modern rule (Utah) · Go Syfert
← Utah issues

modern rule in Utah

9 Utah opinions name it 2 courts 1912–2019 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Utah courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
cluster 245485green
ca10 · 1958 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
1 sentence

2015The judicial gardeners through whose carelessness it has crept in should be able to eliminate it, or at least to prevent its further growth."); Bernstein v. United States, 256 F.2d 697, 705 (10th Cir. *79 1958) ("[The election of remedies doctrine] has been consistently criticized as harsh and not a favorite of equity."); Waffer Int'l Corp. v. Khorsandi, 69 Cal.App.4th 1261 , 82 Cal.Rptr.2d 241, 251 (1999) ("Courts and commentators have long recognized the harshness of the election of remedies doctrine and have for some time looked upon it with disfavor." (internal quotation marks omitted)). 1

11
Waffer International Corp. v. Khorsandigreen
calctapp · 1999 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
2 sentences

2015The judicial gardeners through whose carelessness it has crept in should be able to eliminate it, or at least to prevent its further growth."); Bernstein v. United States, 256 F.2d 697, 705 (10th Cir. *79 1958) ("[The election of remedies doctrine] has been consistently criticized as harsh and not a favorite of equity."); Waffer Int'l Corp. v. Khorsandi, 69 Cal.App.4th 1261 , 82 Cal.Rptr.2d 241, 251 (1999) ("Courts and commentators have long recognized the harshness of the election of remedies doctrine and have for some time looked upon it with disfavor." (internal quotation marks omitted)). 1

2015The judicial gardeners through whose carelessness it has crept in should be able to eliminate it, or at least to prevent its further growth."); Bernstein v. United States, 256 F.2d 697, 705 (10th Cir. *79 1958) ("[The election of remedies doctrine] has been consistently criticized as harsh and not a favorite of equity."); Waffer Int'l Corp. v. Khorsandi, 69 Cal.App.4th 1261 , 82 Cal.Rptr.2d 241, 251 (1999) ("Courts and commentators have long recognized the harshness of the election of remedies doctrine and have for some time looked upon it with disfavor." (internal quotation marks omitted)). 1

11
Matter of Discipline of Babilisgreen
utah · 1997 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
1 sentence

2015A. The "Truly Compelling Mitigating Circumstances" Standard Is Not "Illusory" {13 The modern standard for attorney sanctions in cases of intentional misappropriation was first set out by this court in Babil-is, where we adopted the rule that "intentional misappropriation of client funds will result in disbarment unless the lawyer can demonstrate truly compelling mitigating circumstances." 951 P.2d at 217 (internal quotation marks omitted).

11
United California Bank v. Prudential Insurance Co. of Americagreen
arizctapp · 1983 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 1990–1990
2 sentences

1990Co., Etc., 140 Ariz. 238 , 681 P.2d 390, 433 (Ct.App. 1983); see, e.g., Upland Indus.

1990Co., Etc., 140 Ariz. 238 , 681 P.2d 390, 433 (Ct.App. 1983); see, e.g., Upland Indus.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Utah. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

CaseCitedYears
Freeman v. Hewit green
scotus · 1947
1 sentence

2019In that case the high court overruled the previously governing analytical approach established in Freeman v. Hewit, 329 U.S. 249 (1946), and Spector Motor Service v. O’Connor, 340 U.S. 602 (1951).

12019–2019
Spector Motor Service, Inc. v. O'Connor red
scotus · 1951
1 sentence

2019In that case the high court overruled the previously governing analytical approach established in Freeman v. Hewit, 329 U.S. 249 (1946), and Spector Motor Service v. O’Connor, 340 U.S. 602 (1951).

12019–2019
Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady green
scotus · 1977
1 sentence

2019Finally, we apply Wynne to conclude that Utah’s tax scheme is constitutional. 1 ¶24 The modern framework for evaluating the validity of state taxes under the Dormant Commerce Clause has its origins in Complete Auto, 430 U.S. 274 .

12019–2019
Ogle v. Freeman green
kan · 1939
2 sentences

1951In Ogle v. Freeman, 150 Kan. 864 , 96 P.2d 670, 674 , (11-15), the court called attention to an earlier case and said: "* * * this court repudiated the proposition that ordinary firmness of mind should be included in the standard by which to test the existence of duress * * *. "`The courts now generally recognize that this definition is inaccurate for at least two specific reasons, viz.: First, experience has furnished no yardstick by which the firmness of the human will can be measured; and, second, even though that could be done, one having a weak will is as much entitled to the protection o

1951In Ogle v. Freeman, 150 Kan. 864 , 96 P.2d 670, 674 , (11-15), the court called attention to an earlier case and said: "* * * this court repudiated the proposition that ordinary firmness of mind should be included in the standard by which to test the existence of duress * * *. "`The courts now generally recognize that this definition is inaccurate for at least two specific reasons, viz.: First, experience has furnished no yardstick by which the firmness of the human will can be measured; and, second, even though that could be done, one having a weak will is as much entitled to the protection o

11951–1951
Robinson v. Missisquoi R. R. green
vt · 1887
1 sentence

1939Co., 59 Vt. 426 , 10 A. 522 .

11939–1939
Breidenthal v. Grooms neutral
okla · 1932
2 sentences

1939“A more modern rule and that now followed by the greater number of courts is that the whole deed and every part thereof is to be taken into consideration in determining the intent of the grantor, and clauses in the deed subsequent to the granting clause are given effect so as to curtail, limit, or qualify the estate conveyed in the granting clause.” Breidenthal v. Grooms, 161 Okl. 74 , 17 P. 2d 688, 689 ; Forgeus v. Santa Cruz County, 24 Cal. App. 193 , 140 P. 1092 ; Robinson v. Missisquoi R.

