elementary rule (Illinois) · Go Syfert
← Illinois issues

elementary rule in Illinois

150 Illinois opinions name it 3 courts 1873–2026 17 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Illinois courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (24)

CaseFollowedCited
Smithberg v. Illinois Municipal Retirement Fundgreen
ill · 2000 · cited in 9 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2003–2026
2 sentences

2026See e.g., Smithberg v. Illinois Municipal Retirement Fund, 192 Ill. 2d 291, 297 (2000) (“It is an elementary principle of law that a court is vested with the inherent power to enforce its orders.”).

2023“It is an elementary principle of law that a court is vested with the inherent power to enforce its orders.” Smithberg, 192 Ill. 2d at 297 ; see also In re Estate of Steinfeld, 158 Ill. 2d 1, 19 (1994) (once a court has jurisdiction over both the parties and the subject matter, it has “inherent power to enforce its orders by way of contempt”).

89
People v. Parteegreen
ill · 1988 · cited in 6 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1995–2025
2 sentences

2025“It is an elementary principle of statutory interpretation that no statute should be construed in a manner which will lead to consequences which are absurd, inconvenient, or unjust.” People v. Partee, 125 Ill. 2d 24, 30-31 (1988).

2025“It is an elementary principle of statutory interpretation that no statute should be construed in a manner which will lead to consequences which are absurd, inconvenient, or unjust.” People v. Partee, 125 Ill. 2d 24, 30-31 (1988).

56
Cities Service Oil Co. v. Village of Oak Brookgreen
illappct · 1980 · cited in 5 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1993–2025
2 sentences

2025County of Cook v. Illinois Fraternal Order of Police Labor Council, 358 Ill. App. 3d 667, 671 (2005); see American Society of Lubrication Engineers v. Roetheli, 249 Ill. App. 3d 1038, 1042 (1993) (“ ‘It is an elementary principle of law that judicial power essentially involves the right to enforce the results of its own exertion.’ ” (quoting Cities Service Oil Co. v. Village of Oak Brook, 84 Ill. App. 3d 381, 384 (1980))); Baltimore & Ohio R.R.

2009App. 3d 1038, 1042 , 621 N.E.2d 30 (1993) (“ ‘It is an elementary principle of law that judicial power essentially involves the right to enforce the results of its own exertion’ ”), quoting Cities Service Oil Co. v. Village of Oak Brook, 84 Ill.

45
People v. Bakergreen
ill · 1978 · cited in 4 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2000–2003
2 sentences

2003“It is an elementary principle of law that a court is vested with the inherent power to enforce its orders.” Smithberg v. Illinois Municipal Retirement Fund, 192 Ill. 2d 291, 297 (2000), citing In re Baker, 71 Ill. 2d 480, 484 (1978).

2003“It is an elementary principle of law that a court is vested with the inherent power to enforce its orders.” Smithberg v. Illinois Municipal Retirement Fund , 192 Ill. 2d 291, 297 (2000), citing In re Baker , 71 Ill. 2d 480, 484 (1978).

44
In re Marriage of Parisgreen
illappct · 2021 · cited in 3 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2023–2026
2 sentences

2026See In re Marriage of Paris, 2020 IL App (1st) 181116, ¶ 38 (recognizing, as an elementary rule of statutory construction, that when the legislature uses certain words in one instance and different words in another, it intends a different 18 meaning).

2023In re Marriage of Paris, 2020 IL App (1st) 181116, ¶ 38 (“An elementary rule of construction is that when the legislature uses certain words in one instance and different words in another, it intends a different meaning.”). -4- More importantly, however, this provision would be meaningless if it were understood to refer only to subsection (c).

23
Aurora Pizza Hut, Inc. v. Haytergreen
illappct · 1979 · cited in 3 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1992–2021
2 sentences

2021Aurora Pizza Hut, Inc. v. Hayter, 79 Ill.

2019Aurora Pizza Hut, Inc. v. Hayter, 79 Ill. App. 3d 1102, 1105-06 (1979). ¶ 40 Furthermore, the record on appeal adequately allows this court to review the propriety of the court’s interim fee award.

