail and a “Road Ends” sign at the eastern edge of the 20-foot strip indicates that the road commission (as opposed to DLDA members) intended to do anything to maintain the 20-foot strip itself in a “reasonably passable condition.” This Court has listed the circumstances under which a claim of adverse possession may be established: In order to establish a claim of adverse possession, a plaintiff must provide “clear and cogent proof that possession has been actual, visible, open, notorious, exclusive, continuous, and uninterrupted for the statutory period o

2010We do not believe that placing a guardrail and a “Road Ends” sign at the eastern edge of the 20-foot strip indicates that the road commission (as opposed to DLDA members) intended to do anything to maintain the 20-foot strip itself in a “reasonably passable condition.” This Court has listed the circumstances under which a claim of adverse possession may be established: In order to establish a claim of adverse possession, a plaintiff must provide “clear and cogent proof that possession has been actual, visible, open, notorious, exclusive, continuous, and uninterrupted for the statutory period o

12010–2010
People v. Wright green
mich · 1992
1 sentence

1994Thus, the "critical inquiry is whether the information withheld by the *230 police would have changed the defendant’s appraisal and understanding of the circumstances of the waiver.” Id.

11994–1994
People v. Brown green
michctapp · 1994
1 sentence

1994Contrary to Judge Deegan’s assertion that requiring the police to inform the suspect of an attorney’s attempted contact "would create in Michigan a Gordian knot concerning Miranda rights,” Brown, supra, p 539 , the courts would focus on this "critical inquiry” and look to other relevant factors such as the relationship between the attorney and the defendant, the nature of counsel’s request, the conduct of the suspect, and the extent to which the police had reasonable notice of counsel’s request.

11994–1994
Aster v. Gross green
vactapp · 1988
2 sentences

1992Virginia: See Marion v Marion, 11 Va App 659; 401 SE2d 432 (1991) (fault that has an economic effect upon the marital property or its value may be considered); Aster v Gross, 7 Va App 1; 371 SE2d 833 (1988) (although the Virginia property division statute provides that the court may take into account the circumstances and factors in bringing about the end of the marriage, the only fault that counts in equitable distribution is economic fault).

1992Virginia: See Marion v Marion, 11 Va App 659; 401 SE2d 432 (1991) (fault that has an economic effect upon the marital property or its value may be considered); Aster v Gross, 7 Va App 1; 371 SE2d 833 (1988) (although the Virginia property division statute provides that the court may take into account the circumstances and factors in bringing about the end of the marriage, the only fault that counts in equitable distribution is economic fault ).

11992–1992
Anderson v. Anderson green
ga · 1976
2 sentences

1992West Virginia: See 14 W Va Code 48-2-32, excluding the consideration of fault or marital misconduct "except for a consideration of the economic consequences of conduct.” Georgia: See Anderson v Anderson, 237 Ga 886; 230 SE2d 272 (1976) (evidence of marital misconduct of either party in a divorce action based on the no-fault ground that the marriage is irretrievably broken is not admissible with regard either to alimony or the division of property between the parties).

1992West Virginia: See 14 W Va Code 48-2-32, excluding the consideration of fault or marital misconduct "except for a consideration of the economic consequences of conduct." [20] Georgia: See Anderson v Anderson, 237 Ga 886; 230 SE2d 272 (1976) (evidence of marital misconduct of either party in a divorce action based on the no-fault ground that the marriage is irretrievably broken is not admissible with regard either to alimony or the division of property between the parties).

11992–1992
Marion v. Marion green
vactapp · 1991
2 sentences

1992Virginia: See Marion v Marion, 11 Va App 659; 401 SE2d 432 (1991) (fault that has an economic effect upon the marital property or its value may be considered); Aster v Gross, 7 Va App 1; 371 SE2d 833 (1988) (although the Virginia property division statute provides that the court may take into account the circumstances and factors in bringing about the end of the marriage, the only fault that counts in equitable distribution is economic fault).

1992Virginia: See Marion v Marion, 11 Va App 659; 401 SE2d 432 (1991) (fault that has an economic effect upon the marital property or its value may be considered); Aster v Gross, 7 Va App 1; 371 SE2d 833 (1988) (although the Virginia property division statute provides that the court may take into account the circumstances and factors in bringing about the end of the marriage, the only fault that counts in equitable distribution is economic fault ).

