departure rule (Missouri) · Go Syfert
← Missouri issues

departure rule in Missouri

16 Missouri opinions name it 2 courts 1878–2018 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Missouri courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
Pearson v. Kostergreen
mo · 2012 · cited in 1 Missouri opinions naming this issue, 2012–2012
1 sentence

2012See Pearson I, 359 S.W.3d at 40 .

11
Perryman v. Perrymangreen
moctapp · 2003 · cited in 1 Missouri opinions naming this issue, 2008–2008
1 sentence

2008See See Perryman, 117 S.W.3d at 685-86 ; Thompson, 27 S.W.3d at 505-06 ; Carter, 869 S.W.2d at 829 ; Markwardt, 617 S.W.2d at 462-63 .

11
Swanson v. Georgia Casualty Co.green
· 1926 · cited in 1 Missouri opinions naming this issue, 1956–1956
2 sentences

1956Swanson v. Georgia Casualty Co., 315 Mo. 1007 , 287 S.W. 455, 462 [7]; Reid v. Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, Mo. App., 232 S.W. 185 , 188 [3, 5]; Ellyson v.. Missouri Power & Light Co., Mo.App., 59 S.W.2d 714 , 717 [3-5].

1956Swanson v. Georgia Casualty Co., 315 Mo. 1007 , 287 S.W. 455, 462 [7]; Reid v. Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, Mo. App., 232 S.W. 185 , 188 [3, 5]; Ellyson v.. Missouri Power & Light Co., Mo.App., 59 S.W.2d 714 , 717 [3-5].

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Missouri. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (24)

CaseCitedYears
State v. Grim green
mo · 1993
1 sentence

2018Grim , 854 S.W.2d at 411 .

12018–2018
Padilla v. Kentucky green
scotus · 2010
2 sentences

2017The motion court found that "Missouri courts have consistently held that counsel has no obligation to inform a defendant of the parole consequences of his guilty plea." The motion court further found that "parole eligibility is considered to be a 'collateral consequence' of a plea, about which counsel has no obligation to inform the defendant." The motion court observed that this Court has rejected arguments urging a departure from this rule in the wake of Padilla v. Kentucky , 559 U.S. 356 , 130 S.Ct. 1473 , 176 L.Ed.2d 284 (2010).

2017The motion court found that "Missouri courts have consistently held that counsel has no obligation to inform a defendant of the parole consequences of his guilty plea." The motion court further found that "parole eligibility is considered to be a 'collateral consequence' of a plea, about which counsel has no obligation to inform the defendant." The motion court observed that this Court has rejected arguments urging a departure from this rule in the wake of Padilla v. Kentucky , 559 U.S. 356 , 130 S.Ct. 1473 , 176 L.Ed.2d 284 (2010).

12017–2017
Markwardt v. Markwardt green
moctapp · 1981
1 sentence

2008See See Perryman, 117 S.W.3d at 685-86 ; Thompson, 27 S.W.3d at 505-06 ; Carter, 869 S.W.2d at 829 ; Markwardt, 617 S.W.2d at 462-63 .

12008–2008
In re the Marriage Thompson green
moctapp · 2000
1 sentence

2008See See Perryman, 117 S.W.3d at 685-86 ; Thompson, 27 S.W.3d at 505-06 ; Carter, 869 S.W.2d at 829 ; Markwardt, 617 S.W.2d at 462-63 .

12008–2008
Carter v. Carter green
moctapp · 1994
1 sentence

2008See See Perryman, 117 S.W.3d at 685-86 ; Thompson, 27 S.W.3d at 505-06 ; Carter, 869 S.W.2d at 829 ; Markwardt, 617 S.W.2d at 462-63 .

12008–2008
Pratte v. Coffman green
mo · 1862
2 sentences

1984After stating and adopting the rule, which has been called the Mansfield view, the court noted "that cases may arise, particularly when life and liberty are at stake, which may call for a departure from the rule." Id. at 78 .

1984After stating and adopting the rule, which has been called the Mansfield view, the court noted “that cases may arise, particularly when life and liberty are at stake, which may call for a departure from the rule.” Id. at 78 .

11984–1984
Presbyterian Church in US v. Mary Elizabeth Blue Hull Memorial Presbyterian Church green
scotus · 1969
2 sentences

1983In so holding the court observed “[a]nd there are neutral principles of law, developed for use in all property disputes, which can be applied without ‘establishing’ churches to which property is awarded.” Presbyterian Church v. Hull Church, supra, 393 U.S. at 449 , 89 S.Ct. at 606 , 21 L.Ed.2d at 665 .

