elementary rule (Oklahoma) · Go Syfert
← Oklahoma issues

elementary rule in Oklahoma

46 Oklahoma opinions name it 4 courts 1900–2007 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Oklahoma courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (7)

CaseFollowedCited
Commodore Home Systems, Inc. v. CITICORP ACCEPTANCE COMPANY, INC.green
okla · 1989 · cited in 2 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1996–1998
2 sentences

1998Matter of Estate of Hoobler, 1996 OK 56, n. 12 , 925 P.2d 13 , citing, Commodore Home Systems, Inc. v. Citicorp Acceptance Co., Inc., 1989 OK 46 , 780 P.2d 674, 678 ; 15 O.S.1991 § 106. [4] Plaintiffs' evidence was that they relied upon the representations of Apache both before and after they elected to participate pursuant to the pooling order.

1998Matter of Estate of Hoobler, 1996 OK 56, n. 12 , 925 P.2d 13 , citing, Commodore Home Systems, Inc. v. Citicorp Acceptance Co., Inc., 1989 OK 46 , 780 P.2d 674, 678 ; 15 O.S.1991 § 106. [4] Plaintiffs' evidence was that they relied upon the representations of Apache both before and after they elected to participate pursuant to the pooling order.

12
Miller v. Younggreen
okla · 1946 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1994–1994
2 sentences

1994"It is an elementary principle of the law of contracts that in order to recover upon a contract, the contractor complaining of his contrac-tee's non-performance must first establish his own performance or a valid excuse for his failure to perform.” Miller v. Young, 197 Okla. 503, 172 P.2d 994, 995 (1946). .

1994"It is an elementary principle of the law of contracts that in order to recover upon a contract, the contractor complaining of his contrac-tee's non-performance must first establish his own performance or a valid excuse for his failure to perform.” Miller v. Young, 197 Okla. 503, 172 P.2d 994, 995 (1946). .

11
State v. Bonninggreen
mont · 1921 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1993–1993
2 sentences

1993See State v. Bonning, 60 Mont. 362 , 199 P. 274, 275 (1921), one of the cases on which this Court relied in Sprouse, 3 P.2d at 919 .

1993See State v. Bonning, 60 Mont. 362 , 199 P. 274, 275 (1921), one of the cases on which this Court relied in Sprouse, 3 P.2d at 919 .

11
Sprouse v. Stategreen
oklacrimapp · 1931 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1993–1993
2 sentences

1993See State v. Bonning, 60 Mont. 362 , 199 P. 274, 275 (1921), one of the cases on which this Court relied in Sprouse, 3 P.2d at 919 .

1993See State v. Bonning, 60 Mont. 362, 199 P. 274, 275 (1921), one of the cases on which this Court relied in Sprouse, 3 P.2d at 919 .

11
Porter v. Commissioners of Kingfisher Countygreen
okla · 1898 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1979–1979
2 sentences

1979Porter v. Commissioners of Kingfisher County, 6 Okl. 550 , 51 P. 741, 743 (1898). 5 .

1979Porter v. Commissioners of Kingfisher County, 6 Okl. 550 , 51 P. 741, 743 (1898). 5 .

11
Kennedy v. Worcester Consolidated Street Railway Co.green
mass · 1911 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1938–1938
11
Dzuris v. Piercegreen
mass · 1913 · cited in 1 Oklahoma opinions naming this issue, 1938–1938
11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oklahoma. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (57)

CaseCitedYears
In Re Belt green
scotus · 1895
2 sentences

1958We have an authority directly in point to the question now under consideration in the case of In re Belt, 159 U.S. 95 , 15 S.Ct. 987 , 40 L.Ed. 88 .

1958We have an authority directly in point to the question now under consideration in the case of In re Belt, 159 U.S. 95 , 15 S.Ct. 987 , 40 L.Ed. 88 .

31908–1958
McCarty v. State neutral
oklacrimapp · 1930
2 sentences

1959The case of McCarty v. State, 46 Okl.Cr. 332 , 287 P. 1053 was quoted, where it is said : “An information is sufficient if it pleads every element essential to charge the crime pleaded, in plain, concise, and intelligible language, and apprises the defendant in an intelligible way of precisely what he must be prepared to meet.” Judge Doyle, who wrote the opinion for the Court in the case of Harry v. State, supra [ 59 Okl.Cr. 302 , 58 P.2d 343 ], went on to say, however, in the body of the opinion': “It is an elementary principle in criminal jurisprudence that every material fact essential to t

