corollary rule (Oregon) · Go Syfert
← Oregon issues

corollary rule in Oregon

26 Oregon opinions name it 3 courts 1897–2026 5 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Oregon courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (4)

CaseFollowedCited
First National Bank v. Marion Countygreen
or · 1942 · cited in 2 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1970–2023
2 sentences

2023This is so because of the corollary principle that taxes are assessed only against the one having title[.] * * *.” Id. (citing First National Bank of Portland v. Marion County, 169 Or 595 , 612–13, 130 P2d 9 (1942) (leaseholds and other interests in real property generally “are not, for the purpose of taxation, made severable and assessable in the names of the owners of the respective interests”).

2023This is so because of the corollary principle that taxes are assessed only against the one having title[.] * * *.” Id. (citing First National Bank of Portland v. Marion County, 169 Or 595 , 612–13, 130 P2d 9 (1942) (leaseholds and other interests in real property generally “are not, for the purpose of taxation, made severable and assessable in the names of the owners of the respective interests”).

12
Ainsworth v. Combined Insurance Co. of Americagreen
nev · 1988 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 2022–2022
1 sentence

2022Co. of Am., 104 Nev 587, 592, 763 P2d 673, 676 (1988) (“A consumer buys insurance for security, Cite as 317 Or App 233 (2022) 247 principle in Farris, noting that “insurance contracts * * * are made for economic and financial peace of mind.” 284 Or at 465 .4 A corollary to that principle is that statutes regulating the business of insurance—notice of cancellation require- ments, for instance—are likewise intended to ensure peace of mind for policyholders.

11
State Ex Rel. Oregon State Bar v. Wrightgreen
or · 1977 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 2006–2006
2 sentences

2006See, e.g., State ex rel Oregon State Bar v. Wright, 280 Or 713, 715 , 573 P2d 294 (1977) (holding that punishment for civil contempt should be restricted to cases in which the violation of a court order is with “bad intent”).

2006See, e.g., State ex rel Oregon State Bar v. Wright, 280 Or 713, 715 , 573 P2d 294 (1977) (holding that punishment for civil contempt should be restricted to cases in which the violation of a court order is with “bad intent”).

11
Hitchcock v. Duggergreen
scotus · 1987 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1988–1988
2 sentences

1988These rules are now well established, and the State does not question them." In 1987, the Court unanimously reversed a death sentence when the state court had excluded mitigating factors that were not made relevant by Florida law: "We think it could not be clearer that the advisory jury was instructed not to consider, and the sentencing judge refused to consider, evidence of nonstatutory mitigating circumstances, and that the proceedings therefore did not comport with the requirements of Skipper v. South Carolina, 476 US 1 , 90 LEd2d 1 , 106 SCt 1669 (1986), Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 US 104 , 7

1988These rules are now well established, and the State does not question them." In 1987, the Court unanimously reversed a death sentence when the state court had excluded mitigating factors that were not made relevant by Florida law: "We think it could not be clearer that the advisory jury was instructed not to consider, and the sentencing judge refused to consider, evidence of nonstatutory mitigating circumstances, and that the proceedings therefore did not comport with the requirements of Skipper v. South Carolina, 476 US 1 , 90 LEd2d 1 , 106 SCt 1669 (1986), Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 US 104 , 7

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oregon. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (34)

CaseCitedYears
State v. Miller green
orctapp · 2024
2 sentences

2026From that conclusion, the court determined that “Miranda warnings were not required, which rendered the corollary requirement to obtain a valid waiver of [the rights enumerated in those warnings] unnecessary.” Id. at 609 .5 The court further concluded that the trial court had not erred in denying the motion to suppress the results of the blood test.

2026Id. at 609 .

32026–2026
Commonwealth, Inc. v. Department of Revenue green
or · 1971
2 sentences

2023Although a property’s owner is responsible for the taxes, it is not only the owner’s interest that is appraised, but “[t]he entire beneficial interest in the property.” Commonwealth, Inc. v. Dept. of Rev., 259 Or 140, 145 , 484 P2d 1103 (1971).

2023Although a property’s owner is responsible for the taxes, it is not only the owner’s interest that is appraised, but “[t]he entire beneficial interest in the property.” Commonwealth, Inc. v. Dept. of Rev., 259 Or 140, 145 , 484 P2d 1103 (1971).

12023–2023
Farris v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. green
or · 1978
1 sentence

2022Co. of Am., 104 Nev 587, 592, 763 P2d 673, 676 (1988) (“A consumer buys insurance for security, Cite as 317 Or App 233 (2022) 247 principle in Farris, noting that “insurance contracts * * * are made for economic and financial peace of mind.” 284 Or at 465 .4 A corollary to that principle is that statutes regulating the business of insurance—notice of cancellation require- ments, for instance—are likewise intended to ensure peace of mind for policyholders.