23
Ake v. Oklahomagreen
scotus · 1985 · cited in 3 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1991–2002
2 sentences

2002This elementary principle, grounded in significant part on the fourteenth amendment’s due process guarantee of fundamental fairness, derives from the belief that justice cannot be equal where, simply as a result of his poverty, a defendant is denied the opportunity to participate meaningfully in a judicial proceeding in which his liberty is at stake.” Ake v. Oklahoma, 470 U.S. 68, 76 , 84 L.

2002This elementary principle, grounded in significant part on the fourteenth amendment’s due process guarantee of fundamental fairness, derives from the belief that justice cannot be equal where, simply as a result of his poverty, a defendant is denied the opportunity to participate meaningfully in a judicial proceeding in which his liberty is at stake.” Ake v. Oklahoma, 470 U.S. 68, 76 , 84 L.

23
American Society of Lubrication Engineers v. Roetheligreen
illappct · 1993 · cited in 2 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2009–2025
2 sentences

2025County of Cook v. Illinois Fraternal Order of Police Labor Council, 358 Ill. App. 3d 667, 671 (2005); see American Society of Lubrication Engineers v. Roetheli, 249 Ill. App. 3d 1038, 1042 (1993) (“ ‘It is an elementary principle of law that judicial power essentially involves the right to enforce the results of its own exertion.’ ” (quoting Cities Service Oil Co. v. Village of Oak Brook, 84 Ill. App. 3d 381, 384 (1980))); Baltimore & Ohio R.R.

2009App. 3d 1038, 1042 , 621 N.E.2d 30 (1993) (“ ‘It is an elementary principle of law that judicial power essentially involves the right to enforce the results of its own exertion’ ”), quoting Cities Service Oil Co. v. Village of Oak Brook, 84 Ill.

22
In Re Estate of Divinegreen
illappct · 1994 · cited in 2 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2004–2004
2 sentences

2004App. 3d 799, 810 , 635 N.E.2d 581 (1994) (“It is an elementary rule of appellate practice that an appellant may not make a point merely by stating it without presenting arguments in support of it.

2004App. 3d 799, 810 , 635 N.E.2d 581 (1994) ("It is an elementary rule of appellate practice that an appellant may not make a point merely by stating it without presenting arguments in support of it.

22
In Re Marriage of Hartmangreen
illappct · 1999 · cited in 2 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2003–2003
2 sentences

2003“Where a domestic relations order has been entered, the trial court retains jurisdiction to enforce its order (In re Marriage of Hartman, 305 Ill.

2003“Where a domestic relations order has been entered, the trial court retains jurisdiction to enforce its order ( In re Marriage of Hartman , 305 Ill.

22
Reichelt v. Andersongreen
illappct · 1921 · cited in 2 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1982–2025
2 sentences

2025App. 3d 591, 601 (2009). ¶ 27 “It is an elementary rule of appellate practice that an appellant may not make a point by merely stating it, without presenting any arguments or reasons in support of it[,] and this court will not search through the record for possible errors on which a judgment may be reversed.” Reichelt v. Anderson, 222 Ill.

1982(Reichelt v. Anderson (1921), 222 Ill.

12
Godare v. Sterling Steel Casting Co.green
illappct · 1981 · cited in 2 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1983–2018
2 sentences

2018“It is an elementary rule of contract law that a condition precedent must be performed or no contractual liability results.” Godare v. Sterling Steel Casting Co., 103 Ill.

1983It is an elementary rule of contract law that a condition precedent must be performed before contractual liability arises. ( Godare v. Sterling Steel Casting Co. (1981), 103 Ill.

12
District of Columbia v. Hellergreen
scotus · 2008 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
Baltimore & Ohio Railroad v. United Statesgreen
scotus · 1929 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
People v. Careygreen
illappct · 2008 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
In re Estate of Frakesgreen
illappct · 2020 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
County of Cook v. Illinois Fraternal Order of Police Labor Councilgreen
illappct · 2005 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
People v. Browngreen
illappct · 1993 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
11
Texas Fidelity & Bonding Co. v. City of Austingreen
tex · 1922 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2024–2024
11
Mitchell v. Mahingreen
ill · 1972 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2024–2024
11
The Village of Vernon Hills v. Heelangreen
ill · 2015 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2024–2024
11
In Re Marriage of Hallgreen
illappct · 2010 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2023–2023
11
In Re Estate of Steinfeldgreen
ill · 1994 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2023–2023
11
In re Marriage of Krilichgreen
illappct · 2023 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 2023–2023
11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Illinois. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (56)