1959The case of McCarty v. State, 46 Okl.Cr. 332 , 287 P. 1053 was quoted, where it is said : “An information is sufficient if it pleads every element essential to charge the crime pleaded, in plain, concise, and intelligible language, and apprises the defendant in an intelligible way of precisely what he must be prepared to meet.” Judge Doyle, who wrote the opinion for the Court in the case of Harry v. State, supra [ 59 Okl.Cr. 302 , 58 P.2d 343 ], went on to say, however, in the body of the opinion': “It is an elementary principle in criminal jurisprudence that every material fact essential to t

21959–1959
National Outdoor Advertising Co. v. Kalkhurst green
okla · 1966
2 sentences

2007National Outdoor Advertising v. Kalkhurst, 1966 OK 85 , 418 P.2d 661 . 116 An acceptance must be absolute and unqualified; if qualified, it is a new proposal. 15 0.98.2001 § 71.

2007National Outdoor Advertising v. Kalkhurst, 1966 OK 85 , 418 P.2d 661 . 116 An acceptance must be absolute and unqualified; if qualified, it is a new proposal. 15 0.98.2001 § 71.

12007–2007
Estate of Hoobler green
okla · 1996
2 sentences

1998Matter of Estate of Hoobler, 1996 OK 56, n. 12 , 925 P.2d 13 , citing, Commodore Home Systems, Inc. v. Citicorp Acceptance Co., Inc., 1989 OK 46 , 780 P.2d 674, 678 ; 15 O.S.1991 § 106. [4] Plaintiffs' evidence was that they relied upon the representations of Apache both before and after they elected to participate pursuant to the pooling order.

1998Matter of Estate of Hoobler, 1996 OK 56, n. 12 , 925 P.2d 13 , citing, Commodore Home Systems, Inc. v. Citicorp Acceptance Co., Inc., 1989 OK 46 , 780 P.2d 674, 678 ; 15 O.S.1991 § 106. [4] Plaintiffs' evidence was that they relied upon the representations of Apache both before and after they elected to participate pursuant to the pooling order.

11998–1998
Dean v. Crisp green
oklacrimapp · 1975
1 sentence

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

11979–1979
Lee v. Boswell green
almd · 1971
1 sentence

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

11979–1979
Bates v. Old Mac Coal Co. green
okla · 1954
1 sentence

1979A statement of the facts constituting the cause of action, in ordinary and concise language, and without repetition.” This requirement that a petition in a civil action must allege the facts which entitle the pleader to relief is consistent with the expressed requirements for an accusation under 22 O.S.1971 § 1183 providing: “The accusation must state the offense charged, in ordinary and concise language, without repetition, and in such a manner as to enable a person of common understanding to know what is intended.” In the case of Bates v. Old Mac Oil Co., 271 P.2d 315 (Okl.1954) this court s

11979–1979
Board of Education v. Board of County Commissioners neutral
· 1904
2 sentences

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

11979–1979
Olson v. Logan County Bank neutral
okla · 1911
2 sentences

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

1979Boeing Company v. State, supra. When an *369 Alabama taxing statute was held unconstitutional, the Court held that the former statute, purportedly repealed by the new, remained in effect. “ ‘The elementary rule of statutory construction is without exception that a void act cannot operate to repeal a valid existing statute, and the law remains in full force and operation as if the repeal had never been attempted.’ ” Weissinger v. Boswell, 330 F.Supp. 615 (M.D.Ala., N.D.1971). 3 .The holding in Porter, supra, was recognized by the Supreme Court in Board of Education v. Board of Com'rs., 14 Okl.

11979–1979
Empire Oil & Refining Co. v. Chapman green
okla · 1938
2 sentences

1978Empire Oil & Refining Co. v. Chapman, 182 Okl. 639 , 79 P.2d 608 (1938); State v. North American Life Ins.

1978Empire Oil & Refining Co. v. Chapman, 182 Okl. 639 , 79 P.2d 608 (1938); State v. North American Life Ins.

11978–1978
In re Matthews neutral
· 1901
1 sentence

1971State v. Bartley, 39 Neb. 353 , 58 N.W. 172 ; In Re Matthews, 109 F. 603 ; Ambler v. Whipple, 139 Ill. 311 , 28 N.E. 841 .

11971–1971
State ex rel. First National Bank v. Bartley green
neb · 1894
2 sentences

1971State v. Bartley, 39 Neb. 353 , 58 N.W. 172 ; In Re Matthews, 109 F. 603 ; Ambler v. Whipple, 139 Ill. 311 , 28 N.E. 841 .

1971State v. Bartley, 39 Neb. 353 , 58 N.W. 172 ; In Re Matthews, 109 F. 603 ; Ambler v. Whipple, 139 Ill. 311 , 28 N.E. 841 .