1983In so holding the court observed “[a]nd there are neutral principles of law, developed for use in all property disputes, which can be applied without ‘establishing’ churches to which property is awarded.” Presbyterian Church v. Hull Church, supra, 393 U.S. at 449 , 89 S.Ct. at 606 , 21 L.Ed.2d at 665 .

11983–1983
Sioux City Bridge Co. v. Dakota County green
scotus · 1923
2 sentences

1981As the Supreme Court of the United States said in Sioux City Bridge Co., supra, 260 U.S. at 446 , 43 S.Ct. at 192 : “This court holds that the right of the taxpayer whose property alone is taxed at 100 percent of its true value is to have his assessment reduced to the percentage of that value at which others are taxed even though this is a departure from the requirement of statute.

1981As the Supreme Court of the United States said in Sioux City Bridge Co., supra, 260 U.S. at 446 , 43 S.Ct. at 192 : “This court holds that the right of the taxpayer whose property alone is taxed at 100 percent of its true value is to have his assessment reduced to the percentage of that value at which others are taxed even though this is a departure from the requirement of statute.

11981–1981
International Shoe Co. v. Washington green
scotus · 1945
2 sentences

1947This course of conduct of authorized agents within the state in our judgment constituted a doing of business there in such wise that the harvester company might be fairly said to have been there, doing business, and amenable to the process of the courts of the state." The ruling in the International Harvester Company case and prior rulings of the kind have proceeded under the doctrine of what is termed presence in the state, but the recent ruling in International Shoe Co. v. State of Washington et al., 326 U.S. 310 , 66 S.Ct. 154 , 90 L.Ed. 110 , has been considered a departure from such doctr

1947This course of conduct of authorized agents within the state in our judgment constituted a doing of business there in such wise that the harvester company might be fairly said to have been there, doing business, and amenable to the process of the courts of the state." The ruling in the International Harvester Company case and prior rulings of the kind have proceeded under the doctrine of what is termed presence in the state, but the recent ruling in International Shoe Co. v. State of Washington et al., 326 U.S. 310 , 66 S.Ct. 154 , 90 L.Ed. 110 , has been considered a departure from such doctr

11947–1947
Moore v. Fleischman Yeast Co. neutral
mich · 1934
1 sentence

1941Other authorities than the ones heretofore considered support the proposition that where an employer engages an individual to render personal service and in conjunction therewith to furnish trucks, horses, wagons or other things with which to do the work, the expenses of such other things are regarded as special expenses entailed upon the employee by the nature of the employment and are not included in the earnings of the employee. [71 C.J., p. 809, sec. 529; Beuhner v. Bowman, 81 Ind. App. 395 , 143 N.E. 366 ; Moore v. Fleischman Yeast Co. (Mich. Sup. Ct.), 256 N.W. 589 .] There is no room in

11941–1941
Buhner v. Bowman green
indctapp · 1924
2 sentences

1941Other authorities than the ones heretofore considered support the proposition that where an employer engages an individual to render personal service and in conjunction therewith to furnish trucks, horses, wagons or other things with which to do the work, the expenses of such other things are regarded as special expenses entailed upon the employee by the nature of the employment and are not included in the earnings of the employee. [71 C.J., p. 809, sec. 529; Beuhner v. Bowman, 81 Ind. App. 395 , 143 N.E. 366 ; Moore v. Fleischman Yeast Co. (Mich. Sup. Ct.), 256 N.W. 589 .] There is no room in

1941Other authorities than the ones heretofore considered support the proposition that where an employer engages an individual to render personal service and in conjunction therewith to furnish trucks, horses, wagons or other things with which to do the work, the expenses of such other things are regarded as special expenses entailed upon the employee by the nature of the employment and are not included in the earnings of the employee. [71 C.J., p. 809, sec. 529; Beuhner v. Bowman, 81 Ind. App. 395 , 143 N.E. 366 ; Moore v. Fleischman Yeast Co. (Mich. Sup. Ct.), 256 N.W. 589 .] There is no room in

11941–1941
Traders' Bank v. Payne neutral
moctapp · 1888
1 sentence

1938The general rule is that an action on a tax bill is subject to the legal incidents of one founded on a special contract and that the plaintiff, in order to recover thereon, must show a substantial compliance with his contract; but Section 6841, by its provisions, permits and authorizes a departure from such rule (Traders' Bank v. Payne, 31 Mo. App. 512 ) and allows a recovery for the reasonable value, if shown by the evidence, where the evidence fails to show substantial compliance with the contract and where it fails to show that the pavement or the work done was worthless.

