modern rule (Wisconsin) · Go Syfert
← Wisconsin issues

modern rule in Wisconsin

20 Wisconsin opinions name it 3 courts 1900–2021 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Wisconsin courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (5)

CaseFollowedCited
Whitman v. American Trucking Assns., Inc.green
scotus · 2001 · cited in 1 Wisconsin opinions naming this issue, 2021–2021
1 sentence

2021Rev 327, 333 (2002). "[T]he Constitution does not speak of 'intelligible principles.' Rather, it speaks in much simpler terms: 'All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress.'" Whitman v. American Trucking Ass'ns, 12 No. 2020AP1718-OA.rgb Inc., 531 U.S. 457, 487 (2001) (Thomas, J., concurring).

11
Hedtcke v. Sentry Insurancegreen
wis · 1982 · cited in 1 Wisconsin opinions naming this issue, 2020–2020
1 sentence

2020Id. at 485 (“Courts adopting the modern rule focus on the contract of insurance rather than the interests and obligations arising from the nature of the property ownership.” (footnote omitted)).

11
Trustees of Indiana University v. Town of Rhinegreen
wisctapp · 1992 · cited in 1 Wisconsin opinions naming this issue, 1993–1993
2 sentences

1993Trustees of Indiana University v. Town of Rhine, 170 Wis. 2d 293, 299 , 488 N.W.2d 128, 130 (Ct. App. 1992).

1993Trustees of Indiana University v. Town of Rhine, 170 Wis. 2d 293, 299 , 488 N.W.2d 128, 130 (Ct. App. 1992).

11
National Conversion Corp. v. Cedar Building Corp.green
ny · 1969 · cited in 1 Wisconsin opinions naming this issue, 1993–1993
2 sentences

1993Id. at 355 (citations omitted).

1993Id. at 355 (citations omitted).

11
In Matter of Grantgreen
wis · 1978 · cited in 1 Wisconsin opinions naming this issue, 1979–1979
2 sentences

1979Matter of Grant, 83 Wis.2d 77, 85 , 264 N.W.2d 587, 590 (1978). [3, 4] In Kastigar the United States Supreme Court established the modern requirement against direct or derivative use of immunized testimony: [I]mmunity from use and derivative use is coextensive with the scope of the privilege against self-incrimination, and therefore is sufficient to compel testimony over a claim of the privilege . . . .

1979Matter of Grant, 83 Wis.2d 77, 85 , 264 N.W.2d 587, 590 (1978). [3, 4] In Kastigar the United States Supreme Court established the modern requirement against direct or derivative use of immunized testimony: [I]mmunity from use and derivative use is coextensive with the scope of the privilege against self-incrimination, and therefore is sufficient to compel testimony over a claim of the privilege . . . .

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Wisconsin. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (20)

CaseCitedYears
St. Luke's Hospital Ass'n v. City of Milwaukee green
wis · 1967
2 sentences

2009Ass'n v. City of Milwaukee, 35 Wis. 2d 660, 668-69 , 151 N.W.2d 750 (1967)).

2009Ass'n v. City of Milwaukee, 35 Wis. 2d 660, 668-69 , 151 N.W.2d 750 (1967)).

21979–2009
Muench v. Public Service Commission green
wis · 1952
2 sentences

1996It is true that the initial paragraph in that decision states our conclusion that the plaintiff’s complaint "is sufficient to state a cause of action in inverse condemnation or private nuisance." A reading of the entire opinion immediately reveals that the holding of the case is that the complaint stated a claim for both claims. 6 If the Village pursues its direct condemnation claim to permanently take the property, the amount of plaintiffs' damages will no doubt be reduced by the fact of the prior reduction in value. 7 The evidence reveals that one of the plaintiffs purchased his property few

1975Muench v. Public Service Comm. (1952), 261 Wis. 492, 506 , 53 N. W. 2d 514 , 55 N. W. 2d 40 , established the modern test of navigability: “[A]ny stream is ‘navigable in fact’ which is capable of floating any boat, skiff, or canoe, of the shallowest draft used for recreational purposes.” There was evidence in the instant case to show that modern recreational canoes and kayaks could successfully be used for recreational purposes in as little as three inches of water.