11971–1971
Carroll v. State green
oklacrimapp · 1959
1 sentence

1971In Caroll v. State, Okl.Cr., 347 P.2d 812 , (1959) this Court stated: “It is an elementary principle in criminal jurisprudence that every material fact essential to the commission of a criminal offense must be alleged in the indictment or information.” It is therefore ordered that the conviction of the Fell and Wolfe Oil Company, in the County Court of Okmulgee County, Oklahoma, in case no. 6854, shall be reversed and remanded with instructions to dismiss.

11971–1971
Ambler v. Whipple green
· 1891
2 sentences

1971State v. Bartley, 39 Neb. 353 , 58 N.W. 172 ; In Re Matthews, 109 F. 603 ; Ambler v. Whipple, 139 Ill. 311 , 28 N.E. 841 .

1971State v. Bartley, 39 Neb. 353 , 58 N.W. 172 ; In Re Matthews, 109 F. 603 ; Ambler v. Whipple, 139 Ill. 311 , 28 N.E. 841 .

11971–1971
Board of County Com'rs v. State Highway Commission neutral
okla · 1936
2 sentences

1970Also, in Board of County Commissioners of Canadian County v. State Highway Commission, 176 Okl. 207 , 55 P.2d 106 , it was held: "It is an elementary rule of law that governmental duties or power cannot be contracted away. . . ." The rule stated in Brown v. State Election Board, supra, applied.

1970Also, in Board of County Commissioners of Canadian County v. State Highway Commission, 176 Okl. 207 , 55 P.2d 106 , it was held: "It is an elementary rule of law that governmental duties or power cannot be contracted away. . . ." The rule stated in Brown v. State Election Board, supra, applied.

11970–1970
Sims v. United Bridge and Iron green
okla · 1965
1 sentence

1966Hartzell v. Choctaw Lumber Co. of Delaware et al., 163 Okl. 240 , 22 P.2d 387 ; Georgia State Savings Ass’n of Savannah, Ga. v. Elias, 192 Okl. 227 , 135 P.2d 36 ; Sims v. United Bridge and Iron et al., Okl., 402 P.2d 911 .

11966–1966
Georgia State Savings Ass'n v. Elias neutral
okla · 1943
2 sentences

1966Hartzell v. Choctaw Lumber Co. of Delaware et al., 163 Okl. 240 , 22 P.2d 387 ; Georgia State Savings Ass’n of Savannah, Ga. v. Elias, 192 Okl. 227 , 135 P.2d 36 ; Sims v. United Bridge and Iron et al., Okl., 402 P.2d 911 .

1966Hartzell v. Choctaw Lumber Co. of Delaware et al., 163 Okl. 240 , 22 P.2d 387 ; Georgia State Savings Ass’n of Savannah, Ga. v. Elias, 192 Okl. 227 , 135 P.2d 36 ; Sims v. United Bridge and Iron et al., Okl., 402 P.2d 911 .

11966–1966
Hartzell v. Choctaw Lbr. Co. green
okla · 1933
2 sentences

1966Hartzell v. Choctaw Lumber Co. of Delaware et al., 163 Okl. 240 , 22 P.2d 387 ; Georgia State Savings Ass’n of Savannah, Ga. v. Elias, 192 Okl. 227 , 135 P.2d 36 ; Sims v. United Bridge and Iron et al., Okl., 402 P.2d 911 .

1966Hartzell v. Choctaw Lumber Co. of Delaware et al., 163 Okl. 240 , 22 P.2d 387 ; Georgia State Savings Ass’n of Savannah, Ga. v. Elias, 192 Okl. 227 , 135 P.2d 36 ; Sims v. United Bridge and Iron et al., Okl., 402 P.2d 911 .

11966–1966
Harry v. State neutral
oklacrimapp · 1936
1 sentence

1959The case of McCarty v. State, 46 Okl.Cr. 332 , 287 P. 1053 was quoted, where it is said : “An information is sufficient if it pleads every element essential to charge the crime pleaded, in plain, concise, and intelligible language, and apprises the defendant in an intelligible way of precisely what he must be prepared to meet.” Judge Doyle, who wrote the opinion for the Court in the case of Harry v. State, supra [ 59 Okl.Cr. 302 , 58 P.2d 343 ], went on to say, however, in the body of the opinion': “It is an elementary principle in criminal jurisprudence that every material fact essential to t

11959–1959
Morrison v. Fry green
okla · 1953
2 sentences

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

11958–1958
Lowden v. Oklahoma County, Excise Board neutral
okla · 1940
2 sentences

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

11958–1958
Bell v. Crum green
okla · 1940
2 sentences

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

1958We are familiar with former decisions in Morrison v. Fry, 208 Okl. 239 , 255 P.2d 270 ; Lowden v. Oklahoma County Excise Board, 186 Okl. 706 , 100 P.2d 448 , and Bell v. Crum, 188 Okl. 67 , 106 P.2d 518 , cited in brief of defendant in 'error.