11992–1992
Culombe v. Connecticut green
scotus · 1961
2 sentences

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

11983–1983
Haynes v. Washington green
scotus · 1963
2 sentences

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

11983–1983
Schneckloth v. Bustamonte green
scotus · 1973
2 sentences

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

1983United States v Grant, 622 F2d 308, 316 (CA 8, 1980), citing Schneckloth v Bustamonte, 412 US 218 ; 93 S Ct 2041 ; 36 L Ed 2d 854 (1973); Haynes v Washington, 373 US 503 ; 83 S Ct 1336 ; 10 L Ed 2d 513 (1963); Culombe v Connecticut, 367 US 568 ; 81 S Ct 1860 ; 6 L Ed 2d 1037 (1961).

11983–1983
Muniga v. General Motors Corp. green
michctapp · 1980
2 sentences

1982See Smith v Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co of Michigan, 234 Mich 119 ; 208 NW 145 (1926); Muniga v General Motors Corp, 102 Mich App 755, 759 ; 302 NW2d 565 (1980).

1982See Smith v Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co of Michigan, 234 Mich 119 ; 208 NW 145 (1926); Muniga v General Motors Corp, 102 Mich App 755, 759 ; 302 NW2d 565 (1980).

11982–1982
People v. Fields green
mich · 1974
1 sentence

1977He should spell out his reasons as well as he can so that counsel and the reviewing court will know and be in a position to evaluate the soundness of his decision.’ Rosenberg, Judicial Discretion of the Trial Court, Viewed from Above, 22 Syracuse L Rev 635, 665-666 (1971).” 391 Mich at 243-244 .

11977–1977
Bartlett v. Melzo green
mich · 1958
1 sentence

1968The cases of Bartlett v. Melzo (1958), 351 Mich 177 , and Bishop v. Plumb (1961), 363 Mich 87 , relied upon by plaintiffs, are not in point.

11968–1968
Rogers v. Richmond green
scotus · 1961
2 sentences

1968Such fear and misapprehension is sufficient to render the plea of guilty to second-degree murder involuntary.” “It is well settled in this State that a conviction on a plea of guilty, involuntarily rendered, presents grounds for a new trial.” See Rogers v. Richmond (1961), 365 US 534 ( 81 S Ct 735 , 5 L Ed 2d 760 ).

1968Such fear and misapprehension is sufficient to render the plea of guilty to second-degree murder involuntary.” “It is well settled in this State that a conviction on a plea of guilty, involuntarily rendered, presents grounds for a new trial.” See Rogers v. Richmond (1961), 365 US 534 ( 81 S Ct 735 , 5 L Ed 2d 760 ).

11968–1968
Bishop v. Plumb green
mich · 1961
11968–1968
Barker v. Valentine neutral
mich · 1900
11933–1933
Van Slyke v. Rooks neutral
mich · 1914
11921–1921

Where else courts name it

NY 214 (1885–2025) CA 182 (1900–2026) PA 125 (1903–2026) IL 121 (1856–2026) TX 115 (1908–2025) OH 76 (1902–2025) FL 62 (1933–2020) NJ 61 (1949–2026) WI 60 (1915–2026) MD 52 (1964–2025) MA 49 (1917–2020) VA 43 (1877–2023) NC 42 (1924–2026) GA 42 (1905–2025) LA 41 (1965–2020) TN 40 (1918–2026) MO 39 (1897–2021) IN 33 (1925–2020) CO 32 (1945–2026) AL 30 (1926–2024) WA 29 (1960–2026) MT 28 (1912–2020) OR 28 (1959–2026) NE 28 (1932–2026) MI 27 (1921–2026) CT 27 (1978–2026) WY 26 (1934–2026) KY 26 (1916–2023) MN 26 (1949–2024) KS 26 (1926–2025) AZ 26 (1963–2022) VT 26 (1913–2026) NM 22 (1990–2023) SD 18 (1940–2024) MS 16 (1921–2020) HI 16 (1925–2021) DC 16 (1973–2024) IA 16 (1915–2023) ND 13 (1974–2012) ID 12 (1925–2024) DE 12 (1977–2026) NV 11 (1948–2026) AR 11 (1956–2001) ME 11 (1965–2022) UT 11 (1985–2024) SC 10 (1925–2024) OK 9 (1910–2021) WV 8 (1940–2026) NH 8 (1973–2021) AK 7 (1976–1996) RI 6 (1971–2012) VI 3 (2006–2012)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check