12022–2022
Moody v. Oregon Community Credit Union green
orctapp · 2022
1 sentence

2022Co. of Am., 104 Nev 587, 592, 763 P2d 673, 676 (1988) (“A consumer buys insurance for security, Cite as 317 Or App 233 (2022) 247 principle in Farris, noting that “insurance contracts * * * are made for economic and financial peace of mind.” 284 Or at 465 .4 A corollary to that principle is that statutes regulating the business of insurance—notice of cancellation require- ments, for instance—are likewise intended to ensure peace of mind for policyholders.

12022–2022
AAA Oregon/Idaho Auto Source, LLC v. State green
or · 2018
2 sentences

2020AAA Oregon/Idaho Auto Source v. Dept. of Rev., 363 Or 411, 417-18 , 423 P3d 71 (2018).

2020AAA Oregon/Idaho Auto Source v. Dept. of Rev., 363 Or 411, 417-18 , 423 P3d 71 (2018).

12020–2020
Swan Lake Moulding Co. v. Department of Revenue green
or · 1970
2 sentences

2019This is so because of the corollary principle that taxes are assessed only against the one having title[.]" 257 Or. at 625 , 478 P.2d 393 .

2019This is so because of the corollary principle that taxes are assessed only against the one having title[.]" 257 Or. at 625 , 478 P.2d 393 .

12019–2019
Dreyer v. Portland General Electric Co. green
or · 2006
1 sentence

2007The court expressly left open the question whether “Oregon accepts the filed-rate doctrine or the corollary rule against retroactive ratemaking.” Id. at 270 n 10.

12007–2007
Carlson v. Myers green
or · 1998
2 sentences

2005Another is a corollary to that presumption: "[I]t is presumed that such changes in meaning do not go further than is expressly declared or necessarily implied." Id.

2005Another is a corollary to that presumption: “[I]t is presumed that such changes in meaning do not go further than is expressly declared or necessarily implied.” Id.

12005–2005
Smith v. Multnomah County Board of Commissioners green
or · 1994
2 sentences

2002Smith v. Multnomah County Board of Commissioners, 318 Or 302, 309 , 865 P2d 356 (1994).

2002Smith v. Multnomah County Board of Commissioners, 318 Or 302, 309 , 865 P2d 356 (1994).

12002–2002
Farmers Insurance v. Stockton green
orctapp · 1992
1 sentence

2001Because the right of an injured party “to recover under an insurance policy is derived from the contractual rights of the named insured,” id. at 123 , a declaratory judgment between the parties to the contract on the insurance company’s indemnity obligation would determine whether the injured party could recover under the insurance contract.

12001–2001
Chambers v. Mississippi green
scotus · 1973
2 sentences

1992Not only was he precluded from cross-examining McDonald, but, as the State conceded at oral argument, he was also restricted in the scope of his direct examination by the rule’s corollary requirement that the party calling the witness is bound by anything [the witness] might say. [Chambers] was, therefore, effectively prevented from exploring the circumstances of McDonald’s three prior oral confessions and from challenging the renunciation of the written confession.” Id. at 296-97 .

1992(Footnotes omitted.) The combination of these two aspects of the “voucher” rule, the Court held, “interfered with Chambers’ right [of confrontation and cross-examination, under the Sixth Amendment, as applied to the states under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment] to defend against the State’s charges.” Id. at 298 .

11992–1992
Eddings v. Oklahoma green
scotus · 1982
2 sentences

1988Equally clear is the corollary rule that the sentencer may not refuse to consider or be precluded from considering "any relevant mitigating evidence." 455 US, at 114 , 71 LEd2d 1 , 102 SCt 869 [at 876].

1988Equally clear is the corollary rule that the sentencer may not refuse to consider or be precluded from considering "any relevant mitigating evidence." 455 US, at 114 , 71 LEd2d 1 , 102 SCt 869 [at 876].

11988–1988
Lockett v. Ohio green
scotus · 1978
2 sentences

1988These rules are now well established, and the State does not question them." In 1987, the Court unanimously reversed a death sentence when the state court had excluded mitigating factors that were not made relevant by Florida law: "We think it could not be clearer that the advisory jury was instructed not to consider, and the sentencing judge refused to consider, evidence of nonstatutory mitigating circumstances, and that the proceedings therefore did not comport with the requirements of Skipper v. South Carolina, 476 US 1 , 90 LEd2d 1 , 106 SCt 1669 (1986), Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 US 104 , 7

1988These rules are now well established, and the State does not question them." In 1987, the Court unanimously reversed a death sentence when the state court had excluded mitigating factors that were not made relevant by Florida law: "We think it could not be clearer that the advisory jury was instructed not to consider, and the sentencing judge refused to consider, evidence of nonstatutory mitigating circumstances, and that the proceedings therefore did not comport with the requirements of Skipper v. South Carolina, 476 US 1 , 90 LEd2d 1 , 106 SCt 1669 (1986), Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 US 104 , 7

11988–1988
Skipper v. South Carolina green
scotus · 1986
2 sentences

1988Equally clear is the corollary rule that the sentencer may not refuse to consider or be precluded from considering `any relevant mitigating evidence' [citation omitted]." *1205 Skipper v. South Carolina, supra, 476 U.S. at 4 , 106 S.Ct. at 1670-71 .