CaseCitedYears
Kibs v. People neutral
ill · 1876
2 sentences

1961Law, secs. 164, 372; Kibs v. People, 81 Ill. 599 .’ ” There is no way for this court to tell whether the indictment was laid under paragraph 9-92 of chapter 24 (Cities and Villages Act) or under paragraph 449 of chapter 38 (Criminal Code) of the Illinois Eevised Statutes.

1942Law, secs. 164, 372; Kibs v. People, 81 Ill. 599 .” In People v. Barnes, 314 Ill. 140 , in discussing the same question, the following language was used: “It is not sufficient to charge an offense in the language of the statute, alone, where by its generality it may embrace acts which it was not the intent of the statute to punish.

61885–1961
Krome v. Halbert neutral
ill · 1914
2 sentences

1927(Hoyne v. Danisch, 264 Ill. 467 .) It is an elementary rule that-in ascertaining this contention all parts of a statute must be considered together, and not each part, phrase, clause, sentence or section by itself. (36 Cyc. 1131; Krome v. Halbert, 263 Ill. 172 ; Hoyne v. Danisch, supra.) ’ ’ Commenting further in that case the court say: “Such provisions are wholly irreconcilable with the idea that the right to such salary is also to depend upon the number of hours of service and to be calculated upon a per diem basis.” “The intention of the law-makers is the law, and this intention should be

1915(Hoyne v. Danisch, 264 Ill. 467 .) It is an elementary rule that in ascertaining this intention all parts of a statute must be considered together, and not each part, phrase, clause, sentence or section by itself. (36 Cyc. 1131; Krome v. Halbert, 263 Ill. 172 ; Hoyne v. Danisch, supra.) When this act is so construed the legislative intent is clear.

41914–1927
Teagarden v. Hetfield neutral
ind · 1859
2 sentences

1921The court in the latter case at page 230 says :■ “The elementary rule is this: ‘But where the damages, through the natural consequences of the act complained of, are not the necessary result of it, they are termed special damages, which the law does not imply, and therefore, in order to prevent a surprise upon the defendant, they must be particularly specified in the declaration, or the plaintiff will not be permitted to give evidence of them on the trial. ’ 2 Gfreenleaf on Evidence, sec. 254; Teagarden v. Hetfield, 11 Ind. 522 .” It is next contended by appellant that appellee failed to show

1899There the same rule is again announced, though not in the same language thus (p. 230): “ The elementary rule is this: But where the damages, though the natural consequences of the act complained of, are not the necessary result of it, they are termed special damages, which the law does not imply, and therefore, in order to prevent a surprise upon the defendant, they must be particularly specified in the declaration, or the plaintiff will not be permitted to give evidence of them on the trial. 2 Greenleaf on Ev., Sec. 251; Teagarden v. Hetfield, 11 Ind. 522 .” To the same effect are: Chicago W.

31885–1921
Miller v. Moffat neutral
illappct · 1910
2 sentences

2010The rule prohibiting royalty leases, while a well-known mineral law rule, is at its essence “an elementary principle of the law of contracts” (Miller, 153 Ill.

2010App. 1 (1910), in which a 50-year royalty lease in Randolph County was held to be void ab initio for a lack of mutuality, based upon “an elementary principle of the law of contracts that if one party to a contract is under no obligation to perform at all the contract is void.” Miller, 153 Ill.

22010–2010
People v. Hicks green
ill · 1987
2 sentences

2009Plaintiff cites Hicks , which stated: "It is an elementary rule of statutory construction that `[t]he addition of a new provision in a statute by amendment is an indication of the absence of its implied or prior existence.' [Citation.] Absent substantial considerations to the contrary, `an amendatory change in the language of a statute creates a presumption that it was intended to change the law as it theretofore existed.'" Hicks, 119 Ill.2d at 34 , 115 Ill.Dec. 623 , 518 N.E.2d 148 .