11938–1938
Wilson v. North Missouri Railroad neutral
mo · 1870
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Gould v. Smith neutral
mo · 1871
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Harrison v. Bartlett neutral
mo · 1872
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Douglas v. Orr neutral
mo · 1875
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
McHugh v. Meyer neutral
mo · 1875
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Parkinson v. Caplinger green
mo · 1877
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Thies v. Garbe neutral
mo · 1885
1 sentence

1886Parkinson v. Caplinger, 65 Mo. 290 ; Harrison v. Bartlett, 51 Mo. 170 ; Wilson v. Railroad, 46 Mo. 36 ; Gould v. Smith, 48 Mo. 43 ; Douglass v. Orr, 58 Mo. 573 ; McHugh v. Meyers, 61 Mo. 334 ; Thies v. Garbe, 88 Mo. 146 .

11886–1886
Fitzgerald v. Thomas neutral
· 1876
1 sentence

1882The precise question involved here was passed upon by this court in Fitzgerald v. Thomas, 61 Mo. 499 ; Fitzpatrick v. Thomas, 61 Mo. 512, 515 , and decided adversely to plaintiff, and we see no reason for a departure from the doctrine announced in these cases.

11882–1882
Fitzpatrick v. Thomas neutral
· 1876
1 sentence

1882The precise question involved here was passed upon by this court in Fitzgerald v. Thomas, 61 Mo. 499 ; Fitzpatrick v. Thomas, 61 Mo. 512, 515 , and decided adversely to plaintiff, and we see no reason for a departure from the doctrine announced in these cases.

11882–1882
Dorr v. Stockdale neutral
iowa · 1865
1 sentence

1880The same author, in the following section, refers to the case of Dorr v. Stockdale, 19 Iowa 269 , to which 'counsel of defendants have cited us as sustaining the resolution of the 17th February, 1871, as the only Amex-ican case showing a departure from the rule laid down by him. 4. -: withdrawal of stock.

11880–1880
People v. Sanford green
cal · 1872
1 sentence

1879People v. Sanford, 43 Cal. 29 .

11879–1879
Dickson v. Desire's Administrator green
· 1856
1 sentence

1878In Missouri, however, there is a departure from the rule adopted in the majority of the States ; and it is settled (Dickson v. Desire, supra) that the statutory covenant of seisin, and against encumbrances, are continuing covenants, broken when made, of course, .if broken at all, but upon breach of which only nominal damages can be recovered before a loss occurs, and then enuring to the benefit of the grantee' in regular liue of succession from the original covenantor, upon whom the loss may fall.

11878–1878

Where else courts name it

NY 129 (1848–2026) WA 99 (1896–2026) OR 53 (1887–2022) TX 52 (1856–2024) CA 47 (1910–2025) PA 45 (1895–2026) MN 40 (1888–2026) OH 35 (1924–2026) IL 32 (1899–2024) FL 31 (1929–2025) MI 25 (1894–2022) NJ 22 (1891–2026) MD 22 (1930–2025) TN 21 (1882–2012) AL 20 (1879–2000) KS 19 (1900–2022) VA 18 (1842–2013) NE 17 (1902–2022) MA 16 (1862–2012) MO 16 (1878–2018) MS 16 (1962–2008) CO 14 (1899–2013) IN 14 (1891–2024) SD 14 (1966–2024) WI 13 (1880–2006) LA 13 (1848–1991) DC 13 (1975–2021) ND 13 (1905–2022) MT 12 (1887–2024) AZ 12 (1938–2024) WV 11 (1907–2024) RI 11 (1966–2020) IA 10 (1895–2016) NC 8 (1898–2026) NM 8 (1914–2022) AR 6 (1898–2004) GA 6 (1859–2022) NV 6 (1926–2018) UT 6 (1891–2007) HI 6 (1978–2018) SC 5 (1932–2010) KY 5 (1913–1998) CT 5 (1974–2019) OK 4 (1927–2018) ME 4 (1854–2009) NH 4 (1840–2014) ID 4 (1928–2005) WY 4 (1963–2004) VT 4 (1926–2015) DE 3 (1961–1991) AK 3 (1886–2013)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check