1988Equally clear is the corollary rule that the sentencer may not refuse to consider or be precluded from considering `any relevant mitigating evidence' [citation omitted]." *1205 Skipper v. South Carolina, supra, 476 U.S. at 4 , 106 S.Ct. at 1670-71 .

11988–1988
Jones v. Warmsprings Irrigation District green
or · 1939
2 sentences

1988Jones v. Warm-springs Irrigation Dist., 162 Or 186, 198 , 91 P2d 542 (1939).

1988Jones v. Warm-springs Irrigation Dist., 162 Or 186, 198 , 91 P2d 542 (1939).

11988–1988
Schlecht v. Bliss green
or · 1975
2 sentences

1987In Schlecht v. Bliss, 271 Or 304, 310 , 532 P2d 1 (1975), the court said: “In summary it is necessary, in ruling on a motion to dismiss an appeal, to examine the relief sought by the appellant on appeal.

1987In Schlecht v. Bliss, 271 Or 304, 310 , 532 P2d 1 (1975), the court said: “In summary it is necessary, in ruling on a motion to dismiss an appeal, to examine the relief sought by the appellant on appeal.

11987–1987
Rogue River Management Co. v. Shaw green
or · 1966
2 sentences

1980Rogue River Management Co. v. Shaw, 243 Or 54, 60-61 , 411 P2d 440 (1966); and see Widner Electric v. Lee, 272 Or 445, 451 , 537 P2d 527 (1975).

1980Rogue River Management Co. v. Shaw, 243 Or 54, 60-61 , 411 P2d 440 (1966); and see Widner Electric v. Lee, 272 Or 445, 451 , 537 P2d 527 (1975).

11980–1980
Widner Electric & Industrial, Inc. v. Lee green
or · 1975
2 sentences

1980Rogue River Management Co. v. Shaw, 243 Or 54, 60-61 , 411 P2d 440 (1966); and see Widner Electric v. Lee, 272 Or 445, 451 , 537 P2d 527 (1975).

1980Rogue River Management Co. v. Shaw, 243 Or 54, 60-61 , 411 P2d 440 (1966); and see Widner Electric v. Lee, 272 Or 445, 451 , 537 P2d 527 (1975).

11980–1980
Hanna v. Hope green
· 1917
2 sentences

1980It was held in Hanna v. Hope, 86 Or 303, 308-09 , 168 P 618 (1917), that "[a] party is entitled to the relief arising under the law from the facts alleged and proved by him even though he claims for them a value which they do not possess.” A corollary of that principle is that facts alleged as part of a counterclaim may also raise a defense, and that in the absence of a timely objection the allegations comprising a defense need not be stated separately from the counterclaim to be effective as such.

1980It was held in Hanna v. Hope, 86 Or 303, 308-09 , 168 P 618 (1917), that "[a] party is entitled to the relief arising under the law from the facts alleged and proved by him even though he claims for them a value which they do not possess.” A corollary of that principle is that facts alleged as part of a counterclaim may also raise a defense, and that in the absence of a timely objection the allegations comprising a defense need not be stated separately from the counterclaim to be effective as such.

11980–1980
Belle v. Brown neutral
or · 1900
2 sentences

1976"A party failing to assert a claim in a suit in equity, in which it might have been litigated with propriety, will not be permitted afterwards to enforce it in a second suit, unless his failure to do so in the first instance was caused by the fraud of his adversary, and was not attributable to his own negligence: * * *.” Belle v. Brown, 37 Or 588, 592-593 , 61 P 1024 (1900).

1976"A party failing to assert a claim in a suit in equity, in which it might have been litigated with propriety, will not be permitted afterwards to enforce it in a second suit, unless his failure to do so in the first instance was caused by the fraud of his adversary, and was not attributable to his own negligence: * * *.” Belle v. Brown, 37 Or 588, 592-593 , 61 P 1024 (1900).

11976–1976
Lane County v. R. A. Heintz Construction Co. green
or · 1961
2 sentences

1975Lane County v. Heintz Const. Co., 228 Or 152 , 364 P2d 627 (1961).