1939“A more modern rule and that now followed by the greater number of courts is that the whole deed and every part thereof is to be taken into consideration in determining the intent of the grantor, and clauses in the deed subsequent to the granting clause are given effect so as to curtail, limit, or qualify the estate conveyed in the granting clause.” Breidenthal v. Grooms, 161 Okl. 74 , 17 P. 2d 688, 689 ; Forgeus v. Santa Cruz County, 24 Cal. App. 193 , 140 P. 1092 ; Robinson v. Missisquoi R.

11939–1939
Forgeus v. County of Santa Cruz green
ca9 · 1914
2 sentences

1939“A more modern rule and that now followed by the greater number of courts is that the whole deed and every part thereof is to be taken into consideration in determining the intent of the grantor, and clauses in the deed subsequent to the granting clause are given effect so as to curtail, limit, or qualify the estate conveyed in the granting clause.” Breidenthal v. Grooms, 161 Okl. 74 , 17 P. 2d 688, 689 ; Forgeus v. Santa Cruz County, 24 Cal. App. 193 , 140 P. 1092 ; Robinson v. Missisquoi R.

1939“A more modern rule and that now followed by the greater number of courts is that the whole deed and every part thereof is to be taken into consideration in determining the intent of the grantor, and clauses in the deed subsequent to the granting clause are given effect so as to curtail, limit, or qualify the estate conveyed in the granting clause.” Breidenthal v. Grooms, 161 Okl. 74 , 17 P. 2d 688, 689 ; Forgeus v. Santa Cruz County, 24 Cal. App. 193 , 140 P. 1092 ; Robinson v. Missisquoi R.

11939–1939
Neenan v. City of St. Joseph green
mo · 1894
2 sentences

1925Joseph, 126 Mo. 89 , 28 S. W. 963 , is as follows: “A judgment is not such an entirety as not to be amendable or subject to correction as to one of the parties alone, unless the substantial rights of the others would be injuriously affected thereby.” See, also, Nashville St.

1925Joseph, 126 Mo. 89 , 28 S. W. 963 , is as follows: “A judgment is not such an entirety as not to be amendable or subject to correction as to one of the parties alone, unless the substantial rights of the others would be injuriously affected thereby.” See, also, Nashville St.

11925–1925
Gómez v. Ardura de Joglar neutral
prsupreme · 1936
1 sentence

1922In speaking to that point in Donaldson v. Grant, 15 Utah, 239 , 49 Pac. 781 , the court said: “ * * * And we have no doubt that the indorsement and delivery of the note to the plaintiff were equivalent to an assignment and delivery of the mortgage to him also.” The modern doctrine that the mortgage follows the note as an incident was thus long ago recognized by this court, and, so far as the writer is aware, has never been departed from, although I know of no case in which Donaldson v. Grant was expressly followed.

11922–1922
People v. Edwards neutral
cal · 1881
1 sentence

1912Her true name in full was Georgiana Jeanette Lake, and it was no variance to describe her as Georgiana Lake; and the question of identity was put at rest by her presence.” In the cases of People v. Edwards, 59 Cal. 359 , and People v. Main, 114 Cal. 632 , 46 Pac. 612 , the modern rule is also adopted.

11912–1912
People v. Main neutral
cal · 1896
2 sentences

1912Her true name in full was Georgiana Jeanette Lake, and it was no variance to describe her as Georgiana Lake; and the question of identity was put at rest by her presence.” In the cases of People v. Edwards, 59 Cal. 359 , and People v. Main, 114 Cal. 632 , 46 Pac. 612 , the modern rule is also adopted.

1912Her true name in full was Georgiana Jeanette Lake, and it was no variance to describe her as Georgiana Lake; and the question of identity was put at rest by her presence.” In the cases of People v. Edwards, 59 Cal. 359 , and People v. Main, 114 Cal. 632 , 46 Pac. 612 , the modern rule is also adopted.

11912–1912

Where else courts name it

CA 141 (1885–2026) NY 88 (1806–2025) PA 79 (1855–2024) IN 60 (1874–2024) MO 59 (1892–2025) IL 53 (1868–2013) TX 48 (1913–2022) TN 41 (1875–2025) IA 41 (1871–2021) MD 40 (1964–2025) MI 40 (1879–2023) NC 39 (1893–2022) WA 38 (1901–2024) CT 36 (1917–2022) KY 36 (1857–2025) OH 33 (1894–2026) AL 32 (1876–2026) CO 31 (1896–2023) NJ 31 (1832–2025) AZ 31 (1922–2018) OK 30 (1913–2004) KS 29 (1893–2024) WV 28 (1893–2013) VA 24 (1882–2026) NM 24 (1904–2024) OR 21 (1871–2014) WI 20 (1900–2021) FL 20 (1931–2017) LA 17 (1871–2020) MS 17 (1904–1998) MA 17 (1906–2025) NE 16 (1888–1981) MN 15 (1875–2024) DC 12 (1976–2011) ND 12 (1893–1980) DE 11 (1900–2018) HI 11 (1921–2011) ME 11 (1903–2020) AR 10 (1907–2010) UT 9 (1912–2019) MT 9 (1899–1936) SC 9 (1927–2023) WY 8 (1933–2013) GA 8 (1848–2010) AK 8 (1970–2011) ID 7 (1909–1992) SD 7 (1890–2007) NH 6 (1974–2024) VT 5 (1932–2025) RI 5 (1901–1983) NV 4 (1910–1932) VI 2 (1991–1998)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check