2009Plaintiff cites Hicks, which stated: “It is an elementary rule of statutory construction that ‘[t]he addition of a new provision in a statute by amendment is an indication of the absence of its implied or prior existence.’ [Citation.] Absent substantial considerations to the contrary, ‘an amendatory change in the language of a statute creates a presumption that it was intended to change the law as it theretofore existed.’ ” Hicks, 119 Ill. 2d at 34 .

21996–2009
People ex rel. Reiter v. Lupe green
ill · 1950
2 sentences

2007Indeed, Reiter reached its holding in part by drawing comparisons to proceedings at law, noting that “[n]o one could contend in a law case that a plaintiff who had obtained a decision in an Appellate Court, reversing the ruling of a trial court which had taken his case away from the court or jury, would have the right to present his evidence from the first trial in transcript form at a new trial.” Reiter, 405 Ill. at 72-73 .

2007Indeed, Reiter reached its holding in part by drawing comparisons to proceedings at law, noting that "[n]o one could contend in a law case that a plaintiff who had obtained a decision in an Appellate Court, reversing the ruling of a trial court -9- No. 2--05--1212 which had taken his case away from the court or jury, would have the right to present his evidence from the first trial in transcript form at a new trial." Reiter, 405 Ill. at 72-73 .

22007–2007
People v. Bales green
ill · 1985
2 sentences

1992People v. Bales (1985), 108 Ill.2d 182, 188 , 91 Ill.Dec. 171 , 483 N.E.2d 517 . "[I]t is an elementary rule of construction that all sections of an act relating to the same subject matter should be considered together unless to do so would be plainly contrary to the legislative intent." (2A N. Singer, Sutherland on Statutory Construction § 47.06, at 151 (5th ed. 1992).) Article I of the Code pertains to offenses relating to titles and registration and is part of the general statutory scheme entitled "ANTI-THEFT LAWS." (Ill.Rev.Stat. 1989, ch. 95½, par. 4-100 et seq. ) Section 3-100 et seq. of

1992People v. Bales (1985), 108 Ill.2d 182, 188 , 91 Ill.Dec. 171 , 483 N.E.2d 517 . "[I]t is an elementary rule of construction that all sections of an act relating to the same subject matter should be considered together unless to do so would be plainly contrary to the legislative intent." (2A N. Singer, Sutherland on Statutory Construction § 47.06, at 151 (5th ed. 1992).) Article I of the Code pertains to offenses relating to titles and registration and is part of the general statutory scheme entitled "ANTI-THEFT LAWS." (Ill.Rev.Stat. 1989, ch. 95½, par. 4-100 et seq. ) Section 3-100 et seq. of

21992–1992
Faith v. Martoccio green
illappct · 1974
2 sentences

1990Faith v. Martoccio (1974), 21 Ill.App.3d 999, 1003 , 316 N.E.2d 164 .

1990Faith v. Martoccio (1974), 21 Ill.App.3d 999, 1003 , 316 N.E.2d 164 .

21990–1990
North Chicago Street Railroad v. Ackley green
ill · 1897
2 sentences

1985(North Chicago Street R.R. v. Ackley, 171 Ill. 100, 111 , 49 N.E. 222 .) In any event, the assignee can obtain no greater right or interest than that possessed by the assignor, inasmuch as one cannot convey that which he does not have.

1976(North Chicago Street R.R. v. Ackley, 171 Ill. 100, 111 , 49 N.E. 222 .) In any event, the assignee can obtain no greater right or interest than that possessed by the assignor, inasmuch as one cannot convey that which he does not have.

21976–1985
Sup v. Cervenka green
ill · 1928
2 sentences

1983In Sup v. Cervenka, 331 Ill. 459 , the rule to which we refer is thus stated: `It is an elementary rule in the construction of a statute that the intention of the legislature must primarily be determined from the language of the statute itself and not from conjectures aliunde.

1983In Sup v. Cervenka, 331 Ill. 459 , the rule to which we refer is thus stated: ‘It is an elementary rule in the construction of a statute that the intention of the legislature must primarily be determined from the language of the statute itself and not from conjectures aliunde.