1975Lane County v. Heintz Const. Co., 228 Or 152 , 364 P2d 627 (1961).

11975–1975
Stewart v. Jefferson Plywood Company green
or · 1970
1 sentence

1973We broadened this basic concept of blameworthiness to include an anticipation of general kinds of harm to persons in the general class threatened: “An important corollary of this principle is that ‘liability is confined to harms actually resulting that are of the general kind to be anticipated from the conduct and, for the same reason, liability is confined to situations in which the person harmed is one of the general class threatened.’ ” 255 Or at 608-609 .

11973–1973
Swift & Co. v. Peterson green
or · 1951
2 sentences

1958Swift & Co. and Armour & Co. v. Peterson, 192 Or 97, 108 , 233 P2d 216 , and cases there cited; 2 Lewis’ Sutherland, Statutory Construction (2d ed) 927 § 498. *148 Although, both parties very properly read the challenged 90-day residential period as being included in and as an element within the six-month period established by Art II, § 2, they part on the question of its constitutional validity.

1958Swift & Co. and Armour & Co. v. Peterson, 192 Or 97, 108 , 233 P2d 216 , and cases there cited; 2 Lewis’ Sutherland, Statutory Construction (2d ed) 927 § 498. *148 Although, both parties very properly read the challenged 90-day residential period as being included in and as an element within the six-month period established by Art II, § 2, they part on the question of its constitutional validity.

11958–1958
Dam v. Lake Aliso Riding School green
cal · 1936
1 sentence

1958Dam v. Lake Aliso Riding School, 6 Cal2d 395, 57 P2d 1315 and Gittens v. Lundberg, 3 Utah2d 392, 284 P2d 1115 .

11958–1958
Gittens v. Lundberg green
utah · 1955
1 sentence

1958Dam v. Lake Aliso Riding School, 6 Cal2d 395, 57 P2d 1315 and Gittens v. Lundberg, 3 Utah2d 392, 284 P2d 1115 .

11958–1958
Burford v. Kersey green
miss · 1873
1 sentence

1900A party failing to assert a claim in a suit in equity, in which it might have been litigated with propriety, will not be permitted afterwards to enforce it in a second suit, unless his failure to do so in the first instance was caused by the fraud of his adversary, and was not attributable to his own negligence : Stewart v. Stebbins, 30 Miss. 66 ; Burford v. Kersey, 48 Miss. 642 . 2.

11900–1900
Stewart v. Stebbins neutral
miss · 1855
11900–1900
Simmons v. Fielder & Sessions neutral
ala · 1871
11897–1897
McFarlan v. . Watson neutral
· 1850
11897–1897
Robbins v. . Fuller neutral
ny · 1862
11897–1897
Jennings v. Alexander neutral
· 1856
11897–1897
Gordon v. Freeman neutral
ill · 1849
11897–1897
Major v. Hawkes neutral
mont · 1850
11897–1897
Gram v. Cadwell neutral
nysupct · 1826
11897–1897

Statutes the citing opinions construe

OR § Or. Rev. Stat. § 135.335 (3) OR § Or. Rev. Stat. § 163.115 (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

TX 409 (1913–2026) CA 280 (1900–2026) IL 103 (1873–2023) NY 87 (1911–2025) PA 86 (1915–2024) NJ 77 (1896–2026) MD 69 (1928–2023) WA 66 (1922–2026) MO 65 (1905–2025) GA 57 (1912–2023) FL 49 (1938–2023) AL 44 (1909–2015) OH 39 (1932–2026) MI 37 (1940–2023) CT 37 (1937–2025) LA 35 (1919–2024) IN 34 (1918–2019) IA 32 (1917–2023) MS 32 (1876–2022) WI 32 (1965–2024) KS 27 (1875–2026) OR 26 (1897–2026) TN 26 (1904–2025) KY 25 (1922–2024) WV 24 (1901–2023) VA 23 (1963–2024) WY 23 (1968–2022) SC 20 (1907–2020) CO 19 (1912–2021) DE 19 (1945–2026) VT 17 (1913–2025) MT 16 (1898–2012) NC 15 (1921–2018) AZ 15 (1956–2018) MA 14 (1951–2024) NM 14 (1914–2014) RI 14 (1968–2018) OK 13 (1925–2014) ME 12 (1922–2020) NE 12 (1959–2023) MN 12 (1954–2025) ID 11 (1977–2021) DC 11 (1976–2025) UT 11 (1979–2026) AR 11 (1927–2017) ND 7 (1895–2015) NV 6 (1983–2015) NH 3 (1997–2021) SD 3 (1998–2003) HI 2 (1944–2015) AK 2 (1993–2023)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check