21975–1996
Counselman v. Hitchcock green
scotus · 1892
2 sentences

1979It prohibits the prosecu-torial authorities from using the compelled testimony in any respect, and it therefore insures that the testimony cannot lead to the infliction of criminal penalties on the witness. [Footnotes omitted.] [Emphasis in original.] 6 In Counselman v. Hitchcock, 142 U.S. 547 (1892) the court held that an immunity statute must afford transactional immunity if testimony is to be compelled.

1979It prohibits the prosecutorial authorities from using the compelled testimony in any respect, and it therefore insures that the testimony cannot lead to the infliction of criminal penalties on the witness. [Footnotes omitted.] [Emphasis in original.] [6] In Counselman v. Hitchcock, 142 U.S. 547 (1892) the court held that an immunity statute must afford transactional immunity if testimony is to be compelled.

21979–1979
Gundy v. United States green
scotus · 2019
1 sentence

2021Although this rule remains in place, see Gundy, 139 S. Ct. at 2123 , it is quite apparent that it supplanted the Constitution's separation of powers. ¶63 The Constitution "contain[s] a discernible, textually grounded non-delegation principle that is far removed from the modern doctrine." Gary Lawson, Delegation and Original Meaning, 88 Va. L.

12021–2021
Sisters of Saint Mary v. City of Madison green
wis · 1979
1 sentence

2009"While the statute must be given a strict construction in favor of taxation, the modern rule is that the statute must be given a 'strict but reasonable' construction." Id. (citing Columbia Hosp.

12009–2009
Wilson v. Arkansas green
scotus · 1995
1 sentence

2001Wilson, 514 U.S. at 931 -32 (citing Semayne's Case, 77 Eng.

12001–2001
Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady green
scotus · 1977
2 sentences

1997The modern test for the propriety of a tax on interstate commerce was first set forth in Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274 (1977).

1997The modern test for the propriety of a tax on interstate commerce was first set forth in Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274 (1977).

11997–1997
Walz v. Tax Comm'n of City of New York green
scotus · 1970
1 sentence

1982Walz v. Tax Commission of City of New York , 397 U.S. 664 (1970).

11982–1982
First National Bank of Glendale v. Sheriff of Milwaukee County green
wis · 1967
2 sentences

1978We interpret the Code as incorporating the rationale of the Peterson ease, i.e., that the debtor may sell the collateral; that the debtor’s transfer of collateral will not destroy the secured party’s interest; and that if the transfer of collateral occurs at a time when the debtor is not in default (and the transfer is not an event of default), the secured creditor has no immediate *17 remedy against either the debtor or the transferee. 19 We do not reach the question whether a transfer of collateral which constitutes a default or which occurs after the debtor’s default is a conversion, becaus

1978We interpret the Code as incorporating the rationale of the Peterson ease, i.e., that the debtor may sell the collateral; that the debtor’s transfer of collateral will not destroy the secured party’s interest; and that if the transfer of collateral occurs at a time when the debtor is not in default (and the transfer is not an event of default), the secured creditor has no immediate *17 remedy against either the debtor or the transferee. 19 We do not reach the question whether a transfer of collateral which constitutes a default or which occurs after the debtor’s default is a conversion, becaus

11978–1978
Midland National Bank & Trust Co. v. Peterson neutral
wis · 1938
1 sentence

1978This is in accordance with the modern rule that for all practical purposes chattel mortgages are mere liens.” Midland National Bank & Trust Company v. Peterson, 229 Wis. 19, 20 , 281 N.W. 688 (1938). 18 As the Peterson case illustrates, prior to enacting the Code Wisconsin recognized the debtor’s right to transfer his or her interest.