11958–1958
Messick v. Johnson neutral
okla · 1934
2 sentences

1946Messick v. Johnson, 167 Okla. 463 , 30 P. 2d 176 ; Am.

1946Messick v. Johnson, 167 Okla. 463 , 30 P. 2d 176 ; Am.

11946–1946
Tidal Oil Co. v. Pease green
okla · 1931
2 sentences

1945We said in Tidal Oil Company v. Pease, 153 Okla. 137 , 5 P. 2d 389 , that it was not the intent or purpose of that act to prevent the owner of land from contracting with another to flow the forbidden substances upon or over his land.

1945We said in Tidal Oil Company v. Pease, 153 Okla. 137 , 5 P. 2d 389 , that it was not the intent or purpose of that act to prevent the owner of land from contracting with another to flow the forbidden substances upon or over his land.

11945–1945
Goldey v. Morning News green
scotus · 1895
2 sentences

1943But if the facts show that such application is made solely in order to preserve the right of a party to deny such jurisdiction, there is no reason to presume a waiver of such right or an intent to submit to such jurisdiction. ‘It is an elementary principle of jurisprudence that a court of justice cannot acquire jurisdiction over the person of one who has no residence within its territorial jurisdiction except by actual service of notice within the jurisdiction upon him, or upon some one authorized to accept service in his behalf, or by his waiver, by general appearance or otherwise, of the wan

1943But if the facts show that such application is made solely in order to preserve the right of a party to deny such jurisdiction, there is no reason to presume a waiver of such right or an intent to submit to such jurisdiction. ‘It is an elementary principle of jurisprudence that a court of justice cannot acquire jurisdiction over the person of one who has no residence within its territorial jurisdiction except by actual service of notice within the jurisdiction upon him, or upon some one authorized to accept service in his behalf, or by his waiver, by general appearance or otherwise, of the wan

11943–1943
Kline v. Mueller green
okla · 1928
11938–1938
Sedgwick v. National Bank green
· 1922
11936–1936
Kuhn v. Dickey neutral
calctapp · 1924
11936–1936
Barr v. Knotts green
wva · 1926
11935–1935
Morrison v. Atkinson green
okla · 1906
11935–1935
Silvey's Estate v. Koppell green
· 1917
11935–1935
Hall v. Goldsworthy green
kan · 1932
11934–1934
Smart v. Bassler green
okla · 1924
11934–1934
Bain v. Tye green
kyctapp · 1914
11934–1934
Sosbee v. Clark neutral
okla · 1922
11933–1933
Atwood v. Rose neutral
okla · 1912
11933–1933
Murnan v. Isbell green
okla · 1928
11929–1929
Fahey v. Mitchell neutral
okla · 1925
11929–1929
Munn v. Mid-Continent Motor Securities Co. neutral
okla · 1924
11929–1929
Brooks v. Chaplin green
vt · 1831
11928–1928

Where else courts name it

CA 301 (1889–2026) TX 180 (1876–2026) GA 147 (1899–2022) IL 143 (1873–2026) NY 141 (1833–2019) CT 86 (1835–2025) IN 85 (1879–2024) PA 78 (1834–2021) FL 76 (1899–2025) NC 70 (1824–2026) KY 63 (1891–2026) WI 63 (1875–2022) MO 55 (1881–2024) IA 55 (1863–2023) VA 54 (1851–2025) MD 54 (1906–2022) MI 53 (1888–2026) TN 52 (1875–2025) AL 51 (1874–2022) WV 50 (1884–2024) MA 48 (1880–2025) AR 47 (1898–2024) LA 47 (1908–2009) OK 46 (1900–2007) MT 42 (1893–2017) WA 41 (1891–2025) KS 39 (1916–2021) ME 37 (1851–2022) OR 33 (1887–2015) NE 32 (1892–2019) MS 29 (1895–2023) HI 29 (1902–2026) MN 28 (1888–2015) OH 27 (1881–2020) CO 26 (1894–2010) NJ 25 (1867–2025) UT 23 (1899–2013) SD 19 (1894–2026) SC 19 (1907–2018) ID 17 (1909–2023) DE 16 (1932–2020) AZ 15 (1903–2009) ND 13 (1898–2020) NM 12 (1907–2023) WY 12 (1930–2014) VT 10 (1865–1986) NH 10 (1860–2016) NV 9 (1913–2015) RI 6 (1895–2017) AK 6 (1985–2023) DC 6 (1948–2013) PR 3 (1904–1939) VI 2 (1984–2007)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check