21958–1983
The PEOPLE v. Dixon green
ill · 1961
2 sentences

1983(People v. Dixon (1961), 22 Ill. 2d 513 , 177 N.E.2d 224 .) However, where there is no evidence of addiction, the attempt to impeach a witness on that basis has been held to be “improper unless the examiner is prepared to make a showing to support the intended questions.” (People v. Brown (1966), 76 Ill.

1983(People v. Dixon (1961), 22 Ill. 2d 513 , 177 N.E.2d 224 .) However, where there is no evidence of addiction, the attempt to impeach a witness on that basis has been held to be “improper unless the examiner is prepared to make a showing to support the intended questions.” (People v. Brown (1966), 76 Ill.

21971–1983
Mahlstedt v. Ideal Lighting Co. green
ill · 1915
2 sentences

1971"It is an elementary rule that where the court or jury can make their own deductions they shall not be made by those who testify." ( Mahlstedt v. Ideal Lighting Co., 271 Ill. 154, 171 .) This rule was not cast aside by the decisions cited by the majority.

1971“It is an elementary rule that where the court or jury can make their own deductions they shall not be made by those who testify.” (Mahlstedt v. Ideal Lighting Co., 271 Ill. 154, 171 .) This rule was not cast aside by the decisions cited by the majority.

21971–1971
Pierce v. Carpentier green
ill · 1960
2 sentences

1970Pierce v. Carpentier, 20 Ill2d 526, 169 NE2d 747 (1960).

1970Pierce v. Carpentier, 20 Ill2d 526, 169 NE2d 747 ; Washington Mfg.

21970–1970
Hoyne v. Danisch green
ill · 1914
2 sentences

1927(Hoyne v. Danisch, 264 Ill. 467 .) It is an elementary rule that-in ascertaining this contention all parts of a statute must be considered together, and not each part, phrase, clause, sentence or section by itself. (36 Cyc. 1131; Krome v. Halbert, 263 Ill. 172 ; Hoyne v. Danisch, supra.) ’ ’ Commenting further in that case the court say: “Such provisions are wholly irreconcilable with the idea that the right to such salary is also to depend upon the number of hours of service and to be calculated upon a per diem basis.” “The intention of the law-makers is the law, and this intention should be

1927(Hoyne v. Danisch, 264 Ill. 467 .) It is an elementary rule that-in ascertaining this contention all parts of a statute must be considered together, and not each part, phrase, clause, sentence or section by itself. (36 Cyc. 1131; Krome v. Halbert, 263 Ill. 172 ; Hoyne v. Danisch, supra.) ’ ’ Commenting further in that case the court say: “Such provisions are wholly irreconcilable with the idea that the right to such salary is also to depend upon the number of hours of service and to be calculated upon a per diem basis.” “The intention of the law-makers is the law, and this intention should be

21915–1927
Evans v. People green
mich · 1863
2 sentences

1915(Evans v. People, 12 Mich. 27 .) Expert evidence is admissible when the witnesses offered as experts have peculiar knowledge or experience not common to the world, which renders their opinions founded on such knowledge or experience an aid to the court or jury in determining the question at issue.

1911(Evans v. People, 12 Mich. 27 .) Expert evidence is not confined to classed and specified professions, but is applicable wherever peculiar skill and judgment applied to a particular subject are required to explain results or to trace them to their causes.

21911–1915
Maiss v. Metropolitan Amusement Ass'n green
ill · 1909
2 sentences

1914(Sutherland on Stat. Const. sec. 215; Maiss v. Metropolitan Amusement Ass’n, 241 Ill. 177 ; Soby v. People, 134 id. 66.) In the construction of a statute the courts are not confined to a literal meaning of the words, but the intention may be collected from the necessity or objects of the act and its words may be enlarged or restricted according to its intent.

1914(Sutherland on Stat. Const, sec. 215; Maiss v. Metropolitan Amusement Ass’n, 241 Ill. 177 ; Soby v. People, 134 id. 66.) * * * The several provisions of the statute should be construed together in the light of the purpose and objects of the act, so as to give effect to the main intent, even though in so doing particular provisions are not construed according to their literal reading.” Krome v. Halbert, 263 Ill. 172 .