11978–1978
LeMay v. City of Oconto green
wis · 1938
1 sentence

1978This is in accordance with the modern rule that for all practical purposes chattel mortgages are mere liens.” Midland National Bank & Trust Company v. Peterson, 229 Wis. 19, 20 , 281 N.W. 688 (1938). 18 As the Peterson case illustrates, prior to enacting the Code Wisconsin recognized the debtor’s right to transfer his or her interest.

11978–1978
Hazard v. Warner neutral
wash · 1923
2 sentences

1930Jur. p. 95 : “While the rule has been too often declared to be ignored, it seems to be founded upon a misconception of the maxim to which it is traced, and the efforts of the courts to engraft exceptions have led practically in many cases to an annulment of the rule itself.” The modern rule is well stated in Hazard v. Warner, 122 Wash. 687 , 211 Pac. 732 , 31 A. L.

1930Jur. p. 95 : “While the rule has been too often declared to be ignored, it seems to be founded upon a misconception of the maxim to which it is traced, and the efforts of the courts to engraft exceptions have led practically in many cases to an annulment of the rule itself.” The modern rule is well stated in Hazard v. Warner, 122 Wash. 687 , 211 Pac. 732 , 31 A. L.

11930–1930
Lardner v. Williams green
wis · 1898
2 sentences

1930And this is so although the parties knew what words were employed and their ordinary meaning/ ” The following Wisconsin cases clearly show that the decisions of this court are in harmony with the modern rule: In Lardner v. Williams, 98 Wis. 514, 521 , 74 N. W. 346 , Mr. Justice WiNSLOW, speaking for the court, said: “In the present case it was conclusively shown, not only by the circumstances but by direct evidence, that both mortgagor and mortgagees intended and agreed that the fee of .the land should be mortgaged, and not the mere life estate, and that they knew that the power to mortgage ca

1930And this is so although the parties knew what words were employed and their ordinary meaning/ ” The following Wisconsin cases clearly show that the decisions of this court are in harmony with the modern rule: In Lardner v. Williams, 98 Wis. 514, 521 , 74 N. W. 346 , Mr. Justice WiNSLOW, speaking for the court, said: “In the present case it was conclusively shown, not only by the circumstances but by direct evidence, that both mortgagor and mortgagees intended and agreed that the fee of .the land should be mortgaged, and not the mere life estate, and that they knew that the power to mortgage ca

11930–1930
Shuman v. Shuman green
wis · 1892
2 sentences

1923The modern rule laid down by Lord LaNgdale in Hargrave v. Hargrave, 9 Beav. 552, has been expressly accepted by this court in Shuman v. Shuman, 83 Wis. 250 , 53 N. W. 455 .

1923The modern rule laid down by Lord LaNgdale in Hargrave v. Hargrave, 9 Beav. 552, has been expressly accepted by this court in Shuman v. Shuman, 83 Wis. 250 , 53 N. W. 455 .

11923–1923
Builders Lumber & Supply Co. v. Chicago Bonding & Surety Co. green
· 1918
2 sentences

1923See 1 Brandt, Suretyship (3d ed.) § 103 and cases cited; Builders L. & S. Co. v. Chicago B. & S. Co. 167 Wis. 167 , 166 N. W. 320 .

1923See 1 Brandt, Suretyship (3d ed.) § 103 and cases cited; Builders L. & S. Co. v. Chicago B. & S. Co. 167 Wis. 167 , 166 N. W. 320 .

11923–1923
Matteson v. Ellsworth green
wis · 1871
1 sentence

1906This court is in harmony therewith, as suggested by counsel for appellant, referring to Matteson v. Ellsworth, 28 Wis. 254, 256 , and Glenwood Mfg.

11906–1906
United States v. Huckabee green
· 1873
1 sentence

1900In U. S. v. Huckabee, 16 Wall. 414 , a case generally cited as giving a very clear definition of duress according to the modern doctrine on the subject, Mr. Justice Clieeord said: “Unlawful duress is a good defense to a contract if it includes such degree of constraint or danger, either actually inflicted or threatened and impending, as is sufficient in severity or apprehension to overcome the mind and will of a person of ordinary firmness.” On the same line, Mr. Justice Coleeick, in Hines v. Comm’rs of Hamilton Co. 93 Ind. 266 , said, citing from 4 Wait, Act. & Def. 490: “ Mere threats of vio

11900–1900
Cotzhausen v. Simon green
· 1879
1 sentence

1900As was said by this court in effect, in Cotzhausen v. Simon, 47 Wis. 103 , if representations by a vendor be material and false, and the-vendee rely upon them to his injury, he may recover of the vendor on the ground of fraud the damages he sustains thereby which are the natural and proximate results of the wrong; and such is the case whether the falsehood be wilful or not, for a vendor has no right to make even a mistake in facts material to a contract except under penalty of responding in damages.

11900–1900
Youngs v. Simm neutral
illappct · 1891
1 sentence

1900There must be a reasonable ground for creating an apprehension that the threats will be carried into execution, in the mind of a man of ordinary firmness and courage, and must operate upon him directly, so as to overcome his will.” Similar language is used in legal opinions of courts of many of the states, as will be shown by reference to the following: Youngs v. Simm, 41 Ill.

11900–1900
Hines v. Board of Commissioners neutral
ind · 1884
1 sentence

1900In U. S. v. Huckabee, 16 Wall. 414 , a case generally cited as giving a very clear definition of duress according to the modern doctrine on the subject, Mr. Justice Clieeord said: “Unlawful duress is a good defense to a contract if it includes such degree of constraint or danger, either actually inflicted or threatened and impending, as is sufficient in severity or apprehension to overcome the mind and will of a person of ordinary firmness.” On the same line, Mr. Justice Coleeick, in Hines v. Comm’rs of Hamilton Co. 93 Ind. 266 , said, citing from 4 Wait, Act. & Def. 490: “ Mere threats of vio

11900–1900

Statutes the citing opinions construe

WI § Wis. Stat. § 70.11 (3) WI § Wis. Stat. § 802.08 (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

CA 141 (1885–2026) NY 88 (1806–2025) PA 79 (1855–2024) IN 60 (1874–2024) MO 59 (1892–2025) IL 53 (1868–2013) TX 48 (1913–2022) TN 41 (1875–2025) IA 41 (1871–2021) MD 40 (1964–2025) MI 40 (1879–2023) NC 39 (1893–2022) WA 38 (1901–2024) CT 36 (1917–2022) KY 36 (1857–2025) OH 33 (1894–2026) AL 32 (1876–2026) CO 31 (1896–2023) NJ 31 (1832–2025) AZ 31 (1922–2018) OK 30 (1913–2004) KS 29 (1893–2024) WV 28 (1893–2013) VA 24 (1882–2026) NM 24 (1904–2024) OR 21 (1871–2014) WI 20 (1900–2021) FL 20 (1931–2017) LA 17 (1871–2020) MS 17 (1904–1998) MA 17 (1906–2025) NE 16 (1888–1981) MN 15 (1875–2024) DC 12 (1976–2011) ND 12 (1893–1980) DE 11 (1900–2018) HI 11 (1921–2011) ME 11 (1903–2020) AR 10 (1907–2010) UT 9 (1912–2019) MT 9 (1899–1936) SC 9 (1927–2023) WY 8 (1933–2013) GA 8 (1848–2010) AK 8 (1970–2011) ID 7 (1909–1992) SD 7 (1890–2007) NH 6 (1974–2024) VT 5 (1932–2025) RI 5 (1901–1983) NV 4 (1910–1932) VI 2 (1991–1998)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check