21914–1914
Prichard v. People neutral
ill · 1894
2 sentences

1905The allegation being that the defendant knew that his former wife was living, it is sought to be inferred, by way of argument, that she must have been in fact living, but it is an elementary rule of pleading, both civil and criminal, that allegations of fact in pleading should be direct and positive and not merely" argumentative or inferential. ” Prichard v. People, 149 Ill. 50, 54 .

1899Law, Secs. 164, 372; Kibs v. The People, 81 Ill. 599 .” In Prichard v. The People, 149 Ill. 50 , it seems to have been urged by counsel for the people, that if the offense was so plainly charged that its nature could be easily understood by the jury, that was sufficient, in respect to which the court say: “ Whether the description of the offense is so plain that its nature could be easily understood by the jury, must depend on whether it is described with at least a reasonable degree of certainty, using the term ‘ certainty ’ in its common law sense.” The indictment was for bigamy, and alleged

21899–1905
K4 Enterprises, Inc. v. Grater, Inc. green
illappct · 2009
1 sentence

2026K4 Enterprises, Inc. 394 Ill. App. 3d at 313 .

12026–2026
People v. Wunderlich green
illappct · 2020
12024–2024
Evans v. Cook County State's Attorney green
ill · 2021
12024–2024
Best v. Taylor MacHine Works green
ill · 1997
12009–2009
Gault v. Sideman green
illappct · 1963
11995–1995
McDunn v. Williams green
ill · 1993
11995–1995
Nicholl v. Scaletta green
illappct · 1982
11994–1994
People v. Gholston green
illappct · 1984
11993–1993
People v. Miles neutral
illappct · 1973
11988–1988
McCastle v. Sheinkop green
ill · 1987
11988–1988
People v. Nunn green
ill · 1979
11987–1987
Stigler v. City of Chicago green
ill · 1971
11987–1987
Roosevelt University v. Mayfair Construction Co. green
illappct · 1975
11987–1987
Western National Bank v. Village of Kildeer green
ill · 1960
11987–1987
Litwin v. Timbercrest Estates, Inc. green
illappct · 1976
11986–1986
People v. Rink green
ill · 1983
11986–1986
In Re Estate of Wilkening green
illappct · 1982
11986–1986
Jones v. EAGLE II green
illappct · 1981
11986–1986
People v. Brown green
illappct · 1966
11983–1983
Leon v. Max E. Miller & Son, Inc. green
illappct · 1974
11983–1983
Edwards v. Hill green
ill · 1849
11983–1983
Milani v. Proesel green
ill · 1958
11983–1983
In Re Estate of Kime green
illappct · 1976
11981–1981

Statutes the citing opinions construe

IL § 750 ILCS 5/508 (6)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

CA 306 (1889–2026) TX 189 (1874–2026) NY 157 (1833–2019) GA 155 (1899–2022) IL 150 (1873–2026) IN 86 (1879–2024) CT 85 (1835–2025) PA 79 (1834–2021) NC 78 (1824–2026) FL 76 (1911–2026) WI 71 (1862–2022) KY 64 (1891–2026) MO 64 (1881–2024) AL 60 (1874–2022) IA 57 (1863–2023) MD 56 (1906–2022) MI 55 (1886–2026) VA 55 (1851–2025) TN 53 (1875–2025) MA 52 (1870–2025) WV 51 (1884–2024) LA 49 (1908–2009) OK 47 (1900–2007) AR 47 (1898–2024) MT 46 (1893–2017) WA 40 (1891–2025) KS 39 (1916–2021) ME 39 (1851–2022) OR 35 (1887–2015) NE 34 (1892–2019) MN 31 (1888–2024) MS 30 (1895–2023) HI 30 (1899–2026) OH 28 (1896–2020) CO 26 (1894–2010) UT 25 (1899–2013) NJ 24 (1867–2025) ID 23 (1909–2023) SC 21 (1907–2018) SD 20 (1894–2026) DE 17 (1932–2023) AZ 16 (1902–2009) WY 15 (1905–2014) ND 15 (1898–2020) NH 14 (1860–2016) NM 12 (1907–2023) VT 12 (1865–1986) NV 11 (1905–2015) RI 6 (1895–2017) DC 6 (1948–2013) AK 6 (1985–2023) PR 3 (1904–1939) VI 2 (1984–2007)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check